Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

No Friendly Observer: The Local-Friendliness Ledger

William Alexander Aldred

Published Nov 2, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Every laboratory notebook rests on one quiet assumption: that what was seen in the room is a fact for everyone outside the room. In 2018 Frauchiger and Renner showed that three natural demands on reasoning agents — that quantum theory applies at every scale (Q), that agents reasoning with the same theory do not contradict each other (C), and that a measurement has one outcome for the agent who makes it (S) — cannot all hold together. In 2020 Bong and collaborators proved a theory-independent theorem: any theory in which observed events are absolute, influences are local, and experimental choices are not pre-correlated with the world must obey Local Friendliness inequalities that quantum correlations violate, and a photonic experiment violated a genuine one. This paper states both theorems at the strength their authors printed, enters the two photonic receipts with their numbers (Proietti et al. 2019: S = 2.416 ± 0.075 against a bound of 2, from 1,794 six-photon events; Bong et al. 2020: genuine LF inequality, bound 0, maximum quantum value 1.345, first LF violation at state parameter 0.87 after a Bell-without-LF separation at 0.80–0.81), evaluates the three exits — surrender absoluteness of observed events, surrender locality, or surrender free choice — plus the fourth door of denying the friend was an observer, and prints in full the live seam: in both experiments the friend was a photon, and whether a photon's path is an observer is the very thing under dispute. Grade: MENU STANDS — THREE EXITS PRICED, FRIEND UNPROVEN. This paper stands outside my work on the vacuum catastrophe; it draws nothing from that work and repairs nothing in it, and it touches no claim of that program.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23926015

Related papers

Towards violations of Local Friendliness with quantum computers

William J. Zeng, Farrokh Labib, Vincent Russo

Local Friendliness (LF) inequalities follow from seemingly reasonable assumptions about reality: (i) ``absoluteness of observed events'' (e.g., every observed event happens for all observers) and (ii) ``local agency'' (e.g., free choices can be made uncorrelated with other events outside their future light cone). Extended Wigner's Friend Scenario (EWFS) thought experiments show that textbook quantum mechanics violates these inequalities. Thus, experimental evidence of these violations would make these two assumptions incompatible. In [Nature Physics 16, 1199 (2020)], the authors experimentally implemented an EWFS, using a photonic qubit to play the role of each of the ``friends'' and measured violations of LF. One may question whether a photonic qubit is a physical system that counts as an ``observer'' and thereby question whether the experiment's outcome is significant. Intending to measure increasingly meaningful violations, we propose using a statistical measure called the ``branch factor'' to quantify the ``observerness'' of the system. We then encode the EWFS as a quantum circuit such that the components of the circuit that define the friend are quantum systems of increasing branch factor. We run this circuit on quantum simulators and hardware devices, observing LF violations as the system sizes scale. As errors in quantum computers reduce the significance of the violations, better quantum computers can produce better violations. Our results extend the state of the art in proof-of-concept experimental violations from branch factor 0.0 to branch factor 16.0. This is an initial result in an experimental program for measuring LF violations at increasingly meaningful branch factors using increasingly more powerful quantum processors and networks. We introduce this program as a fundamental science application for near-term and developing quantum technology.

arXiv:2409.15302•Quantum•Sep 5, 2025•6 citations

A possibilistic no-go theorem on the Wigner’s friend paradox

Marwan Haddara, Eric G. Cavalcanti

Abstract The famous ‘Wigner’s friend’ paradox highlights the difficulty of modelling the evolution of quantum systems under measurement in situations where observers themselves are considered to be subject to the laws of quantum mechanics. In recent years, variations of the original Wigner’s friend paradox have been recognized as fruitful arenas for probing the foundations of quantum theory. In particular (Bong et al 2020 Nat. Phys. 16 1199) demonstrated a contradiction between a set of intuitive assumptions called ‘Local Friendliness’ (LF) and certain quantum phenomena on an extended version of the Wigner’s friend paradox. The LF assumptions can be understood as the conjunction of two independent assumptions: Absoluteness of Observed Events requires that any event observed by any observer has an absolute, rather than relative, value; Local Agency is the assumption that an intervention cannot be correlated with relevant events outside its future light cone. These assumptions are weaker than the assumptions that lead to Bell’s theorem, and thus while the LF result may be considered to be conceptually comparable to Bell’s result, its implications are even deeper. The proof of the LF no-go theorem, however, relies on probability theory, and a fundamental question remained whether or not LF is an inherently statistical concept. Here we present a probability-free version of the LF theorem, building upon Hardy’s no-go theorem for local hidden variables. The argument is phrased in the language of possibilities, which we make formal by using a modal logical approach. It relies on a weaker version of Local Agency, which we call ‘Possibilistic Local Agency’: the assumption that an intervention cannot affect the possibilities of events outside its future light cone.

arXiv:2205.12223•New Journal of Physics•Aug 9, 2023•28 citations

Local friendliness polytopes in multipartite scenarios

Marwan Haddara, Eric G. Cavalcanti

Recently, the local friendliness (LF) no-go theorem has attracted considerable interest due to its deep foundational implications. This no-go theorem applies to scenarios which combine Bell experiments with Wigner's friend-type setups, containing spacelike separated superobservers assumed to be capable of performing quantum operations on a local observer, also known as their ``friend.'' The theorem shows that a set of assumptions termed ``local friendliness''---weaker than the set of assumptions required for proving Bell's theorem---constrains the space of probabilistic behaviors in extended Wigner's friend scenarios to the ``local friendliness (LF) polytope,'' and that quantum correlations can, in principle, violate those constraints. In this work, we extend the study of local friendliness to multipartite scenarios---with arbitrary but finite numbers of superobservers, friends, measurements, and outcomes---and fully characterize the corresponding LF polytopes, their relationships with each other, with the Bell polytope, the no-signaling polytope, and the quantum set of correlations. In particular, we identify, via constructive proofs, all the canonical LF scenarios where the LF polytope coincides with the Bell polytope---hence identifying all the scenarios where ``genuine LF inequalities'' may arise. Among other results, we also show that whenever the LF polytope is distinct from the Bell and the no-signaling polytope, it also is neither contained in nor contains the quantum set of correlations. Apart from the foundational motivation of better understanding the constraints from local friendliness, our results may also find use in a priori unrelated contexts of device-independent information processing, where the LF polytopes have also been shown to arise, under the name of ``partially deterministic polytopes.''

arXiv:2407.20346•Physical Review A•Jan 9, 2025•7 citations

A "thoughtful" Local Friendliness no-go theorem: a prospective experiment with new assumptions to suit

Howard M. Wiseman, Eric G. Cavalcanti, Eleanor Gilbert Rieffel

A recent paper by two of us and co-workers \cite{CQD20}, based on an extended Wigner's friend scenario, demonstrated that certain empirical correlations predicted by quantum theory (QT) violate inequalities derived from a set of metaphysical assumptions we called "Local Friendliness" (LF). These assumptions are strictly weaker than those used for deriving Bell inequalities. Crucial to the theorem was the premise that a quantum system with reversible evolution could be an observer (colloquially, a "friend"). However, that paper was noncommittal on what would constitute an observer for the purpose of an experiment. Here, we present a new LF no-go theorem which takes seriously the idea that a system's having thoughts is a sufficient condition for it to be an observer. Our new derivation of the LF inequalities uses four metaphysical assumptions, three of which are thought-related, including one that is explicitly called "Friendliness". These four assumptions, in conjunction, allow one to derive LF inequalities for experiments involving the type of system that "Friendliness" refers to. In addition to these four metaphysical assumptions, this new no-go theorem requires two assumptions about what is technologically feasible: Human-Level Artificial Intelligence, and Universal Quantum Computing which is fast and large scale. The latter is often motivated by the belief that QT is universal, but this is not an assumption of the theorem. The intent of the new theorem is to give a clear goal for future experimentalists, and a clear motivation for trying to achieve that goal. We review various approaches to QT in light of our theorem. The popular stance that "quantum theory needs no interpretation" does not question any of our assumptions and so is ruled out. Finally, we quantitatively discuss how difficult the experiment we envisage would be, and briefly discuss milestones on the paths towards it.

arXiv:2209.08491•Quantum•Sep 14, 2023•40 citations

QBism on Locality and Nonlocality

John B. DeBrota, Christopher A. Fuchs, Rüdiger Schack

Recently Pienaar (2026), building on work of Cavalcanti (2021), has shown that QBism cannot always assume distinct observers' quantum-measurement outcomes---say, of Wigner and his friend---are embedded in a single spacetime. This follows from QBism's rejection of the `Absoluteness of Observed Events' assumption in the Bong et al. no-go theorem. Thus, QBism has no choice but to treat the notion of spacetime every bit as personalistic as it treats quantum states and quantum measurement outcomes. In a way, this is not a surprise to QBists, as they have taken the notion of `personalist spacetimes' to be the ansatz most compatible with their other views since at least 2009. But it does enjoin us to finally make crystal clear the sense in which QBism is a purely local interpretation of quantum mechanics despite this new theorem and despite quantum theory's age-old violation of Bell's inequalities. With the extra clarity we also hope to poise QBism for a distinctly new way to approach issues at the interface of quantum theory and gravity.

quant-pharXiv:2608.05368•Aug 7, 2026•2 citations

Agent-Like Observers in Extended Wigner's Friend Scenarios on Quantum Computers

Joshua Laux

The Wigner's friend thought experiment raises the question of whether quantum theory can be applied consistently to systems that include observers. Extended Wigner's Friend Scenarios develop this question by considering several observers who may assign different descriptions to the same experiment. In the Local Friendliness (LF) framework, these scenarios lead to experimentally testable inequalities derived from assumptions such as Absoluteness of Observed Events and Local Agency. Motivated by the “Thoughtful” version of the Local Friendliness no-go theorem, which points towards future LF tests with human-level artificial agents implemented on quantum computers, this thesis implements the “friend” with explicit agent-like functionality within a reversible quantum circuit. Several such agents are constructed and embedded into a one-friend Extended Wigner's Friend Scenario, following recent work that uses quantum computers as a platform for LF violations with more sophisticated “friend” systems. These agents store measurement outcomes, condition later operations on stored information, and, in the most structured case, use Born-rule probabilities to bet on the outcomes of their own future observations. The circuits are implemented in Qiskit, simulated ideally and with IBM-device noise models, and executed on ibm_marrakesh. In ideal simulations, all agent implementations reproduce the maximal quantum violation of a Local Friendliness inequality up to finite-shot fluctuations. Hardware runs show positive Local Friendliness violations for all implemented agents, with decreasing violation strength consistent with greater noise accumulation. The observed violations also remain above an estimated bound obtained by considering relaxations of a Local Friendliness assumption. These results provide a first step towards more structured agent-like friend models in LF experiments on quantum computers.

•May 1, 2026•0 citations
Every laboratory notebook rests on one quiet assumption: that what was seen in the room is a fact for everyone outside the room. In 2018 Frauchiger and Renner showed that three natural demands on reasoning agents — that quantum theory applies at every scale (Q), that agents reasoning with the same theory do not contradict each other (C), and that a measurement has one outcome for the agent who makes it (S) — cannot all hold together. In 2020 Bong and collaborators proved a theory-independent theorem: any theory in which observed events are absolute, influences are local, and experimental choices are not pre-correlated with the world must obey Local Friendliness inequalities that quantum correlations violate, and a photonic experiment violated a genuine one. This paper states both theorems at the strength their authors printed, enters the two photonic receipts with their numbers (Proietti et al. 2019: S = 2.416 ± 0.075 against a bound of 2, from 1,794 six-photon events; Bong et al. 2020: genuine LF inequality, bound 0, maximum quantum value 1.345, first LF violation at state parameter 0.87 after a Bell-without-LF separation at 0.80–0.81), evaluates the three exits — surrender absoluteness of observed events, surrender locality, or surrender free choice — plus the fourth door of denying the friend was an observer, and prints in full the live seam: in both experiments the friend was a photon, and whether a photon's path is an observer is the very thing under dispute. Grade: MENU STANDS — THREE EXITS PRICED, FRIEND UNPROVEN. This paper stands outside my work on the vacuum catastrophe; it draws nothing from that work and repairs nothing in it, and it touches no claim of that program.
Local Friendliness (LF) inequalities follow from seemingly reasonable assumptions about reality: (i) ``absoluteness of observed events'' (e.g., every observed event happens for all observers) and (ii) ``local agency'' (e.g., free choices can be made uncorrelated with other events outside their future light cone). Extended Wigner's Friend Scenario (EWFS) thought experiments show that textbook quantum mechanics violates these inequalities. Thus, experimental evidence of these violations would make these two assumptions incompatible. In [Nature Physics 16, 1199 (2020)], the authors experimentally implemented an EWFS, using a photonic qubit to play the role of each of the ``friends'' and measured violations of LF. One may question whether a photonic qubit is a physical system that counts as an ``observer'' and thereby question whether the experiment's outcome is significant. Intending to measure increasingly meaningful violations, we propose using a statistical measure called the ``branch factor'' to quantify the ``observerness'' of the system. We then encode the EWFS as a quantum circuit such that the components of the circuit that define the friend are quantum systems of increasing branch factor. We run this circuit on quantum simulators and hardware devices, observing LF violations as the system sizes scale. As errors in quantum computers reduce the significance of the violations, better quantum computers can produce better violations. Our results extend the state of the art in proof-of-concept experimental violations from branch factor 0.0 to branch factor 16.0. This is an initial result in an experimental program for measuring LF violations at increasingly meaningful branch factors using increasingly more powerful quantum processors and networks. We introduce this program as a fundamental science application for near-term and developing quantum technology.
Abstract The famous ‘Wigner’s friend’ paradox highlights the difficulty of modelling the evolution of quantum systems under measurement in situations where observers themselves are considered to be subject to the laws of quantum mechanics. In recent years, variations of the original Wigner’s friend paradox have been recognized as fruitful arenas for probing the foundations of quantum theory. In particular (Bong et al 2020 Nat. Phys. 16 1199) demonstrated a contradiction between a set of intuitive assumptions called ‘Local Friendliness’ (LF) and certain quantum phenomena on an extended version of the Wigner’s friend paradox. The LF assumptions can be understood as the conjunction of two independent assumptions: Absoluteness of Observed Events requires that any event observed by any observer has an absolute, rather than relative, value; Local Agency is the assumption that an intervention cannot be correlated with relevant events outside its future light cone. These assumptions are weaker than the assumptions that lead to Bell’s theorem, and thus while the LF result may be considered to be conceptually comparable to Bell’s result, its implications are even deeper. The proof of the LF no-go theorem, however, relies on probability theory, and a fundamental question remained whether or not LF is an inherently statistical concept. Here we present a probability-free version of the LF theorem, building upon Hardy’s no-go theorem for local hidden variables. The argument is phrased in the language of possibilities, which we make formal by using a modal logical approach. It relies on a weaker version of Local Agency, which we call ‘Possibilistic Local Agency’: the assumption that an intervention cannot affect the possibilities of events outside its future light cone.
Recently, the local friendliness (LF) no-go theorem has attracted considerable interest due to its deep foundational implications. This no-go theorem applies to scenarios which combine Bell experiments with Wigner's friend-type setups, containing spacelike separated superobservers assumed to be capable of performing quantum operations on a local observer, also known as their ``friend.'' The theorem shows that a set of assumptions termed ``local friendliness''---weaker than the set of assumptions required for proving Bell's theorem---constrains the space of probabilistic behaviors in extended Wigner's friend scenarios to the ``local friendliness (LF) polytope,'' and that quantum correlations can, in principle, violate those constraints. In this work, we extend the study of local friendliness to multipartite scenarios---with arbitrary but finite numbers of superobservers, friends, measurements, and outcomes---and fully characterize the corresponding LF polytopes, their relationships with each other, with the Bell polytope, the no-signaling polytope, and the quantum set of correlations. In particular, we identify, via constructive proofs, all the canonical LF scenarios where the LF polytope coincides with the Bell polytope---hence identifying all the scenarios where ``genuine LF inequalities'' may arise. Among other results, we also show that whenever the LF polytope is distinct from the Bell and the no-signaling polytope, it also is neither contained in nor contains the quantum set of correlations. Apart from the foundational motivation of better understanding the constraints from local friendliness, our results may also find use in a priori unrelated contexts of device-independent information processing, where the LF polytopes have also been shown to arise, under the name of ``partially deterministic polytopes.''
A recent paper by two of us and co-workers \cite{CQD20}, based on an extended Wigner's friend scenario, demonstrated that certain empirical correlations predicted by quantum theory (QT) violate inequalities derived from a set of metaphysical assumptions we called "Local Friendliness" (LF). These assumptions are strictly weaker than those used for deriving Bell inequalities. Crucial to the theorem was the premise that a quantum system with reversible evolution could be an observer (colloquially, a "friend"). However, that paper was noncommittal on what would constitute an observer for the purpose of an experiment. Here, we present a new LF no-go theorem which takes seriously the idea that a system's having thoughts is a sufficient condition for it to be an observer. Our new derivation of the LF inequalities uses four metaphysical assumptions, three of which are thought-related, including one that is explicitly called "Friendliness". These four assumptions, in conjunction, allow one to derive LF inequalities for experiments involving the type of system that "Friendliness" refers to. In addition to these four metaphysical assumptions, this new no-go theorem requires two assumptions about what is technologically feasible: Human-Level Artificial Intelligence, and Universal Quantum Computing which is fast and large scale. The latter is often motivated by the belief that QT is universal, but this is not an assumption of the theorem. The intent of the new theorem is to give a clear goal for future experimentalists, and a clear motivation for trying to achieve that goal. We review various approaches to QT in light of our theorem. The popular stance that "quantum theory needs no interpretation" does not question any of our assumptions and so is ruled out. Finally, we quantitatively discuss how difficult the experiment we envisage would be, and briefly discuss milestones on the paths towards it.
Recently Pienaar (2026), building on work of Cavalcanti (2021), has shown that QBism cannot always assume distinct observers' quantum-measurement outcomes---say, of Wigner and his friend---are embedded in a single spacetime. This follows from QBism's rejection of the `Absoluteness of Observed Events' assumption in the Bong et al. no-go theorem. Thus, QBism has no choice but to treat the notion of spacetime every bit as personalistic as it treats quantum states and quantum measurement outcomes. In a way, this is not a surprise to QBists, as they have taken the notion of `personalist spacetimes' to be the ansatz most compatible with their other views since at least 2009. But it does enjoin us to finally make crystal clear the sense in which QBism is a purely local interpretation of quantum mechanics despite this new theorem and despite quantum theory's age-old violation of Bell's inequalities. With the extra clarity we also hope to poise QBism for a distinctly new way to approach issues at the interface of quantum theory and gravity.
The Wigner's friend thought experiment raises the question of whether quantum theory can be applied consistently to systems that include observers. Extended Wigner's Friend Scenarios develop this question by considering several observers who may assign different descriptions to the same experiment. In the Local Friendliness (LF) framework, these scenarios lead to experimentally testable inequalities derived from assumptions such as Absoluteness of Observed Events and Local Agency. Motivated by the “Thoughtful” version of the Local Friendliness no-go theorem, which points towards future LF tests with human-level artificial agents implemented on quantum computers, this thesis implements the “friend” with explicit agent-like functionality within a reversible quantum circuit. Several such agents are constructed and embedded into a one-friend Extended Wigner's Friend Scenario, following recent work that uses quantum computers as a platform for LF violations with more sophisticated “friend” systems. These agents store measurement outcomes, condition later operations on stored information, and, in the most structured case, use Born-rule probabilities to bet on the outcomes of their own future observations. The circuits are implemented in Qiskit, simulated ideally and with IBM-device noise models, and executed on ibm_marrakesh. In ideal simulations, all agent implementations reproduce the maximal quantum violation of a Local Friendliness inequality up to finite-shot fluctuations. Hardware runs show positive Local Friendliness violations for all implemented agents, with decreasing violation strength consistent with greater noise accumulation. The observed violations also remain above an estimated bound obtained by considering relaxations of a Local Friendliness assumption. These results provide a first step towards more structured agent-like friend models in LF experiments on quantum computers.