Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Verifiable and Collusion-Resistant Dynamic Multi-Party Quantum Private Comparison Protocol

Wang Qi, LI Shuai

Published Aug 1, 2026• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

ObjectiveThis paper aims to address the issues of existing Multi-Party Quantum Private Comparison (MQPC) protocols-namely, their reliance on entangled states, weak collusion resistance, poor dynamic scalability, and low qubit efficiency-while realizing a high-security, low-overhead, and dynamically scalable MQPC solution.MethodsA quantum-classical hybrid architecture is adopted in this paper. Global random masks are generated through ring public key encryption. Information-theoretically secure distribution of masks is achieved based on locally indistinguishable Orthogonal Product States (OPS). Private information is encoded via hash obfuscation. Chain-based differential verification is designed to implement private comparison. Dynamic member management is realized relying on Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) and ring structure reconstruction.ResultsUnder the semi-honest model, the protocol can resist external attacks, internal malicious attacks, and collusion attacks by n-1 nodes. Its qubit efficiency reaches a constant level of O (1), which is improved by approximately 50% compared with contrast schemes using entangled states. It supports real-time addition and deletion of participants without interrupting the core process.ConclusionWithout the need for a fully trusted third party or joint measurements, the protocol achieves the unification of security, efficiency, and dynamicity. It breaks through the core limitations of existing MQPC protocols and provides a practical technical solution for Quantum Private Comparison (QPC) in large-scale dynamic distributed scenarios.

Related papers

Multi-party quantum private size comparison protocol with d-dimensional Bell states

Bing Wang, Li-Hua Gong, Sanqiu Liu

A feasible multi-party quantum private comparison (MQPC) protocol based on d -dimensional Bell states was proposed. In the protocol, all participants can independently encrypt their privacies and send them to a semi-honest quantum third party (TP) through authenticated channels. Then, the TP can determine the size relationship among all participants’ privacies without gaining access to the private information. We verified correctness and effectiveness of the proposed protocol with some examples. In addition, compared with other similar protocols, it is not necessary to perform unitary operation on particles and only single-particle measurement is required. Furthermore, the relatively high qubit efficiency is promised. The security analysis verifies that the proposed protocol can counteract external and internal attacks in theory.

Frontiers in Physics•Aug 22, 2022•14 citations

Multi-Party Quantum Private Comparison Based on Bell States

Wanqing Wu, Jiahui Wu, LingNa Guo

Multi-party quantum private comparison (MQPC) assumes responsibility for overseeing the flow of data and communication among diverse entities, wherein it boasts powerful security capabilities that have garnered substantial attention. Most current MQPC protocols rely on difficult-to-prepare quantum states and are inefficient in their use of resources. In this paper, we propose a novel MQPC protocol without entanglement swapping, thereby building upon the assumption of an ideal channel. This protocol is based on Bell states, which simplifies implementation and addresses the challenges associated with using complex quantum states; it also enables the comparison of secret information by having a trusted party prepare and transmit encoded quantum sequences to participants, thereby facilitating efficient equality comparison among all parties. Our MQPC protocol showcased remarkable efficiency in comparison to existing protocols for quantum private comparison. Furthermore, the incorporation of decoy photon and shared key technologies made external and internal attacks ineffective, thereby ensuring the utmost security and integrity of the protocol.

Entropy•Aug 2, 2023•9 citations

Multiparty Quantum Private Comparison Protocol Using n-Particle GHZ State

Min Hou, Yue Wu, Shibin Zhang

Multiparty quantum private comparison (MQPC) aims to determine the equality relationship of inputs from multiple participants while maintaining the confidentiality of these inputs. Current MQPC protocols primarily focus on utilizing d-level quantum states, which limits feasible implementation. To address this issue, we introduce an MQPC protocol that utilizes n-particle Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state to enable private comparison while preserving the secrecy of individual inputs. A semi-honest third party (TP), adhering to protocol specifications but potentially curious about private data, generates and distributes GHZ state qubits to all participants. Each party encodes their secret input through rotation operations on their allocated qubits and returns the modified state to the TP, which then performs single-particle quantum measurements to derive the outcomes without accessing the raw inputs. The protocol’s sequence distribution method yields a high qubit efficiency of 1/n, outperforming many existing MQPC protocols. Security analysis confirms resilience against external adversaries employing quantum attack strategies and collusion attempts among participants. Simulations using IBM Qiskit validate the feasibility of the protocol, which relies on GHZ state preparation, single-qubit operations, and single-particle quantum measurements.

Mathematics•Oct 27, 2025•2 citations

Multi-party quantum private comparison of size relationship with two third parties based on d-dimensional Bell states

Jiang-Yuan Lian, Xia Li, Tian-Yu Ye

Abstract In this paper, we put forward a multi-party quantum private comparison (MQPC) protocol with two semi-honest third parties (TPs) by adopting d -dimensional Bell states, which can judge the size relationship of private integers from more than two users within one execution of protocol. Each TP is permitted to misbehave on her own but cannot collude with others. In the proposed MQPC protocol, TPs are only required to apply d -dimensional single-particle measurements rather than d -dimensional Bell state measurements. There are no quantum entanglement swapping and unitary operations required in the proposed MQPC protocol. The security analysis validates that the proposed MQPC protocol can resist both the outside attacks and the participant attacks. The proposed MQPC protocol is adaptive for the case that n users want to compare the size relationship of their private integers under the control of two supervisors. Furthermore, the proposed MQPC protocol can be used in the strange user environment, because there are not any communication and pre-shared key between each pair of users.

arXiv:2210.13688•Physica Scripta•Jan 25, 2023•20 citations

A semi-quantum private comparison protocol based on hybrid quantum states

Yan Hou, Jian Li, S. Liu +1 more

Abstract Semi-quantum private comparison (SQPC) is a quantum cryptographic protocol that allows two classical participants to securely determine whether their private inputs are equal, with the assistance of a semi-honest third party possessing full quantum capabilities. However, most existing SQPC protocols suffer from low qubit efficiency and high implementation costs, primarily due to their reliance on pre-shared keys and complex entangled state preparations. To address these limitations, we propose a novel SQPC protocol based on hybrid quantum states, which integrates Bell states and single-qubit states within a circular transmission architecture. The protocol eliminates the requirement for pre-shared keys and reduces consumption of quantum resources by introducing randomness in the placement of quantum states. Security analysis demonstrates that the proposed protocol is robust against measure–resend attacks, entanglement measurement attacks and internal threats from dishonest participants. Furthermore, performance evaluation shows that the proposed protocol achieves a high qubit efficiency, quantified as η = n 10 n + 1 , where n is the number of bits compared. This efficiency surpasses that of several previously proposed SQPC protocols.

Laser Physics Letters•Nov 1, 2025•2 citations

Quantum Private Comparison Protocol with Cluster States

Min Hou, Yue Wu

In this paper, we introduce a quantum private comparison (QPC) protocol designed for two players to securely and privately assess the equality of their private information. The protocol utilizes four-particle cluster states prepared by a semi-honest third party (TP), who strictly adheres to the protocol without deviation or collusion with any participant. The TP facilitates the private comparison by enabling users to encode their information through bit-flip or phase-shift operators applied to the received quantum sequences. Once the information is encoded, the sequences are returned to the TP, who can derive the comparison results without accessing any details of the private information. This design ensures correctness, privacy, and fairness throughout the process. The QPC protocol is robust against both external threats and participant attacks due to the incorporation of the decoy-state method and quantum key distribution techniques. Additionally, the protocol employs unitary operations and Bell-basis measurements, enhancing its technical feasibility for practical implementation. Notably, the proposed protocol achieves a qubit efficiency of up to 50%. This efficiency, combined with its strong security features, establishes the QPC protocol as a promising solution for private information comparisons within the realm of quantum cryptography.

Axioms•Jan 19, 2025•6 citations
ObjectiveThis paper aims to address the issues of existing Multi-Party Quantum Private Comparison (MQPC) protocols-namely, their reliance on entangled states, weak collusion resistance, poor dynamic scalability, and low qubit efficiency-while realizing a high-security, low-overhead, and dynamically scalable MQPC solution.MethodsA quantum-classical hybrid architecture is adopted in this paper. Global random masks are generated through ring public key encryption. Information-theoretically secure distribution of masks is achieved based on locally indistinguishable Orthogonal Product States (OPS). Private information is encoded via hash obfuscation. Chain-based differential verification is designed to implement private comparison. Dynamic member management is realized relying on Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) and ring structure reconstruction.ResultsUnder the semi-honest model, the protocol can resist external attacks, internal malicious attacks, and collusion attacks by n-1 nodes. Its qubit efficiency reaches a constant level of O (1), which is improved by approximately 50% compared with contrast schemes using entangled states. It supports real-time addition and deletion of participants without interrupting the core process.ConclusionWithout the need for a fully trusted third party or joint measurements, the protocol achieves the unification of security, efficiency, and dynamicity. It breaks through the core limitations of existing MQPC protocols and provides a practical technical solution for Quantum Private Comparison (QPC) in large-scale dynamic distributed scenarios.
A feasible multi-party quantum private comparison (MQPC) protocol based on d -dimensional Bell states was proposed. In the protocol, all participants can independently encrypt their privacies and send them to a semi-honest quantum third party (TP) through authenticated channels. Then, the TP can determine the size relationship among all participants’ privacies without gaining access to the private information. We verified correctness and effectiveness of the proposed protocol with some examples. In addition, compared with other similar protocols, it is not necessary to perform unitary operation on particles and only single-particle measurement is required. Furthermore, the relatively high qubit efficiency is promised. The security analysis verifies that the proposed protocol can counteract external and internal attacks in theory.
Multi-party quantum private comparison (MQPC) assumes responsibility for overseeing the flow of data and communication among diverse entities, wherein it boasts powerful security capabilities that have garnered substantial attention. Most current MQPC protocols rely on difficult-to-prepare quantum states and are inefficient in their use of resources. In this paper, we propose a novel MQPC protocol without entanglement swapping, thereby building upon the assumption of an ideal channel. This protocol is based on Bell states, which simplifies implementation and addresses the challenges associated with using complex quantum states; it also enables the comparison of secret information by having a trusted party prepare and transmit encoded quantum sequences to participants, thereby facilitating efficient equality comparison among all parties. Our MQPC protocol showcased remarkable efficiency in comparison to existing protocols for quantum private comparison. Furthermore, the incorporation of decoy photon and shared key technologies made external and internal attacks ineffective, thereby ensuring the utmost security and integrity of the protocol.
Multiparty quantum private comparison (MQPC) aims to determine the equality relationship of inputs from multiple participants while maintaining the confidentiality of these inputs. Current MQPC protocols primarily focus on utilizing d-level quantum states, which limits feasible implementation. To address this issue, we introduce an MQPC protocol that utilizes n-particle Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) state to enable private comparison while preserving the secrecy of individual inputs. A semi-honest third party (TP), adhering to protocol specifications but potentially curious about private data, generates and distributes GHZ state qubits to all participants. Each party encodes their secret input through rotation operations on their allocated qubits and returns the modified state to the TP, which then performs single-particle quantum measurements to derive the outcomes without accessing the raw inputs. The protocol’s sequence distribution method yields a high qubit efficiency of 1/n, outperforming many existing MQPC protocols. Security analysis confirms resilience against external adversaries employing quantum attack strategies and collusion attempts among participants. Simulations using IBM Qiskit validate the feasibility of the protocol, which relies on GHZ state preparation, single-qubit operations, and single-particle quantum measurements.
Abstract In this paper, we put forward a multi-party quantum private comparison (MQPC) protocol with two semi-honest third parties (TPs) by adopting d -dimensional Bell states, which can judge the size relationship of private integers from more than two users within one execution of protocol. Each TP is permitted to misbehave on her own but cannot collude with others. In the proposed MQPC protocol, TPs are only required to apply d -dimensional single-particle measurements rather than d -dimensional Bell state measurements. There are no quantum entanglement swapping and unitary operations required in the proposed MQPC protocol. The security analysis validates that the proposed MQPC protocol can resist both the outside attacks and the participant attacks. The proposed MQPC protocol is adaptive for the case that n users want to compare the size relationship of their private integers under the control of two supervisors. Furthermore, the proposed MQPC protocol can be used in the strange user environment, because there are not any communication and pre-shared key between each pair of users.
Abstract Semi-quantum private comparison (SQPC) is a quantum cryptographic protocol that allows two classical participants to securely determine whether their private inputs are equal, with the assistance of a semi-honest third party possessing full quantum capabilities. However, most existing SQPC protocols suffer from low qubit efficiency and high implementation costs, primarily due to their reliance on pre-shared keys and complex entangled state preparations. To address these limitations, we propose a novel SQPC protocol based on hybrid quantum states, which integrates Bell states and single-qubit states within a circular transmission architecture. The protocol eliminates the requirement for pre-shared keys and reduces consumption of quantum resources by introducing randomness in the placement of quantum states. Security analysis demonstrates that the proposed protocol is robust against measure–resend attacks, entanglement measurement attacks and internal threats from dishonest participants. Furthermore, performance evaluation shows that the proposed protocol achieves a high qubit efficiency, quantified as η = n 10 n + 1 , where n is the number of bits compared. This efficiency surpasses that of several previously proposed SQPC protocols.
In this paper, we introduce a quantum private comparison (QPC) protocol designed for two players to securely and privately assess the equality of their private information. The protocol utilizes four-particle cluster states prepared by a semi-honest third party (TP), who strictly adheres to the protocol without deviation or collusion with any participant. The TP facilitates the private comparison by enabling users to encode their information through bit-flip or phase-shift operators applied to the received quantum sequences. Once the information is encoded, the sequences are returned to the TP, who can derive the comparison results without accessing any details of the private information. This design ensures correctness, privacy, and fairness throughout the process. The QPC protocol is robust against both external threats and participant attacks due to the incorporation of the decoy-state method and quantum key distribution techniques. Additionally, the protocol employs unitary operations and Bell-basis measurements, enhancing its technical feasibility for practical implementation. Notably, the proposed protocol achieves a qubit efficiency of up to 50%. This efficiency, combined with its strong security features, establishes the QPC protocol as a promising solution for private information comparisons within the realm of quantum cryptography.