A solvable Gaussian network, the ground state of a scalar field on a weighted lattice with a truncated exponential interaction kernel, admits exact computation of the entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions. In the companion paper this model was used to test the matter sector of Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument, with a first law whose contact term is consistent with the conformal value 2π ξ_c. That consistency is a statement about finite lattices extrapolated to the continuum; the present work isolates the step that was extrapolated: the convergence of the lattice modular data of a ball to the continuum modular Hamiltonian computed by Longo and Morsella. We formulate convergence conjectures (C1, C1a, C1a', C1b) and prove none of the deep ones. What is proved is elementary and stated with its proof status: the exact first law with the modular-Hamiltonian matrices of a restricted Gaussian state; a bulk identity for lattice balls, Σ_u κ_u = K(ℓ_A)(1 + O(ℓ^(-2))); sharp cell estimates for smooth lattice sums; a purely geometric test of the bulk identity over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 32; a non-Lipschitz obstruction at the band edge ν = 1/2, illustrated exactly by a two-oscillator model; and perturbation bounds with an accumulated-weight estimate that organises one proof strategy for C1a around a counting statement, provided a mode-wise condition holds—which fails at the extreme edge. For the counting we state a hypothesis E1' at fixed threshold. The numerical section reports every value computed here, over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 12 with five dilute band probes per radius. The two-parameter decomposition R_c - 1 = a + b / x_eff^2 gives b = 0.959, 0.985, 0.997 and a = 0.039, 0.027, 0.021 at ℓ = 8, 10, 12, both moving towards the conformal values 1 and 0; the rates are not resolved, the direction of the trend is not robust against removing the smallest-band probe, and the dominant systematic of the pipeline (the k = 0 infrared prescription) shifts b by up to 0.23 at ℓ = 8, an order of magnitude above the ℓ-trend itself. The ℓ ≤ 32 field data of the companion paper remain cited, not recomputed. All numbers generated in this work are reproduced by distributed programs with a test suite.
A solvable Gaussian network, the ground state of a scalar field on a weighted lattice with a truncated exponential interaction kernel, admits exact computation of the entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions. In the companion paper this model was used to test the matter sector of Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument, with a first law whose contact term is consistent with the conformal value 2π ξ_c. That consistency is a statement about finite lattices extrapolated to the continuum; the present work isolates the step that was extrapolated: the convergence of the lattice modular data of a ball to the continuum modular Hamiltonian computed by Longo and Morsella. We formulate convergence conjectures (C1, C1a, C1a', C1b) and prove none of the deep ones. What is proved is elementary and stated with its proof status: the exact first law with the modular-Hamiltonian matrices of a restricted Gaussian state; a bulk identity for lattice balls, Σ_u κ_u = K(ℓ_A)(1 + O(ℓ^(-2))); sharp cell estimates for smooth lattice sums; a purely geometric test of the bulk identity over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 32; a non-Lipschitz obstruction at the band edge ν = 1/2, illustrated exactly by a two-oscillator model; and perturbation bounds with an accumulated-weight estimate that organises one proof strategy for C1a around a counting statement, provided a mode-wise condition holds—which fails at the extreme edge. For the counting we state a hypothesis E1' at fixed threshold. The numerical section reports every value computed here, over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 12 with five dilute band probes per radius. The two-parameter decomposition R_c - 1 = a + b / x_eff^2 gives b = 0.959, 0.985, 0.997 and a = 0.039, 0.027, 0.021 at ℓ = 8, 10, 12, both moving towards the conformal values 1 and 0; the rates are not resolved, the direction of the trend is not robust against removing the smallest-band probe, and the dominant systematic of the pipeline (the k = 0 infrared prescription) shifts b by up to 0.23 at ℓ = 8, an order of magnitude above the ℓ-trend itself. The ℓ ≤ 32 field data of the companion paper remain cited, not recomputed. All numbers generated in this work are reproduced by distributed programs with a test suite.
A solvable Gaussian network, the ground state of a scalar field on a weighted lattice with a truncated exponential interaction kernel, admits exact computation of the entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions. In the companion paper this model was used to test the matter sector of Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument, with a first law whose contact term is consistent with the conformal value 2πξ_c. That consistency is a statement about finite lattices extrapolated to the continuum; the present paper isolates the step that was extrapolated: the convergence of the lattice modular data of a ball to the continuum modular Hamiltonian computed by Longo and Morsella. I formulate convergence conjectures (C1, C1a, C1a', C1b) and prove none of the deep ones. What is proved is elementary and stated with its proof status: the exact first law with the modular-Hamiltonian matrices of a restricted Gaussian state; a bulk identity for lattice balls, Σᵤ κᵤ = K(ℓ_A)(1 + O(ℓ⁻²)); sharp cell estimates for smooth lattice sums; a purely geometric test of the bulk identity over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 32; a non-Lipschitz obstruction at the band edge ν = 1/2, illustrated exactly by a two-oscillator model; and perturbation bounds with an accumulated-weight estimate which organises one proof strategy for C1a around a counting statement, provided a mode-wise condition holds, which fails at the extreme edge. For the counting I state a hypothesis E1' at fixed threshold s. The numerical section reports every value computed here, over 4 ≤ ℓ ≤ 12 with five dilute band probes per radius. The two-parameter decomposition R_c − 1 = a + b/x_eff² gives b = 0.959, 0.985, 0.997 and a = 0.039, 0.027, 0.021 at ℓ = 8, 10, 12, both moving towards the conformal values 1 and 0; the rates are not resolved, the direction of the trend is not robust against removing the smallest-band probe, and the dominant systematic of the pipeline (the k = 0 infrared prescription) shifts b by up to 0.23 at ℓ = 8, an order of magnitude above the ℓ-trend itself. The ℓ ≤ 32 field data of the companion paper remain cited, not recomputed. All numbers generated in this work are reproduced by distributed programs with a test suite.
Jacobson's entanglement-equilibrium argument derives the Einstein equation from (i) an area law with finite Newton constant, (ii) a first law for the matter modular Hamiltonian, and (iii) stationarity of the vacuum entropy of small geodesic balls at fixed volume. We test these ingredients on a solvable family of network states: a pair sector whose entanglement encodes a Riemannian metric, combined with the Gaussian ground state of a scalar field on the same weighted graph, for which entropies and modular Hamiltonians of arbitrary regions are computed exactly. Every assumption is isolated as a hypothesis and classified as proved, derived, computed, or imposed by construction. (1) Derivation (conditional). The wave-packet quadratic form of the exact massless modular Hamiltonian of a ball, computed by Longo and Morsella, is identical to the bulk form K_bulk = 2π ∫ κ T_00^(min) + (2π ξ_c n / ℓ) ∫ φ^2 exhibited by the lattice data; the contact-term coefficient χ = 2π ξ_c and the response R = 1 + ξ_c n(n+2)/(ωℓ/c)^2 are identified, not fitted. The step from the continuum identity to the lattice is a modular-convergence statement (Conjecture C1) which we do not prove: a proved proposition on the non-analyticity of the entropy function at the band edge, together with a heuristic accumulation argument, shows why the spectral convergence of the matter sector does not imply it. The lattice data support C1: q_∞ = 1.02 ± 0.02 in n = 2 (up to 1.09 in n = 3 at the accessible radii ℓ ≤ 8). (2) Geometry (recovered, not emergent). The metric is imposed on the pair sector by construction; what is tested is the inverse map. An identifiability lemma shows the entropic distance matrix determines the manifold up to isometry; on S^2 the blind pipeline recovers the dimension (c_2 = 3.13 ≈ π), detects curvature through the negative tail of the MDS spectrum, and measures the curvature radius to 4%. (3) Causal structure (bounded, then computed). For the oscillator sector we prove a field-commutator cone bound with explicit constants, valid on arbitrary point sets, with cone velocity v_φ = 3.05 = 3.1 c_lat; the exact field commutator shows the physical front propagates at c_lat, with Lorentz violation controlled by β = γ(6,m)/16γ(4,m) = 0.384 as (kξ)^2. (4) Equilibrium. The equilibrium postulate is proved equivalent to the reconstructed metric having constant scalar curvature (Einstein only in n = 2); passivity supplies an exact constrained second-variation identity: at fixed geometry and fixed modular energy the vacuum is a local maximum of the generalised entropy along every constrained matter direction. The entropic flow whose fixed points are the equilibrium geometries is defined, not derived; in n = 2 it coincides with the normalised Ricci flow, whose convergence is Hamilton's theorem. (5) Spectral convergence (leading order, black box). For deterministic quasi-uniform sequences on curved manifolds the form-consistency step is proved explicitly, and eigenvalue convergence is obtained only conditionally by citing the graph discretisation of the Laplace–Beltrami operator as a black box. The curvature renormalisation of the speed of sound, c_eff^2 = c^2(1 - R_s γ(n+4,m)ξ^2 / 6n γ(n+2,m)), is verified on S^2 to 1%. For non-uniform random point sets the raw operator converges to a drift operator, and a blind density correction computed from entropic ball counts repairs it, recovering the manifold spectrum to within 0.2–2.3% plus a counting bias of order 1 / N̄_(r_b). All numbers are generated by the programs distributed with this work.
I study the modular data of a free harmonic field on a periodic lattice with a positive mass regulator, restricted to ball-shaped regions. The entropy response of a region to a weak band-limited probe is a sum of first-order shifts of the symplectic eigenvalues, weighted by a logarithmic factor that diverges at the band edge. Because a ball has many symplectic eigenvalues extremely close to one half, this weighted response is not controlled by any uniform-continuity argument. The paper asks what can be said rigorously about it, and what the answer implies for the entanglement-equilibrium programme.The main results are: (1) an exact factorization of the region data through a boundary Schur complement, which writes the deviation of the symplectic eigenvalues from one half as half the squared singular values of an explicit boundary operator; (2) a trace bound on the number of symplectic gaps above a threshold, with an area-scaling form based on exponential locality, so that both parts of the band-edge counting hypothesis of the companion analysis become theorems at every fixed positive mass; (3) a bound on the weighted first-order response by the operator norm of an explicit positive operator of rank at most 4b times the entropy weights of the 4b smallest gaps, proved by a majorization argument that uses neither locality nor translation invariance; (4) a finite-strength version based on the Lidskii-Wielandt inequality, and a gap-independent bound of order tau times the logarithm of the ratio of the region size to tau on the exact entropy increase; (5) a scheme-independence theorem: the exact statements hold for every positive matrix on every finite set and depend on the discretization only through the restricted covariance data, the ranks, and the region size; (6) explicit power-law bounds in the radius on the band-edge part and on the resolved part of the first-order response, valid for a class defined by three stated hypotheses; (7) a dichotomy for the rank-based strategy: a vanishing envelope forces the whole response ratio to vanish and is therefore incompatible with the conformal identification, so any proof of the identification must resolve individual modes; (8) a quantitative saturation bound at fixed probe strength showing that the first-order divergence at the edge is a small-strength artefact and that, along the top of the trace-small window, the two orders of limits do not commute.Numerical results are given for a two-dimensional model with mass 0.01, obtained in extended precision with a companion program that uses an exact reflection-symmetry block decomposition. The smallest symplectic gaps fall below 10 to the minus 29 for balls of radius up to 12. The response ratio to the area term does not approach the conformal prediction in the accessible window for small band centers, the edge share of the response lies between about 0.2 and 1.1 without a visible trend, and the locality constants of the analytic part are not informative in this regime. The limits of the results are stated explicitly: no proof that the model belongs to any of the classes for which the conditional statements hold, no lower bound on the smallest gap, no massless counting theorem, and no dynamical statement of any kind.All numerical data are produced by two self-contained Python programs, published together with the paper, that reproduce every table and print all internal consistency checks.
This paper studies the modular data of Gaussian ground states of a free harmonic field on a periodic lattice with positive mass regulator, restricted to ball-shaped regions. The entropy response of a region to weak band-limited probes is analyzed through the symplectic spectrum of the reduced covariance data. The paper establishes an exact factorization of the modular data through a boundary Schur complement and derives rigorous bounds on the number of symplectic gaps above a threshold. It proves a rank-based bound on the weighted first-order entropy response, extends the analysis to finite perturbation strength, and demonstrates scheme independence of the main results. The exact statements apply to arbitrary finite positive covariance matrices and do not depend on lattice structure, translation invariance, dimensionality, or kernel profile beyond the restricted covariance data. Conditional power-law bounds are derived for classes of Gaussian ball states satisfying explicitly stated hypotheses. A dichotomy theorem shows that rank-based envelope methods alone cannot establish convergence to the continuum conformal prediction. Instead, any successful proof of such convergence must resolve individual mode contributions. Extended-precision numerical calculations are performed for a two-dimensional lattice model with positive mass regulator. The smallest resolved symplectic gaps reach values as small as 5.3e-29. The numerical results confirm the exact theorems and illustrate the limitations of current convergence strategies. Several open problems are identified, including the absence of lower bounds on the smallest gap, the lack of a massless counting theorem, and the unresolved convergence of the response ratio to the continuum prediction. The work contributes rigorous finite-dimensional results on Gaussian modular data, clarifies which assumptions are required for convergence programs based on entanglement equilibrium, and delineates both the possibilities and limitations of rank-based approaches.
Bostelmann, Cadamuro and Minz noted that they presented no proof of convergence of finite-dimensional modular data to the continuum, and that this requires further work; the closest constructive framework, the operator-algebraic scaling-limit programme, likewise leaves modular-data convergence untreated. For half-line free fermions we prove such a theorem for compact-local wavelet schemes, and one delimiting it. Positively, for gauge-invariant quasi-free CAR states, strong exhaustion, strong embedded covariance convergence, and endpoint faithfulness imply norm convergence of local state restrictions and strong-resolvent convergence, after faithful block-completion, of the log-odds modular generators; Trotter–Kato gives local modular-automorphism convergence. We verify these inputs for admissible schemes, including the pinned Daubechies embedding along a dyadic refinement sequence and, under a multiresolution-exhaustion hypothesis, the fixed-order Cohen–Daubechies–Vial boundary model; in the pinned model, local state restrictions on smooth windows away from the endpoint converge at rate O(a^{s}), 0<s ≤ p fixed, those reaching it at rate O(a^{1/2}), the exact order of the driving defect for p ≥ 2 with nonzero endpoint value. Negatively, the locality of this convergence is sharp within a subclass (compactly supported orthonormal-translate interior generator, boundary-free pullback modulo compacts, alias-free, and satisfying the hypotheses of the abstract theorem) for the raw (un-renormalized, infrared-unmodified) fixed-cutoff comparison: a non-exact passband at an interior Fermi-window point makes both Powers–Størmer–Araki square-root defects noncompact, so that comparison supplies no same-folium global normality, whereas exact passband with trace-class boundary error does. Compact support forbids exact passband: the locality yielding local modular convergence obstructs the raw global comparison.
In a previous paper [1] I reduced the Einstein equation for geometries emerging fromentanglement networks to an entropy statement, but I exhibited no explicit family of statesin which the seven hypotheses H1–H7 hold. Here I construct a family in a restricted sectorand determine precisely how far it goes. The states are products of two-qubit pure statesattached to pairs of points sampled from a compact Riemannian manifold, the entropyof a pair decaying exponentially with the Riemannian distance. I prove: (i) the mutualinformation law of H1 holds with vanishing error, so that the metric-reconstruction lemmasof [1] apply with explicit rates; (ii) the state is the unique ground state of a commutinglocal Hamiltonian that satisfies Lieb–Robinson bounds uniformly, but whose causal coneis degenerate; (iii) in the iterated limit of vanishing vertex spacing followed by vanishingcorrelation length, the entropy of every region with C2 boundary equals its area divided by4Gℏ with G explicit, so that H3 holds with Smat = 0; (iv) consequently the equilibriumhypothesis H5, for static observers, holds at a point if and only if the scalar curvature of theslice equals 2Λc, i.e. the Hamiltonian constraint, and the scalar curvature can be read off fromentropy differences of volume-matched balls. Numerical evaluation of the continuum entropyfunctional indicates that finite-correlation-length corrections to the volume-matched entropydifference are of relative order (ξ/ℓ)2. The model contains no matter, so H4 and H6 holdonly vacuously; its Lorentzian limit H2(b) is not realized; H7 is not addressed. I also correcta statement in [1] on the scaling of Newton’s constant. The result is a consistency proof forthe geometric half of the hypothesis system, not a derivation of the Einstein equation.