Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Postulates of the Atom, Priced: What Bohr Assumed, What the Assumptions Buy, and the Rydberg Constant They Return

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 3, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Census evaluation (row CC-95) of the postulate bundle of Bohr's 'On the Constitution of Atoms and Molecules,' Phil. Mag. 26, 1-25 (1913), member by member against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The bundle -- stationary states that do not radiate against classical electrodynamics; radiation only in sudden quantum jumps by a process the paper does not describe; the frequency condition h nu = E_i - E_f, explicitly not the orbital frequency; states selected by angular-momentum quantization L = n hbar -- is asserted whole against the classical theory the paper still uses for the states' energies. Computed from the postulates plus named CODATA constants (inputs, never used as derived): R_inf = m_e e^4/(8 eps0^2 h^3 c) = 1.097373156807e7 m^-1 against the measured 1.0973731568e7 m^-1; ground-state energy -13.598287 eV (reduced mass) against the measured 13.59844 eV; Bohr radius 5.2917721091e-11 m; Balmer-alpha 656.4696 nm and Lyman-alpha 121.5684 nm against their measured inputs; the emitted 2-to-1 frequency at exactly 3.000000 times the initial orbital frequency, where classical theory requires 1; and the classical Larmor collapse the first postulate suspends, tau = 1.556177e-11 s. Remainders at full size: helium and every multi-electron atom stand outside the bundle's reach (qualitative grade); the jump mechanism and the non-radiation remain postulated, not derived -- closure came by replacement in 1925-26 quantum mechanics, credited to the later theory. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23937705

Related papers

The Non-relativistic Hydrogen Atom

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

One must always do what one really cannot. —Niels Bohr A groundbreaking event in the development of the quantum theory of atomic structure is the remarkable discovery by Johann Jacob Balmer in 1884. He figured out that Anders Jonas Angstrom's measurements of the wavelengths = 4101.2, 4340.1, 4860.74, and 6562.10 Å of the four prominent lines in the spectrum of the hydrogen atom fit the formula, where b = 3645.6 Å, and n = 3, 4, 5, 6. This is an outstanding illustration of the arithmetic genius that Balmer was, being an arithmetic teacher in a girls’ school. Balmer's formula was independently rediscovered by Johannes Robert Rydberg six years later, and rationalized in the planetary model of the old quantum theory proposed by Niels Bohr in 1913. Orbits, however, are intangible, position and momentum measurements not being compatible. Solution to the Schrödinger equation with appropriate boundary conditions satisfactorily account for the Balmer–Rydberg–Bohr formula, explaining the discrete eigenenergies of the hydrogen atom. In Section 5.1, we discuss the bound-state solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom. However, the Schrödinger equation does not fully account for the degeneracy of the energy levels of (even the nonrelativistic) hydrogen atom. This bemusing condition is addressed in the Sections 5.2 and 5.3 of this chapter, and the continuum eigenfunctions are discussed in Section 5.4. 5.1 Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Hydrogen Atom As the very first atom in the periodic table, the hydrogen atom is the simplest one. It is the prototype of one-electron central field atomic systems (including ions) for which exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation can be obtained. The electron–proton two-particles Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom is where and are respectively the notional position vectors in a laboratory frame of reference of the electron and the proton, and m e and m p their respective masses. The gradient operators and seek space derivatives with respect to the electron and the proton coordinates respectively, and the interaction potential energy operator depends on the relative distance between the two particles. The center of mass of the two particles is located at and the reduced mass which is located at the position vector with respect to the center of mass.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

IX. The Quantum Postulate and The Recent Development of Atomic Theory [4]

Niels Bohr•Jan 1, 1985•0 citations

The Separation, Priced: Born and Oppenheimer's Adiabatic Truncation, the Parameter of a Seventh That Justifies It, and the Couplings It Deletes

William Alexander Aldred

Census evaluation (row CC-121) of the founding step of Born and Oppenheimer's 'Zur Quantentheorie der Molekeln,' Ann. Phys. 389, 457-484 (1927), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is a truncation: the molecular wavefunction expanded in kappa = (m_e/M)^(1/4), the electronic problem solved at fixed nuclei, the electronic energy used as the nuclear potential surface, and the derivative (nonadiabatic) couplings dropped -- with no error bound on the deleted terms proved in the paper. Verified in the notebook (8 checks, exit 0) from named constants (proton-electron mass ratio 1836.15267343; atomic mass unit 1822.888486209 electron masses) and declared bench inputs: kappa = 0.152765 for hydrogen (1/kappa = 6.546 -- a parameter of a seventh), kappa^2 = 0.023337, kappa^4 = 5.446170e-4 returning the mass ratio identically; the ladder 1 : kappa^2 : kappa^4 uses the declared Rydberg input (13.605693 eV) down to a vibrational rung of 0.317516 eV = 2560.94 cm^-1 and a rotational rung of 0.007410 eV = 59.76 cm^-1, printed as order exhibits only. Remainders at full size: adjacent rungs are separated by only 1/kappa^2 = 42.850, so kappa^2-order terms are 2.33% effects at the lightest nucleus and the deleted couplings are a whole class of them; across the declared nuclear grid kappa falls from 0.152743 (H-1) to 0.055961 (Fe-56), so the truncation is weakest at its motivating nucleus; and where electronic surfaces approach within the vibrational rung (0.3175 eV at bench) the deleted couplings become the leading physics -- a fence the 1927 paper contains no term to evaluate. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face: no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

VIII. The Quantum Postulate and The Recent Development of Atomic Theory [3]

Niels Bohr•Jan 1, 1985•0 citations

Adiabatic Continuity, Assumed: Landau's Fermi-Liquid Correspondence, the Relations It Returns, and the Instabilities at Its Edge

William Alexander Aldred

Census evaluation (row CC-116) of the founding step of Landau's 'The Theory of a Fermi Liquid,' Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 30, 1058 (1956), with 'Oscillations in a Fermi Liquid,' 32, 59 (1957), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is one correspondence postulate -- the interacting system's low-lying states assumed in one-to-one adiabatic correspondence with the free Fermi gas's -- plus the per-material Landau parameter set, phenomenological inputs throughout (all notebook values are declared bench values, not any material's parameters). Verified in the notebook (9 checks, exit 0): m*/m = 1 + F1s/3 returns 1.000 / 1.500 / 2.000 / 2.800 / 3.000 across the declared grid with the specific-heat ratio equal to it; at one combined bench point the compressibility ratio is 0.1818 and the spin susceptibility ratio exactly 4.000; zero sound is solved exactly from the l = 0 dispersion relation, s = 1.0051 at F0s = 0.5 to 3.2568 at F0s = 30. Remainders at full size: no parameter is computed for any material; the stability boundaries are unguarded (compressibility ratio 200.00 at F0s = -0.99, diverging at -1; m*/m = 0.0333 at F1s = -2.9); and in any attractive pairing channel, however weak, the correspondence fails outright with no threshold. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face (CC-91 form): no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

The Model Hamiltonian, Postulated: Hubbard's Two-Term Lattice, Its Own Exact Two-Site Answer, and the Asymptote That Leaves It

William Alexander Aldred

Census evaluation (row CC-118) of the founding step of Hubbard's 'Electron Correlations in Narrow Energy Bands,' Proc. R. Soc. A 276, 238-257 (1963), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is one truncated Hamiltonian: the solid's Coulomb problem replaced by postulation with two terms (nearest-neighbour hopping t, on-site repulsion U), every longer-range interaction, further band, and lattice dynamics deleted, with U and t free parameters. Verified in the notebook (7 checks, exit 0) from the postulated Hamiltonian alone on the two-site, two-electron bench with t declared as the unit: ground energy from -2.000000t at U = 0 to -0.039984t at U/t = 100, ionic (double-occupancy) weight from exactly 0.500000 to 0.000400. Remainders at full size: the field's own asymptote J = 4t^2/U departs from the model's own exact gap by 10% at U/t = 6.0302, by 20.71% at U/t = 4, and by 156.16% at U/t = 1; neither parameter is set for any material in the founding text; and the deleted terms have no states in the model's Hilbert space, so the truncation's error is not a number the model can print about itself. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face (CC-91 form): no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations
Census evaluation (row CC-95) of the postulate bundle of Bohr's 'On the Constitution of Atoms and Molecules,' Phil. Mag. 26, 1-25 (1913), member by member against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The bundle -- stationary states that do not radiate against classical electrodynamics; radiation only in sudden quantum jumps by a process the paper does not describe; the frequency condition h nu = E_i - E_f, explicitly not the orbital frequency; states selected by angular-momentum quantization L = n hbar -- is asserted whole against the classical theory the paper still uses for the states' energies. Computed from the postulates plus named CODATA constants (inputs, never used as derived): R_inf = m_e e^4/(8 eps0^2 h^3 c) = 1.097373156807e7 m^-1 against the measured 1.0973731568e7 m^-1; ground-state energy -13.598287 eV (reduced mass) against the measured 13.59844 eV; Bohr radius 5.2917721091e-11 m; Balmer-alpha 656.4696 nm and Lyman-alpha 121.5684 nm against their measured inputs; the emitted 2-to-1 frequency at exactly 3.000000 times the initial orbital frequency, where classical theory requires 1; and the classical Larmor collapse the first postulate suspends, tau = 1.556177e-11 s. Remainders at full size: helium and every multi-electron atom stand outside the bundle's reach (qualitative grade); the jump mechanism and the non-radiation remain postulated, not derived -- closure came by replacement in 1925-26 quantum mechanics, credited to the later theory. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.
One must always do what one really cannot. —Niels Bohr A groundbreaking event in the development of the quantum theory of atomic structure is the remarkable discovery by Johann Jacob Balmer in 1884. He figured out that Anders Jonas Angstrom's measurements of the wavelengths = 4101.2, 4340.1, 4860.74, and 6562.10 Å of the four prominent lines in the spectrum of the hydrogen atom fit the formula, where b = 3645.6 Å, and n = 3, 4, 5, 6. This is an outstanding illustration of the arithmetic genius that Balmer was, being an arithmetic teacher in a girls’ school. Balmer's formula was independently rediscovered by Johannes Robert Rydberg six years later, and rationalized in the planetary model of the old quantum theory proposed by Niels Bohr in 1913. Orbits, however, are intangible, position and momentum measurements not being compatible. Solution to the Schrödinger equation with appropriate boundary conditions satisfactorily account for the Balmer–Rydberg–Bohr formula, explaining the discrete eigenenergies of the hydrogen atom. In Section 5.1, we discuss the bound-state solutions of the Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom. However, the Schrödinger equation does not fully account for the degeneracy of the energy levels of (even the nonrelativistic) hydrogen atom. This bemusing condition is addressed in the Sections 5.2 and 5.3 of this chapter, and the continuum eigenfunctions are discussed in Section 5.4. 5.1 Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Hydrogen Atom As the very first atom in the periodic table, the hydrogen atom is the simplest one. It is the prototype of one-electron central field atomic systems (including ions) for which exact analytical solution to the Schrödinger equation can be obtained. The electron–proton two-particles Schrödinger equation for the hydrogen atom is where and are respectively the notional position vectors in a laboratory frame of reference of the electron and the proton, and m e and m p their respective masses. The gradient operators and seek space derivatives with respect to the electron and the proton coordinates respectively, and the interaction potential energy operator depends on the relative distance between the two particles. The center of mass of the two particles is located at and the reduced mass which is located at the position vector with respect to the center of mass.
Census evaluation (row CC-121) of the founding step of Born and Oppenheimer's 'Zur Quantentheorie der Molekeln,' Ann. Phys. 389, 457-484 (1927), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is a truncation: the molecular wavefunction expanded in kappa = (m_e/M)^(1/4), the electronic problem solved at fixed nuclei, the electronic energy used as the nuclear potential surface, and the derivative (nonadiabatic) couplings dropped -- with no error bound on the deleted terms proved in the paper. Verified in the notebook (8 checks, exit 0) from named constants (proton-electron mass ratio 1836.15267343; atomic mass unit 1822.888486209 electron masses) and declared bench inputs: kappa = 0.152765 for hydrogen (1/kappa = 6.546 -- a parameter of a seventh), kappa^2 = 0.023337, kappa^4 = 5.446170e-4 returning the mass ratio identically; the ladder 1 : kappa^2 : kappa^4 uses the declared Rydberg input (13.605693 eV) down to a vibrational rung of 0.317516 eV = 2560.94 cm^-1 and a rotational rung of 0.007410 eV = 59.76 cm^-1, printed as order exhibits only. Remainders at full size: adjacent rungs are separated by only 1/kappa^2 = 42.850, so kappa^2-order terms are 2.33% effects at the lightest nucleus and the deleted couplings are a whole class of them; across the declared nuclear grid kappa falls from 0.152743 (H-1) to 0.055961 (Fe-56), so the truncation is weakest at its motivating nucleus; and where electronic surfaces approach within the vibrational rung (0.3175 eV at bench) the deleted couplings become the leading physics -- a fence the 1927 paper contains no term to evaluate. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face: no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.
Census evaluation (row CC-116) of the founding step of Landau's 'The Theory of a Fermi Liquid,' Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 30, 1058 (1956), with 'Oscillations in a Fermi Liquid,' 32, 59 (1957), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is one correspondence postulate -- the interacting system's low-lying states assumed in one-to-one adiabatic correspondence with the free Fermi gas's -- plus the per-material Landau parameter set, phenomenological inputs throughout (all notebook values are declared bench values, not any material's parameters). Verified in the notebook (9 checks, exit 0): m*/m = 1 + F1s/3 returns 1.000 / 1.500 / 2.000 / 2.800 / 3.000 across the declared grid with the specific-heat ratio equal to it; at one combined bench point the compressibility ratio is 0.1818 and the spin susceptibility ratio exactly 4.000; zero sound is solved exactly from the l = 0 dispersion relation, s = 1.0051 at F0s = 0.5 to 3.2568 at F0s = 30. Remainders at full size: no parameter is computed for any material; the stability boundaries are unguarded (compressibility ratio 200.00 at F0s = -0.99, diverging at -1; m*/m = 0.0333 at F1s = -2.9); and in any attractive pairing channel, however weak, the correspondence fails outright with no threshold. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face (CC-91 form): no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.
Census evaluation (row CC-118) of the founding step of Hubbard's 'Electron Correlations in Narrow Energy Bands,' Proc. R. Soc. A 276, 238-257 (1963), against a fixed bench (what is postulated, what is derived, what the postulates return numerically, what they cannot reach). The step is one truncated Hamiltonian: the solid's Coulomb problem replaced by postulation with two terms (nearest-neighbour hopping t, on-site repulsion U), every longer-range interaction, further band, and lattice dynamics deleted, with U and t free parameters. Verified in the notebook (7 checks, exit 0) from the postulated Hamiltonian alone on the two-site, two-electron bench with t declared as the unit: ground energy from -2.000000t at U = 0 to -0.039984t at U/t = 100, ionic (double-occupancy) weight from exactly 0.500000 to 0.000400. Remainders at full size: the field's own asymptote J = 4t^2/U departs from the model's own exact gap by 10% at U/t = 6.0302, by 20.71% at U/t = 4, and by 156.16% at U/t = 1; neither parameter is set for any material in the founding text; and the deleted terms have no states in the model's Hilbert space, so the truncation's error is not a number the model can print about itself. Scout-grade verification disclosed on the manuscript's face (CC-91 form): no verbatim quotation, no page-specific claim. EXTENSION. Vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED; quantum gravity NOT SOLVED.