Double standards when describing helium and positronium atoms
Igor Pavlovich Popov
The purpose of the work is to check the validity of generalizing the an-gular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair to any many-particle quantum system, including positronium. Methodology. For the purposes of this work, a semiclassical consideration is quite sufficient. To increase the reliability for helium, a quantum solution is additionally given. It is believed that the total minimum angular momentum of a two-particle quan-tum system – positronium is equal to ћ. When generalizing the angular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair and an electron-positron pair to a pair of helium electrons, its radius turns out to be almost four times less than the established value. And this means only one thing – the generalization of the angular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair to a pair of helium electrons is illegal. Therefore, each helium electron has a minimum angular mo-mentum equal to ћ. And the angular momentum of a pair of helium electrons is equal to the sum of the angular momentum of each electron. The double standards lie in the fact that, on the one hand, a quantum system – an electron-positron pair – is endowed with a quantum of angular momentum ћ, and on the other hand, a quantum system – a pair of helium electrons – is not endowed with this quantum (it is endowed with two quanta). And since double standards are unacceptable, an elementary dilemma arises – either the radius of helium should be quadrupled, or the radius of positronium should be quadrupled. The task is simplified by the fact that recently the value of the radius of positronium was completely unambiguously corrected, which turned out to be exactly four times larger than was commonly believed. Thus, the helium atom retains its size. It has been established that endowing a Cooper pair of electrons with a quantum of angular momentum ћ is just as illegitimate as in the case of positronium. The angular momentum of a many-particle quantum system, due to its additivity, must be divided between the particles of the system. It has been established that the quantum of angular momentum ћ can be attributed to only one quantum particle, and cannot be attributed to a quantum collection of particles.
Vestnik Тomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta Khimiya•Jan 1, 2024•3 citations