Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Where Did the Interference Go? Eleven Quantum Paradoxes Worked Out with Amplitudes and Records

Sergei Gontsarenko

Published Oct 29, 2026• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

A computational tutorial on standard quantum probability, written in the language of complex amplitudes (“arrows”) and environmental records. Eleven well-known puzzles — two-path interference, the quantum eraser, delayed choice, the Zeno effect and interaction-free measurement, decoherence, Bell–CHSH, GHZ, Hardy’s argument, the Peres–Mermin square, no-signalling and the information–disturbance trade-off — are each worked out explicitly, step by step. For every example the paper separates three things that are often merged: what quantum theory predicts, which classical model (with which assumptions) is excluded, and what is left to interpretation. A further worked example shows that one and the same loss of interference can leave records whose accessible which-path information ranges from none to complete, and how the difference can be estimated from data. Reported tests of higher-order interference are collected with their original uncertainty conventions. Every computed number is reproduced by released, seeded Python scripts; expected results were fixed (with SHA-256 hashes) before each script was run. The scripts, expected-result files and an independent reviewer’s cross-check are attached to this record and embedded in the PDF. No new physical law or quantum algorithm is claimed; the contribution is a connected, verifiable teaching path.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23758746

Related papers

Decoherence without facts: a one-knob model of where which-path records live

Sergei Gontsarenko

Vanished interference fringes do not by themselves tell us that the environment has recorded which path a particle took. This preprint studies a minimal model that separates the two: a qubit acquires a controlled phase from N environment qubits whose purity is set by one knob η ∈ [0,1]. The loss of fringes is the same for every η; what changes is where the information goes. At η = 1 every fragment of the environment carries a copy of the path; for smaller η records become biased coins, and the number of records needed for 0.9 bit grows as 2.7114/(1 − h_η) in the weak-record limit; at η = 0 the qubit is completely dephased while the modelled environment holds no path record and no system–environment entanglement, only a global parity from which any initial state can be restored. For a single witness the paper gives closed formulas for the path knowledge K and the phase-corrected visibility V along a family of readouts between the "kick" and "path" bases, and shows that this family is optimal: with phase-only feed-forward and no postselection, every readout obeys (K/η)² + V² ≤ 1. A two-path clock is the N = 1 case. The PDF embeds all verification scripts, their outputs, seven key files with expected values, a README and a list of SHA-256 hashes; the same files are in the ZIP. Exploratory calculations are distinguished from subsequent verification checks, and the known errors found during review are documented, not removed. No new physical law is claimed. Calculations, figures and typesetting were assisted by AI tools (Claude, Anthropic), used as tools; the author is responsible for the content.

•Nov 2, 2026•0 citations

Retained Records and Recoverable Interference in Discrete Phase Histories

Dae Hoon Kim

This preprint, ISTP Paper II, examines which records must be retained to predict recoverable interference in a two-path quantum system. Identical path statistics can accompany different outcomes of a later joint or conditioned measurement. The analysis distinguishes coherent recombination, summation over unobserved quantum registers, and classical coarse graining after readout. An exact representation assigns nonnegative integer histories to eight phase addresses and implements a specified Clifford+T gate family. For a fixed later outcome, the reduced path state is sufficient over all joint preparations precisely when the measurement effect acts as the identity on the discarded register. Explicit equal-marginal examples demonstrate the consequences when this condition fails. With preparation, transport, record coupling and overall normalization held fixed, four discrete phase settings determine the complex interference coefficient, showing why cancellation at a single setting does not establish an absence of coherence. Three-register circuits compare an accessible path marker with a further environmental record: interference recovered by conditioning on the accessible marker remains limited by the residual environmental overlap. The gates and quadratic Born readout are adopted inputs. The results organize standard quantum structures into a conditional, exactly reproducible account of retained information and measurement access. They do not derive spatial propagation or individual detector events from discrete updates, and they introduce no new erasure principle or departure from quantum mechanics. The spatial screen map and displayed record ordering are explicitly illustrative. This v2.5.1 deposit includes the manuscript, Supplementary Information, editable manuscript sources, and reproducibility package v4.1.1, with exact rational and quadratic-surd data, executable verification commands, and an independent exact-coordinate verifier. CHSH is retained only as a supplementary implementation reference; photoemission is treated separately. Rights: CC BY 4.0 applies to the manuscript, Supplementary Information, and the author's original explanatory figures and tables. Software and build scripts retain their existing rights and are not covered by the manuscript license. See RIGHTS_SCOPE.md and the license notices within the accompanying archives.

•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations

Delayed Choice and Quantum Eraser: An Illustrated Guide Based on the Wave-or-Particle Geometric Framework

junfeng gu

The delayed-choice experiment and the quantum eraser experiment are two of the most challenging interpretive problems in quantum mechanics. Standard textbook accounts trace the presence or absence of interference to whether the experimenter "knows" the photon's path — a causal framework implying backward-in-time influence. This article offers an intuitive, diagram-rich account grounded in the wave-or-particle geometric framework, revealing that both experiments share a far simpler backbone: interference depends solely on how many waves reach a given detector. One wave → no interference. Two waves → interference. This conclusion alters no mathematical prediction of quantum mechanics; it merely flips the causal arrow from "knowing the path destroys interference" to "the number of waves creates interference." A forthcoming main paper will present the complete three-column correspondence (experimental step → geometry → QFT standard) with full algebraic verification.

•Aug 2, 2026•0 citations

Which Bell Causality? Operational Abelianization and a Rideout–Sorkin Theorem for Quantum Sequential Growth

Thomas G Hamilton

Classical Rideout–Sorkin growth is constrained by Bell-type spectator independence, whose equivalent scalar formulations need not remain equivalent for noncommuting quantum transitions. We ask which comparison domains matter for the finite-cylinder predictions of causal-past-ordered quantum sequential growth. Four conventions are distinguished: own-core, direct, source-faithful, and broad. With invertible finite-dimensional transitions, an operator Markov sum rule, and strict covariance of reached vectors, direct Bell implies a parent-independent precursor factorization and a faithful commutative algebra on the reached module. This yields an algebra-valued Rideout–Sorkin reconstruction with a single exceptional junction correction. Although the four conventions have strictly different full-matrix solution classes, the operator defects in three separating examples are invisible on reached states. By contrast, an explicit all-stage rank-two own-core model violates a direct-Bell graft constraint at the level of its Gram kernel, establishing a genuine predictive separation. An all-stage broad-Bell example and a general visibility criterion show that the junction correction can also affect finite-cylinder interference. These results distinguish full operator identities from reached dynamics and coherent finite-cylinder data; they do not claim an extension to covariant infinite-history events. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds ten standalone Python scripts that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all ten certificates and reports ALL PASS. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the scripts are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Third paper in a series, following T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788, and "Bell causality and operational rigidity in quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D. Adds a mechanism theorem for own-core predictive separation in a stated class of complete models: all normalized precursor factors commute, the only possible obstruction is the two-chain graft, all nine birth-six target pairs are decided, and the complete Gram kernel is direct-Bell realizable if and only if the three-chain growth weight is not split. Exact-arithmetic certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24159976.

•Nov 9, 2026•1 citation

Collective charge response is not determined by the few-particle sectors

M.J. Baek

Preprint and reproducibility archive; not peer reviewed. What this record contains. The full text of the manuscript "Identical Few-Particle Gauge Hamiltonians, Programmable Collective Charge Response" (M. J. Baek), its Supplementary Information with complete proofs, and the archive that certifies every closed-form value the paper states. The result. Few-particle dynamics are routinely used to infer collective response in paired quantum matter. This work constructs finite-range interacting response twins that defeat that inference exactly. For any prescribed finite p, two positive finite-range parents have complete static gauge Hamiltonians that coincide at every Peierls link phase on every sector N ≤ p and first separate at N = p+1; their zero-twist finite-density ground rays are the same Dicke condensate, yet their collective charge curvatures differ extensively. The obstruction has no universal depth, and the paper locates it exactly: the blind depth equals the spectator body order, the algebraic bound is independent of geometric range, and bounded range still bounds depth only through the number of sites a ball can hold — so no arbitrary-depth family of uniformly fixed range is claimed. Conversely, a structurally closed exact-pair tower closes at depth two. What is hidden is designable: with d(d+1)/2 displacement families the whole symmetric response-tensor difference is locally realizable at interior filling, and a triangular-lattice twin pair differs only in shear while both diagonal responses stay equal. A 4×4 hard-core-qubit discriminator gives an exact factor-of-two contrast with an internal null control and a state-preparation certificate in 17 equal-time settings. What is certified, and what is not. Results proved in closed form are stated as theorems and proved in full in the Supplementary Information; results established by exact rational or symbolic computation are labelled computer-assisted and carry the script that produces them; the 16-qubit discriminator is a blueprint with an end-to-end noise simulation, not a hardware demonstration, which is not claimed anywhere. Scope limits, open proof lines and one refuted conjecture are recorded explicitly rather than omitted. The archive. response_twins_unified_v1.0.zip contains the manuscript and Supplementary sources, the proof notes, the complete fail-closed verification harness (31 executed stages in release mode — 27 claim-bearing certificate stages, 1 non-claim diagnostic stage and three fail-closed gates — and 24 in quick mode) with one frozen log per stage, independent reimplementations of the load-bearing calculations, negative controls that must fail, the exact-arithmetic certificates behind every closed-form value in the paper, the figure-generation scripts, the scientific claim and provenance record (79 rows with status and scope notes, 50 of them naming the in-archive script or certificate that checks them, the rest saying in words why not), and a per-file SHA-256 manifest of all 209 payload files. Verifying it. Extract the archive and run python3 REPRODUCIBILITY/run_all.py --mode quick for the fast subset or --mode release for all 31 stages; bash BUILD.sh rebuilds both PDFs from source. The three gates check journal-format limits, the release payload against its manifest, and every number the documentation states about the artefacts. Running the harness does not modify the archive: all runtime output is written outside the immutable tree, so verification cannot invalidate the manifest. README.md separates reproducing the content (TeX Live 2023 or newer) from reproducing the archived PDF bytes, which needs the exact producing build recorded inside the PDFs. Licences. Manuscript, Supplementary Information and documentation CC BY 4.0; source code MIT; certificate data CC0 1.0. LICENSE.md is the authoritative per-file mapping and is included both in the archive and as a separate file on this record.

•Aug 7, 2026•0 citations

Demystifying the delayed-choice quantum eraser

Tabish Qureshi

Abstract The delayed-choice quantum eraser has long been a subject of controversy, and has been looked at as being incomprehensible to having retro-causal effect in time. Here the delayed-choice quantum eraser is theoretically analyzed using standard quantum mechanics. Employing a Mach–Zehnder interferometer, instead of a conventional two-slit interference, brings in surprising clarity. Some common mistakes in interpreting the experiment are pointed out. It is demonstrated that in the delayed mode there is no which-way information present after the particle is registered on the screen or the final detectors, contrary to popular belief. However, it is shown that another kind of path information is present even after the particle is registered in the final detectors. The registered particle can be used to predict the results of certain yet to be made measurements on the which-way detector. This novel correlation can be tested in a careful experiment. It is consequently argued that there is no big mystery in the experiment, and no retro-causal effect whatsoever.

arXiv:1908.03920•European Journal of Physics•May 12, 2020•22 citations
A computational tutorial on standard quantum probability, written in the language of complex amplitudes (“arrows”) and environmental records. Eleven well-known puzzles — two-path interference, the quantum eraser, delayed choice, the Zeno effect and interaction-free measurement, decoherence, Bell–CHSH, GHZ, Hardy’s argument, the Peres–Mermin square, no-signalling and the information–disturbance trade-off — are each worked out explicitly, step by step. For every example the paper separates three things that are often merged: what quantum theory predicts, which classical model (with which assumptions) is excluded, and what is left to interpretation. A further worked example shows that one and the same loss of interference can leave records whose accessible which-path information ranges from none to complete, and how the difference can be estimated from data. Reported tests of higher-order interference are collected with their original uncertainty conventions. Every computed number is reproduced by released, seeded Python scripts; expected results were fixed (with SHA-256 hashes) before each script was run. The scripts, expected-result files and an independent reviewer’s cross-check are attached to this record and embedded in the PDF. No new physical law or quantum algorithm is claimed; the contribution is a connected, verifiable teaching path.
Vanished interference fringes do not by themselves tell us that the environment has recorded which path a particle took. This preprint studies a minimal model that separates the two: a qubit acquires a controlled phase from N environment qubits whose purity is set by one knob η ∈ [0,1]. The loss of fringes is the same for every η; what changes is where the information goes. At η = 1 every fragment of the environment carries a copy of the path; for smaller η records become biased coins, and the number of records needed for 0.9 bit grows as 2.7114/(1 − h_η) in the weak-record limit; at η = 0 the qubit is completely dephased while the modelled environment holds no path record and no system–environment entanglement, only a global parity from which any initial state can be restored. For a single witness the paper gives closed formulas for the path knowledge K and the phase-corrected visibility V along a family of readouts between the "kick" and "path" bases, and shows that this family is optimal: with phase-only feed-forward and no postselection, every readout obeys (K/η)² + V² ≤ 1. A two-path clock is the N = 1 case. The PDF embeds all verification scripts, their outputs, seven key files with expected values, a README and a list of SHA-256 hashes; the same files are in the ZIP. Exploratory calculations are distinguished from subsequent verification checks, and the known errors found during review are documented, not removed. No new physical law is claimed. Calculations, figures and typesetting were assisted by AI tools (Claude, Anthropic), used as tools; the author is responsible for the content.
This preprint, ISTP Paper II, examines which records must be retained to predict recoverable interference in a two-path quantum system. Identical path statistics can accompany different outcomes of a later joint or conditioned measurement. The analysis distinguishes coherent recombination, summation over unobserved quantum registers, and classical coarse graining after readout. An exact representation assigns nonnegative integer histories to eight phase addresses and implements a specified Clifford+T gate family. For a fixed later outcome, the reduced path state is sufficient over all joint preparations precisely when the measurement effect acts as the identity on the discarded register. Explicit equal-marginal examples demonstrate the consequences when this condition fails. With preparation, transport, record coupling and overall normalization held fixed, four discrete phase settings determine the complex interference coefficient, showing why cancellation at a single setting does not establish an absence of coherence. Three-register circuits compare an accessible path marker with a further environmental record: interference recovered by conditioning on the accessible marker remains limited by the residual environmental overlap. The gates and quadratic Born readout are adopted inputs. The results organize standard quantum structures into a conditional, exactly reproducible account of retained information and measurement access. They do not derive spatial propagation or individual detector events from discrete updates, and they introduce no new erasure principle or departure from quantum mechanics. The spatial screen map and displayed record ordering are explicitly illustrative. This v2.5.1 deposit includes the manuscript, Supplementary Information, editable manuscript sources, and reproducibility package v4.1.1, with exact rational and quadratic-surd data, executable verification commands, and an independent exact-coordinate verifier. CHSH is retained only as a supplementary implementation reference; photoemission is treated separately. Rights: CC BY 4.0 applies to the manuscript, Supplementary Information, and the author's original explanatory figures and tables. Software and build scripts retain their existing rights and are not covered by the manuscript license. See RIGHTS_SCOPE.md and the license notices within the accompanying archives.
The delayed-choice experiment and the quantum eraser experiment are two of the most challenging interpretive problems in quantum mechanics. Standard textbook accounts trace the presence or absence of interference to whether the experimenter "knows" the photon's path — a causal framework implying backward-in-time influence. This article offers an intuitive, diagram-rich account grounded in the wave-or-particle geometric framework, revealing that both experiments share a far simpler backbone: interference depends solely on how many waves reach a given detector. One wave → no interference. Two waves → interference. This conclusion alters no mathematical prediction of quantum mechanics; it merely flips the causal arrow from "knowing the path destroys interference" to "the number of waves creates interference." A forthcoming main paper will present the complete three-column correspondence (experimental step → geometry → QFT standard) with full algebraic verification.
Classical Rideout–Sorkin growth is constrained by Bell-type spectator independence, whose equivalent scalar formulations need not remain equivalent for noncommuting quantum transitions. We ask which comparison domains matter for the finite-cylinder predictions of causal-past-ordered quantum sequential growth. Four conventions are distinguished: own-core, direct, source-faithful, and broad. With invertible finite-dimensional transitions, an operator Markov sum rule, and strict covariance of reached vectors, direct Bell implies a parent-independent precursor factorization and a faithful commutative algebra on the reached module. This yields an algebra-valued Rideout–Sorkin reconstruction with a single exceptional junction correction. Although the four conventions have strictly different full-matrix solution classes, the operator defects in three separating examples are invisible on reached states. By contrast, an explicit all-stage rank-two own-core model violates a direct-Bell graft constraint at the level of its Gram kernel, establishing a genuine predictive separation. An all-stage broad-Bell example and a general visibility criterion show that the junction correction can also affect finite-cylinder interference. These results distinguish full operator identities from reached dynamics and coherent finite-cylinder data; they do not claim an extension to covariant infinite-history events. Contents of this record: the manuscript (PDF) and its LaTeX source, and a certificates bundle. The bundle holds ten standalone Python scripts that check every finite computation cited in the paper using exact integer and rational arithmetic, together with their result files and SHA-256 checksums. Reproducibility: the scripts use only the Python standard library. Unzip the bundle and, inside its folder, run: python3 run_all.py. It verifies the checksums, runs all ten certificates and reports ALL PASS. The all-stage theorems are proved in the manuscript; the scripts are finite checks. Status: research preprint, not peer reviewed. Third paper in a series, following T. G. Hamilton, "Noncommutative quantum sequential growth under state-level covariance: existence, fixed-seed rigidity, and geometric limits", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.23953788, and "Bell causality and operational rigidity in quantum sequential growth", Zenodo (2026), doi:10.5281/zenodo.24006143.Version 2 (13 November 2026): revised for submission to Physical Review D. Adds a mechanism theorem for own-core predictive separation in a stated class of complete models: all normalized precursor factors commute, the only possible obstruction is the two-chain graft, all nine birth-six target pairs are decided, and the complete Gram kernel is direct-Bell realizable if and only if the three-chain growth weight is not split. Exact-arithmetic certificates: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24159976.
Preprint and reproducibility archive; not peer reviewed. What this record contains. The full text of the manuscript "Identical Few-Particle Gauge Hamiltonians, Programmable Collective Charge Response" (M. J. Baek), its Supplementary Information with complete proofs, and the archive that certifies every closed-form value the paper states. The result. Few-particle dynamics are routinely used to infer collective response in paired quantum matter. This work constructs finite-range interacting response twins that defeat that inference exactly. For any prescribed finite p, two positive finite-range parents have complete static gauge Hamiltonians that coincide at every Peierls link phase on every sector N ≤ p and first separate at N = p+1; their zero-twist finite-density ground rays are the same Dicke condensate, yet their collective charge curvatures differ extensively. The obstruction has no universal depth, and the paper locates it exactly: the blind depth equals the spectator body order, the algebraic bound is independent of geometric range, and bounded range still bounds depth only through the number of sites a ball can hold — so no arbitrary-depth family of uniformly fixed range is claimed. Conversely, a structurally closed exact-pair tower closes at depth two. What is hidden is designable: with d(d+1)/2 displacement families the whole symmetric response-tensor difference is locally realizable at interior filling, and a triangular-lattice twin pair differs only in shear while both diagonal responses stay equal. A 4×4 hard-core-qubit discriminator gives an exact factor-of-two contrast with an internal null control and a state-preparation certificate in 17 equal-time settings. What is certified, and what is not. Results proved in closed form are stated as theorems and proved in full in the Supplementary Information; results established by exact rational or symbolic computation are labelled computer-assisted and carry the script that produces them; the 16-qubit discriminator is a blueprint with an end-to-end noise simulation, not a hardware demonstration, which is not claimed anywhere. Scope limits, open proof lines and one refuted conjecture are recorded explicitly rather than omitted. The archive. response_twins_unified_v1.0.zip contains the manuscript and Supplementary sources, the proof notes, the complete fail-closed verification harness (31 executed stages in release mode — 27 claim-bearing certificate stages, 1 non-claim diagnostic stage and three fail-closed gates — and 24 in quick mode) with one frozen log per stage, independent reimplementations of the load-bearing calculations, negative controls that must fail, the exact-arithmetic certificates behind every closed-form value in the paper, the figure-generation scripts, the scientific claim and provenance record (79 rows with status and scope notes, 50 of them naming the in-archive script or certificate that checks them, the rest saying in words why not), and a per-file SHA-256 manifest of all 209 payload files. Verifying it. Extract the archive and run python3 REPRODUCIBILITY/run_all.py --mode quick for the fast subset or --mode release for all 31 stages; bash BUILD.sh rebuilds both PDFs from source. The three gates check journal-format limits, the release payload against its manifest, and every number the documentation states about the artefacts. Running the harness does not modify the archive: all runtime output is written outside the immutable tree, so verification cannot invalidate the manifest. README.md separates reproducing the content (TeX Live 2023 or newer) from reproducing the archived PDF bytes, which needs the exact producing build recorded inside the PDFs. Licences. Manuscript, Supplementary Information and documentation CC BY 4.0; source code MIT; certificate data CC0 1.0. LICENSE.md is the authoritative per-file mapping and is included both in the archive and as a separate file on this record.
Abstract The delayed-choice quantum eraser has long been a subject of controversy, and has been looked at as being incomprehensible to having retro-causal effect in time. Here the delayed-choice quantum eraser is theoretically analyzed using standard quantum mechanics. Employing a Mach–Zehnder interferometer, instead of a conventional two-slit interference, brings in surprising clarity. Some common mistakes in interpreting the experiment are pointed out. It is demonstrated that in the delayed mode there is no which-way information present after the particle is registered on the screen or the final detectors, contrary to popular belief. However, it is shown that another kind of path information is present even after the particle is registered in the final detectors. The registered particle can be used to predict the results of certain yet to be made measurements on the which-way detector. This novel correlation can be tested in a careful experiment. It is consequently argued that there is no big mystery in the experiment, and no retro-causal effect whatsoever.