Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Hamiltonian That Was Chosen: Hubbard's Model, Priced

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 5, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A solid is not a thing you can put on a stage. It is electrons in a lattice, every one of them repelling every other, bands on bands, the ions themselves moving — a problem with no exact address. In 1963 J. Hubbard cut that problem down to a stage set: a lattice, one band, a hop of strength t between neighbours, and a repulsion U met only when two electrons land on the same site. Two terms. I credit the cut at full strength in this paper: the two-term model is the working minimal model of correlated electrons, the instrument the metal–insulator debate, superexchange, and the cuprate problem still run on, and my bench solves its smallest room exactly and finds the machinery sound — the six-state two-electron spectrum returns its singlet ground state, its threefold triplet, and its ionic level in agreement with the closed form to 1.110e-15. What I evaluate is where the stage set comes from: it is chosen. The full Coulomb problem of the solid is replaced by postulation, every longer-range interaction, every higher band, and the lattice's own motion deleted with no error bound computed in 1963 or carried on the model's face since; and the two strengths, t and U, enter as dials the paper supplies but cannot set, collapsing on the bench to a single effective number, the ratio U/t. The value has a sharp edge, and it is internal: the field's standard large-U formula for the singlet–triplet gap, J = 4t²/U, departs from the model's own exact two-site gap by +156.1553% at U/t = 1 and +20.7107% at U/t = 4, and stays wrong by more than 10% for every U/t below 6.030227 — an error incurred inside the chosen Hamiltonian, before a single deleted term is evaluated. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23985047

Related papers

The Model Hamiltonian, Postulated: Hubbard's Two-Term Lattice, Its Own Exact Two-Site Answer, and the Asymptote That Leaves It

William Alexander Aldred

Census evaluation (row CC-118) of the founding step of Hubbard's 'Electron Correlations in Narrow Energy Bands,' Proc. R. Soc. A 276, 238-257 (1963), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is one truncated Hamiltonian: the solid's Coulomb problem replaced by postulation with two terms (nearest-neighbour hopping t, on-site repulsion U), every longer-range interaction, further band, and lattice dynamics deleted, with U and t free parameters. Verified in the notebook (7 checks, exit 0) from the postulated Hamiltonian alone on the two-site, two-electron bench with t declared as the unit: ground energy from -2.000000t at U = 0 to -0.039984t at U/t = 100, ionic (double-occupancy) weight from exactly 0.500000 to 0.000400. Remainders at full size: the field's own asymptote J = 4t^2/U departs from the model's own exact gap by 10% at U/t = 6.0302, by 20.71% at U/t = 4, and by 156.16% at U/t = 1; neither parameter is set for any material in the founding text; and the deleted terms have no states in the model's Hilbert space, so the truncation's error is not a number the model can print about itself. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face (CC-91 form): no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

The Ground State for the Hubbard Model on Finite Frustrated Lattices

Kazuhiro Sano, Ken'ichi Takano

The Hubbard Hamiltonian with infinite on-site repulsion and negative transfer is diagonalized numerically on 3×3 frustrated lattices, such as the square lattice with next-nearest-neighbor transfer and the triangular lattice. The number of electrons is chosen to be less by just one electron than that in the exactly half-filled band. When the strength of the frustration is sufficiently large, a singlet state appears as the ground state. Then, the total spin of the lowest excited state is unity. There is an excitation gap for the square lattice but not for the triangular lattice.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Dec 15, 1987•8 citations

Magnetism and Superconductivity in the Two-Band Hubbard Model: A Variational Monte Carlo Perspective

Caterina De Franco

Mott insulators and high-temperature superconductivity: models and materialsBand theory was the first successful theoretical description of metals and insulators.Indeed, it was able to predict the metallic or insulating character of a given material by simple inspection of the electronic spectrum.The solution of the Schrödinger equation, in the presence of the periodic potential, generated by the lattice, gives rise to a band structure, namely a set of electronic states specified by E n (q) (where q is the momentum and n is an integer that labels the band) (Ashcroft and Mermin 2011).At zero temperature, the many-body ground state is obtained by populating the lowest-energy levels, in accordance with the Pauli principle.Then, the distinction between metals and insulators is determined by the filling of the electronic bands: whenever the highest occupied band is completely filled and there is a finite gap to the lowest unoccupied one, the system is an insulator; otherwise, in the presence of partially filled electronic bands, the system is a metal.The foundations of the band theory rely on a strong approximation in which electrons behave as independent particles.Here, the Coulomb interaction is replaced by an effective single-particle potential that represents the average (mean-field) interaction felt by each electrons and generated by all the other ones.In the early years of quantum mechanics the band picture was already well established, however, a few transition-metal 1 filling is considered.The breakdown of the band theory becomes clear when the electronelectron interaction is not negligible.Let us consider a single atom with an electron in the 1s orbital with energy at .When adding a second electron, the total energy turns out to be 2 at + U where U is the Coulomb interaction between the two electrons (see Fig. 1.1).These energy levels are fundamentally different from the usual single-electron spectrum.

•Oct 26, 2018•0 citations

The Two-Valued Spin and Its One Neighbour: Lenz and Ising's Postulated Magnet, Priced

William Alexander Aldred

In 1920 Wilhelm Lenz simplified the magnet to two-valued variables on a lattice, and in 1925 Ernst Ising solved the one-dimensional case of that simplification in his doctoral thesis, a problem suggested to him by Lenz. I credit those papers at full strength: they produced the first exactly soluble model of a magnet, an exact negative result in one dimension, and, through the later exact two-dimensional solution at this same address, the founding landmark of the modern theory of critical phenomena and universality. Nothing in this paper falsifies a result derived inside the model, and nothing in it disputes the model's organising power. What I evaluate is the standing of the model itself in 1920 and 1925. A magnet is replaced, by postulation, with variables sigma_i = ±1 on a lattice, interacting only as nearest neighbours through a single coupling J in H = -J sum over nearest-neighbour pairs of sigma_i sigma_j. The continuous moment, its transverse components, every longer-range interaction and every multi-spin interaction are deleted, and J is a free parameter that no step in 1920 or 1925 sets from the material. My bench evaluates what that postulation carries, on declared inputs only. In two dimensions, on a square lattice, the exact condition sinh(2/t_c) = 1 returns t_c = 2.269185, where t = k_B T / J, with sinh(2/t_c) = 1.000000 at that point; mean field, with coordination number z = 4, returns 4.000000, an overstatement of 76.274717 per cent. The spontaneous magnetisation in Yang's form is M = 0.999276 at t = 1, M = 0.911319 at t = 2 and M = 0.671854 at t = 2.25, and it is zero at and above t_c. In one dimension, Ising's own case, the exact critical temperature is 0.000000, while mean field, with z = 2, invents a transition at 2.000000; the correlation length xi/a = 27.296022 at t = 0.5, 3.671861 at t = 1, 1.295443 at t = 2 and 0.710818 at t = 4, finite at every temperature above zero. Counted plainly: 1 postulated Hamiltonian, carrying 1 fitted coupling and 2 deletion classes, against 0 derivations in 1920 and 1925. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations

Two theorems on the Hubbard model

Élliott H. Lieb

In the attractive Hubbard Model (and some extended versions of it), the ground state is proved to have spin angular momentum S=0 for every (even) electron filling. In the repulsive case, and with a bipartite lattice and a half-filled band, the ground state has S=(1/2\ensuremath{\parallel}B\ensuremath{\Vert}-\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Vert}, where \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert} (\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}) is the number of sites in the B (A) sublattice. In both cases the ground state is unique. The second theorem confirms an old, unproved conjecture in the \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}=\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert} case and yields, with \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\ne}\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}, the first provable example of itinerant-electron ferromagnetism. The theorems hold in all dimensions without even the necessity of a periodic lattice structure.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 6, 1989•2,244 citations

The Correspondence That Was Assumed: Landau's Fermi Liquid, Priced

William Alexander Aldred

There is a liquid that is not made of atoms in the ordinary sense but of the excitations of a Fermi sea, and for seventy years it has been the working language of every normal metal and of liquid helium-3. Lev Landau built that language in 1956 from a single correspondence idea: switch the interactions on slowly, and the interacting system's low-lying states stand in one-to-one correspondence with the free Fermi gas's — the quasiparticle. From it flow an effective mass, a specific heat linear in temperature with a computable enhancement, compressibility and susceptibility ratios, first sound, and the prediction of zero sound, a collective mode later found in nature. I credit all of it at full strength in this paper. What I evaluate is the correspondence's provenance, and the provenance of the numbers the machinery runs on. The correspondence is assumed, not proved: nothing in the 1956 paper shows it survives a real interaction, and its failures — a pairing instability in any attractive channel, the Mott transition, one dimension, where the quasiparticle pole dissolves entirely — were found by exception, not predicted from inside. The Landau parameters the theory runs on are per-material fitted inputs, an infinite tower truncated by hand, and its exact relations recombine them without deriving any: on my bench the effective-mass ratio runs from 0.033333 to 6.000000 as the single fitted input F₁ˢ runs from −2.90 to +15.00 — the output is the input, divided by three and shifted by one. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.

•Nov 5, 2026•0 citations
A solid is not a thing you can put on a stage. It is electrons in a lattice, every one of them repelling every other, bands on bands, the ions themselves moving — a problem with no exact address. In 1963 J. Hubbard cut that problem down to a stage set: a lattice, one band, a hop of strength t between neighbours, and a repulsion U met only when two electrons land on the same site. Two terms. I credit the cut at full strength in this paper: the two-term model is the working minimal model of correlated electrons, the instrument the metal–insulator debate, superexchange, and the cuprate problem still run on, and my bench solves its smallest room exactly and finds the machinery sound — the six-state two-electron spectrum returns its singlet ground state, its threefold triplet, and its ionic level in agreement with the closed form to 1.110e-15. What I evaluate is where the stage set comes from: it is chosen. The full Coulomb problem of the solid is replaced by postulation, every longer-range interaction, every higher band, and the lattice's own motion deleted with no error bound computed in 1963 or carried on the model's face since; and the two strengths, t and U, enter as dials the paper supplies but cannot set, collapsing on the bench to a single effective number, the ratio U/t. The value has a sharp edge, and it is internal: the field's standard large-U formula for the singlet–triplet gap, J = 4t²/U, departs from the model's own exact two-site gap by +156.1553% at U/t = 1 and +20.7107% at U/t = 4, and stays wrong by more than 10% for every U/t below 6.030227 — an error incurred inside the chosen Hamiltonian, before a single deleted term is evaluated. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.
Census evaluation (row CC-118) of the founding step of Hubbard's 'Electron Correlations in Narrow Energy Bands,' Proc. R. Soc. A 276, 238-257 (1963), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is one truncated Hamiltonian: the solid's Coulomb problem replaced by postulation with two terms (nearest-neighbour hopping t, on-site repulsion U), every longer-range interaction, further band, and lattice dynamics deleted, with U and t free parameters. Verified in the notebook (7 checks, exit 0) from the postulated Hamiltonian alone on the two-site, two-electron bench with t declared as the unit: ground energy from -2.000000t at U = 0 to -0.039984t at U/t = 100, ionic (double-occupancy) weight from exactly 0.500000 to 0.000400. Remainders at full size: the field's own asymptote J = 4t^2/U departs from the model's own exact gap by 10% at U/t = 6.0302, by 20.71% at U/t = 4, and by 156.16% at U/t = 1; neither parameter is set for any material in the founding text; and the deleted terms have no states in the model's Hilbert space, so the truncation's error is not a number the model can print about itself. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face (CC-91 form): no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.
The Hubbard Hamiltonian with infinite on-site repulsion and negative transfer is diagonalized numerically on 3×3 frustrated lattices, such as the square lattice with next-nearest-neighbor transfer and the triangular lattice. The number of electrons is chosen to be less by just one electron than that in the exactly half-filled band. When the strength of the frustration is sufficiently large, a singlet state appears as the ground state. Then, the total spin of the lowest excited state is unity. There is an excitation gap for the square lattice but not for the triangular lattice.
Mott insulators and high-temperature superconductivity: models and materialsBand theory was the first successful theoretical description of metals and insulators.Indeed, it was able to predict the metallic or insulating character of a given material by simple inspection of the electronic spectrum.The solution of the Schrödinger equation, in the presence of the periodic potential, generated by the lattice, gives rise to a band structure, namely a set of electronic states specified by E n (q) (where q is the momentum and n is an integer that labels the band) (Ashcroft and Mermin 2011).At zero temperature, the many-body ground state is obtained by populating the lowest-energy levels, in accordance with the Pauli principle.Then, the distinction between metals and insulators is determined by the filling of the electronic bands: whenever the highest occupied band is completely filled and there is a finite gap to the lowest unoccupied one, the system is an insulator; otherwise, in the presence of partially filled electronic bands, the system is a metal.The foundations of the band theory rely on a strong approximation in which electrons behave as independent particles.Here, the Coulomb interaction is replaced by an effective single-particle potential that represents the average (mean-field) interaction felt by each electrons and generated by all the other ones.In the early years of quantum mechanics the band picture was already well established, however, a few transition-metal 1 filling is considered.The breakdown of the band theory becomes clear when the electronelectron interaction is not negligible.Let us consider a single atom with an electron in the 1s orbital with energy at .When adding a second electron, the total energy turns out to be 2 at + U where U is the Coulomb interaction between the two electrons (see Fig. 1.1).These energy levels are fundamentally different from the usual single-electron spectrum.
In 1920 Wilhelm Lenz simplified the magnet to two-valued variables on a lattice, and in 1925 Ernst Ising solved the one-dimensional case of that simplification in his doctoral thesis, a problem suggested to him by Lenz. I credit those papers at full strength: they produced the first exactly soluble model of a magnet, an exact negative result in one dimension, and, through the later exact two-dimensional solution at this same address, the founding landmark of the modern theory of critical phenomena and universality. Nothing in this paper falsifies a result derived inside the model, and nothing in it disputes the model's organising power. What I evaluate is the standing of the model itself in 1920 and 1925. A magnet is replaced, by postulation, with variables sigma_i = ±1 on a lattice, interacting only as nearest neighbours through a single coupling J in H = -J sum over nearest-neighbour pairs of sigma_i sigma_j. The continuous moment, its transverse components, every longer-range interaction and every multi-spin interaction are deleted, and J is a free parameter that no step in 1920 or 1925 sets from the material. My bench evaluates what that postulation carries, on declared inputs only. In two dimensions, on a square lattice, the exact condition sinh(2/t_c) = 1 returns t_c = 2.269185, where t = k_B T / J, with sinh(2/t_c) = 1.000000 at that point; mean field, with coordination number z = 4, returns 4.000000, an overstatement of 76.274717 per cent. The spontaneous magnetisation in Yang's form is M = 0.999276 at t = 1, M = 0.911319 at t = 2 and M = 0.671854 at t = 2.25, and it is zero at and above t_c. In one dimension, Ising's own case, the exact critical temperature is 0.000000, while mean field, with z = 2, invents a transition at 2.000000; the correlation length xi/a = 27.296022 at t = 0.5, 3.671861 at t = 1, 1.295443 at t = 2 and 0.710818 at t = 4, finite at every temperature above zero. Counted plainly: 1 postulated Hamiltonian, carrying 1 fitted coupling and 2 deletion classes, against 0 derivations in 1920 and 1925. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: **REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING** — PREMISE-ONLY, explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: **vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.**
In the attractive Hubbard Model (and some extended versions of it), the ground state is proved to have spin angular momentum S=0 for every (even) electron filling. In the repulsive case, and with a bipartite lattice and a half-filled band, the ground state has S=(1/2\ensuremath{\parallel}B\ensuremath{\Vert}-\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Vert}, where \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert} (\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}) is the number of sites in the B (A) sublattice. In both cases the ground state is unique. The second theorem confirms an old, unproved conjecture in the \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}=\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert} case and yields, with \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\ne}\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}, the first provable example of itinerant-electron ferromagnetism. The theorems hold in all dimensions without even the necessity of a periodic lattice structure.
There is a liquid that is not made of atoms in the ordinary sense but of the excitations of a Fermi sea, and for seventy years it has been the working language of every normal metal and of liquid helium-3. Lev Landau built that language in 1956 from a single correspondence idea: switch the interactions on slowly, and the interacting system's low-lying states stand in one-to-one correspondence with the free Fermi gas's — the quasiparticle. From it flow an effective mass, a specific heat linear in temperature with a computable enhancement, compressibility and susceptibility ratios, first sound, and the prediction of zero sound, a collective mode later found in nature. I credit all of it at full strength in this paper. What I evaluate is the correspondence's provenance, and the provenance of the numbers the machinery runs on. The correspondence is assumed, not proved: nothing in the 1956 paper shows it survives a real interaction, and its failures — a pairing instability in any attractive channel, the Mott transition, one dimension, where the quasiparticle pole dissolves entirely — were found by exception, not predicted from inside. The Landau parameters the theory runs on are per-material fitted inputs, an infinite tower truncated by hand, and its exact relations recombine them without deriving any: on my bench the effective-mass ratio runs from 0.033333 to 6.000000 as the single fitted input F₁ˢ runs from −2.90 to +15.00 — the output is the input, divided by three and shifted by one. Grade for this census entry, printed at full size: REASON FOUND / STILL TURNING — explicitly not a kill and not a falsification. The program headline stands unmoved: vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED / PARTIAL, producing-count 0.