Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Emergent quantum electrodynamics from a three-dimensional bosonic lattice: Coulomb law, photons, and Fermi statistics without fundamental fermions

Yichao Liu

Published Oct 16, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study a three-dimensional periodic lattice model whose degrees of freedom are entirely bosonic — Gamma operators and compact U(1) rotors on each link — following the framework of Levin and Wen. Working on a cubic lattice with 64 vertices, 192 edges, and 960 rotor links, we demonstrate numerically that four hallmarks of quantum electrodynamics emerge simultaneously from a single set of local couplings: (i) a 1/r Coulomb interaction between static charges, derived analytically from the line-graph Green’s function and verified on lattices up to L=128; (ii) two transverse photon branches with linear dispersion; (iii) Fermi statistics of composite string-endpoint excitations, confirmed by 23,040 exact anticommutation checks and explicit seven-hop exchange paths; and (iv) a local conservation law that locks charge and flux degrees of freedom. We also identify an exact compensation symmetry of the full Hamiltonian that obstructs the readout of topological labels through native gauge-invariant observables.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23410243

Related papers

Quantum Computing 2+1-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics

Arianna Crippa

This thesis investigates advances in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, with a focus on (2+1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (QED), which shares important features with (3+1)-dimensional quantum chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first project investigates the ongoing coupling in a compact pure U(1) gauge theory using a step-scaling function approach. A quantum variational method allows calculations over a wide range of couplings. Plaquette expectation value results are compared with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can potentially be extended to the study of QED, which also includes fermionic matter. The second project investigates the static potential between two charges, analyzing the Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves the development of a tailored variational approach that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device agree well with classical simulations, validating the method. Furthermore, this work evaluates superconducting quantum devices, noting issues with noise but also demonstrating improvements in hardware and potential through error limitation. Overall, this work underscores the feasibility of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computers. This thesis explores advancements in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, focusing on (2+1)-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which shares key features with (3+1)-dimensional Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first investigates the running coupling in a compact U(1) pure gauge theory using a step scaling function approach. A quantum variational method enables computation across a wide range of couplings. The plaquette expectation value is matched with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can be eventually extended to study QED, where fermionic matter is included. The second project examines the static potential between two charges, analyzing Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves developing a custom variational Ansatz that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device align well with exact classical simulations, validating the method. Additionally, the thesis evaluates superconducting devices, identifying noise challenges but noting improvements in hardware and the potential of error mitigation. Overall, this work highlights the viability of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computing.

•Dec 4, 2025•0 citations

Quantum ether: Photons and electrons from a rotor model

Michael Levin, Xiao-Gang Wen

We give an example of a purely bosonic model---a rotor model on the 3D cubic lattice---whose low energy excitations behave like massless U(1) gauge bosons and massless Dirac fermions. This model can be viewed as a ``quantum ether;'' a medium that gives rise to both photons and electrons. It illustrates a general mechanism for the emergence of gauge bosons and fermions known as ``string-net condensation.'' Other, more complex, string-net condensed models can have excitations that behave like gluons, quarks and other particles in the standard model. This suggests that photons, electrons and other elementary particles may have a unified origin: string-net condensation in our vacuum.

arXiv:hep-th/0507118•Physical Review B•Jan 23, 2006•83 citations

Non-compact Kogut-Susskind gauge theories: 1D lattice models with exact ${\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})$ gauge invariance

Carlos Fulgado-Claudio, Torsten V. Zache

The Kogut-Susskind (KS) formulation of gauge theories constructs quantum many-body Hamiltonians with gauge invariance under a compact Lie group exactly implemented on a spatial lattice. Here, we revisit this construction for a non-compact gauge group. Although motivated in part by theories like general relativity whose first-order formulation involves the non-compact Lorentz group as a local symmetry, we focus on simpler cases in one spatial dimension akin to the Schwinger model. In a bottom-up approach, we show how exact gauge invariance under the simplest non-compact Lie group ${\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})$ can be retained exactly on a 1D lattice, and highlight the differences that arise with respect to compact gauge groups, including a continuous spectrum of the Casimir operators of the gauge fields and the emergence of infinite-dimensional representations of the matter fields. For the pure gauge theory, we discuss how a consistent restriction to the positive semigroup ${\rm SL}^{+}(2,\mathbb{R})$ reproduces well-known results from the quantization of Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity. Motivated by the constraint structure of general dilaton gravity, we introduce static charges coupled to the non-compact gauge field, which can be realised by single-fermion degrees of freedom living in an additional, synthetic dimension. With static charges our lattice model remains exactly integrable, but when extending to dynamical fermionic matter, we arrive at an interacting 1D ${\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})$ KS gauge theory. We give an interpretation of this model as a chain of charges sequentially connected by strings whose tension pulls matter left or right depending on the sign of the relative continuous ${\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})$ fluxes. This picture becomes exact when the involved ${\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})$ charges are strongly self-interacting, where we solve the reduced two-body problem analytically.

arXiv:2611.06771•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Gauge-invariant rotor Hamiltonian from dual variables of 3D U(1) gauge theory

Judah Unmuth-Yockey

We present a tensor formulation for free compact electrodynamics in three Euclidean dimensions and use this formulation to construct a quantum Hamiltonian in the continuous-time limit. Gauge-invariance is maintained at every step and ultimately the gauge fields are integrated out, removing all initial gauge freedom. The resulting Hamiltonian can be written as a rotor model. The energy eigenvalues for this Hamiltonian are computed using the tensor renormalization group, and are compared with perturbation theory. We find good agreement between the calculations, demonstrating a smooth passage from the statistical lattice Lagrangian description to the quantum Hamiltonian description.

arXiv:1811.05884•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Apr 9, 2019•68 citations

Analysis of the confinement string in (2 + 1)-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics with a trapped-ion quantum computer

Arianna Crippa, Karl Jansen, Enrico Rinaldi

Compact lattice Quantum Electrodynamics is a complex quantum field theory with dynamical gauge and matter fields and it has similarities with Quantum Chromodynamics, in particular asymptotic freedom and confinement. We consider a (2+1)-dimensional lattice discretization of Quantum Electrodynamics with the inclusion of dynamical fermionic matter. We define a suitable quantum algorithm to measure the static potential as a function of the distance between two charges on the lattice and we use a variational quantum calculation to explore the Coulomb, confinement and string breaking regimes. A symmetry-preserving and resource-efficient variational quantum circuit is employed to prepare the ground state of the theory at various values of the coupling constant, corresponding to different physical distances, allowing the accurate extraction of the static potential from a quantum computer. We demonstrate that results from quantum experiments on the Quantinuum H1-1 trapped-ion device and emulator, with full connectivity between qubits, agree with classical noiseless simulations using circuits with 10 and 24 qubits. Moreover, we visualize the electric field flux configurations that mostly contribute in the wave-function of the quantum ground state in the different regimes of the potential, thus giving insights into the mechanisms of confinement and string breaking. These results are a promising step forward in the grand challenge of solving higher dimensional lattice gauge theory problems with quantum computing algorithms.

arXiv:2411.05628•Nov 8, 2024•63 citations

U(1) fields from qubits: An approach via D-theory algebra

David E Berenstein, Hiroki Kawai, Richard C. Brower

A new quantum link microstructure was proposed for the lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD) Hamiltonian, replacing the Wilson gauge links with a bilinear of fermionic qubits, later generalized to D-theory. This formalism provides a general framework for building lattice field theory algorithms for quantum computing. We focus mostly on the simplest case of a quantum rotor for a single compact U(1) field. We also make some progress for non-Abelian setups, making it clear that the ideas developed in the U(1) case extend to other groups. These in turn are building blocks for 1 + 0 -dimensional ( 1 + 0 -D) matrix models, 1 + 1 -D sigma models and non-Abelian gauge theories in 2 + 1 and 3 + 1 dimensions. By introducing multiple flavors for the U(1) field, where the flavor symmetry is gauged, we can efficiently approach the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space of the quantum O(2) rotor with increasing flavors. The emphasis of the method is on preserving the symplectic algebra exchanging fermionic qubits by sigma matrices (or hard bosons) and developing a formal strategy capable of generalization to a SU ( 3 ) field for lattice QCD and other non-Abelian 1 + 1 -D sigma models or 3 + 1 -D gauge theories. For U(1), we discuss briefly the qubit algorithms for the study of the discrete 1 + 1 -D sine-Gordon equation. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2201.02412•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 9, 2024•7 citations
We study a three-dimensional periodic lattice model whose degrees of freedom are entirely bosonic — Gamma operators and compact U(1) rotors on each link — following the framework of Levin and Wen. Working on a cubic lattice with 64 vertices, 192 edges, and 960 rotor links, we demonstrate numerically that four hallmarks of quantum electrodynamics emerge simultaneously from a single set of local couplings: (i) a 1/r Coulomb interaction between static charges, derived analytically from the line-graph Green’s function and verified on lattices up to L=128; (ii) two transverse photon branches with linear dispersion; (iii) Fermi statistics of composite string-endpoint excitations, confirmed by 23,040 exact anticommutation checks and explicit seven-hop exchange paths; and (iv) a local conservation law that locks charge and flux degrees of freedom. We also identify an exact compensation symmetry of the full Hamiltonian that obstructs the readout of topological labels through native gauge-invariant observables.
This thesis investigates advances in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, with a focus on (2+1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (QED), which shares important features with (3+1)-dimensional quantum chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first project investigates the ongoing coupling in a compact pure U(1) gauge theory using a step-scaling function approach. A quantum variational method allows calculations over a wide range of couplings. Plaquette expectation value results are compared with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can potentially be extended to the study of QED, which also includes fermionic matter. The second project investigates the static potential between two charges, analyzing the Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves the development of a tailored variational approach that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device agree well with classical simulations, validating the method. Furthermore, this work evaluates superconducting quantum devices, noting issues with noise but also demonstrating improvements in hardware and potential through error limitation. Overall, this work underscores the feasibility of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computers. This thesis explores advancements in quantum simulation methods for lattice gauge theories, focusing on (2+1)-dimensional Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which shares key features with (3+1)-dimensional Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), such as confinement and asymptotic freedom. Two main projects are developed. The first investigates the running coupling in a compact U(1) pure gauge theory using a step scaling function approach. A quantum variational method enables computation across a wide range of couplings. The plaquette expectation value is matched with classical Monte Carlo simulations to obtain, in principle, the physical value of the lattice spacing. This method can be eventually extended to study QED, where fermionic matter is included. The second project examines the static potential between two charges, analyzing Coulomb, confining, and string-breaking regimes. It involves developing a custom variational Ansatz that incorporates system symmetries and mutual information to represent fermionic degrees of freedom. Results from a trapped-ion quantum device align well with exact classical simulations, validating the method. Additionally, the thesis evaluates superconducting devices, identifying noise challenges but noting improvements in hardware and the potential of error mitigation. Overall, this work highlights the viability of variational quantum algorithms for lattice gauge theory simulations and demonstrates their promise for advancing theoretical physics with quantum computing.
We give an example of a purely bosonic model---a rotor model on the 3D cubic lattice---whose low energy excitations behave like massless U(1) gauge bosons and massless Dirac fermions. This model can be viewed as a ``quantum ether;'' a medium that gives rise to both photons and electrons. It illustrates a general mechanism for the emergence of gauge bosons and fermions known as ``string-net condensation.'' Other, more complex, string-net condensed models can have excitations that behave like gluons, quarks and other particles in the standard model. This suggests that photons, electrons and other elementary particles may have a unified origin: string-net condensation in our vacuum.
Non-compact Kogut-Susskind gauge theories: 1D lattice models with exact SL(2,R){\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})SL(2,R) gauge invariance
The Kogut-Susskind (KS) formulation of gauge theories constructs quantum many-body Hamiltonians with gauge invariance under a compact Lie group exactly implemented on a spatial lattice. Here, we revisit this construction for a non-compact gauge group. Although motivated in part by theories like general relativity whose first-order formulation involves the non-compact Lorentz group as a local symmetry, we focus on simpler cases in one spatial dimension akin to the Schwinger model. In a bottom-up approach, we show how exact gauge invariance under the simplest non-compact Lie group SL(2,R){\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})SL(2,R) can be retained exactly on a 1D lattice, and highlight the differences that arise with respect to compact gauge groups, including a continuous spectrum of the Casimir operators of the gauge fields and the emergence of infinite-dimensional representations of the matter fields. For the pure gauge theory, we discuss how a consistent restriction to the positive semigroup SL+(2,R){\rm SL}^{+}(2,\mathbb{R})SL+(2,R) reproduces well-known results from the quantization of Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity. Motivated by the constraint structure of general dilaton gravity, we introduce static charges coupled to the non-compact gauge field, which can be realised by single-fermion degrees of freedom living in an additional, synthetic dimension. With static charges our lattice model remains exactly integrable, but when extending to dynamical fermionic matter, we arrive at an interacting 1D SL(2,R){\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})SL(2,R) KS gauge theory. We give an interpretation of this model as a chain of charges sequentially connected by strings whose tension pulls matter left or right depending on the sign of the relative continuous SL(2,R){\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})SL(2,R) fluxes. This picture becomes exact when the involved SL(2,R){\rm SL}(2,\mathbb{R})SL(2,R) charges are strongly self-interacting, where we solve the reduced two-body problem analytically.
We present a tensor formulation for free compact electrodynamics in three Euclidean dimensions and use this formulation to construct a quantum Hamiltonian in the continuous-time limit. Gauge-invariance is maintained at every step and ultimately the gauge fields are integrated out, removing all initial gauge freedom. The resulting Hamiltonian can be written as a rotor model. The energy eigenvalues for this Hamiltonian are computed using the tensor renormalization group, and are compared with perturbation theory. We find good agreement between the calculations, demonstrating a smooth passage from the statistical lattice Lagrangian description to the quantum Hamiltonian description.
Compact lattice Quantum Electrodynamics is a complex quantum field theory with dynamical gauge and matter fields and it has similarities with Quantum Chromodynamics, in particular asymptotic freedom and confinement. We consider a (2+1)-dimensional lattice discretization of Quantum Electrodynamics with the inclusion of dynamical fermionic matter. We define a suitable quantum algorithm to measure the static potential as a function of the distance between two charges on the lattice and we use a variational quantum calculation to explore the Coulomb, confinement and string breaking regimes. A symmetry-preserving and resource-efficient variational quantum circuit is employed to prepare the ground state of the theory at various values of the coupling constant, corresponding to different physical distances, allowing the accurate extraction of the static potential from a quantum computer. We demonstrate that results from quantum experiments on the Quantinuum H1-1 trapped-ion device and emulator, with full connectivity between qubits, agree with classical noiseless simulations using circuits with 10 and 24 qubits. Moreover, we visualize the electric field flux configurations that mostly contribute in the wave-function of the quantum ground state in the different regimes of the potential, thus giving insights into the mechanisms of confinement and string breaking. These results are a promising step forward in the grand challenge of solving higher dimensional lattice gauge theory problems with quantum computing algorithms.
A new quantum link microstructure was proposed for the lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD) Hamiltonian, replacing the Wilson gauge links with a bilinear of fermionic qubits, later generalized to D-theory. This formalism provides a general framework for building lattice field theory algorithms for quantum computing. We focus mostly on the simplest case of a quantum rotor for a single compact U(1) field. We also make some progress for non-Abelian setups, making it clear that the ideas developed in the U(1) case extend to other groups. These in turn are building blocks for 1 + 0 -dimensional ( 1 + 0 -D) matrix models, 1 + 1 -D sigma models and non-Abelian gauge theories in 2 + 1 and 3 + 1 dimensions. By introducing multiple flavors for the U(1) field, where the flavor symmetry is gauged, we can efficiently approach the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space of the quantum O(2) rotor with increasing flavors. The emphasis of the method is on preserving the symplectic algebra exchanging fermionic qubits by sigma matrices (or hard bosons) and developing a formal strategy capable of generalization to a SU ( 3 ) field for lattice QCD and other non-Abelian 1 + 1 -D sigma models or 3 + 1 -D gauge theories. For U(1), we discuss briefly the qubit algorithms for the study of the discrete 1 + 1 -D sine-Gordon equation. Published by the American Physical Society 2024