Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

How Not to Build Microcrypt — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

Published Nov 13, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A key challenge in quantum cryptography is to build quantum one-wayness and pseudorandomness without the use of (quantum computable) one-way functions. So far, this has turned out to be a difficult task, with only a few proposed candidates that are not directly built from one-way functions. Even within these few proposed candidates, we have lacked the techniques to analyze when proposed constructions may inadvertently yield one-way functions. In this work, we introduce efficient NP-aided shadow tomography of quantum states. We prove that collections of {\em computable} pure states can be learned via efficient NP-aided shadow tomography, where we say that a state is computable if the amplitude and phase on any computational basis term can be classically efficiently computed given the description of an efficient preparation circuit for the state. We also give new algorithms for NP-aided learning of unitaries given polynomially many queries to the unitary. By building on this, we show Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24186666

Related papers

How Not to Build Microcrypt

Aditya Gulati, Dakshita Khurana, Kabir Tomer

A key challenge in quantum cryptography is to build quantum one-wayness and pseudorandomness without the use of (quantum computable) one-way functions. So far, this has turned out to be a difficult task, with only a few proposed candidates that are not directly built from one-way functions. Even within these few proposed candidates, we have lacked the techniques to analyze when proposed constructions may inadvertently yield one-way functions. In this work, we introduce efficient NP-aided shadow tomography of quantum states. We prove that collections of {\em computable} pure states can be learned via efficient NP-aided shadow tomography, where we say that a state is computable if the amplitude and phase on any computational basis term can be classically efficiently computed given the description of an efficient preparation circuit for the state. We also give new algorithms for NP-aided learning of unitaries given polynomially many queries to the unitary. By building on this, we show that many existing architectures for PRS and PRU, including some that were explicitly introduced for the purposes of avoiding one-way functions (e.g., Hamiltonian Phase States, Bostanci et. al., TQC 2025), actually do imply the existence of one-way functions or imply \(\NP\) hardness. We hope that these no-go results will inform future investigations into building PRS and PRUs from assumptions that are plausibly outside the complexity class NP.

quant-pharXiv:2609.30253•Sep 25, 2026•1 citation

Proper Agnostic Learning of Matrix Product States and Tree Tensor Networks — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

We establish proper agnostic learning of matrix product states and tree tensor networks. Given copies of an arbitrary quantum state $ρ$, our algorithms return a state $|ψ\rangle$ of chosen bond dimension such that $\langleψ| ρ|ψ\rangle$ is within $\varepsilon$ of the optimum over the model class, without assuming that $ρ$ itself belongs to or is well approximated by that class. The main idea is to use improper learning to compress the mixed-state objective, reducing proper agnostic learning to optimization against a finite collection of explicitly specified pure states. We then introduce a comparator-dual compression procedure that reduces the bond dimension of these targets while uniformly preserving their overlaps with all bounded-bond comparators, with an error independent of system size. For matrix product states, this gives polynomial copy complexity in the system size, local dimension, bond dimension, and $1/\varepsilon$, together with polynomial runtime in the system size for fi Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Nov 13, 2026•0 citations

How to Build Pseudorandom Unitaries in Microcrypt

Aditya Gulati, Dakshita Khurana, Kabir Tomer

We provide the first evidence relative to a classical oracle that pseudorandom unitaries (PRUs) can exist without quantum-computable one-way functions. To obtain this result, we first prove that five independent random diagonal phase layers interleaved with Hadamard transforms \[ U=F_5HF_4HF_3HF_2HF_1 \] form a strong PRU with security under adaptive, controlled access to the unitary, its inverse, transpose, and complex conjugate. Our main result is that, when the phase layers are implemented using a classical random oracle O, the construction remains secure against uniform BQP adversaries with coherent access to suitable Boolean completions of classical-input $QMA^{PH}^{O}}$ decision problems. Such an adversary can invert (even quantum-computable) one-way functions and solve efficiently verifiable one-way puzzles defined relative to O. Our result therefore provides classical-oracle evidence that PRUs do not imply quantum-computable one-way functions, in the form of a black-box separation. We substantially strengthen the classical-oracle result of Kretschmer, Qian, and Tal (STOC 2025) by obtaining PRUs secure against these QMA-aided adversaries. Our construction also consists of a simple, efficient circuit that queries a random function, suggesting a route to concrete implementation via the random-oracle heuristic.

quant-pharXiv:2610.03711•Oct 5, 2026•0 citations

Commitments from Quantum One-Wayness

Dakshita Khurana, Kabir Tomer

One-way functions are central to classical cryptography. They are necessary for the existence of non-trivial classical cryptosystems, and also sufficient to realize meaningful primitives including commitments, pseudorandom generators and digital signatures. At the same time, a mounting body of evidence suggests that assumptions even weaker than one-way functions may suffice for many cryptographic tasks of interest in a quantum world, including bit commitments and secure multi-party computation. This work studies one-way state generators [Morimae-Yamakawa, CRYPTO 2022], a natural quantum relaxation of one-way functions. Given a secret key, a one-way state generator outputs a hard to invert quantum state. A fundamental question is whether this type of quantum one-wayness suffices to realize quantum cryptography. We obtain an affirmative answer to this question, by proving that one-way state generators with pure state outputs imply quantum bit commitments and secure multiparty computation. Along the way, we use efficient shadow tomography [Huang et. al., Nature Physics 2020] to build an intermediate primitive with classical outputs, which we call a (quantum) one-way puzzle. Our main technical contribution is a proof that one-way puzzles imply quantum bit commitments. This proof develops new techniques for pseudoentropy generation [Hastad et. al., SICOMP 1999] from arbitrary distributions, which may be of independent interest.

arXiv:2310.11526•ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jun 10, 2024•47 citations

Hardness of Pathfinding in a Welded Tree — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

Starting from the entrance of a welded tree, a quantum walk algorithm can find its exit vertex exponentially faster than any classical algorithm. However, it has been an open question whether any quantum algorithm is able to efficiently find a path from the entrance to the exit. We answer this by proving an exponential quantum query lower bound for finding such path. Specifically, for trees of height $n$, any quantum query algorithm requires at least $Ω(2^{n/24})$ queries in order to succeed with constant probability. Our proof uses the compressed permutation oracle technique in order to construct databases which track the graph information an algorithm has learned and forgotten, and show that no efficient quantum algorithm can build an entrance-to-exit path in these records. Source: http://arxiv.org/abs/2609.20651v1 (arXiv:2609.20651v1) Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Nov 7, 2026•0 citations

On the Computational Hardness of Quantum One-Wayness

Bruno Pasqualotto Cavalar, Eli Goldin, Matthew Gray +3 more

There is a large body of work studying what forms of computational hardness are needed to realize classical cryptography. In particular, one-way functions and pseudorandom generators can be built from each other, and thus require equivalent computational assumptions to be realized. Furthermore, the existence of either of these primitives implies that P ≠ N P , which gives a lower bound on the necessary hardness.One can also define versions of each of these primitives with quantum output: respectively one-way state generators and pseudorandom state generators. Unlike in the classical setting, it is not known whether either primitive can be built from the other. Although it has been shown that pseudorandom state generators for certain parameter regimes can be used to build one-way state generators, the implication has not been previously known in full generality. Furthermore, to the best of our knowledge, the existence of one-way state generators has no known implications in complexity theory.We show that pseudorandom states compressing n bits to log ⁡ n + 1 qubits can be used to build one-way state generators and pseudorandom states compressing n bits to ω ( log ⁡ n ) qubits are one-way state generators. This is a nearly optimal result since pseudorandom states with fewer than c log ⁡ n -qubit output can be shown to exist unconditionally. We also show that any one-way state generator can be broken by a quantum algorithm with classical access to a P P oracle.An interesting implication of our results is that a t ( n ) -copy one-way state generator exists unconditionally, for every t ( n ) = o ( n / log ⁡ n ) . This contrasts nicely with the previously known fact that O ( n ) -copy one-way state generators require computational hardness. We also outline a new route towards a black-box separation between one-way state generators and quantum bit commitments.

arXiv:2312.08363•Quantum•Mar 27, 2025•22 citations
A key challenge in quantum cryptography is to build quantum one-wayness and pseudorandomness without the use of (quantum computable) one-way functions. So far, this has turned out to be a difficult task, with only a few proposed candidates that are not directly built from one-way functions. Even within these few proposed candidates, we have lacked the techniques to analyze when proposed constructions may inadvertently yield one-way functions. In this work, we introduce efficient NP-aided shadow tomography of quantum states. We prove that collections of {\em computable} pure states can be learned via efficient NP-aided shadow tomography, where we say that a state is computable if the amplitude and phase on any computational basis term can be classically efficiently computed given the description of an efficient preparation circuit for the state. We also give new algorithms for NP-aided learning of unitaries given polynomially many queries to the unitary. By building on this, we show Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
A key challenge in quantum cryptography is to build quantum one-wayness and pseudorandomness without the use of (quantum computable) one-way functions. So far, this has turned out to be a difficult task, with only a few proposed candidates that are not directly built from one-way functions. Even within these few proposed candidates, we have lacked the techniques to analyze when proposed constructions may inadvertently yield one-way functions. In this work, we introduce efficient NP-aided shadow tomography of quantum states. We prove that collections of {\em computable} pure states can be learned via efficient NP-aided shadow tomography, where we say that a state is computable if the amplitude and phase on any computational basis term can be classically efficiently computed given the description of an efficient preparation circuit for the state. We also give new algorithms for NP-aided learning of unitaries given polynomially many queries to the unitary. By building on this, we show that many existing architectures for PRS and PRU, including some that were explicitly introduced for the purposes of avoiding one-way functions (e.g., Hamiltonian Phase States, Bostanci et. al., TQC 2025), actually do imply the existence of one-way functions or imply \(\NP\) hardness. We hope that these no-go results will inform future investigations into building PRS and PRUs from assumptions that are plausibly outside the complexity class NP.
We establish proper agnostic learning of matrix product states and tree tensor networks. Given copies of an arbitrary quantum state ρρρ, our algorithms return a state ∣ψ⟩|ψ\rangle∣ψ⟩ of chosen bond dimension such that ⟨ψ∣ρ∣ψ⟩\langleψ| ρ|ψ\rangle⟨ψ∣ρ∣ψ⟩ is within ε\varepsilonε of the optimum over the model class, without assuming that ρρρ itself belongs to or is well approximated by that class. The main idea is to use improper learning to compress the mixed-state objective, reducing proper agnostic learning to optimization against a finite collection of explicitly specified pure states. We then introduce a comparator-dual compression procedure that reduces the bond dimension of these targets while uniformly preserving their overlaps with all bounded-bond comparators, with an error independent of system size. For matrix product states, this gives polynomial copy complexity in the system size, local dimension, bond dimension, and 1/ε1/\varepsilon1/ε, together with polynomial runtime in the system size for fi Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
We provide the first evidence relative to a classical oracle that pseudorandom unitaries (PRUs) can exist without quantum-computable one-way functions. To obtain this result, we first prove that five independent random diagonal phase layers interleaved with Hadamard transforms U=F5HF4HF3HF2HF1 U=F_5HF_4HF_3HF_2HF_1 U=F5​HF4​HF3​HF2​HF1​ form a strong PRU with security under adaptive, controlled access to the unitary, its inverse, transpose, and complex conjugate. Our main result is that, when the phase layers are implemented using a classical random oracle O, the construction remains secure against uniform BQP adversaries with coherent access to suitable Boolean completions of classical-input $QMA^{PH}^{O}}$ decision problems. Such an adversary can invert (even quantum-computable) one-way functions and solve efficiently verifiable one-way puzzles defined relative to O. Our result therefore provides classical-oracle evidence that PRUs do not imply quantum-computable one-way functions, in the form of a black-box separation. We substantially strengthen the classical-oracle result of Kretschmer, Qian, and Tal (STOC 2025) by obtaining PRUs secure against these QMA-aided adversaries. Our construction also consists of a simple, efficient circuit that queries a random function, suggesting a route to concrete implementation via the random-oracle heuristic.
One-way functions are central to classical cryptography. They are necessary for the existence of non-trivial classical cryptosystems, and also sufficient to realize meaningful primitives including commitments, pseudorandom generators and digital signatures. At the same time, a mounting body of evidence suggests that assumptions even weaker than one-way functions may suffice for many cryptographic tasks of interest in a quantum world, including bit commitments and secure multi-party computation. This work studies one-way state generators [Morimae-Yamakawa, CRYPTO 2022], a natural quantum relaxation of one-way functions. Given a secret key, a one-way state generator outputs a hard to invert quantum state. A fundamental question is whether this type of quantum one-wayness suffices to realize quantum cryptography. We obtain an affirmative answer to this question, by proving that one-way state generators with pure state outputs imply quantum bit commitments and secure multiparty computation. Along the way, we use efficient shadow tomography [Huang et. al., Nature Physics 2020] to build an intermediate primitive with classical outputs, which we call a (quantum) one-way puzzle. Our main technical contribution is a proof that one-way puzzles imply quantum bit commitments. This proof develops new techniques for pseudoentropy generation [Hastad et. al., SICOMP 1999] from arbitrary distributions, which may be of independent interest.
Starting from the entrance of a welded tree, a quantum walk algorithm can find its exit vertex exponentially faster than any classical algorithm. However, it has been an open question whether any quantum algorithm is able to efficiently find a path from the entrance to the exit. We answer this by proving an exponential quantum query lower bound for finding such path. Specifically, for trees of height nnn, any quantum query algorithm requires at least Ω(2n/24)Ω(2^{n/24})Ω(2n/24) queries in order to succeed with constant probability. Our proof uses the compressed permutation oracle technique in order to construct databases which track the graph information an algorithm has learned and forgotten, and show that no efficient quantum algorithm can build an entrance-to-exit path in these records. Source: http://arxiv.org/abs/2609.20651v1 (arXiv:2609.20651v1) Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
There is a large body of work studying what forms of computational hardness are needed to realize classical cryptography. In particular, one-way functions and pseudorandom generators can be built from each other, and thus require equivalent computational assumptions to be realized. Furthermore, the existence of either of these primitives implies that P ≠ N P , which gives a lower bound on the necessary hardness.One can also define versions of each of these primitives with quantum output: respectively one-way state generators and pseudorandom state generators. Unlike in the classical setting, it is not known whether either primitive can be built from the other. Although it has been shown that pseudorandom state generators for certain parameter regimes can be used to build one-way state generators, the implication has not been previously known in full generality. Furthermore, to the best of our knowledge, the existence of one-way state generators has no known implications in complexity theory.We show that pseudorandom states compressing n bits to log ⁡ n + 1 qubits can be used to build one-way state generators and pseudorandom states compressing n bits to ω ( log ⁡ n ) qubits are one-way state generators. This is a nearly optimal result since pseudorandom states with fewer than c log ⁡ n -qubit output can be shown to exist unconditionally. We also show that any one-way state generator can be broken by a quantum algorithm with classical access to a P P oracle.An interesting implication of our results is that a t ( n ) -copy one-way state generator exists unconditionally, for every t ( n ) = o ( n / log ⁡ n ) . This contrasts nicely with the previously known fact that O ( n ) -copy one-way state generators require computational hardness. We also outline a new route towards a black-box separation between one-way state generators and quantum bit commitments.