In 1928 George Gamow explained alpha decay by quantum tunnelling: a particle pre-formed inside the nucleus leaks through its barrier, and the lifetime is the assault frequency times the barrier's penetration factor. The factor is derived in the paper and is one of the permanent returns of twentieth-century physics. The object the lifetime is read off, however, is a "decaying state" obtained by solving the stationary Schrödinger equation under a boundary condition imposed by hand — purely outgoing waves at infinity — which returns a complex eigenvalue E - i\Gamma/2 and an eigenfunction that grows exponentially outside the barrier and belongs to no Hilbert space. This paper runs one declared Hamiltonian three ways. Under the outgoing-wave-only (Siegert) condition it has a pole at E_R = 2.253744 with width \Gamma = 0.176964 and lifetime \tau = 5.650874. A real-energy resonance scan of the same barrier — no complex eigenvalue anywhere — finds the same resonance with width 0.178767, differing from the pole's by a relative +0.010189. Boxed by a second wall, the same Hamiltonian is self-adjoint, its spectrum is real, and every width is 0.000000 exactly: nothing decays. The lifetime is manufactured by the boundary condition; the price of the postulate is the whole of \Gamma. Count: 1 boundary-condition postulate, 0 derivations in 1928 of the decaying state as an eigenstate of a self-adjoint problem. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.
In 1928 George Gamow explained alpha decay by quantum tunnelling: a particle pre-formed inside the nucleus leaks through its barrier, and the lifetime is the assault frequency times the barrier's penetration factor. The factor is derived in the paper and is one of the permanent returns of twentieth-century physics. The object the lifetime is read off, however, is a "decaying state" obtained by solving the stationary Schrödinger equation under a boundary condition imposed by hand — purely outgoing waves at infinity — which returns a complex eigenvalue E - i\Gamma/2 and an eigenfunction that grows exponentially outside the barrier and belongs to no Hilbert space. This paper runs one declared Hamiltonian three ways. Under the outgoing-wave-only (Siegert) condition it has a pole at E_R = 2.253744 with width \Gamma = 0.176964 and lifetime \tau = 5.650874. A real-energy resonance scan of the same barrier — no complex eigenvalue anywhere — finds the same resonance with width 0.178767, differing from the pole's by a relative +0.010189. Boxed by a second wall, the same Hamiltonian is self-adjoint, its spectrum is real, and every width is 0.000000 exactly: nothing decays. The lifetime is manufactured by the boundary condition; the price of the postulate is the whole of \Gamma. Count: 1 boundary-condition postulate, 0 derivations in 1928 of the decaying state as an eigenstate of a self-adjoint problem. Census headline, unchanged: NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL · producing-count 0.
In (1), an outline of the derivation of the Gamow factor for alpha decay from a nucleus is given. In one dimension, the approach considers three regions in space, one with an incident and reflected free particle wavefunction, the second (within a square V barrier) with an exponentially growing and falling solution, and the third, with a single free particle wavefunction exp(-iEt)exp(ipx+phase) representing the escaped alpha particle. Alpha decay is treated as a quantum tunneling problem and the wavefunction and its first derivative d/dx must be continuous. A second step in (1), however, is to assume that one may write a time related wavefunction as exp(- g t), where d/dt partial Integral dx (region) W*W = ½ (-i W* d/dx W + i W d/dx W*). This may appear to be a quantum mechanical equation, but we argue that this is nothing more than the classical continuity equation. In fact, in (2) we argued that quantum mechanics does not exist without classical equations. In particular, the quantum free particle wavefunctions exp(-iEt) and exp(ipx) follow exp(iEt)exp(-iEt) = 1 and exp(-ipx)exp(ipx) = 1 to link them classical densities in time and space for particles moving with a constant speed. If there is a decay in time and space, then the appropriate classical equation is the continuity one. Writing d/dt partial d(t) = constant d(t) yields the familiar exp(-g t) form. We apply the ideas of the Gamow factor to a set of photons bouncing back and forth in an n1 1-dimensional cavity surrounded by n2 (n2>n1) index of refraction material. In this case, if the photons are synchronized then one may follow them classically. The catch is that the probability to reflect or refract is quantum. In general, one would not write exp(-g t) in such a scenario, but would formally write an equation of the form: fraction of remaining photons = R power Integer(t/t1), where R is the probability to reflect and integer(t/t1) is the number of cycles.. If, however, the probability to refract is very small, we show that one may in fact obtain the same result as in the case of exp(- g t) for g <<1. Alternatively, if the cavity is small in length and the speed of the particle (c in the case of light) is large, one could approximate the situation by d/dt partial d(t)= constant d(t) and then obtain exp(-g t), having the photons no longer in deterministic motion.
The exact relation τ = ℏ/Γ between the width Γ of a resonance and the lifetime τ for the decay of this resonance could not be obtained in standard quantum theory based on the Hilbert space or Schwartz space axiom in non-relativistic physics as well as in the relativistic regime. In order to obtain the exact relation, one has to modify the Hilbert space axiom or the Schwartz space axiom and choose new boundary conditions based on the Hardy space axioms in which the space of the states and the space of the observables are described by two different Hardy spaces. As consequences of the new Hardy space axioms, one obtains, instead of the symmetric time evolution for the states and the observables, asymmetrical time evolutions for the states and observables which are described by two semi-groups. A relativistic resonance obeying the exponential time evolution can be described by a relativistic Gamow vector, which is defined as superposition of the exact out-plane wave states with a Breit-Wigner energy distribution of the width Γ.
We examine a one-dimensional model of a decaying quantum system, e.g., one that could simulate decay. A particle is initially confined in a region and leaks out, tunnelling through a potential barrier. The same model has been examined before, primarily to study decay properties which are determined by the wavefunction of the particle within the potential barrier. However, the wavefunction of this model (and of any similar models) outside the potential barrier has not been obtained explicitly as a function of position and time. We obtain the wavefunction outside as well as inside the potential barrier by solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, and explore various features of the space-time development of the system. In an early study by Winter it was pointed out that the probability current just outside the barrier, after a long time, may fluctuate and can be negative, i.e., inward. We find that under certain circumstances the amplitude of the fluctuations increases significantly as the distance from the barrier increases. We propose a simple approximate wavefunction that works well when the decay is very slow. The Gamow wavefunction, commonly used to describe the -decay process, is not appropriate at large distances. Our wavefunction can be used anywhere and is normalized in the usual manner.
Gamow vectors are generalized eigenvectors of the Hamiltonian with complex eigenvalues that describe exponentially decaying (or growing) states. The energy wavefunctions corresponding to Gamow vectors have a pole immediately below (or above) the real axis in the complex energy plane. Although complex energy values were introduced more than half a century ago for the theory of alpha decay, they have become disreputable and have been banished from quantum mechanics textbooks because of mathematical problems and incorrect physical interpretation. Developments in modern mathematics have now provided a mathematical foundation that has led to the correct physical interpretation. In this article, energy eigenvectors with complex eigenvalues are first introduced by explicitly considering a specific simple decaying system. Then, an elementary account of the properties of Gamow vectors is given. The results from the decaying system provide a motivation for the introduction of Gamow vectors and some of the background information needed to understand their properties.
Abstract We discuss the procedure of solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation via a separation ansatz that leads to the time-independent Schrödinger equation. The resulting equation is in the form of an eigenvalue problem for the Hamiltonian, whose solutions are the stationary states. We derive and discuss the bound states and corresponding energy levels for several one-dimensional potentials of interest, including the finite and infinite potential well, the Dirac-delta potential, and the square double-well modelling the spatial configuration of the ammonia molecule. We then turn to the scattered solutions and discuss reflection from and transmission through a finite potential barrier, thus encountering the tunnel effect, which we in turn formulate more generally using the Gamow factor. This leads us to the interesting phenomenon of tunnelling resonances
For single-particle nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, a Gamow state is an eigenfunction of the Hamiltonian with complex eigenvalue. Gamow states are not normalizable; they depend on time via the usual multiplier exp(-iEt) supplemented by a cutoff at an expanding wavefront. Gamow states have been used to extend nuclear shell models; they are to metastable states as normalizable eigenfunctions are to bound states. In this paper we generalize Gamow states to decays with multiple outgoing particles. We derive the exact form of the expanding wavefront, even for relativistic outgoing particles. In the non-relativistic limit we derive the exact form of the multi-particle Gamow state contribution to the system propagator (Green's function).