Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Kochen–Specker Next Door: What the Dimension ≥ 3 Obstructions Do and Do Not Touch in Paper #363's Territory

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 2, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Discharges item D-361-409-06: paper #363's Kochen-Specker open condition, given its own packet. The obstruction is stated at its exact strength - no single assignment of spectrum values to all observables in dimension at least 3 can respect functional composition on commuting sets - and its finite engine, the Peres-Mermin square, is verified exactly (row products all +I, column products +I, +I, -I, forcing +1 = -1 by parity). The border against #363's tiers is then exact: the expectation-valued additive tier is untouched because its values are not in the spectrum, and Gleason's theorem in fact forces its trace form in dimension at least 3; the per-observable outcome-law tier is untouched because Kochen-Specker constrains joint assignments, not marginals. A joint noncontextual reproducing scheme is killed twice over, independently - its values must be eigenvalues by #363's support argument, and no such eigenvalue assignment exists by Kochen-Specker. No conclusion of #161, #363 or #452 moves. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23936251

Related papers

Moments in Any Dimension: Paper #363's Two-Tier Map, Rebuilt for a General Observable

William Alexander Aldred

Discharges item D-361-409-05: paper #363's two-tier separation, rebuilt for a general observable in a general finite dimension. Tier one: the assignment v(A) = Tr(rho A) is additive pointwise and reproduces every first moment exactly in every dimension (numerical additivity error below 1e-15 in dimensions 3 and 4). Tier two: the variance form Q(A) = Tr(rho A^2) - (Tr rho A)^2 is positive semidefinite on the space of Hermitian operators in every dimension, so a Gaussian random operator with that covariance gives a scheme reproducing first and second moments of every observable simultaneously (verified by sampling in dimensions 3 and 4), at the same price as the qubit case: its values are almost never eigenvalues. Tier three: the outcome law of any observable in any dimension is supported exactly on its spectrum, so any scheme whose values are certain single-measurement returns and which reproduces the full statistics obeys the eigenvalue rule almost surely. Moments yes, outcomes no, in any finite dimension. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.

•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

The canonical class of the MASA context stack and the Peres-Mermin obstruction

Manuel Flores Gordillo

Quantum measurements need not reveal preexisting values: the outcome assigned to an observable can depend on which compatible observables are measured with it. This contextuality underlies the Peres-Mermin proof of the Kochen-Specker theorem and, in quantum computation with magic states, tracks the even/odd parity of the local dimension separating the classically simulable from the genuinely quantum. ATTRIBUTION: the even/odd value classification of state-independent qudit contextuality (the parity dichotomy and the fixed obstruction value d/2) is due to Abramsky, Cercelescu and Constantin, FSCD 2024; this paper supplies its geometric and cohomological ACCOUNT, not a rediscovery of it. Organizing all measurement contexts of M_n(C) into the stack [X/PU(n)] of maximal abelian subalgebras, we show the lifting class of U(1) -> U(n) -> PU(n) is vacuous on the action groupoid U(n) x X but, on PU(n) x X, is a canonical degree-2 class of order exactly n. Its real shadow, through the signed-permutation group B_n, is a Z_2 extension splitting if and only if n is odd, with "-I is a rotation square iff n is even" as the mechanism; at n=4 it restricts to the real two-qubit Pauli class, whose pairing with the Peres-Mermin word is -1, exactly the obstruction to a noncontextual value assignment. We compute H^2 = Z/n (+) Z_2 for n >= 4 and identify the canonical class as a generator of the Z/n summand. STATUS AND SCOPE. Every step is tagged Complete, Sketch (reduced to a named standard theorem whose hypotheses are verified), or Gap, and a status table closes the paper. The finite and algebraic core is machine-checked by scripts in the public suite. The geometric layer rests on standard but non-elementary facts about differentiable-stack cohomology and the Lyndon-Hochschild-Serre spectral sequence; that bookkeeping is reduced to named standard theorems and AWAITS SPECIALIST REVIEW. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article, and should be read at that strength. The finite Weyl value spectrum is developed in a companion paper. Code, data and verification suite: https://github.com/manuflog/contextuality-obstructions Note on methods: large-language-model assistants (Anthropic Claude) were used substantially in drafting, in developing the verification scripts, in literature search and in proposing proofs. Every load-bearing claim is machine-verified independently of that assistance, and the author takes full responsibility for the results, including any errors.

•Jul 27, 2026•0 citations

First Moments Yes, Outcomes No: The Non-Eigenvalue Door on the Pauli Exhibit Is Shut

William Alexander Aldred

Obstruction packet on house paper #161's third kill condition: exhibit a dispersion-free assignment scheme reproducing the quantum statistics while returning non-eigenvalues for single measurements. On #161's own Pauli exhibit family the result is two-sided. Construction side: non-eigenvalue schemes reproduce moments -- the Bloch assignment v(n) = n.r is pointwise additive, returns the non-eigenvalue 0 for sigma_y in |+x>, and matches every quantum first moment exactly (max additivity deviation 4.4e-16 over 500 random pairs); a randomised version with E[w] = r and Cov(w) = I - r r^T matches every second moment = 1 as well, at the printed price E|w|^2 = 3 (sampled 2.9989 at 2e6 draws). Obstruction side: any scheme whose assigned values are the certain returns of single measurements and whose mixture reproduces the full quantum statistics must have its value law equal to the Born outcome law, which is supported exactly on the spectrum {+1,-1} for every spin component; hence its non-eigenvalue mass is zero almost surely in every direction. Numerically the randomised scheme's value law puts mass 0.000000 on the spectrum against the Born law's 1 (mutually singular laws, total-variation distance 1; 31.7% of values outside [-1,+1]). The kill condition therefore does not fire within the exhibit's stated scope: first moments yes, second moments yes, outcomes no. The eigenvalue rule is forced by spectral support independently of S1 and of the 1932 correspondence premise II. Boundary printed: non-return-valued beables (Bohm 1952) and eigenvalue-valued qubit models (Bell 1966) are different species and untouched; general-dimension formulation unclaimed. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.

•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Moments in Infinite Dimension: Paper #452's Two-Tier Map at Continuous Spectrum — What Survives, What Needs a Priced Hypothesis, What Fails

William Alexander Aldred

Discharges item D-441-462-05: the infinite-dimensional, continuous-spectrum form of packet #452's two-tier map (paper #363's moments-yes/outcomes-no separation), graded INCREMENTAL. Tier three is discharged in the measure-theoretic form #452 said was owed: for a self-adjoint observable A with spectral measure E and any density operator rho, the outcome law mu(Delta) = Tr(rho E(Delta)) gives the complement of the spectrum measure zero, so any return-valued scheme reproducing the full statistics takes values in the spectrum almost surely. Two finite-form sentences fail verbatim and are corrected with exhibits: 'eigenvalue almost surely' is false at continuous spectrum (the multiplication operator on L^2[0,1] has spectrum [0,1] and no eigenvalues), and 'supported exactly on the spectrum' survives only as inclusion (a half-supported state has support [0,1/2], a proper subset). Tier one survives verbatim for bounded observables and under a finite-first-moment domain hypothesis for unbounded ones. Tier two survives as a Gaussian process on finite families (verified in the infinite model at Monte Carlo scale), but #452's single Gaussian random operator provably does not exist for any state: the variance form's trace over any Hilbert-Schmidt basis is +infinity, by an explicit witness family (partial sums 2.749756, 25.250000, 250.250000), so the Sazonov-Minlos trace-class condition fails; the rigging rescue is evaluated at the observable scope it costs. Closest prior art is classical: von Neumann's spectral framework, Sazonov-Minlos on Gaussian measures, Gross's abstract Wiener spaces. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.

•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

A variant of the Kochen-Specker theorem localising value indefiniteness

Alastair A. Abbott, Cristian S. Calude, Karl Svozil

The Kochen-Specker theorem proves the inability to assign, simultaneously, noncontextual definite values to all (of a finite set of) quantum mechanical observables in a consistent manner. If one assumes that any definite values behave noncontextually, one can nonetheless only conclude that some observables (in this set) are value indefinite. In this paper, we prove a variant of the Kochen-Specker theorem showing that, under the same assumption of noncontextuality, if a single one-dimensional projection observable is assigned the definite value 1, then no one-dimensional projection observable that is incompatible (i.e., non-commuting) with this one can be assigned consistently a definite value. Unlike standard proofs of the Kochen-Specker theorem, in order to localise and show the extent of value indefiniteness, this result requires a constructive method of reduction between Kochen-Specker sets. If a system is prepared in a pure state ψ, then it is reasonable to assume that any value assignment (i.e., hidden variable model) for this system assigns the value 1 to the observable projecting onto the one-dimensional linear subspace spanned by ψ, and the value 0 to those projecting onto linear subspaces orthogonal to it. Our result can be interpreted, under this assumption, as showing that the outcome of a measurement of any other incompatible one-dimensional projection observable cannot be determined in advance, thus formalising a notion of quantum randomness.

arXiv:1503.01985•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 2015•62 citations

Generalised Kochen–Specker theorem for finite non-deterministic outcome assignments

Ravishankar Ramanathan

The Kochen–Specker (KS) theorem is a cornerstone result in quantum foundations, establishing that quantum correlations in Hilbert spaces of dimension d ≥ 3 cannot be explained by (consistent) hidden variable theories that assign a single deterministic outcome to each measurement. Specifically, there exist finite sets of vectors in these dimensions such that no non-contextual deterministic ({0, 1}) outcome assignment is possible obeying the rules of exclusivity and completeness—that the sum of assignments to every set of mutually orthogonal vectors be ≤1 and the sum of value assignments to any d mutually orthogonal vectors be equal to 1. Another central result in quantum foundations is Gleason’s theorem that justifies the Born rule as a mathematical consequence of the quantum formalism. The KS theorem can be seen as a consequence of Gleason’s theorem and the logical compactness theorem. In a similar vein, Gleason’s theorem also indicates the existence of KS-type finite vector constructions to rule out other finite-alphabet outcome assignments beyond the {0, 1} case. Here, we propose a generalisation of the KS theorem that rules out hidden variable theories with outcome assignments in the set {0, p, 1 − p, 1} for p ∈ [0, 1/d) ∪ (1/d, 1/2]. The case p = 1/2 is especially physically significant. We show that in this case the result rules out (consistent) hidden variable theories that are fundamentally binary, i.e., theories where each measurement has fundamentally at most two outcomes (in contrast to the single deterministic outcome per measurement ruled out by KS). We present a device-independent application of this generalised KS theorem by constructing a two-player non-local game for which a perfect quantum winning strategy exists (a Pseudo-telepathy game) while no perfect classical strategy exists even if the players are provided with additional no-signaling resources of PR-box type (with marginals in {0, 1/2, 1}).

arXiv:2402.09186•npj Quantum Information•Oct 10, 2024•2 citations
Discharges item D-361-409-06: paper #363's Kochen-Specker open condition, given its own packet. The obstruction is stated at its exact strength - no single assignment of spectrum values to all observables in dimension at least 3 can respect functional composition on commuting sets - and its finite engine, the Peres-Mermin square, is verified exactly (row products all +I, column products +I, +I, -I, forcing +1 = -1 by parity). The border against #363's tiers is then exact: the expectation-valued additive tier is untouched because its values are not in the spectrum, and Gleason's theorem in fact forces its trace form in dimension at least 3; the per-observable outcome-law tier is untouched because Kochen-Specker constrains joint assignments, not marginals. A joint noncontextual reproducing scheme is killed twice over, independently - its values must be eigenvalues by #363's support argument, and no such eigenvalue assignment exists by Kochen-Specker. No conclusion of #161, #363 or #452 moves. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.
Discharges item D-361-409-05: paper #363's two-tier separation, rebuilt for a general observable in a general finite dimension. Tier one: the assignment v(A) = Tr(rho A) is additive pointwise and reproduces every first moment exactly in every dimension (numerical additivity error below 1e-15 in dimensions 3 and 4). Tier two: the variance form Q(A) = Tr(rho A^2) - (Tr rho A)^2 is positive semidefinite on the space of Hermitian operators in every dimension, so a Gaussian random operator with that covariance gives a scheme reproducing first and second moments of every observable simultaneously (verified by sampling in dimensions 3 and 4), at the same price as the qubit case: its values are almost never eigenvalues. Tier three: the outcome law of any observable in any dimension is supported exactly on its spectrum, so any scheme whose values are certain single-measurement returns and which reproduces the full statistics obeys the eigenvalue rule almost surely. Moments yes, outcomes no, in any finite dimension. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.
Quantum measurements need not reveal preexisting values: the outcome assigned to an observable can depend on which compatible observables are measured with it. This contextuality underlies the Peres-Mermin proof of the Kochen-Specker theorem and, in quantum computation with magic states, tracks the even/odd parity of the local dimension separating the classically simulable from the genuinely quantum. ATTRIBUTION: the even/odd value classification of state-independent qudit contextuality (the parity dichotomy and the fixed obstruction value d/2) is due to Abramsky, Cercelescu and Constantin, FSCD 2024; this paper supplies its geometric and cohomological ACCOUNT, not a rediscovery of it. Organizing all measurement contexts of M_n(C) into the stack [X/PU(n)] of maximal abelian subalgebras, we show the lifting class of U(1) -> U(n) -> PU(n) is vacuous on the action groupoid U(n) x X but, on PU(n) x X, is a canonical degree-2 class of order exactly n. Its real shadow, through the signed-permutation group B_n, is a Z_2 extension splitting if and only if n is odd, with "-I is a rotation square iff n is even" as the mechanism; at n=4 it restricts to the real two-qubit Pauli class, whose pairing with the Peres-Mermin word is -1, exactly the obstruction to a noncontextual value assignment. We compute H^2 = Z/n (+) Z_2 for n >= 4 and identify the canonical class as a generator of the Z/n summand. STATUS AND SCOPE. Every step is tagged Complete, Sketch (reduced to a named standard theorem whose hypotheses are verified), or Gap, and a status table closes the paper. The finite and algebraic core is machine-checked by scripts in the public suite. The geometric layer rests on standard but non-elementary facts about differentiable-stack cohomology and the Lyndon-Hochschild-Serre spectral sequence; that bookkeeping is reduced to named standard theorems and AWAITS SPECIALIST REVIEW. This is a preprint, not a peer-reviewed article, and should be read at that strength. The finite Weyl value spectrum is developed in a companion paper. Code, data and verification suite: https://github.com/manuflog/contextuality-obstructions Note on methods: large-language-model assistants (Anthropic Claude) were used substantially in drafting, in developing the verification scripts, in literature search and in proposing proofs. Every load-bearing claim is machine-verified independently of that assistance, and the author takes full responsibility for the results, including any errors.
Obstruction packet on house paper #161's third kill condition: exhibit a dispersion-free assignment scheme reproducing the quantum statistics while returning non-eigenvalues for single measurements. On #161's own Pauli exhibit family the result is two-sided. Construction side: non-eigenvalue schemes reproduce moments -- the Bloch assignment v(n) = n.r is pointwise additive, returns the non-eigenvalue 0 for sigma_y in |+x>, and matches every quantum first moment exactly (max additivity deviation 4.4e-16 over 500 random pairs); a randomised version with E[w] = r and Cov(w) = I - r r^T matches every second moment = 1 as well, at the printed price E|w|^2 = 3 (sampled 2.9989 at 2e6 draws). Obstruction side: any scheme whose assigned values are the certain returns of single measurements and whose mixture reproduces the full quantum statistics must have its value law equal to the Born outcome law, which is supported exactly on the spectrum {+1,-1} for every spin component; hence its non-eigenvalue mass is zero almost surely in every direction. Numerically the randomised scheme's value law puts mass 0.000000 on the spectrum against the Born law's 1 (mutually singular laws, total-variation distance 1; 31.7% of values outside [-1,+1]). The kill condition therefore does not fire within the exhibit's stated scope: first moments yes, second moments yes, outcomes no. The eigenvalue rule is forced by spectral support independently of S1 and of the 1932 correspondence premise II. Boundary printed: non-return-valued beables (Bohm 1952) and eigenvalue-valued qubit models (Bell 1966) are different species and untouched; general-dimension formulation unclaimed. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.
Discharges item D-441-462-05: the infinite-dimensional, continuous-spectrum form of packet #452's two-tier map (paper #363's moments-yes/outcomes-no separation), graded INCREMENTAL. Tier three is discharged in the measure-theoretic form #452 said was owed: for a self-adjoint observable A with spectral measure E and any density operator rho, the outcome law mu(Delta) = Tr(rho E(Delta)) gives the complement of the spectrum measure zero, so any return-valued scheme reproducing the full statistics takes values in the spectrum almost surely. Two finite-form sentences fail verbatim and are corrected with exhibits: 'eigenvalue almost surely' is false at continuous spectrum (the multiplication operator on L^2[0,1] has spectrum [0,1] and no eigenvalues), and 'supported exactly on the spectrum' survives only as inclusion (a half-supported state has support [0,1/2], a proper subset). Tier one survives verbatim for bounded observables and under a finite-first-moment domain hypothesis for unbounded ones. Tier two survives as a Gaussian process on finite families (verified in the infinite model at Monte Carlo scale), but #452's single Gaussian random operator provably does not exist for any state: the variance form's trace over any Hilbert-Schmidt basis is +infinity, by an explicit witness family (partial sums 2.749756, 25.250000, 250.250000), so the Sazonov-Minlos trace-class condition fails; the rigging rescue is evaluated at the observable scope it costs. Closest prior art is classical: von Neumann's spectral framework, Sazonov-Minlos on Gaussian measures, Gross's abstract Wiener spaces. Quantum gravity NOT SOLVED; vacuum catastrophe NOT SOLVED.
The Kochen-Specker theorem proves the inability to assign, simultaneously, noncontextual definite values to all (of a finite set of) quantum mechanical observables in a consistent manner. If one assumes that any definite values behave noncontextually, one can nonetheless only conclude that some observables (in this set) are value indefinite. In this paper, we prove a variant of the Kochen-Specker theorem showing that, under the same assumption of noncontextuality, if a single one-dimensional projection observable is assigned the definite value 1, then no one-dimensional projection observable that is incompatible (i.e., non-commuting) with this one can be assigned consistently a definite value. Unlike standard proofs of the Kochen-Specker theorem, in order to localise and show the extent of value indefiniteness, this result requires a constructive method of reduction between Kochen-Specker sets. If a system is prepared in a pure state ψ, then it is reasonable to assume that any value assignment (i.e., hidden variable model) for this system assigns the value 1 to the observable projecting onto the one-dimensional linear subspace spanned by ψ, and the value 0 to those projecting onto linear subspaces orthogonal to it. Our result can be interpreted, under this assumption, as showing that the outcome of a measurement of any other incompatible one-dimensional projection observable cannot be determined in advance, thus formalising a notion of quantum randomness.
The Kochen–Specker (KS) theorem is a cornerstone result in quantum foundations, establishing that quantum correlations in Hilbert spaces of dimension d ≥ 3 cannot be explained by (consistent) hidden variable theories that assign a single deterministic outcome to each measurement. Specifically, there exist finite sets of vectors in these dimensions such that no non-contextual deterministic ({0, 1}) outcome assignment is possible obeying the rules of exclusivity and completeness—that the sum of assignments to every set of mutually orthogonal vectors be ≤1 and the sum of value assignments to any d mutually orthogonal vectors be equal to 1. Another central result in quantum foundations is Gleason’s theorem that justifies the Born rule as a mathematical consequence of the quantum formalism. The KS theorem can be seen as a consequence of Gleason’s theorem and the logical compactness theorem. In a similar vein, Gleason’s theorem also indicates the existence of KS-type finite vector constructions to rule out other finite-alphabet outcome assignments beyond the {0, 1} case. Here, we propose a generalisation of the KS theorem that rules out hidden variable theories with outcome assignments in the set {0, p, 1 − p, 1} for p ∈ [0, 1/d) ∪ (1/d, 1/2]. The case p = 1/2 is especially physically significant. We show that in this case the result rules out (consistent) hidden variable theories that are fundamentally binary, i.e., theories where each measurement has fundamentally at most two outcomes (in contrast to the single deterministic outcome per measurement ruled out by KS). We present a device-independent application of this generalised KS theorem by constructing a two-player non-local game for which a perfect quantum winning strategy exists (a Pseudo-telepathy game) while no perfect classical strategy exists even if the players are provided with additional no-signaling resources of PR-box type (with marginals in {0, 1/2, 1}).