Proposed Chronology Protection as a Potentially Fundamental Law: From Double-Slit Erasure to History-Tagged Invariants (v3 with Epilogue and IBM Test Proposal)
v3 adds: (1) Novelty Statement, (2) Chapter 11: IBM Quantum Test Proposal with Qiskit code and empty results table, (3) Chapter 12: Minimal History Category Hist_2 for the double-slit. Chapters 5, 6, 10 are proved results. Chapters 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12 are models, sketches, and proposals. No value for lambda is claimed. This is a self-published preprint, not peer-reviewed. Previous version: v2 DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23966652
v3 adds: (1) Novelty Statement, (2) Chapter 11: IBM Quantum Test Proposal with Qiskit code and empty results table, (3) Chapter 12: Minimal History Category Hist_2 for the double-slit. Chapters 5, 6, 10 are proved results. Chapters 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12 are models, sketches, and proposals. No value for lambda is claimed. This is a self-published preprint, not peer-reviewed. Previous version: v2 DOI 10.5281/zenodo.23966652
v2 adds Epilogue: Newton, Einstein, and the Next Discrepancy, and a new toy model in Chapter 3. We propose that Hawking's Chronology Protection Conjecture should be grounded in quantum mechanics rather than remain only a conjecture about general relativity. We interpret measurement in the double-slit experiment as a manifestation of a chronology protection law: the universe enforces non-contradiction. This paper makes the proposal mathematically precise where it can be made precise, and honest where it cannot. Proved in this paper: (i) an obstruction class [c] != 0 in H^2(G_tot, A) via bar resolution and cup product, and (ii) decidability of history-equality for regular histories in O(n log n) via Hopcroft minimisation. The protection law itself is formulated as a definition plus a testable suppression factor A_protected = A * exp[-lambda V S_loop], not as a derived theorem of standard quantum mechanics. It is a proposed principle + testable factor, not a proved derivation. Lambda has no measured value yet. New in v2, Chapter 3.3: 2-path interferometer toy model deriving the suppression from decoherence per loop, with table for N = 1, 5, 10, 50, 100. The remaining chapters give models and sketches with explicit gaps for H^2 identification, K0, Ext^2, tilting, classifying topos, and S-matrix correction. No full formalization in Lean of H^2, D^b, topos theory, or quantum field theory is claimed. Lean is used only for value-checks on the E,T pair. Status guide: Proved = complete proof given. Definition = stipulated formalism. Model = analogy, not proof. Sketch = outline with explicit gap. Conjecture = precise statement not proved here.
This treatise proposes that Hawking's Chronology Protection Conjecture should be grounded in quantum mechanics rather than remain a conjecture about general relativity. We interpret the measurement process in the double-slit experiment as a manifestation of a chronology protection law: the universe enforces the principle of non-contradiction — that a particle cannot be recorded as being in two places with definite which-path information while also exhibiting interference. We formalize as A_protected(h) = A(h) * exp[-λ * V(h) * S_loop], where V=1 for contradictory histories, S_loop is loop action, λ is protection coupling analogous to G. Unique contributions: (1) Inversion of Hawking — double-slit as laboratory demonstration of protection, (2) Entanglement as retrocausal erasure preserving light-speed limit c, (3) Falsifiable experimental test via P-CTC circuits on IBM Quantum ibm_kingston with tunable paradox strength r. Author: Robert Aaron TseglinDate: 2026-11-03Keywords: chronology protection, closed timelike curves, quantum eraser, P-CTC, double-slit, retrocausality
Concept first proposed conceptually in self-published treatise on Sept 21, 2020 (30pp, Amazon KDP) as: "the universe erases the past to comply with its own laws, triggered by measurement in the double slit as a fundamental force like gravity." v4 formalization (Nov 3, 2026): We replace circular consistency projector P_consistency with Lorentz-invariant Θ(s^2), s^2=c^2Δt^2-|Δx|^2. We couple Unruh-DeWitt detector to scalar field in Morris-Thorne wormhole with time shift ΔT, Wightman image sum W=Σ 1/[(t-t'-nΔT)^2 - ...]. Derivation yields |<E2|E1>| = exp[-ΔT^2/2T_P^2] far from horizon, →0 at ΔT_c=L/c, where T_P^2=ħG/c^5. This proves in toy model <T_μν>→infinity iff <E2|E1>→0. Vacuum divergence is identified as which-path decoherence. Force: F_c = -k_B T_dS ∇ log Tr(E) = k_B T_dS ΔT/T_P^2, diverging at chronology horizon. Falsifiable prediction: V(ΔT)=exp[-ΔT^2/2T_P,sim^2] testable on IBM Quantum with Lloyd post-selected CTC circuit. Ancillary Qiskit code in appendix. Original 2020 concept: 2020-09-21. Formalization v4: 2026-11-03. References: Hawking PRD 46,603 (1992), Visser gr-qc/0204023, Brun gr-qc/0209061, Deutsch PRD 44,3197, Lloyd PRL 106,040403, Zurek Phys Today, Birrell & Davies. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23914171
In 2020, the author proposed a Chronology Protection Law derived from quantum mechanics (Tseglin, 2020, self-published). That work was theoretical and not peer-reviewed, and did not propose a falsifiable experimental difference from standard quantum mechanics. This paper corrects that gap. It does not claim that chronology protection exists. It does not claim that standard quantum mechanics is wrong. It claims a protocol. We propose a pre-registered delayed-choice quantum eraser experiment that tests for a measurable difference between standard quantum mechanics and a chronology protection force. We define specific observables: visibility loss (ΔV ≥ 0.05), energy cost (ΔE > 5σ), and time delay (Δt > 5σ), with control-vs-control baseline and replication in 3 labs. No experimental result is claimed in this paper. If the predicted anomaly is not observed, the chronology protection force as defined here is ruled out at the tested scale. Protocol version: v1.0, November 15, 2026. Keywords: chronology protection, delayed-choice quantum eraser, quantum mechanics, falsifiable protocol, Hawking, causality
ON THE VERSION NUMBER. "v3" is the version of the NOTE, not of this Zenodo deposit. Versions 1 (February 2026) and 2 were circulated privately and never deposited; v1 contained four errors of substance, which are stated with their repairs in the "What changed" section rather than quietly removed. This is the first Zenodo deposit, so if you see a deposit counter it will not match the document version. The document version is the one that matters for citation. Preprint, version 3 (complete rewrite). This note is the synthesis of the contextuality-obstructions program; the proofs live in the companion papers. The proposal is that the Copenhagen viewpoint, stripped of its rhetoric, is a set of structural statements about one geometric object: the transformation groupoid of measurement contexts (maximal abelian subalgebras) with its canonical U(1) 2-cocycle. In that formulation: local validity, the exact classicality of every single context, is a theorem with an explicit witness; complementarity is the nonvanishing holonomy of the cocycle along closed context loops, which detects exactly the all-versus-nothing sector of contextuality; collapse is pinned by statistics, repeatability and covariance to a one-parameter family per degenerate block whose unique efficient member is the Lueders rule, with a classical twin theorem identifying the same axioms' classical solution as Bayesian conditioning; observer-relativity of facts and the movable cut are theorems of an enlarged observer-context category; and the Frauchiger-Renner argument localizes to an ordinary state-dependent violation, with contextual fraction exactly 1/6, carried by a single CHSH facet, the loop holonomy of the observer switch being provably trivial. ATTRIBUTION. The classification of achievable state-independent values, the even/odd dichotomy and the fixed value d/2, is due to Abramsky, Cercelescu and Constantin (FSCD 2024). It is recast here in certificate language; the priority is theirs and is stated in the text. HARDWARE CAVEAT, STATED UP FRONT. Two signatures were measured on superconducting hardware. The quoted significances, about 56 sigma for the triangle holonomy and 35.4 sigma for the Peres-Mermin witness above the deterministic bound 4, are shot-noise statistical only, computed under the implemented model. They are not systematics-aware, and neither experiment is loophole-free. Read them as consistency checks on real hardware, not as precision measurements. ERRATA. Version 1 of this note contained four errors of substance. Section "What changed" states each of them and its repair. They are recorded rather than quietly removed. STATUS AND SCOPE. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article. Each tenet is either a theorem of the companion papers, a machine-verified certificate in the public suite, or is explicitly labeled a conjecture. The paper offers structural characterizations within its stated axioms; it is not an interpretation-free derivation of Copenhagen and it does not claim to resolve the measurement problem. AI-ASSISTANCE DISCLOSURE. This work was carried out with substantial AI assistance. Every load-bearing claim is machine-verified by scripts that ship with the papers, and the author takes full responsibility for the contents. COMPANIONS. Paper A: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630431 . Paper B: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630630 . Paper D: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21630697 . Paper C: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21633744 (posted 2026-07-28, after three adversarial review passes; it carries a labelled retraction of an earlier sqrt(2) reading). VERIFICATION CODE. https://github.com/manuflog/contextuality-obstructions