Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Intrinsic Classification of Quantum Sequential Growth: Gram Kernels, First-Junction Realization, and the Equivalence of Bell Conventions

Thomas G Hamilton

Published Nov 9, 2026• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In quantum sequential growth of causal sets, the coherent predictions for finite histories are summarized by the Gram kernel of the reached history vectors, which fixes all finite-cylinder interference. A formally consistent kernel need not come from any complete growth dynamics, so a realization criterion decides which candidate quantum causal processes are admissible. For finite-dimensional, causal-past-ordered growth, and building on the operational descent and Bell-convention results of a preceding paper, we answer two questions. Realizability: a kernel arises from a complete direct-Bell model if and only if it satisfies five intrinsic conditions. Four of them (normalization, positivity and refinement; invertible graft graphs; commutation; Markov invertibility) reconstruct the unique minimal commutative late dynamics, and a first-junction rank condition decides whether that dynamics lifts. Sufficiency is proved by an injective-envelope dilation, which yields a full broad-Bell model on a carrier of dimension at most 2·dim(U)·rank(K), also when the relevant algebra is nonsemisimple. Consequently direct, source-faithful and broad Bell causality have identical kernel classes, despite their different full-matrix model classes. Observational completeness: apart from the empty/singleton pair, two finite causal sets are identified by every such model exactly when they have equal size and equal augmented past-profile multisets. Explicit examples show that a realizable kernel can require a carrier larger than its reached space, and that a consistent reduced kernel can fail the first-junction condition. We separate these finite-cylinder results from own-core classification, infinite-history extension and finite-prefix recognition. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds twelve standalone Python programs that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the programs use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all twelve programs and reports ALL 12 PROGRAMS PASSED. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the programs are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Fourth paper in a series; it builds directly on T. G. Hamilton, "Which Bell causality? Operational abelianization and a Rideout–Sorkin theorem for quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24083829, which in turn follows doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143 and doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D as a companion to “Which Bell causality?” (doi:10.5281/zenodo.24181929). Mathematics unchanged; presentation, references and the statement of the own-core open problem updated.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.24085714

Related papers

Which Bell Causality? Operational Abelianization and a Rideout–Sorkin Theorem for Quantum Sequential Growth

Thomas G Hamilton

Classical Rideout–Sorkin growth is constrained by Bell-type spectator independence, whose equivalent scalar formulations need not remain equivalent for noncommuting quantum transitions. We ask which comparison domains matter for the finite-cylinder predictions of causal-past-ordered quantum sequential growth. Four conventions are distinguished: own-core, direct, source-faithful, and broad. With invertible finite-dimensional transitions, an operator Markov sum rule, and strict covariance of reached vectors, direct Bell implies a parent-independent precursor factorization and a faithful commutative algebra on the reached module. This yields an algebra-valued Rideout–Sorkin reconstruction with a single exceptional junction correction. Although the four conventions have strictly different full-matrix solution classes, the operator defects in three separating examples are invisible on reached states. By contrast, an explicit all-stage rank-two own-core model violates a direct-Bell graft constraint at the level of its Gram kernel, establishing a genuine predictive separation. An all-stage broad-Bell example and a general visibility criterion show that the junction correction can also affect finite-cylinder interference. These results distinguish full operator identities from reached dynamics and coherent finite-cylinder data; they do not claim an extension to covariant infinite-history events. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds ten standalone Python scripts that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all ten certificates and reports ALL PASS. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the scripts are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Third paper in a series, following T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788, and "Bell causality and operational rigidity in quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D. Adds a mechanism theorem for own-core predictive separation in a stated class of complete models: all normalized precursor factors commute, the only possible obstruction is the two-chain graft, all nine birth-six target pairs are decided, and the complete Gram kernel is direct-Bell realizable if and only if the three-chain growth weight is not split. Exact-arithmetic certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24159976.

•Nov 9, 2026•1 citation

Structure and rigidity of own-core quantum sequential growth

Thomas G Hamilton

A causal set represents discrete events and their causal ordering, while quantum sequential growth assigns coherent vectors to alternative birth histories. Earlier work showed that a weak, “own-core” form of Bell causality can permit finite-cylinder predictions forbidden by stronger forms. This article asks how rigid that extra freedom is, including when the first nonempty transition is nonscalar. We exhaust the nonsingular two-dimensional cyclic scalar-singleton chart. At its noncommuting witness, the exact birth-six Jacobian has 348 variables, rank 340, and kernel dimension eight; at birth seven it has 1,620 variables, rank 1,611, and kernel dimension nine. An explicit invertible all-stage family integrates every tangent in both kernels, giving smooth finite-cutoff solution germs. We also determine the role of nonscalar singleton transitions on a two-dimensional carrier with one common gregarious matrix from size three onward. Bell causality alone does not force broad Bell, as an exact noncovariant counterexample demonstrates. In contrast, strict reached-vector covariance and full spanning force each nonscalar model on this locus to satisfy broad Bell on its original matrices, even when early gregarious matrices do not commute. Consequently, on the complete spanning two-dimensional common-matrix locus, own-core predictions exceed the direct-Bell class exactly for a scalar singleton with a split three-chain weight. Explicit all-stage nonscalar models show that kernels outside the scalar-singleton class do exist but already satisfy broad Bell. Block-extension spaces and three-dimensional slices delimit the result. Higher-dimensional, nonspanning and non-common-matrix cases remain open.

•Nov 13, 2026•0 citations

Bell Causality and Operational Rigidity in Quantum Sequential Growth: What noncommuting transition operators can do on reachable causal-set histories

Thomas G Hamilton

A quantum sequential-growth dynamics should allow interference between causal-set histories while respecting the causal and relabelling principles that constrain classical growth. Recent work on causal-past-ordered Bell causality (CPOBC) allows noncommuting transition operators, raising a physical question: can this algebraic freedom act nontrivially on histories that the dynamics actually prepares? For invertible operator-valued growth satisfying the operator Markov sum rule and strict state-vector covariance, we prove a dimension-independent answer for immediate sibling births. At every reached parent with at least two elements, the gregarious operators of its children act identically on the parent's state, and all same-parent transition commutators annihilate that state. The proof uses only source-faithful spectator reductions; it assumes neither operator-level covariance nor global factorization. An all-stage dark-sector model shows why this is not a theorem of operator commutativity. The local conclusion strengthens to the full cyclic module generated by the transitions of any fixed reached parent, ruling out an irreducible transition algebra on that parent for carrier dimension at least two. Conditional reductions and three-dimensional examples delineate the surviving possibilities, including a measure-level effect at the exceptional singleton junction. To our knowledge, this on-state rigidity consequence has not previously been isolated for this CPOBC convention. We identify, but do not resolve, the question of independent non-sibling quantum-measure effects at later births. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds seven standalone Python scripts that reproduce every finite-stage computation in the paper, using exact rational or algebraic-number arithmetic. It also contains logs, result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle, create an empty folder, and from it run: python -I ../certificates/run_all.py. All outputs are written to the current folder. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Companion to T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.

•Nov 6, 2026•1 citation

Reconstructability of background-independent growth dynamics: Markovianity, cocycles, and reflection positivity without reflections

Mingdong He

Reflection positivity (RP) is the single positivity statement through which a Euclidean path integral is promoted to a unitary real-time quantum theory (Osterwalder–Schrader reconstruction). Its classical proofs consult a geometric reflection — an involutive automorphism fixing a hyperplane — which a randomly grown geometry generically lacks. This preprint shows that on ensembles of sequentially assembled geometries the positivity structure survives, and that it is carried entirely by the measure: RP holds if and only if the growth dynamics is memoryless on isomorphism classes. Characterization. Class-level Markovianity, class-local product form with terminal normalization, and history-independent Gram realizability of the conditional chain forms are equivalent; the multiplicative cocycle identity is derived as the Markov property in multiplicative form, not hypothesized separately. Explicit spectrum. Under these conditions the chain form is block-diagonal over terminal classes with rank-one blocks; the positive spectrum equals the arrival measure of the class process, independent of the phase rule — phases act only on the eigenbasis, identifying the chain form with the decoherent diagonal. Sharpness. Outside the class, failure is not gradual: a history-dependent weight family violates the class Markov property with exact rational witnesses (1/60 ≠ 9/260, 1/30 ≠ 3/130), and no Gram realization exists. Physical anchoring. The covariant Rideout–Sorkin family of classical sequential growth dynamics for causal sets satisfies the hypotheses, so all theorems apply verbatim: its chain forms are positive semidefinite at every depth. A dictionary instantiates the framework in causal dynamical triangulations, group field theory and spin foams, tensor/matrix models, and causal sets. Verification. All statements verified by exhaustive exact enumeration in rational arithmetic through graph size eight (isomorphism classes 1–3–14–86–709–8534; full depth-two assembly over all 85,393 paths), across six weight families and three degree bounds.

•Aug 1, 2026•0 citations

Statewise versus operator Bell causality in finite quantum sequential growth: exact separation and recovery at dimension two

Kenichi Osaki

We present a bounded analysis of the finite, nonsingular, occurrence-ON quantum sequential-growth presentation at dimension d=2 and source stages n<=4. The preprint records five ledger-bound results: a frozen strong/strong commutativity baseline; an exact rational fixed-vector/general-covariance and reachable-state/martingale witness of noncommutativity; a source-native Eq. (120) lemma; commutativity on a proper reconstruction slice; and conditional statewise-to-operator recovery lemmas. Its purpose is to make the distinction between statewise and operator semantics auditable, rather than to classify all finite semantics. In particular, it does not claim the full 955 or 721 profiles, a complete finite occurrence-ON classification, or a reachable-visible witness. The bounded U2 auxiliary-ideal investigation is retained as a reproducibility and resource-boundary record, not as a unit-ideal theorem.

•Aug 9, 2026•1 citation

Causal Composition and Unique Quantum Time in a Relational History Model

Yasuhiko Suzuki

# paper-I-v1.0.0 ## Causal Composition and Unique Quantum Time in a Relational History Model **Linear-extension measures, Fock representations, and self-adjoint evolution** This is the first stable public release of QRST Paper I. ## Highlights - Exact separation of unrestricted graph, causal-poset, and causal-Dyson history theories. - Finite-history correspondence with independent Wick and Fock/Dyson constructions. - Explicit causal-poset cut anomaly and a uniqueness theorem for the linear-extension measure. - Fourier reduction of the two-colour generator to two scalar Jacobi operators. - Sharp self-adjointness split between pure branching and nonzero recombination. - Extension-blind finite moments despite extension-dependent spectra and real-time dynamics. ## Epistemic status Large-order coefficient growth, spectral Assumption A, and Lambert-W asymptotics are deliberately excluded and treated in Paper II. ## Included - compiled manuscript PDF and complete LaTeX source; - figures and bibliography; - reproducibility code and tests; - claim matrix and reproducibility map; - build-validation records; - SHA-256 checksums and upload manifest. ## Citation and DOI The preferred citation is recorded in `CITATION.cff`. The Zenodo DOI will be added after the manual deposit is published. ## Integrity Run `python scripts/verify_integrity.py` after downloading the release asset.

•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations
In quantum sequential growth of causal sets, the coherent predictions for finite histories are summarized by the Gram kernel of the reached history vectors, which fixes all finite-cylinder interference. A formally consistent kernel need not come from any complete growth dynamics, so a realization criterion decides which candidate quantum causal processes are admissible. For finite-dimensional, causal-past-ordered growth, and building on the operational descent and Bell-convention results of a preceding paper, we answer two questions. Realizability: a kernel arises from a complete direct-Bell model if and only if it satisfies five intrinsic conditions. Four of them (normalization, positivity and refinement; invertible graft graphs; commutation; Markov invertibility) reconstruct the unique minimal commutative late dynamics, and a first-junction rank condition decides whether that dynamics lifts. Sufficiency is proved by an injective-envelope dilation, which yields a full broad-Bell model on a carrier of dimension at most 2·dim(U)·rank(K), also when the relevant algebra is nonsemisimple. Consequently direct, source-faithful and broad Bell causality have identical kernel classes, despite their different full-matrix model classes. Observational completeness: apart from the empty/singleton pair, two finite causal sets are identified by every such model exactly when they have equal size and equal augmented past-profile multisets. Explicit examples show that a realizable kernel can require a carrier larger than its reached space, and that a consistent reduced kernel can fail the first-junction condition. We separate these finite-cylinder results from own-core classification, infinite-history extension and finite-prefix recognition. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds twelve standalone Python programs that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the programs use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all twelve programs and reports ALL 12 PROGRAMS PASSED. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the programs are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Fourth paper in a series; it builds directly on T. G. Hamilton, "Which Bell causality? Operational abelianization and a Rideout–Sorkin theorem for quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24083829, which in turn follows doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143 and doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D as a companion to “Which Bell causality?” (doi:10.5281/zenodo.24181929). Mathematics unchanged; presentation, references and the statement of the own-core open problem updated.
Classical Rideout–Sorkin growth is constrained by Bell-type spectator independence, whose equivalent scalar formulations need not remain equivalent for noncommuting quantum transitions. We ask which comparison domains matter for the finite-cylinder predictions of causal-past-ordered quantum sequential growth. Four conventions are distinguished: own-core, direct, source-faithful, and broad. With invertible finite-dimensional transitions, an operator Markov sum rule, and strict covariance of reached vectors, direct Bell implies a parent-independent precursor factorization and a faithful commutative algebra on the reached module. This yields an algebra-valued Rideout–Sorkin reconstruction with a single exceptional junction correction. Although the four conventions have strictly different full-matrix solution classes, the operator defects in three separating examples are invisible on reached states. By contrast, an explicit all-stage rank-two own-core model violates a direct-Bell graft constraint at the level of its Gram kernel, establishing a genuine predictive separation. An all-stage broad-Bell example and a general visibility criterion show that the junction correction can also affect finite-cylinder interference. These results distinguish full operator identities from reached dynamics and coherent finite-cylinder data; they do not claim an extension to covariant infinite-history events. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds ten standalone Python scripts that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all ten certificates and reports ALL PASS. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the scripts are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Third paper in a series, following T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788, and "Bell causality and operational rigidity in quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D. Adds a mechanism theorem for own-core predictive separation in a stated class of complete models: all normalized precursor factors commute, the only possible obstruction is the two-chain graft, all nine birth-six target pairs are decided, and the complete Gram kernel is direct-Bell realizable if and only if the three-chain growth weight is not split. Exact-arithmetic certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24159976.
A causal set represents discrete events and their causal ordering, while quantum sequential growth assigns coherent vectors to alternative birth histories. Earlier work showed that a weak, “own-core” form of Bell causality can permit finite-cylinder predictions forbidden by stronger forms. This article asks how rigid that extra freedom is, including when the first nonempty transition is nonscalar. We exhaust the nonsingular two-dimensional cyclic scalar-singleton chart. At its noncommuting witness, the exact birth-six Jacobian has 348 variables, rank 340, and kernel dimension eight; at birth seven it has 1,620 variables, rank 1,611, and kernel dimension nine. An explicit invertible all-stage family integrates every tangent in both kernels, giving smooth finite-cutoff solution germs. We also determine the role of nonscalar singleton transitions on a two-dimensional carrier with one common gregarious matrix from size three onward. Bell causality alone does not force broad Bell, as an exact noncovariant counterexample demonstrates. In contrast, strict reached-vector covariance and full spanning force each nonscalar model on this locus to satisfy broad Bell on its original matrices, even when early gregarious matrices do not commute. Consequently, on the complete spanning two-dimensional common-matrix locus, own-core predictions exceed the direct-Bell class exactly for a scalar singleton with a split three-chain weight. Explicit all-stage nonscalar models show that kernels outside the scalar-singleton class do exist but already satisfy broad Bell. Block-extension spaces and three-dimensional slices delimit the result. Higher-dimensional, nonspanning and non-common-matrix cases remain open.
A quantum sequential-growth dynamics should allow interference between causal-set histories while respecting the causal and relabelling principles that constrain classical growth. Recent work on causal-past-ordered Bell causality (CPOBC) allows noncommuting transition operators, raising a physical question: can this algebraic freedom act nontrivially on histories that the dynamics actually prepares? For invertible operator-valued growth satisfying the operator Markov sum rule and strict state-vector covariance, we prove a dimension-independent answer for immediate sibling births. At every reached parent with at least two elements, the gregarious operators of its children act identically on the parent's state, and all same-parent transition commutators annihilate that state. The proof uses only source-faithful spectator reductions; it assumes neither operator-level covariance nor global factorization. An all-stage dark-sector model shows why this is not a theorem of operator commutativity. The local conclusion strengthens to the full cyclic module generated by the transitions of any fixed reached parent, ruling out an irreducible transition algebra on that parent for carrier dimension at least two. Conditional reductions and three-dimensional examples delineate the surviving possibilities, including a measure-level effect at the exceptional singleton junction. To our knowledge, this on-state rigidity consequence has not previously been isolated for this CPOBC convention. We identify, but do not resolve, the question of independent non-sibling quantum-measure effects at later births. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds seven standalone Python scripts that reproduce every finite-stage computation in the paper, using exact rational or algebraic-number arithmetic. It also contains logs, result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle, create an empty folder, and from it run: python -I ../certificates/run_all.py. All outputs are written to the current folder. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Companion to T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788.
Reflection positivity (RP) is the single positivity statement through which a Euclidean path integral is promoted to a unitary real-time quantum theory (Osterwalder–Schrader reconstruction). Its classical proofs consult a geometric reflection — an involutive automorphism fixing a hyperplane — which a randomly grown geometry generically lacks. This preprint shows that on ensembles of sequentially assembled geometries the positivity structure survives, and that it is carried entirely by the measure: RP holds if and only if the growth dynamics is memoryless on isomorphism classes. Characterization. Class-level Markovianity, class-local product form with terminal normalization, and history-independent Gram realizability of the conditional chain forms are equivalent; the multiplicative cocycle identity is derived as the Markov property in multiplicative form, not hypothesized separately. Explicit spectrum. Under these conditions the chain form is block-diagonal over terminal classes with rank-one blocks; the positive spectrum equals the arrival measure of the class process, independent of the phase rule — phases act only on the eigenbasis, identifying the chain form with the decoherent diagonal. Sharpness. Outside the class, failure is not gradual: a history-dependent weight family violates the class Markov property with exact rational witnesses (1/60 ≠ 9/260, 1/30 ≠ 3/130), and no Gram realization exists. Physical anchoring. The covariant Rideout–Sorkin family of classical sequential growth dynamics for causal sets satisfies the hypotheses, so all theorems apply verbatim: its chain forms are positive semidefinite at every depth. A dictionary instantiates the framework in causal dynamical triangulations, group field theory and spin foams, tensor/matrix models, and causal sets. Verification. All statements verified by exhaustive exact enumeration in rational arithmetic through graph size eight (isomorphism classes 1–3–14–86–709–8534; full depth-two assembly over all 85,393 paths), across six weight families and three degree bounds.
We present a bounded analysis of the finite, nonsingular, occurrence-ON quantum sequential-growth presentation at dimension d=2 and source stages n<=4. The preprint records five ledger-bound results: a frozen strong/strong commutativity baseline; an exact rational fixed-vector/general-covariance and reachable-state/martingale witness of noncommutativity; a source-native Eq. (120) lemma; commutativity on a proper reconstruction slice; and conditional statewise-to-operator recovery lemmas. Its purpose is to make the distinction between statewise and operator semantics auditable, rather than to classify all finite semantics. In particular, it does not claim the full 955 or 721 profiles, a complete finite occurrence-ON classification, or a reachable-visible witness. The bounded U2 auxiliary-ideal investigation is retained as a reproducibility and resource-boundary record, not as a unit-ideal theorem.
# paper-I-v1.0.0 ## Causal Composition and Unique Quantum Time in a Relational History Model **Linear-extension measures, Fock representations, and self-adjoint evolution** This is the first stable public release of QRST Paper I. ## Highlights - Exact separation of unrestricted graph, causal-poset, and causal-Dyson history theories. - Finite-history correspondence with independent Wick and Fock/Dyson constructions. - Explicit causal-poset cut anomaly and a uniqueness theorem for the linear-extension measure. - Fourier reduction of the two-colour generator to two scalar Jacobi operators. - Sharp self-adjointness split between pure branching and nonzero recombination. - Extension-blind finite moments despite extension-dependent spectra and real-time dynamics. ## Epistemic status Large-order coefficient growth, spectral Assumption A, and Lambert-W asymptotics are deliberately excluded and treated in Paper II. ## Included - compiled manuscript PDF and complete LaTeX source; - figures and bibliography; - reproducibility code and tests; - claim matrix and reproducibility map; - build-validation records; - SHA-256 checksums and upload manifest. ## Citation and DOI The preferred citation is recorded in `CITATION.cff`. The Zenodo DOI will be added after the manual deposit is published. ## Integrity Run `python scripts/verify_integrity.py` after downloading the release asset.