Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

No Free Actualization: The Canonical Structure Derived from a Symmetric State Determines the Law of Elementary Registers but Not the Realized Sample — Deterministic No-Go, Instrument Non-Uniqueness, a Smoothing Detailed-Balanced Canonical Closure with Exact Spectrum, and Discontinuity at Spectral Coalescence — RCD Program, Act I, Technical Note I-B1 (v0.1)

Arturo Cerezo García

Published Nov 5, 2026• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Technical Note I-B1 of the RCD program, Act I (continues I-B0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23965761, and I-A0/I-A1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23961108). I-B0 derived, from the frozen input of Act I (an algebra M_d, a state ρ and its full symmetry group G₀), the space 𝒪_ρ of elementary distinctions, its canonical law μ_ρ, the register interface E_ρ and the channel 𝓜_ρ. I-B1 asks whether that structure can produce a concrete record — operationally a pure state δ_Q of the classical algebra C(𝒪_ρ) — without selection, clock, asymmetry or primitive randomness. Result (theorems with numerical control on 17 states in d = 2, 3, 4; no hardware): the No-Free-Actualization Theorem, with four distinct and complementary obstructions. (1) No deterministic G₀-equivariant rule takes μ_ρ to any δ_Q when rank ρ > 1; a concrete record reduces the state's stabilizer from G₀ to H_Q. (2) Every instrument compatible with E_ρ is measure-and-prepare (Haapasalo–Pellonpää), the covariant ones correspond to stabilizer-invariant states, and the segment tQ + (1−t)ρ is covariant with identical statistics: POVM plus symmetry do not fix the post-measurement update; the instrument preparing Q is selected by a declared consistency condition (H_PB, Petz–barycenter), legitimized by the unique affine weak-* continuous extension of the Petz recovery. (3) The canonical closure T_ρ = 𝓜_ρ∘𝓑_ρ is a smoothing kernel (T_ρν ≪ μ_ρ for every ν, never a delta), positive (0 ≤ T_ρ ≤ I) and reversible (detailed balance) with respect to μ_ρ; for ρ = P/r its spectrum is {1, 1/(r+1) with multiplicity r² − 1, 0} with exact contraction (1/(r+1))^{n−1} after the first step and D(Q‖𝓑_ρ(T_ρδ_Q)) = ln((r+1)/2); in d = 2 the spectrum is {1, √(λ₁λ₂) double, 0}, jumping from 1/2 to 1/3 at degeneracy; and a coalescence theorem shows μ_ρ and its second moment discontinuous at every coalescence of positive eigenvalues (Var Tr(P₁Q) jumps from 0 to λ²n₁n₂/(n₁+n₂+1)); every possible distinction lies at the same distance from the barycenter, ‖Q − ρ‖² = 1 − Tr ρ². (4) μ_ρ is realized as Q = gQ₀g* with g Haar-distributed on G₀: the structure derives the law of the sample, not the sample. Stated boundary: it is not claimed that no extension of RCD can derive the event, nor that the event is a fundamental primitive; μ_ρ ⇝ δ_Q is recorded as an open debt; I-A/I-B derive new structure from the Act I input but do not derive that input from a structureless coherence (an upstream question). For I-C the event enters only as a conditional input, and the next wall is stated: can an event be registered without consuming the coherence needed for the next one? Includes an erratum for the two earlier deposits (17 control states, not 16; 14 of rank > 1, not 13). Scripts with SHA-256 manifest; the original run code with a corrected spectral-control error is kept for traceability. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails. "Erratum (v0.2, 5 November 2026): v0.1 of this note and v0.2 of the I-A1 report stated 16 control states; there are 17 (3 in d = 2, 5 in d = 3, 9 in d = 4; 3 pure and 14 of rank > 1), all contained in ia1.out and all passing the gates. Documentary error with no effect on any result or theorem; the I-A0 count (13 cases) is correct. This version corrects the note and the I-A1 report; code and outputs are unchanged."

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23990720

Related papers

Canonical Register Interface and Petz Lock: The Square-Root Measurement on the Canonical Orbit of Elementary Distinctions, Its Petz Recovery as the Barycentric Preparation, and the Loss of Relative Sufficiency for Every Concrete Distinction Unless the State Is Pure — RCD Program, Act I, Technical Note I-B0 (v0.1)

Arturo Cerezo García

Technical Note I-B0 of the RCD program, Act I (continues I-A0/I-A1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23961108, and MEM-0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23926847). Act I left wall I-A resolved in the finite species: the pair (M_d, ρ) canonically determines the orbit 𝒪_ρ of elementary distinctions (rank-one projections) whose Haar barycenter is ρ, selecting none of them. I-B0 asks whether those same data generate, on their own, a register interface — a covariant quantum-to-classical channel whose outcome space is not added from outside — that loses the recoverability of every concrete distinction, with no clock, no preferred basis and no external cut. Results (theorems with numerical control in d = 2, 3, 4 on sixteen states; no hardware): (i) Canonical Register Interface Theorem — E_ρ(dQ) = ρ^{-1/2} Q ρ^{-1/2} dμ_ρ(Q) is a G₀-covariant POVM on 𝒪_ρ integrating to the support (the square-root / pretty-good measurement of the canonical ensemble); the channel 𝓜_ρ(σ)(dQ) = Tr(σ E_ρ(dQ)) satisfies 𝓜_ρ(ρ) = μ_ρ; and its Petz recovery map with respect to ρ is exactly the barycentric preparation ν ↦ ∫Q dν of I-A1, so that the I-A1 barycenter and the I-B0 Petz recovery are the same object seen from both sides; the chain (M_d, ρ) → 𝒪_ρ → μ_ρ → E_ρ → 𝓜_ρ requires no new hypothesis; canonicity is self-aligned uniqueness: among covariant rank-one-seed POVMs on 𝒪_ρ, E_ρ is the only one whose response to Q peaks at Q itself (the others are its central relabelings and, only for ρ = P/2, an anti-aligned measurement exhibited in the review round). (ii) Petz Lock — D(Q‖ρ) = S(ρ) on the whole orbit; the gap Δ_rec = D(Q‖ρ) − D(𝓜_ρ(Q)‖μ_ρ) = χ − I(E_ρ) is Q-independent and vanishes iff rank ρ = 1: for rank greater than one the channel returns ρ but is not sufficient for any pair (Q, ρ), i.e. it does not fully preserve any concrete distinction relative to the reference coherence (not absolute irrecoverability). (iii) Exact benchmark Δ_rec(P/r) = H_r − 1 (harmonic number), equal to the Holevo gap of the accessible information of the uniform ensemble (Jozsa–Robb–Wootters); closed form in d = 2, Δ_rec = S(ρ) − ln((1+s)/2) − 1 + s with s = |λ₁ − λ₂|; and a discontinuity of the gap at spectral degeneracy, 2 ln 2 − 1 ≈ 0.386 versus 1/2 at ρ = I/2, because the stabilizer and the canonical orbit change. Stated boundary: no concrete record is adjudicated — 𝓜_ρ(ρ) = μ_ρ, not δ_Q, and no deterministic equivariant rule can select δ_Q; stochastic selection remains open; the realization of an outcome is the question of I-B1, not opened here. Declared heritage: pretty-good measurement, Petz recovery, Barnum–Knill, Holevo's covariant measurements; what is RCD's own is the input, since the ensemble is derived from symmetry rather than postulated. Scripts with SHA-256 manifest. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails. Erratum (v0.2, 5 November 2026): v0.1 of this note and v0.2 of the I-B0 report said “sixteen states” and “thirteen of rank > 1”; there are 17 control states (3 pure and 14 of rank > 1), all contained in ib0.out and all passing the gates. Documentary error with no effect on any result or theorem. This version corrects the note and the I-B0 report; code and output are unchanged.

•Nov 5, 2026•2 citations

First Distinction and Canonical Minimal Orbit: No-New-Distinction Theorem and the Orbit of Elementary Distinctions Determined by a Symmetric State, with Uniqueness of the Covariant Measure under Ergodicity or for ρ = P/r — RCD Program, Act I, Technical Note I-A0/I-A1 (v0.1)

Arturo Cerezo García

Technical Note I-A0/I-A1 of the RCD program, Act I (continues MEM-0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23926847). The Act I target sheet (v0.3, frozen, included) asks how a perfectly symmetric coherence can produce an inheritable distinction with no clock, no geometry and no external cut, and names three walls: I-A (Schur, fixed-point algebra), I-B (Petz, recoverability), I-C (Wiesbrock–Borchers, inheritance). This note closes the first two diligences of wall I-A in the finite control species: the algebra M_d(C), a state ω_ρ(A) = Tr(ρA) and the unchosen symmetry group G₀ = Aut(M_d, ω_ρ) ≅ ∏ U(n_a)/U(1). Results (theorems with numerical control in d = 2, 3, 4; no hardware): (I-A0) No-New-Distinction Theorem — the fixed-point algebra equals the double commutant {ρ}″ = W*(ρ) = ⊕ C P_a; no covariant distinction is born de novo: the maximally mixed state has none (and trivial modular flow), a non-tracial state has exactly the 2^{m−1} − 1 sums of spectral projections, a pure state exactly one; covariant channels preserve W*(ρ); general lemma: an invariant input cannot select, by an equivariant deterministic rule, a non-invariant member of an orbit. (I-A1, Theorem I) Canonical Minimal Orbit — the minimal projections (rank 1) fall into G₀-orbits classified by p_a(Q) = Tr(P_a Q); the Haar barycenter of an orbit is Σ (p_a/n_a) P_a; exactly one orbit has barycenter ρ, namely p_a = n_a λ_a, of dimension Σ_{λ_a>0}(2n_a − 1) − 1; symmetry selects none of its members but (M_d, ρ) determines the whole homogeneous space of elementary distinctions, with ρ as its barycenter (pure → a point; tracial → CP^{d−1}; ρ = P/r → CP^{r−1}). (I-A1, Theorem II) Measure — G₀-invariant measures on minimal projections with barycenter ρ correspond to measures ν on the simplex with mean p*; the measure is unique with no hypothesis iff ρ = P/r (p* a vertex), otherwise a convex set of covariant decompositions exists (covariant Schrödinger–HJW, explicit two-orbit mixtures exhibited); under ergodicity the measure is the homogeneous μ_ρ, unique for every ρ. First-moment identity ∫ Tr(QE) dμ_ρ = Tr(ρE) recorded as a linear detector, not as Born. Stated limits: finite species only; ergodicity is a declared hypothesis, not derived; nothing here is time, space, register, probability law or physical selection; I-B and I-C are not opened. Scripts with SHA-256 manifest. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails. Erratum (v0.2, 5 November 2026): v0.1 of this note and v0.2 of the I-A1 report stated 16 control states; there are 17 (3 in d = 2, 5 in d = 3, 9 in d = 4; 3 pure and 14 of rank > 1), all contained in ia1.out and all passing the gates. Documentary error with no effect on any result or theorem; the I-A0 count (13 cases) is correct. This version corrects the note and the I-A1 report; code and outputs are unchanged.

•Nov 4, 2026•3 citations

Register with Residual Capacity: An Informative Reading Need Not Consume the Carrier's Quantum Capacity — The A_η Family in the Tracial Sector, Exact Non-Markovianity, Finite-History Reversal, Four Separate Persistences with Flagged Entanglement Survival, a Conditional Inheritance Network, and a Locality No-Go for the Global Instrument — RCD Program, Act I, Technical Note I-C (v0.1)

Arturo Cerezo García

Technical Note I-C of the RCD program, Act I (continues I-B1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23990720; I-B0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23965760; and I-A0/I-A1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23961107). I-B1 left the boundary that every realization is a sample entering conditionally; I-C asks whether an event can be registered without consuming the coherence needed for the next one, leave an inheritable trace, and take part in an inheritance network. In the tracial sector ρ = P/r (r = 2, 3, 4; no hardware; theorems with numerical control, 92 checks with declared tolerances, all passed), results: (I) Register-with-Residual-Capacity Theorem. A rank-one reading on the whole system admits only nuclear instruments (Haapasalo–Pellonpää) and hence breaks entanglement (Horodecki–Shor–Ruskai); the family A_η(Q) = (1−η)P + ηrQ with Lüders operation L_Q = aP + bQ gives, for 0 < η < 1, an informative reading (I_η > 0, with I₁ = ln r − H_r + 1) together with a non-entanglement-breaking depolarizing channel, p_η = 1 − b²/(r+1) > 1/(r+1), whose posterior state (1−η)P/r + ηQ is the I-B1 segment produced by a mechanism. Exact non-Markovianity on labels, k(Q₃|Q₁,Q₂) − k(Q₃|Q₂) = η²√(1−η²) in r = 2. Finite-history reversal theorem: w_n(Q₁…Q_n) = w_n(Q_n…Q₁) for every n, so no arrow comes from label statistics. Four separate persistences: the classical archive; the averaged residual, decaying as ηp_ηⁿ and never zero; entanglement with discarded registers, dying at n_EB = ⌈ln(1/(r+1))/ln p_η⌉; and entanglement with kept registers, with Schmidt rank r along every trajectory and the exact bound λ_min ≥ [(1−η)/(1+(r−1)η)]ⁿ/r — flagged-survival corollary: with the classical register kept the negativity is an integral of branch negativities and stays positive for every finite n; the classical register is the flag that preserves the resolution of entangled branches, not a source of entanglement. (II) Inheritance network, ratified conditionally under a declared connection scheme H_con (carrier registers): acyclicity by strict inclusion, invariance of density, state, registers and predecessors under all compatible linear extensions and relabeling, rhombus with incomparability sustained by commutation and no-signaling, and the exact counterexample 13/8, 5/4, 1/16 showing that a product label does not imply independence (local statistics factorize iff the posterior is a product). Orientation: the boundary source dies (P/r has a preimage; in a qubit L_{Q⊥}L_Q = √(1−η²)P), the contraction source belongs to the average, and accumulation remains declared. Locality no-go: the Kraus operators span M_r, the commutant is trivial and Fix(Φ_η) = ℂP, even for product labels on ℂ²⊗ℂ²: locality cannot be extracted from the algebra of the global instrument. Diagnostics: Rideout–Sorkin Bell causality transcribed to the label law fails; the prefixed rhombus network is not sprinkling-like. Not claimed: time, space, gravity, irreversibility, Bell causality, asymptotic quantum capacity, or the derivation of η, accumulation, connections or factorization; the event debt (No Free Actualization) remains open. Scripts with SHA-256 manifest; run incidents documented. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails.

•Nov 7, 2026•2 citations

Local Validity and Contextual Holonomy: A Structural Formulation of the Copenhagen Principle (v3)

Manuel Flores Gordillo

ON THE VERSION NUMBER. "v3" is the version of the NOTE, not of this Zenodo deposit. Versions 1 (February 2026) and 2 were circulated privately and never deposited; v1 contained four errors of substance, which are stated with their repairs in the "What changed" section rather than quietly removed. This is the first Zenodo deposit, so if you see a deposit counter it will not match the document version. The document version is the one that matters for citation. Preprint, version 3 (complete rewrite). This note is the synthesis of the contextuality-obstructions program; the proofs live in the companion papers. The proposal is that the Copenhagen viewpoint, stripped of its rhetoric, is a set of structural statements about one geometric object: the transformation groupoid of measurement contexts (maximal abelian subalgebras) with its canonical U(1) 2-cocycle. In that formulation: local validity, the exact classicality of every single context, is a theorem with an explicit witness; complementarity is the nonvanishing holonomy of the cocycle along closed context loops, which detects exactly the all-versus-nothing sector of contextuality; collapse is pinned by statistics, repeatability and covariance to a one-parameter family per degenerate block whose unique efficient member is the Lueders rule, with a classical twin theorem identifying the same axioms' classical solution as Bayesian conditioning; observer-relativity of facts and the movable cut are theorems of an enlarged observer-context category; and the Frauchiger-Renner argument localizes to an ordinary state-dependent violation, with contextual fraction exactly 1/6, carried by a single CHSH facet, the loop holonomy of the observer switch being provably trivial. ATTRIBUTION. The classification of achievable state-independent values, the even/odd dichotomy and the fixed value d/2, is due to Abramsky, Cercelescu and Constantin (FSCD 2024). It is recast here in certificate language; the priority is theirs and is stated in the text. HARDWARE CAVEAT, STATED UP FRONT. Two signatures were measured on superconducting hardware. The quoted significances, about 56 sigma for the triangle holonomy and 35.4 sigma for the Peres-Mermin witness above the deterministic bound 4, are shot-noise statistical only, computed under the implemented model. They are not systematics-aware, and neither experiment is loophole-free. Read them as consistency checks on real hardware, not as precision measurements. ERRATA. Version 1 of this note contained four errors of substance. Section "What changed" states each of them and its repair. They are recorded rather than quietly removed. STATUS AND SCOPE. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article. Each tenet is either a theorem of the companion papers, a machine-verified certificate in the public suite, or is explicitly labeled a conjecture. The paper offers structural characterizations within its stated axioms; it is not an interpretation-free derivation of Copenhagen and it does not claim to resolve the measurement problem. AI-ASSISTANCE DISCLOSURE. This work was carried out with substantial AI assistance. Every load-bearing claim is machine-verified by scripts that ship with the papers, and the author takes full responsibility for the contents. COMPANIONS. Paper A: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630431 . Paper B: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630630 . Paper D: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630697 . Paper C: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21633744 (posted 2026-07-28, after three adversarial review passes; it carries a labelled retraction of an earlier sqrt(2) reading). VERIFICATION CODE. https://github.com/manuflog/contextuality-obstructions

•Jul 27, 2026•0 citations

Probability as Lawful Completion

Darren Jeffers

This paper develops a reconstruction of probability that does not begin by assuming a probability space, a probability simplex, or the Born rule. Instead, it asks a prior foundational question: under what physical and mathematical conditions are a set of alternatives entitled to carry positive, additive probabilities at all? The construction begins with lawful histories, future interfaces, and retained records. It distinguishes coherent alternatives from exclusive empirical events, preventing multiple interfering routes from being mistaken for separate probabilistic outcomes. A future-sufficient quotient identifies distinctions that no admitted future test can detect, while a record-qualification step determines when alternatives have become genuine empirical events. Dagger-compatible comparison and positive record factorization then produce a positive comparison kernel, from which normalized event probabilities arise only after the relevant record sectors are certified as exclusive. The framework is extended beyond individual measurements. Compatible finite record refinements generate a global probability measure under explicit realizability conditions; stochastic kernels provide a compositional calculus for carrying probabilistic information through unresolved future structure; and locally classical measurement contexts are assembled into a single positive state on a generally non-Boolean effect structure. This allows globally coherent probability to exist even when no context-independent deterministic assignment of outcomes exists. On a reflection-positive Hilbert-space branch, admissible future contexts are represented by positive effects and positive normalized states by density operators. The Born state-effect law then appears as the finite-dimensional representation of a probability structure that has already been earned through record qualification, positivity, exclusivity, refinement, and contextual consistency rather than introduced as a primitive postulate. The paper also separates two mechanisms that are often conflated: quadratic Born-type weighting arises from dagger self-comparison, whereas equal probabilities for symmetric alternatives arise from symmetry of the outcome structure. A further state-effect bridge analysis classifies residual coordinate freedom and identifies an exceptional rank-two adjugate transformation with Lorentzian signature, which is removed when positive self-dual identification is required. The central interpretation is that probability can function as a lawful form of global completion: it can carry future-relevant law through unresolved structure even when deterministic uniqueness is unavailable. The paper does not derive a mechanism selecting one actual outcome and does not claim that every physical sector satisfies the stated hypotheses. Instead, it provides an explicit dependency-controlled architecture connecting lawful completion, reflection positivity, event qualification, contextuality, stochastic continuation, Hilbert reconstruction, and the Born rule.

•Sep 18, 2026•0 citations

Coherence Cone: Spectral Causal Body of the Binary Views of a Finite Coherence, a Volume-Fixed Candidate Metric with Deformed Light Cones, and Its Closure by Curvature Divergence at the Spectral Boundaries (N = 4, 5) — RCD Program, Technical Note CC-0 to CC-3 (v0.1)

Arturo Cerezo García

Technical Note CC (CC-0 to CC-3) of the RCD program (continues I-F0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24064727). Question: can a single finite coherence ρ ≥ 0 on ℂ^N, with no prior spacetime, produce a four-dimensional scenario with signature 1+3 and a metric g? This note records a construction that reached an explicit metric and was closed by a pre-registered death condition; it does not claim a derived spacetime. Prior art comes first. A two-report prior-art audit with cross-verification (reports, log and consolidation included) classifies as INHERITED: the cone of 2×2 Hermitian matrices with 4·det as the Lorentz form and SL(2,ℂ) (Baez; Arrighi–Patricot), its physical reading in the qubit — velocity, mass, purity, filtering as Lorentz, concurrence, a pure state being "like a photon" (Chen et al.; Bogdanov et al.; Burns–Greenfield–Dressel; Verstraete et al.; Rungta et al.; Fullwood–Vedral–Guzmán-González) —, the set of compressions (Fan–Pall 1957), the Löwner order as causal order (Mori–Šemrl), the density of compressions as a projection of an orbital measure (Olshanski; Faraut; Baryshnikov), the logic "causal order + volume = metric" (Finkelstein 1969; Hawking–King–McCarthy; Malament; Bombelli–Lee–Meyer–Sorkin) and the program of obtaining 3+1 from binary alternatives (Weizsäcker; Finkelstein; Müller–Masanes; Höhn–Müller; Gil). Three close neighbours (Finkelstein 1969, Brody–Hughston 2005, Gil 2026) are cited as the audit reports them, with a declaration of how each was read. OWN, as far as the two searches reached (medium confidence): (1) reading the views V†ρV of an N-level coherence through framed binary windows V ∈ St(2,N) as events — the spectral causal body 𝒟(ρ) = {2λ_{N−1} ≤ u ≤ 2λ₁, 2λ_N ≤ v ≤ 2λ₂, u ≥ v}, a 4-dimensional region bounded by null surfaces at the eigenvalues of ρ, with the trace as time function; (2) the soldering on the space of windows, e_P(X) = X†B + B†X with B = P⊥ρP: signature (1,3) plus a kernel of dimension 4N − 12 exactly where rank B = 2, and no timelike directions for pure ρ; (3) the coherential variance M̄(a) = E[V†ρ²V | a] − a² in closed form (M̄ = (α − a)(a − β) in the central chamber); (4) a specific metric: the pushed-forward invariant measure of the views as volume (Principle of Coherential Volume) and the cone by pullback of the coherential diffusion tensor (Rule C-0); (5) the computed results. Four postulates are declared, not derived: the governing rule C ⟹ g_μν (thesis of the program, not a result), Gate F (a framed binary cut is physical data), the Principle of Volume and Rule C-0. Results. CC-1 (N = 4): closed-form density of views, constant in the core; the volume metric g = (w/8)^{1/2}η has a flat core, curved outer chambers, R ~ d^{−3/2} at the boundary and undeformed cones; a 200,000-sample check agrees (one badly designed criterion failed, is archived, and was rerun with a corrected, pre-fixed criterion). CC-2 (N = 4): with Rule C-0 the metric is no longer conformally flat — Weyl² ≠ 0 in the four chambers and non-radial null geodesics are deflected — but at the outer spectral boundaries R ~ d⁻¹ and Kretschmann ~ d⁻³. CC-3 (N = 5, new input formulas checked by sampling): same qualitative picture, with R ~ d^{−5/2} and Kretschmann ~ d⁻⁵, i.e. stronger than for N = 4. The three death conditions (isotropic variance everywhere; curvature divergence at the outer boundaries; no deflection of null geodesics) and their operational definitions were written in the script headers and hashed before running; the second one triggered in both computations and the principal ratified both closures. One spectrum per N was computed; N ≥ 6, internal chamber walls and degenerate spectra were not. Not claimed: spacetime, gravity, Einstein's equations, absence of singularities. Scripts, outputs and SHA-256 manifest included; all charges of the adversarial rounds documented. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails.

•Nov 11, 2026•3 citations
Technical Note I-B1 of the RCD program, Act I (continues I-B0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23965761, and I-A0/I-A1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23961108). I-B0 derived, from the frozen input of Act I (an algebra M_d, a state ρ and its full symmetry group G₀), the space 𝒪_ρ of elementary distinctions, its canonical law μ_ρ, the register interface E_ρ and the channel 𝓜_ρ. I-B1 asks whether that structure can produce a concrete record — operationally a pure state δ_Q of the classical algebra C(𝒪_ρ) — without selection, clock, asymmetry or primitive randomness. Result (theorems with numerical control on 17 states in d = 2, 3, 4; no hardware): the No-Free-Actualization Theorem, with four distinct and complementary obstructions. (1) No deterministic G₀-equivariant rule takes μ_ρ to any δ_Q when rank ρ > 1; a concrete record reduces the state's stabilizer from G₀ to H_Q. (2) Every instrument compatible with E_ρ is measure-and-prepare (Haapasalo–Pellonpää), the covariant ones correspond to stabilizer-invariant states, and the segment tQ + (1−t)ρ is covariant with identical statistics: POVM plus symmetry do not fix the post-measurement update; the instrument preparing Q is selected by a declared consistency condition (H_PB, Petz–barycenter), legitimized by the unique affine weak-* continuous extension of the Petz recovery. (3) The canonical closure T_ρ = 𝓜_ρ∘𝓑_ρ is a smoothing kernel (T_ρν ≪ μ_ρ for every ν, never a delta), positive (0 ≤ T_ρ ≤ I) and reversible (detailed balance) with respect to μ_ρ; for ρ = P/r its spectrum is {1, 1/(r+1) with multiplicity r² − 1, 0} with exact contraction (1/(r+1))^{n−1} after the first step and D(Q‖𝓑_ρ(T_ρδ_Q)) = ln((r+1)/2); in d = 2 the spectrum is {1, √(λ₁λ₂) double, 0}, jumping from 1/2 to 1/3 at degeneracy; and a coalescence theorem shows μ_ρ and its second moment discontinuous at every coalescence of positive eigenvalues (Var Tr(P₁Q) jumps from 0 to λ²n₁n₂/(n₁+n₂+1)); every possible distinction lies at the same distance from the barycenter, ‖Q − ρ‖² = 1 − Tr ρ². (4) μ_ρ is realized as Q = gQ₀g* with g Haar-distributed on G₀: the structure derives the law of the sample, not the sample. Stated boundary: it is not claimed that no extension of RCD can derive the event, nor that the event is a fundamental primitive; μ_ρ ⇝ δ_Q is recorded as an open debt; I-A/I-B derive new structure from the Act I input but do not derive that input from a structureless coherence (an upstream question). For I-C the event enters only as a conditional input, and the next wall is stated: can an event be registered without consuming the coherence needed for the next one? Includes an erratum for the two earlier deposits (17 control states, not 16; 14 of rank > 1, not 13). Scripts with SHA-256 manifest; the original run code with a corrected spectral-control error is kept for traceability. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails. "Erratum (v0.2, 5 November 2026): v0.1 of this note and v0.2 of the I-A1 report stated 16 control states; there are 17 (3 in d = 2, 5 in d = 3, 9 in d = 4; 3 pure and 14 of rank > 1), all contained in ia1.out and all passing the gates. Documentary error with no effect on any result or theorem; the I-A0 count (13 cases) is correct. This version corrects the note and the I-A1 report; code and outputs are unchanged."
Technical Note I-B0 of the RCD program, Act I (continues I-A0/I-A1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23961108, and MEM-0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23926847). Act I left wall I-A resolved in the finite species: the pair (M_d, ρ) canonically determines the orbit 𝒪_ρ of elementary distinctions (rank-one projections) whose Haar barycenter is ρ, selecting none of them. I-B0 asks whether those same data generate, on their own, a register interface — a covariant quantum-to-classical channel whose outcome space is not added from outside — that loses the recoverability of every concrete distinction, with no clock, no preferred basis and no external cut. Results (theorems with numerical control in d = 2, 3, 4 on sixteen states; no hardware): (i) Canonical Register Interface Theorem — E_ρ(dQ) = ρ^{-1/2} Q ρ^{-1/2} dμ_ρ(Q) is a G₀-covariant POVM on 𝒪_ρ integrating to the support (the square-root / pretty-good measurement of the canonical ensemble); the channel 𝓜_ρ(σ)(dQ) = Tr(σ E_ρ(dQ)) satisfies 𝓜_ρ(ρ) = μ_ρ; and its Petz recovery map with respect to ρ is exactly the barycentric preparation ν ↦ ∫Q dν of I-A1, so that the I-A1 barycenter and the I-B0 Petz recovery are the same object seen from both sides; the chain (M_d, ρ) → 𝒪_ρ → μ_ρ → E_ρ → 𝓜_ρ requires no new hypothesis; canonicity is self-aligned uniqueness: among covariant rank-one-seed POVMs on 𝒪_ρ, E_ρ is the only one whose response to Q peaks at Q itself (the others are its central relabelings and, only for ρ = P/2, an anti-aligned measurement exhibited in the review round). (ii) Petz Lock — D(Q‖ρ) = S(ρ) on the whole orbit; the gap Δ_rec = D(Q‖ρ) − D(𝓜_ρ(Q)‖μ_ρ) = χ − I(E_ρ) is Q-independent and vanishes iff rank ρ = 1: for rank greater than one the channel returns ρ but is not sufficient for any pair (Q, ρ), i.e. it does not fully preserve any concrete distinction relative to the reference coherence (not absolute irrecoverability). (iii) Exact benchmark Δ_rec(P/r) = H_r − 1 (harmonic number), equal to the Holevo gap of the accessible information of the uniform ensemble (Jozsa–Robb–Wootters); closed form in d = 2, Δ_rec = S(ρ) − ln((1+s)/2) − 1 + s with s = |λ₁ − λ₂|; and a discontinuity of the gap at spectral degeneracy, 2 ln 2 − 1 ≈ 0.386 versus 1/2 at ρ = I/2, because the stabilizer and the canonical orbit change. Stated boundary: no concrete record is adjudicated — 𝓜_ρ(ρ) = μ_ρ, not δ_Q, and no deterministic equivariant rule can select δ_Q; stochastic selection remains open; the realization of an outcome is the question of I-B1, not opened here. Declared heritage: pretty-good measurement, Petz recovery, Barnum–Knill, Holevo's covariant measurements; what is RCD's own is the input, since the ensemble is derived from symmetry rather than postulated. Scripts with SHA-256 manifest. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails. Erratum (v0.2, 5 November 2026): v0.1 of this note and v0.2 of the I-B0 report said “sixteen states” and “thirteen of rank > 1”; there are 17 control states (3 pure and 14 of rank > 1), all contained in ib0.out and all passing the gates. Documentary error with no effect on any result or theorem. This version corrects the note and the I-B0 report; code and output are unchanged.
Technical Note I-A0/I-A1 of the RCD program, Act I (continues MEM-0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23926847). The Act I target sheet (v0.3, frozen, included) asks how a perfectly symmetric coherence can produce an inheritable distinction with no clock, no geometry and no external cut, and names three walls: I-A (Schur, fixed-point algebra), I-B (Petz, recoverability), I-C (Wiesbrock–Borchers, inheritance). This note closes the first two diligences of wall I-A in the finite control species: the algebra M_d(C), a state ω_ρ(A) = Tr(ρA) and the unchosen symmetry group G₀ = Aut(M_d, ω_ρ) ≅ ∏ U(n_a)/U(1). Results (theorems with numerical control in d = 2, 3, 4; no hardware): (I-A0) No-New-Distinction Theorem — the fixed-point algebra equals the double commutant {ρ}″ = W*(ρ) = ⊕ C P_a; no covariant distinction is born de novo: the maximally mixed state has none (and trivial modular flow), a non-tracial state has exactly the 2^{m−1} − 1 sums of spectral projections, a pure state exactly one; covariant channels preserve W*(ρ); general lemma: an invariant input cannot select, by an equivariant deterministic rule, a non-invariant member of an orbit. (I-A1, Theorem I) Canonical Minimal Orbit — the minimal projections (rank 1) fall into G₀-orbits classified by p_a(Q) = Tr(P_a Q); the Haar barycenter of an orbit is Σ (p_a/n_a) P_a; exactly one orbit has barycenter ρ, namely p_a = n_a λ_a, of dimension Σ_{λ_a>0}(2n_a − 1) − 1; symmetry selects none of its members but (M_d, ρ) determines the whole homogeneous space of elementary distinctions, with ρ as its barycenter (pure → a point; tracial → CP^{d−1}; ρ = P/r → CP^{r−1}). (I-A1, Theorem II) Measure — G₀-invariant measures on minimal projections with barycenter ρ correspond to measures ν on the simplex with mean p*; the measure is unique with no hypothesis iff ρ = P/r (p* a vertex), otherwise a convex set of covariant decompositions exists (covariant Schrödinger–HJW, explicit two-orbit mixtures exhibited); under ergodicity the measure is the homogeneous μ_ρ, unique for every ρ. First-moment identity ∫ Tr(QE) dμ_ρ = Tr(ρE) recorded as a linear detector, not as Born. Stated limits: finite species only; ergodicity is a declared hypothesis, not derived; nothing here is time, space, register, probability law or physical selection; I-B and I-C are not opened. Scripts with SHA-256 manifest. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails. Erratum (v0.2, 5 November 2026): v0.1 of this note and v0.2 of the I-A1 report stated 16 control states; there are 17 (3 in d = 2, 5 in d = 3, 9 in d = 4; 3 pure and 14 of rank > 1), all contained in ia1.out and all passing the gates. Documentary error with no effect on any result or theorem; the I-A0 count (13 cases) is correct. This version corrects the note and the I-A1 report; code and outputs are unchanged.
Technical Note I-C of the RCD program, Act I (continues I-B1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23990720; I-B0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23965760; and I-A0/I-A1, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23961107). I-B1 left the boundary that every realization is a sample entering conditionally; I-C asks whether an event can be registered without consuming the coherence needed for the next one, leave an inheritable trace, and take part in an inheritance network. In the tracial sector ρ = P/r (r = 2, 3, 4; no hardware; theorems with numerical control, 92 checks with declared tolerances, all passed), results: (I) Register-with-Residual-Capacity Theorem. A rank-one reading on the whole system admits only nuclear instruments (Haapasalo–Pellonpää) and hence breaks entanglement (Horodecki–Shor–Ruskai); the family A_η(Q) = (1−η)P + ηrQ with Lüders operation L_Q = aP + bQ gives, for 0 < η < 1, an informative reading (I_η > 0, with I₁ = ln r − H_r + 1) together with a non-entanglement-breaking depolarizing channel, p_η = 1 − b²/(r+1) > 1/(r+1), whose posterior state (1−η)P/r + ηQ is the I-B1 segment produced by a mechanism. Exact non-Markovianity on labels, k(Q₃|Q₁,Q₂) − k(Q₃|Q₂) = η²√(1−η²) in r = 2. Finite-history reversal theorem: w_n(Q₁…Q_n) = w_n(Q_n…Q₁) for every n, so no arrow comes from label statistics. Four separate persistences: the classical archive; the averaged residual, decaying as ηp_ηⁿ and never zero; entanglement with discarded registers, dying at n_EB = ⌈ln(1/(r+1))/ln p_η⌉; and entanglement with kept registers, with Schmidt rank r along every trajectory and the exact bound λ_min ≥ [(1−η)/(1+(r−1)η)]ⁿ/r — flagged-survival corollary: with the classical register kept the negativity is an integral of branch negativities and stays positive for every finite n; the classical register is the flag that preserves the resolution of entangled branches, not a source of entanglement. (II) Inheritance network, ratified conditionally under a declared connection scheme H_con (carrier registers): acyclicity by strict inclusion, invariance of density, state, registers and predecessors under all compatible linear extensions and relabeling, rhombus with incomparability sustained by commutation and no-signaling, and the exact counterexample 13/8, 5/4, 1/16 showing that a product label does not imply independence (local statistics factorize iff the posterior is a product). Orientation: the boundary source dies (P/r has a preimage; in a qubit L_{Q⊥}L_Q = √(1−η²)P), the contraction source belongs to the average, and accumulation remains declared. Locality no-go: the Kraus operators span M_r, the commutant is trivial and Fix(Φ_η) = ℂP, even for product labels on ℂ²⊗ℂ²: locality cannot be extracted from the algebra of the global instrument. Diagnostics: Rideout–Sorkin Bell causality transcribed to the label law fails; the prefixed rhombus network is not sprinkling-like. Not claimed: time, space, gravity, irreversibility, Bell causality, asymptotic quantum capacity, or the derivation of η, accumulation, connections or factorization; the event debt (No Free Actualization) remains open. Scripts with SHA-256 manifest; run incidents documented. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails.
ON THE VERSION NUMBER. "v3" is the version of the NOTE, not of this Zenodo deposit. Versions 1 (February 2026) and 2 were circulated privately and never deposited; v1 contained four errors of substance, which are stated with their repairs in the "What changed" section rather than quietly removed. This is the first Zenodo deposit, so if you see a deposit counter it will not match the document version. The document version is the one that matters for citation. Preprint, version 3 (complete rewrite). This note is the synthesis of the contextuality-obstructions program; the proofs live in the companion papers. The proposal is that the Copenhagen viewpoint, stripped of its rhetoric, is a set of structural statements about one geometric object: the transformation groupoid of measurement contexts (maximal abelian subalgebras) with its canonical U(1) 2-cocycle. In that formulation: local validity, the exact classicality of every single context, is a theorem with an explicit witness; complementarity is the nonvanishing holonomy of the cocycle along closed context loops, which detects exactly the all-versus-nothing sector of contextuality; collapse is pinned by statistics, repeatability and covariance to a one-parameter family per degenerate block whose unique efficient member is the Lueders rule, with a classical twin theorem identifying the same axioms' classical solution as Bayesian conditioning; observer-relativity of facts and the movable cut are theorems of an enlarged observer-context category; and the Frauchiger-Renner argument localizes to an ordinary state-dependent violation, with contextual fraction exactly 1/6, carried by a single CHSH facet, the loop holonomy of the observer switch being provably trivial. ATTRIBUTION. The classification of achievable state-independent values, the even/odd dichotomy and the fixed value d/2, is due to Abramsky, Cercelescu and Constantin (FSCD 2024). It is recast here in certificate language; the priority is theirs and is stated in the text. HARDWARE CAVEAT, STATED UP FRONT. Two signatures were measured on superconducting hardware. The quoted significances, about 56 sigma for the triangle holonomy and 35.4 sigma for the Peres-Mermin witness above the deterministic bound 4, are shot-noise statistical only, computed under the implemented model. They are not systematics-aware, and neither experiment is loophole-free. Read them as consistency checks on real hardware, not as precision measurements. ERRATA. Version 1 of this note contained four errors of substance. Section "What changed" states each of them and its repair. They are recorded rather than quietly removed. STATUS AND SCOPE. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article. Each tenet is either a theorem of the companion papers, a machine-verified certificate in the public suite, or is explicitly labeled a conjecture. The paper offers structural characterizations within its stated axioms; it is not an interpretation-free derivation of Copenhagen and it does not claim to resolve the measurement problem. AI-ASSISTANCE DISCLOSURE. This work was carried out with substantial AI assistance. Every load-bearing claim is machine-verified by scripts that ship with the papers, and the author takes full responsibility for the contents. COMPANIONS. Paper A: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630431 . Paper B: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630630 . Paper D: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630697 . Paper C: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21633744 (posted 2026-07-28, after three adversarial review passes; it carries a labelled retraction of an earlier sqrt(2) reading). VERIFICATION CODE. https://github.com/manuflog/contextuality-obstructions
This paper develops a reconstruction of probability that does not begin by assuming a probability space, a probability simplex, or the Born rule. Instead, it asks a prior foundational question: under what physical and mathematical conditions are a set of alternatives entitled to carry positive, additive probabilities at all? The construction begins with lawful histories, future interfaces, and retained records. It distinguishes coherent alternatives from exclusive empirical events, preventing multiple interfering routes from being mistaken for separate probabilistic outcomes. A future-sufficient quotient identifies distinctions that no admitted future test can detect, while a record-qualification step determines when alternatives have become genuine empirical events. Dagger-compatible comparison and positive record factorization then produce a positive comparison kernel, from which normalized event probabilities arise only after the relevant record sectors are certified as exclusive. The framework is extended beyond individual measurements. Compatible finite record refinements generate a global probability measure under explicit realizability conditions; stochastic kernels provide a compositional calculus for carrying probabilistic information through unresolved future structure; and locally classical measurement contexts are assembled into a single positive state on a generally non-Boolean effect structure. This allows globally coherent probability to exist even when no context-independent deterministic assignment of outcomes exists. On a reflection-positive Hilbert-space branch, admissible future contexts are represented by positive effects and positive normalized states by density operators. The Born state-effect law then appears as the finite-dimensional representation of a probability structure that has already been earned through record qualification, positivity, exclusivity, refinement, and contextual consistency rather than introduced as a primitive postulate. The paper also separates two mechanisms that are often conflated: quadratic Born-type weighting arises from dagger self-comparison, whereas equal probabilities for symmetric alternatives arise from symmetry of the outcome structure. A further state-effect bridge analysis classifies residual coordinate freedom and identifies an exceptional rank-two adjugate transformation with Lorentzian signature, which is removed when positive self-dual identification is required. The central interpretation is that probability can function as a lawful form of global completion: it can carry future-relevant law through unresolved structure even when deterministic uniqueness is unavailable. The paper does not derive a mechanism selecting one actual outcome and does not claim that every physical sector satisfies the stated hypotheses. Instead, it provides an explicit dependency-controlled architecture connecting lawful completion, reflection positivity, event qualification, contextuality, stochastic continuation, Hilbert reconstruction, and the Born rule.
Technical Note CC (CC-0 to CC-3) of the RCD program (continues I-F0, DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24064727). Question: can a single finite coherence ρ ≥ 0 on ℂ^N, with no prior spacetime, produce a four-dimensional scenario with signature 1+3 and a metric g? This note records a construction that reached an explicit metric and was closed by a pre-registered death condition; it does not claim a derived spacetime. Prior art comes first. A two-report prior-art audit with cross-verification (reports, log and consolidation included) classifies as INHERITED: the cone of 2×2 Hermitian matrices with 4·det as the Lorentz form and SL(2,ℂ) (Baez; Arrighi–Patricot), its physical reading in the qubit — velocity, mass, purity, filtering as Lorentz, concurrence, a pure state being "like a photon" (Chen et al.; Bogdanov et al.; Burns–Greenfield–Dressel; Verstraete et al.; Rungta et al.; Fullwood–Vedral–Guzmán-González) —, the set of compressions (Fan–Pall 1957), the Löwner order as causal order (Mori–Šemrl), the density of compressions as a projection of an orbital measure (Olshanski; Faraut; Baryshnikov), the logic "causal order + volume = metric" (Finkelstein 1969; Hawking–King–McCarthy; Malament; Bombelli–Lee–Meyer–Sorkin) and the program of obtaining 3+1 from binary alternatives (Weizsäcker; Finkelstein; Müller–Masanes; Höhn–Müller; Gil). Three close neighbours (Finkelstein 1969, Brody–Hughston 2005, Gil 2026) are cited as the audit reports them, with a declaration of how each was read. OWN, as far as the two searches reached (medium confidence): (1) reading the views V†ρV of an N-level coherence through framed binary windows V ∈ St(2,N) as events — the spectral causal body 𝒟(ρ) = {2λ_{N−1} ≤ u ≤ 2λ₁, 2λ_N ≤ v ≤ 2λ₂, u ≥ v}, a 4-dimensional region bounded by null surfaces at the eigenvalues of ρ, with the trace as time function; (2) the soldering on the space of windows, e_P(X) = X†B + B†X with B = P⊥ρP: signature (1,3) plus a kernel of dimension 4N − 12 exactly where rank B = 2, and no timelike directions for pure ρ; (3) the coherential variance M̄(a) = E[V†ρ²V | a] − a² in closed form (M̄ = (α − a)(a − β) in the central chamber); (4) a specific metric: the pushed-forward invariant measure of the views as volume (Principle of Coherential Volume) and the cone by pullback of the coherential diffusion tensor (Rule C-0); (5) the computed results. Four postulates are declared, not derived: the governing rule C ⟹ g_μν (thesis of the program, not a result), Gate F (a framed binary cut is physical data), the Principle of Volume and Rule C-0. Results. CC-1 (N = 4): closed-form density of views, constant in the core; the volume metric g = (w/8)^{1/2}η has a flat core, curved outer chambers, R ~ d^{−3/2} at the boundary and undeformed cones; a 200,000-sample check agrees (one badly designed criterion failed, is archived, and was rerun with a corrected, pre-fixed criterion). CC-2 (N = 4): with Rule C-0 the metric is no longer conformally flat — Weyl² ≠ 0 in the four chambers and non-radial null geodesics are deflected — but at the outer spectral boundaries R ~ d⁻¹ and Kretschmann ~ d⁻³. CC-3 (N = 5, new input formulas checked by sampling): same qualitative picture, with R ~ d^{−5/2} and Kretschmann ~ d⁻⁵, i.e. stronger than for N = 4. The three death conditions (isotropic variance everywhere; curvature divergence at the outer boundaries; no deflection of null geodesics) and their operational definitions were written in the script headers and hashed before running; the second one triggered in both computations and the principal ratified both closures. One spectrum per N was computed; N ≥ 6, internal chamber walls and degenerate spectra were not. Not claimed: spacetime, gravity, Einstein's equations, absence of singularities. Scripts, outputs and SHA-256 manifest included; all charges of the adversarial rounds documented. English and Spanish versions; the Spanish text prevails.