Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Momentum Space Analysis of the Infinite Square Well: Operator Domains and Physical Tails

Amir Kahrom

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The infinite square well is a paradigm of energy quantization, but defining its momentum distribution requires specifying an operational measurement protocol. We consider the sudden release of a confined eigenstate followed by free expansion: extending the spatial state by zero onto the real line yields a continuous momentum distribution via the Fourier transform. This continuous distribution is conceptually distinct from the internal Fourier sine series; in particular, p n = nπℏ/L is a characteristic Fourier scale rather than a momentum eigenvalue. Because the first-derivative operator on the interval with Dirichlet boundary conditions lacks a canonical self-adjoint realization, the strictly confined state possesses no intrinsic momentum distribution. The released distribution exhibits shifted probability lobes and an oscillatory p-4 asymptotic tail, yielding a finite second moment ⟨p 2 ⟩ = 2mE n but a divergent fourth moment ⟨p 4 ⟩. These spectral properties directly reflect the Sobolev regularity of the zero-extended state, ψ n ∈ H 1 (R) \ H 2 (R). Finally, we connect this mathematical structure to the variational formulation: the energy quadratic form is well-defined on the form domain H 1 0 (0, L), whereas the operator domain is restricted to H 2 (0, L) ∩ H 1 0 (0, L). This distinction elucidates why finite-energy trial states need not satisfy second-derivative regularity and clarifies the role of orthogonality constraints in variational approximations of excited states.

DOI
10.2139/ssrn.7682796

Related papers

Momentum Space Analysis of the Infinite Square Well: Operator Domains and Physical Tails

Amir Kahrom

The infinite square well is a paradigm of energy quantization, but defining its momentumdistribution requires specifying an operational measurement protocol. We consider the sud-den release of a confined eigenstate followed by free expansion: extending the spatial stateby zero onto the real line yields a continuous momentum distribution via the Fourier trans-form. This continuous distribution is conceptually distinct from the internal Fourier sineseries; in particular, pn = nπℏ/L is a characteristic Fourier scale rather than a momentumeigenvalue. Because the first-derivative operator on the interval with Dirichlet boundaryconditions lacks a canonical self-adjoint realization, the strictly confined state possesses nointrinsic momentum distribution. The released distribution exhibits shifted probability lobesand an oscillatory p−4 asymptotic tail, yielding a finite second moment ⟨p2⟩ = 2mEn but adivergent fourth moment ⟨p4⟩. These spectral properties directly reflect the Sobolev regular-ity of the zero-extended state, ψen ∈ H1(R) \ H2(R). Finally, we connect this mathematicalstructure to the variational formulation: the energy quadratic form is well-defined on theform domain H10(0, L), whereas the operator domain is restricted to H2(0, L) ∩ H10(0, L).This distinction elucidates why finite-energy trial states need not satisfy second-derivativeregularity and clarifies the role of orthogonality constraints in variational approximations ofexcited states.

•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Regularized quantum motion in a bounded set: Hilbertian aspects

Fabio Bagarello, Jean‐Pierre Gazeau, Camillo Trapanı

It is known that the momentum operator canonically conjugated to the position operator for a particle moving in some bounded interval of the line (with Dirichlet boundary conditions) is not essentially self-adjoint: it has a continuous set of self-adjoint extensions. We prove that essential self-adjointness can be recovered by symmetrically weighting the momentum operator with a positive bounded function approximating the indicator function of the considered interval. This weighted momentum operator is consistently obtained from a similarly weighted classical momentum through the so-called Weyl-Heisenberg covariant integral quantization of functions or distributions.

arXiv:2406.06989•Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications•Jun 15, 2024•1 citation

Localization properties of squeezed quantum states in nanoscale space domains

Anton Sergeevich Trushechkin, I. V. Volovich

We construct families of squeezed quantum states on an interval (depending on boundary conditions, we interpret the interval as a circle or as the infinite square potential well) and obtain estimates of position and momentum dispersions for these states. A particular attention is paid to the possibility of proper localization of a particle in nanoscale space domains. One of the constructed family of squeezed states is based on the theta function. It is a generalization of the known coherent and squeezed states on the circle. Also we construct a family of squeezed states based on truncated Gaussian functions and a family of wave packets based on the discretization of an arbitrary continuous momentum probability distribution. The problem of finiteness of the energy dispersion for the squeezed states in the infinite well is discussed. Finally, we perform the limit of large interval length and the semiclassical limit. As a supplementary general result, we show that an arbitrary physical quantity has a finite dispersion if and only if the wave function of a quantum system belongs to the domain of the corresponding self-adjoint operator. This can be regarded as a physical meaning of the domain of a self-adjoint operator.

arXiv:1304.6277•Apr 23, 2013•5 citations

Critical notes of Quantum Mechanics: Momentum Operators

David Carfì

In this note, we examine critically some basic features of momentum operators, both in the case of simple spatial context and in the case of spacetime. The natural time for the domain H of the momentum operator The Laurent Schwartz space Sn endowed with its own semimetric topology and with the Dirac inner product We emphasize that the right topology to consider is the standard Schwartz topology, not the topology induced by the above Dirac inner product which needs to provide probability issues and not continuity properties. The above choice for the space H satisfy at once some fundamental requirements of the theory:0. all the functions of the space H are both smooth and square integrable;1. the operator P reveals indeed a linear endomorphism everywhere defined uponH;2. the operator is continuous with respect to the Schwartz topology;3. the operator P is uniquely extensible to the entire space of tempered distributionsSn′ and this extension is continuous with respect to the standard topology of such distribution space.4. The above unique extension shows the so-called de Broglie waves as natural eigenvectors, although those de Broglie waves are not square integrable. The above third and fourth points induce us to consider that extension as the standard right choice for the momentum operator, not only because that extension contains in- side the previous operator defined on the Schwartz function space, but because - even more stringently - the space of temperate distributions allow us to define rigorously the fundamental concept of continuous quantum state basis and the concepts of Dirac orthogonality and Dirac normalizability for such type of bases. It happens, by the way, that some de Broglie families of quantum waves are indeed quantum basis of the space Sn′ and reveal Dirac orthogonal and Dirac normalizable.

Journal of Mathematical Economics and Finance•Jun 30, 2019•0 citations

Infinite Square Well, Self-Adjointness, and the Dirac Delta Function

Marcos Amaku, Francisco Antônio Bezerra Coutinho, E. Massad +1 more

Abstract One hundred years ago, Dirac presented a groundbreaking method for quantizing classical Hamiltonians. Simplicity is one of the virtues of the procedure, but certain classes of problems require special care. Here, we discuss one such class, the quantization of confined systems, with emphasis on the one-dimensional square well. We examine two presentations of the problem. The first presentation restricts the analysis to the interval $$0\le x\le L$$ . The second presentation considers the entire x axis, but an infinite potential traps the particle in the region $$0\le x\le L$$ . In contrast with the typical treatment in quantum mechanics textbooks, the first presentation imposes nontrivial boundary conditions. Proper treatment of the problem in the second presentation demands the use of delta functions or distributions.

Brazilian Journal of Physics•Mar 19, 2026•1 citation

On the Duality of Momentum in Dirac's Energy-Momentum Space

Michael Lee

This work resolves a foundational tension in Dirac's formulation of relativistic quantum mechanics: momentum appears in two distinct but undifferentiated roles—as a dispersion-locked parameter generating unitary evolution in the relativistic wave equation, and as a free phase variable subject to symplectic flow in the constraint formalism. We demonstrate that this duality reflects an intrinsic Lorentzian structure in energy-momentum space, characterized by the interval dΣ² = dE²/c² − dp². This geometry divides naturally into three sectors: symmetric (dispersion-locked), null (massless, E/|p| = c), and antisymmetric (free-momentum) regimes, each governed by different geometric constraints. Dispersion emerges as the global integral of an exact action one-form, while the (E,p) symplectic structure arises locally as the exterior derivative of the action's inexact form θ_E = E dp. Energy quantization appears as a topological stability condition requiring closed spectral loops to satisfy ∮ E dp = nh, defining "proto-eigenstates" whose Fourier encodings yield standard Hilbert-space eigenstates. We recover both the Bohr spectrum and Dirac fine-structure energies from spectral phase closure, revealing α = e²/(ℏc) as a geometric action-normalization ratio between Maxwell U(1) curvature and Lorentz spinor action—not a coupling parameter from QED perturbation theory. The framework synthesizes unitary flow and symplectic uncertainty into a single bilinear Lorentzian structure, showing quantum states as objective in their symmetric unitary existence but path-dependent in their antisymmetric observed manifestation. This geometric reconstruction bridges Dirac's wave mechanics and constraint formalism through native (E,p) phase space, offering a foundation for quantum theory that treats energy-momentum as primary coordinates rather than conjugate variables derived from spacetime position.

•Jan 7, 2026•0 citations
The infinite square well is a paradigm of energy quantization, but defining its momentum distribution requires specifying an operational measurement protocol. We consider the sudden release of a confined eigenstate followed by free expansion: extending the spatial state by zero onto the real line yields a continuous momentum distribution via the Fourier transform. This continuous distribution is conceptually distinct from the internal Fourier sine series; in particular, p n = nπℏ/L is a characteristic Fourier scale rather than a momentum eigenvalue. Because the first-derivative operator on the interval with Dirichlet boundary conditions lacks a canonical self-adjoint realization, the strictly confined state possesses no intrinsic momentum distribution. The released distribution exhibits shifted probability lobes and an oscillatory p-4 asymptotic tail, yielding a finite second moment ⟨p 2 ⟩ = 2mE n but a divergent fourth moment ⟨p 4 ⟩. These spectral properties directly reflect the Sobolev regularity of the zero-extended state, ψ n ∈ H 1 (R) \ H 2 (R). Finally, we connect this mathematical structure to the variational formulation: the energy quadratic form is well-defined on the form domain H 1 0 (0, L), whereas the operator domain is restricted to H 2 (0, L) ∩ H 1 0 (0, L). This distinction elucidates why finite-energy trial states need not satisfy second-derivative regularity and clarifies the role of orthogonality constraints in variational approximations of excited states.
The infinite square well is a paradigm of energy quantization, but defining its momentumdistribution requires specifying an operational measurement protocol. We consider the sud-den release of a confined eigenstate followed by free expansion: extending the spatial stateby zero onto the real line yields a continuous momentum distribution via the Fourier trans-form. This continuous distribution is conceptually distinct from the internal Fourier sineseries; in particular, pn = nπℏ/L is a characteristic Fourier scale rather than a momentumeigenvalue. Because the first-derivative operator on the interval with Dirichlet boundaryconditions lacks a canonical self-adjoint realization, the strictly confined state possesses nointrinsic momentum distribution. The released distribution exhibits shifted probability lobesand an oscillatory p−4 asymptotic tail, yielding a finite second moment ⟨p2⟩ = 2mEn but adivergent fourth moment ⟨p4⟩. These spectral properties directly reflect the Sobolev regular-ity of the zero-extended state, ψen ∈ H1(R) \ H2(R). Finally, we connect this mathematicalstructure to the variational formulation: the energy quadratic form is well-defined on theform domain H10(0, L), whereas the operator domain is restricted to H2(0, L) ∩ H10(0, L).This distinction elucidates why finite-energy trial states need not satisfy second-derivativeregularity and clarifies the role of orthogonality constraints in variational approximations ofexcited states.
It is known that the momentum operator canonically conjugated to the position operator for a particle moving in some bounded interval of the line (with Dirichlet boundary conditions) is not essentially self-adjoint: it has a continuous set of self-adjoint extensions. We prove that essential self-adjointness can be recovered by symmetrically weighting the momentum operator with a positive bounded function approximating the indicator function of the considered interval. This weighted momentum operator is consistently obtained from a similarly weighted classical momentum through the so-called Weyl-Heisenberg covariant integral quantization of functions or distributions.
We construct families of squeezed quantum states on an interval (depending on boundary conditions, we interpret the interval as a circle or as the infinite square potential well) and obtain estimates of position and momentum dispersions for these states. A particular attention is paid to the possibility of proper localization of a particle in nanoscale space domains. One of the constructed family of squeezed states is based on the theta function. It is a generalization of the known coherent and squeezed states on the circle. Also we construct a family of squeezed states based on truncated Gaussian functions and a family of wave packets based on the discretization of an arbitrary continuous momentum probability distribution. The problem of finiteness of the energy dispersion for the squeezed states in the infinite well is discussed. Finally, we perform the limit of large interval length and the semiclassical limit. As a supplementary general result, we show that an arbitrary physical quantity has a finite dispersion if and only if the wave function of a quantum system belongs to the domain of the corresponding self-adjoint operator. This can be regarded as a physical meaning of the domain of a self-adjoint operator.
In this note, we examine critically some basic features of momentum operators, both in the case of simple spatial context and in the case of spacetime. The natural time for the domain H of the momentum operator The Laurent Schwartz space Sn endowed with its own semimetric topology and with the Dirac inner product We emphasize that the right topology to consider is the standard Schwartz topology, not the topology induced by the above Dirac inner product which needs to provide probability issues and not continuity properties. The above choice for the space H satisfy at once some fundamental requirements of the theory:0. all the functions of the space H are both smooth and square integrable;1. the operator P reveals indeed a linear endomorphism everywhere defined uponH;2. the operator is continuous with respect to the Schwartz topology;3. the operator P is uniquely extensible to the entire space of tempered distributionsSn′ and this extension is continuous with respect to the standard topology of such distribution space.4. The above unique extension shows the so-called de Broglie waves as natural eigenvectors, although those de Broglie waves are not square integrable. The above third and fourth points induce us to consider that extension as the standard right choice for the momentum operator, not only because that extension contains in- side the previous operator defined on the Schwartz function space, but because - even more stringently - the space of temperate distributions allow us to define rigorously the fundamental concept of continuous quantum state basis and the concepts of Dirac orthogonality and Dirac normalizability for such type of bases. It happens, by the way, that some de Broglie families of quantum waves are indeed quantum basis of the space Sn′ and reveal Dirac orthogonal and Dirac normalizable.
Abstract One hundred years ago, Dirac presented a groundbreaking method for quantizing classical Hamiltonians. Simplicity is one of the virtues of the procedure, but certain classes of problems require special care. Here, we discuss one such class, the quantization of confined systems, with emphasis on the one-dimensional square well. We examine two presentations of the problem. The first presentation restricts the analysis to the interval 0≤x≤L0\le x\le L0≤x≤L . The second presentation considers the entire x axis, but an infinite potential traps the particle in the region 0≤x≤L0\le x\le L0≤x≤L . In contrast with the typical treatment in quantum mechanics textbooks, the first presentation imposes nontrivial boundary conditions. Proper treatment of the problem in the second presentation demands the use of delta functions or distributions.
This work resolves a foundational tension in Dirac's formulation of relativistic quantum mechanics: momentum appears in two distinct but undifferentiated roles—as a dispersion-locked parameter generating unitary evolution in the relativistic wave equation, and as a free phase variable subject to symplectic flow in the constraint formalism. We demonstrate that this duality reflects an intrinsic Lorentzian structure in energy-momentum space, characterized by the interval dΣ² = dE²/c² − dp². This geometry divides naturally into three sectors: symmetric (dispersion-locked), null (massless, E/|p| = c), and antisymmetric (free-momentum) regimes, each governed by different geometric constraints. Dispersion emerges as the global integral of an exact action one-form, while the (E,p) symplectic structure arises locally as the exterior derivative of the action's inexact form θ_E = E dp. Energy quantization appears as a topological stability condition requiring closed spectral loops to satisfy ∮ E dp = nh, defining "proto-eigenstates" whose Fourier encodings yield standard Hilbert-space eigenstates. We recover both the Bohr spectrum and Dirac fine-structure energies from spectral phase closure, revealing α = e²/(ℏc) as a geometric action-normalization ratio between Maxwell U(1) curvature and Lorentz spinor action—not a coupling parameter from QED perturbation theory. The framework synthesizes unitary flow and symplectic uncertainty into a single bilinear Lorentzian structure, showing quantum states as objective in their symmetric unitary existence but path-dependent in their antisymmetric observed manifestation. This geometric reconstruction bridges Dirac's wave mechanics and constraint formalism through native (E,p) phase space, offering a foundation for quantum theory that treats energy-momentum as primary coordinates rather than conjugate variables derived from spacetime position.