This thesis will investigate various aspects of the physics of resonating valence bond spin liquids. After giving an introduction to the world that lies beyond Landau's priciple of symmetry breaking, e.g. giving an overview of exotic magnetic phases and how they can be described and: possibly) found, we will study a spin-rotationally invariant model system with a known parent Hamiltonian, and argue its ground state to lie within a highly sought after exotic phase, namely the Z$_{2}$ quantum spin liquid phase. A newly developed numerical procedure --Pfaffian Monte Carlo-- will be introduced to amass evidence that our model Hamiltonian indeed exhibits a Z$_{2}$ quantum spin liquid phase. Subsequently, we will prove a useful mathematical property of the resonating valence bond states: these states are shown to be linearly independent. Various lattices are investigated concerning this property, and its applications and usefullness are discussed. Eventually, we present a simplified model system describing the interplay of the well known Heisenberg interaction and the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya: DM) interaction term acting on a sawtooth chain. The effect of the interplay between the two interaction couplings on the phase diagram is investigated. To do so, we employ modern techniques such as the density matrix renormalization group: DMRG) scheme. We find that for weak DM interaction the system exhibits valence bond order. However, a strong enough DM coupling destroys this order.
This thesis will investigate various aspects of the physics of resonating valence bond spin liquids. After giving an introduction to the world that lies beyond Landau's priciple of symmetry breaking, e.g. giving an overview of exotic magnetic phases and how they can be described and: possibly) found, we will study a spin-rotationally invariant model system with a known parent Hamiltonian, and argue its ground state to lie within a highly sought after exotic phase, namely the Z2 quantum spin liquid phase. A newly developed numerical procedure --Pfaffian Monte Carlo-- will be introduced to amass evidence that our model Hamiltonian indeed exhibits a Z2 quantum spin liquid phase. Subsequently, we will prove a useful mathematical property of the resonating valence bond states: these states are shown to be linearly independent. Various lattices are investigated concerning this property, and its applications and usefullness are discussed. Eventually, we present a simplified model system describing the interplay of the well known Heisenberg interaction and the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya: DM) interaction term acting on a sawtooth chain. The effect of the interplay between the two interaction couplings on the phase diagram is investigated. To do so, we employ modern techniques such as the density matrix renormalization group: DMRG) scheme. We find that for weak DM interaction the system exhibits valence bond order. However, a strong enough DM coupling destroys this order.
The quantum nature of electrons emerges in various exotic ways when they are put together with quantum many-body interactions. In Mott insulating systems with strong electron correlation, frustration and strong quantum fluctuations promote localized electron spins to form nontrivial quantum paramagnetic phases such as quantum spin liquid and valence bond solid preventing the development of conventional magnetic orders. In this thesis, we study such exotic quantum phases in various different frustrated quantum magnets. First, encouraged by the spin liquid phenomenology observed in Ba3XSb2O9 (X=Cu, Ni), we investigate Z2 spin liquids on a three dimensional triangular lattice by employing the Schwinger boson mean-field theory with projective symmetry group analysis. It is found that a nematic spin liquid is energetically favorable on this lattice structure rather than symmetric spin liquids. Next, we study various valence bond solid phases that can appear in kagome lattice antiferromagnets by generalizing the recently proposed phenomenological Z2 gauge theory for the topological Z2 spin liquid state found in the nearest-neighbor kagome lattice Heisenberg model. This work provides a bridge between the topological spin liquid and valence bond solid phases previously proposed for kagome lattice antiferromagnets via vison condensation in the gauge theory. Then, we consider optical conductivity in Mott insulators as an experimental probe to detect quantum paramagnetic phases like valence bond solid. Applying this idea to deformed kagome lattice antiferromagnet Rb2Cu3SnF12 with a 12-site valence bond solid state, we estimate the size of optical conductivity in this quantum magnet. After this, another quantum paramagnet BiCu2PO6 is carefully investigated to clarify its puzzling ground state nature and quasiparticle excitations. Utilizing recent high resolution neutron scattering data, we construct a microscopic spin model and also an effective theory for the low energy spin excitations in the compound. We find significant influences of magnetic anisotropies on the ground state and quasiparticle dynamics. Lastly, we investigate emergent quantum phases in the thin film geometries of the pyrochlore iridates, where a number of exotic quantum ground states are proposed to occur in bulk materials as a result of the interplay between electron correlation and strong spin-orbit coupling. The fate of these bulk phases, as well as the novel quantum states that may arise only in a thin film setting, are studied via a theoretical model that allows layer-dependent magnetic structures.
A one-parameter family of long-range resonating-valence-bond (RVB) state on the square lattice was previously proposed to describe a critical spin liquid (SL) phase of the spin-1/2 frustrated Heisenberg model. We provide evidence that this RVB state in fact also realizes a topological (long-range entangled) Z2 SL, limited by two transitions to critical SL phases. The topological phase is naturally connected to the Z2 gauge symmetry of the local tensor. This Rapid Communication shows that, on one hand, spin-1/2 topological SL with C4v point-group symmetry and SU(2) spin rotation symmetry exists on the square lattice and, on the other hand, criticality and nonbipartiteness are compatible. We also point out that strong similarities between our phase diagram and the ones of classical interacting dimer models suggest both can be described by similar Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions. This scenario is further supported by the analysis of the one-dimensional boundary state. Forms of parent Hamiltonians hosting the Z2 SL are suggested.
This thesis investigates the ground-state properties and quantum phase diagrams of low-dimensional spin systems, with a focus on spin–1/2 ladder chains and related models. These systems provide a fertile ground for exploring the interplay between magnetic frus- tration, quantum correlations, topology, and external fields. By combining advanced nu- merical methods, primarily the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG), with ana- lytical approaches, we analyze how different coupling geometries and magnetic fields give rise to distinct quantum phases, including magnetization plateaus, symmetry-protected and topological phases, and first-order transitions. The study covers both uniform and alternating ladders, as well as coupled ladder systems that interpolate between one- and two-dimensional behavior. In particular, we examine how frustration influences the stabil- ity of collective spin states, and how interladder couplings can drive transitions between resonating valence bond (RVB) states, Haldane phases, and trivial phases hosting collec- tive spin excitations. Although approximate analytical models, such as hard-core boson mappings and spin-wave theory, capture some qualitative aspects of these systems, our results highlight their limitations in accurately describing critical behavior and phase boundaries, reinforcing the importance of high-precision numerical analysis.
Ever since the introduction of resonating valence bond states by P.\\ W.\\ Anderson in 1970s, the search for exotic many--body quantum behavior in peculiar states of matter known as quantum spin liquids has been a central challenge in the field of condensed matter physics. An important searching ground for such \\emph{quantum--ness} is the low energy physics of frustrated magnets. In a quantum system, frustration---the inability of a physical system to achieve a global state that consistently minimizes its energy locally---enables the unavoidable quantum fluctuations to hybridize an extensive number of classical states into highly entangled quantum states at low temperatures. It can be argued that this is the most practical approach to achieve genuine many--body quantum behavior at large scales. The fundamental source of frustration in many physical systems, is the existence of local non--commuting terms. In the case of antiferromagnet spin theories the simplest examples are triangles of nearest--neighboring sites. Consequently, lattices with triangles as building blocks have long been studied in hopes of discovering spin liquids physics. In particular the kagome lattice, which is composed of corner--sharing triangles, has been the center of at least four decades of spin liquid research. This is due to the underconstrained nature of system made out of corner--sharing triangles. After the first three chapters, introduction in chapter~\\ref{chap:intro}, preliminary physics in chapter~\\ref{chap:prelim}, and a brief introduction to spin--liquids in chapter~\\ref{chap:QSLs}, in chapter~\\ref{chap:kagome} I tackle a simpler version of the long-standing problem of spin--1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnets by considering a quasi--1D lattice consisting entirely of corner--sharing triangles, \\emph{kagome strip}. I illustrate that the standard Heisenberg antiferromagnet Hamiltonian over kagome strip is an extended gapless quantum phase, that is well characterized by two fermionic/bosonic gapless modes and power--law decaying spin and bond--energy correlations. I also demonstrate that the correlation functions oscillate at tunably incommensurate wave vectors. It turns out that this phase can be identified by a particular marginal instability of a two-band spinon Fermi surface coupled to an emergent U(1) gauge field. This interpretation is supported by analytic Abelian bosonization and with extensive numerical large--scale density matrix renormalization group study as well as variational Monte Carlo calculations on Gutzwiller ans\\"atz wave functions. This intriguing result is the first numerical demonstration of emergent fermionic spinons in a simple SU(2) invariant nearest-neighbor Heisenberg model beyond the strictly 1D (Bethe chain) limit. The unexpected success of the fermionic spinons in describing the low energy physics of kagome antiferromagnet, reintroduces the questions about the validity of spinon physics as an effective theory of quantum spin liquids. However, numerical methods are still far behind the theoretical advances. And still even today, an accurate description of the quantum spin liquid states using tensor network methods is notoriously challenging. It is known that for large quasi-1D systems, the density matrix renormalization group and related methods usually require significant computational resources and sometimes fail to converge to a satisfactory state. On the other hand, variational wavefunctions acquired from the Gutzwiller projection of gaussian fermionic theories have long served as both a theoretical starting point for the construction of such spin liquid states and as an inspiration for numerical variational Monte Carlo (VMC) to calculate observables of interest. Noting this observation I examine a different method by exploring the possibility of constructing a matrix product state (MPS) representation for a Gutzwiller--projected state from two given MPS representations of gaussian fermionic theories in the \\ref{chap:gutz} chapter. I investigate the complexity of different approaches to achieve Gutzwiller projection for MPSs and introduce the novel algorithm which we call the Guzwiller zipper method. The performance of the algorithm is tested against two copies of a single half-filled band of spin-1/2 fermionic spinons. In a successful attempt to describe the nature of spin liquid states on quasi-1D strips of triangular and kagome-like lattices, I apply this method to two MPS of multi-band fermionic spinon theories and compare with the complexity of the traditional VMC approach. In particular, we methodically disprove the conjecture of a spinon fermi surface spin liquid for the triangular lattice. Finally, I conclude this thesis by laying out a bird's eye view of the current and future of spin liquid physics in kagome and triangular lattices and pointing out numerous possible applications of the novel Gutzwiller zipper method. In addition, I would also discuss its possible extensions to more complicated tensor networks as well as versions for higher spatial dimensions.
In this thesis we apply recently developed, as well as sophisticated quantum Monte Carlo methods to numerically investigate models of strongly correlated electron systems on honeycomb structures. The latter are of particular interest owing to their unique properties when simulating electrons on them, like the relativistic dispersion, strong quantum fluctuations and their resistance against instabilities. This work covers several projects including the advancement of the weak-coupling continuous time quantum Monte Carlo and its application to zero temperature and phonons, quantum phase transitions of valence bond solids in spin-1/2 Heisenberg systems using projector quantum Monte Carlo in the valence bond basis, and the magnetic field induced transition to a canted antiferromagnet of the Hubbard model on the honeycomb lattice. The emphasis lies on two projects investigating the phase diagram of the SU(2) and the SU(N)-symmetric Hubbard model on the hexagonal lattice. At sufficiently low temperatures, condensed-matter systems tend to develop order. An exception are quantum spin-liquids, where fluctuations prevent a transition to an ordered state down to the lowest temperatures. Previously elusive in experimentally relevant microscopic two-dimensional models, we show by means of large-scale quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the SU(2) Hubbard model on the honeycomb lattice, that a quantum spin-liquid emerges between the state described by massless Dirac fermions and an antiferromagnetically ordered Mott insulator. This unexpected quantum-disordered state is found to be a short-range resonating valence bond liquid, akin to the one proposed for high temperature superconductors. Inspired by the rich phase diagrams of SU(N) models we study the SU(N)-symmetric Hubbard Heisenberg quantum antiferromagnet on the honeycomb lattice to investigate the reliability of 1/N corrections to large-N results by means of numerically exact QMC simulations. We study the melting of phases as correlations increase with decreasing N and determine whether the quantum spin liquid found in the SU(2) Hubbard model at intermediate coupling is a specific feature, or also exists in the unconstrained t-J model and higher symmetries.
The set of valence-bond states --- states in which localized spin-1/2 particles are correlated in singlet pairs said to be connected by valence bonds --- provides a useful basis for visualizing singlet ground states of quantum spin systems. For example, the ground state of the uniform one-dimensional nearest-neighbor spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic (AFM) Heisenberg model (the prototypical spin-liquid state) can be viewed as a strongly fluctuating liquid of valence bonds with a power-law length distribution. This intuitive picture directly reflects the long-range spin correlations in this state, as well as the existence of gapless excitations created by breaking long bonds. Valence-bond states also play a key role in describing the physics of random spin-1/2 AFM Heisenberg chains. For these systems, it was shown by Fisher, using a real space renormalization group analysis, that on long-length scales the ground state is described by a single valence-bond state known as a random singlet state. This single valence-bond state should be viewed as a caricature of the true ground state, which will certainly exhibit bond fluctuations on short-length scales. In valence-bond Monte Carlo (VBMC) simulations valence-bond states are used to stochastically sample singlet ground states of quantum spin systems. One of the appealing features of VBMC is that if one imagines viewing the sampled valence-bond states over many Monte Carlo time steps the resulting ''movie" would correspond closely to the intuitive resonating valence bond picture described above. For random Heisenberg chains (and related models) VBMC should therefore provide a useful method for directly studying the phenomenon of random singlet formation on long-length scales, while at the same time capturing the short-range fluctuations which will always be present. In this dissertation I present results of VBMC studies for a class of models which include the uniform and random spin-1/2 AFM Heisenberg chains, as well as models describing chains of interacting non-Abelian quasiparticles --- exotic quasiparticles conjectured to exist in certain fractional quantum Hall states. In addition to numerically computing and analyzing the so-called valence-bond entanglement scaling in these models, I introduce a new quantity which I refer to as the valence-bond fluctuation (the central new result and the main contribution of this dissertation). It is shown that this quantity, which is easy to compute in valence-bond Monte Carlo, provides a direct signature of random singlet phase formation by essentially allowing one to directly ''see" the ''locking" of the ground state into a particular valence-bond state on long-length scales. A detailed scaling analysis of this new quantity is then used to extract the dependence of the fluctuation length scale on disorder strength. Where possible, the results are compared to previous numerical and analytic work on the relevant models.