The collective charging advantage Γ of a quantum battery is a ratio, and noise can raise it even while the battery’s own charging power falls. This paper shows how noise and its correlations set Γ in an idealized global N-body charger, a Dicke cavity battery and two all-to-all two-body chargers.Exact results: local pure dephasing maps the N-cell dynamics onto single-cell dynamics run N times faster, so Γ = N for equal rates. A common-mode share c of the dephasing enters as an effective rate γ_φ[1 + (N − 1)c], so Γ/N depends only on x = (N − 1)c and, for fixed c, levels off at a closed-form constant.Numerical results: local noise raises Γ while power per cell falls; collective dephasing does not. Γ alone therefore cannot rank batteries, and absolute power per cell should be reported with it.Code and data: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.34989034
The collective charging advantage Γ of a quantum battery is a ratio, and noise can raise it even while the battery’s own charging power falls. This paper shows how noise and its correlations set Γ in an idealized global N-body charger, a Dicke cavity battery and two all-to-all two-body chargers.Exact results: local pure dephasing maps the N-cell dynamics onto single-cell dynamics run N times faster, so Γ = N for equal rates. A common-mode share c of the dephasing enters as an effective rate γ_φ[1 + (N − 1)c], so Γ/N depends only on x = (N − 1)c and, for fixed c, levels off at a closed-form constant.Numerical results: local noise raises Γ while power per cell falls; collective dephasing does not. Γ alone therefore cannot rank batteries, and absolute power per cell should be reported with it.Code and data: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.34989034
We study the influence of single-atom dissipation and dephasing noise on the performance of Dicke and Tavis-Cummings quantum batteries, where the electromagnetic field of the cavity hosting the system acts as a charger. For these models a genuine charging process can only occur in the transient regime. Indeed, unless the interaction with the environment is cut off, the asymptotic energy of the battery is solely determined by the environment and does not depend on the initial energy of the electromagnetic field. We numerically estimate the fundamental figures of merit for the model, including the time at which the battery reaches its maximum ergotropy, the average energy, and the energy that needs to be used to switch the battery-charger interaction on and off. Depending on the scaling of the coupling between the battery and the charger, we show that the model can still exhibit a subextensive charging time. However, for the Dicke battery, this effect comes with a higher cost when switching the battery-charger interaction on and off. We also show that as the number of battery constituents increases, both the Dicke and Tavis-Cummings models become asymptotically free, meaning the amount of energy that is not unitarily extractable becomes negligible. We obtain this result numerically and demonstrate analytically that it is a consequence of the symmetry under permutations of the model. Finally, we perform simulations for different values of the detuning, showing that the optimal regime for the Dicke battery is off-resonance, in contrast with what is observed in the Tavis-Cummings case.
A solvable charger--battery model is introduced in which quantum coherence controls both where a quantum battery's charge is stored and how robustly it survives noise. Charging converts the charger's coherence into charger--battery entanglement and splits the deposited work between a locally extractable part and a correlation-locked part accessible only through joint operations; for a qubit, the split obeys an exact complementarity, and at maximal coherence, the battery is locally passive with the entire charge locked in correlations. Robustness follows local accessibility: the stored energy and locally extractable work are population-based, immune to pure dephasing, and limited only by relaxation, with an energy half-life, whereas the correlation-locked work is fragile to both dephasing and relaxation. Dephasing, global and local depolarization, and amplitude damping are treated through a single gain--loss competition algebra, and the resulting storage lifetimes are made concrete with superconducting-transmon parameters.
In the Letter [Physical Review Letters 120, 117702 (2018)], Ferraro \emph{et al.} claimed a quantum advantage in the Dicke quantum battery (QB), whereby N two-level systems (TLS) are coupled to a common photonic mode of a cavity. They argued that compared with the so-called Rabi QB, the Dicke QB exhibits a N quantum enhancement in the charging power because of the entanglement created by the common photonic mode. In this Comment, however, we demonstrate that the apparent N enhancement actually comes from the stronger cavity electric (or magnetic) field under the setup discussed in [Physical Review Letters 120, 117702 (2018)]. This is a trivial classical effect, and there is no true "quantum advantage" in the charging power of the Dicke QB. While somewhat similar questions regarding the origin of the claimed "quantum advantage" have been raised before, here we would like to make it clear that the N enhancement in [Physical Review Letters 120, 117702 (2018)] is purely a classical effect, not attributable to quantum entanglement or collective phenomena. Therefore, we believe that using the term "quantum battery" in this context may be inappropriate and misleading.
Charging a quantum battery through a pumped charger can lock a substantial part of its stored energy inside the bipartite correlations that grow between the constituent cells, and this \emph{correlation ergotropy}, being the energy that no local single-cell operation can reach and that only collective operations can recover, is the object of the present study. Following the charging trajectory of two coupled three-level cells, we find that the correlation ergotropy closely tracks the logarithmic negativity, which shows that the locked energy is carried by genuine bipartite entanglement rather than by coherent collective dynamics alone, and that an equal-strength coherent non-entangling drive produces no such locking at all. For a pure two-cell battery we establish an exact, basis-independent closed form in which the locked energy depends only on the sorted eigenvalues of the reduced cell and the cell energy levels, revealing that the locked fraction rises from zero at the separable corners of the Schmidt simplex to unity at the symmetric maximally entangled state and remains invariant under local unitaries. Decoherence and dephasing, which destroy the correlations, do \emph{not} release this energy but erase it, so extraction must be collective and must take place while the correlations persist, while cold damping leaves the effect intact and thermal occupation suppresses it. These results give a resource-theoretic reading of correlations in quantum batteries, sharpen the line between genuine entanglement and coherent collective dynamics, and point to experimentally accessible conditions for correlated-charge and collective-extraction protocols.
Quantum information theorems state that it is possible to exploit collective quantum resources to greatly enhance the charging power of quantum batteries (QBs) made of many identical elementary units. We here present and solve a model of a QB that can be engineered in solid-state architectures. It consists of N two-level systems coupled to a single photonic mode in a cavity. We contrast this collective model ("Dicke QB"), whereby entanglement is genuinely created by the common photonic mode, to the one in which each two-level system is coupled to its own separate cavity mode ("Rabi QB"). By employing exact diagonalization, we demonstrate the emergence of a quantum advantage in the charging power of Dicke QBs, which scales like sqrt[N] for N≫1.
We investigate charging dynamics in many-body quantum batteries by examining the relationship between instantaneous charging power and the emergence of bipartite, tripartite, and multipartite quantum correlations across different battery--charger configurations. We find that the charging power reaches its maximum before the correlation measures peak, revealing a temporal separation between rapid energy transfer and the buildup of quantum correlations. We further study the role of interaction structure using local and many-body charging Hamiltonians for both unconstrained and constrained charging protocols, in which the total available charging resources are fixed to scale proportionally with the number of spins, thereby isolating the influence of interaction geometry and particle participation on the charging dynamics. In the unconstrained case, the enhanced charging energy observed for higher-order interactions originates primarily from the larger energy scale of the corresponding charging Hamiltonian. Under constrained conditions, however, increasing the interaction order alone provides no advantage over parallel charging when interaction and local spin-flip contributions are balanced, whereas interaction-dominated protocols significantly enhance charging performance, highlighting the importance of collective many-body dynamics. Fully collective interactions yield the largest enhancement in charging power together with stronger multipartite correlations, while partially collective interactions provide only limited improvements. Finally, extending the interaction range through next-nearest-neighbor couplings suppresses the charging power, demonstrating that, under constrained energetic resources, charging performance is governed primarily by interaction structure, particle participation, and collective many-body dynamics rather than by interaction order alone.