Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Thermodynamics of Scale: Entropic c-Functions, Data Processing, Spectral Thermodynamics, Fluctuation Relations, and the Arrow of Time

Ruqing Chen

Published Oct 7, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The irreversibility of the renormalization group (RG) is often described in thermodynamic language: information is "lost" under coarse-graining, c "decreases like an entropy", scale behaves like a temperature, and the RG arrow is compared with the arrow of time. This paper sorts such statements into four kinds (theorems, exact identities, standard physics applied to scale, and conjecture) and checks every exact statement numerically. (1) The c, F and a theorems state that c_UV > c_IR, a decrease from the ultraviolet to the infrared. In the entropic proofs this follows from strong subadditivity and Lorentz invariance, not from a thermodynamic law. For a massive lattice Dirac fermion, the Casini–Huerta function c(ℓ) = 3ℓ dS/dℓ decreases monotonically to zero. At the critical point it reproduces c = 1 times the finite-size chord factor (πℓ/N)cot(πℓ/N). (2) The monotonicity of relative entropy under quantum channels gives a rigorous H-theorem: if an RG step is a channel with an invariant state σ*, then D(Φⁿ(ρ)‖σ*) is non-increasing. This is verified on block restrictions of Gaussian fermion states. (3) Read the heat-kernel time τ as an inverse temperature on the Laplacian spectrum. Then S(τ) = ln P + τ⟨λ⟩ = −D(π_τ‖μ) is non-increasing, where μ is the density-of-states measure. The heat capacity C = τ²Var(λ) obeys C = d_s/2 − (1/2) dd_s/d ln τ, so on scaling plateaus the spectral dimension is twice a heat capacity. For hypercubic lattices C has a closed form, with a Schottky-type maximum of 0.6799 d and the equipartition limit d/2. (4) A physical protocol that changes the correlation length of a lattice field in time obeys the Jarzynski and Crooks relations exactly. For a sudden quench, the Jarzynski estimator has finite variance if and only if ω_f²/ω_i² > 1/2 for every mode. For finite ramp times, an exact Riccati equation for the tilted Gaussian density shows that the softening protocol keeps an infinite variance at every simulated ramp time. For the stiffening protocol the exact relative variances predict the observed standard errors. Jarzynski and Bennett acceptance-ratio estimates recover ΔF to within 0.015. Landauer's bound applies to physical erasure, not to the theorist's coarse-graining map. The identification of the RG arrow with the arrow of time, suggested by dS/CFT and by holographic c-theorems, is stated as a conjecture. Natural bulk candidates are the covariant entropy bound and the area law for past holographic screens. The conjecture does not explain the low-entropy initial state (the Past Hypothesis). This is the fifth paper of a series. The earlier papers are 10.5281/zenodo.23189575, 10.5281/zenodo.23193512, 10.5281/zenodo.23194419 and 10.5281/zenodo.23195881. Code, data and figures: https://github.com/Ruqing1963/scale-thermodynamics

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.23199121

Related papers

Subjective Entropy and Time Asymmetry: A Quantum Channel Capacity Perspective

Bo Zhang

This work presents a conceptual and mathematical framework addressing the longstanding tension between microscopic reversibility in quantum mechanics and macroscopic irreversibility in thermodynamics. Rather than modifying unitary quantum dynamics or invoking ad hoc coarse-graining procedures, the paper proposes that the thermodynamic arrow of time arises as an information-theoretic consequence of the physical limitations of observers. The central hypothesis, termed the Holographic Shannon–Landauer (HSL) framework, models the observer as a finite-bandwidth quantum channel (a Completely Positive Trace-Preserving map). Within this framework, entropy is redefined not as an intrinsic property of matter, but as the quantum relative entropy between the true global quantum state and the state accessible to a bandwidth-limited observer. By formalizing observation as a channel-capacity–constrained physical process, the work derives a Bandwidth–Entropy Monotonicity Theorem, demonstrating that reduced observational resolution necessarily leads to increased observed entropy via the data processing inequality. The Second Law of Thermodynamics emerges naturally from the dynamical spreading of entanglement into degrees of freedom inaccessible to the observer, rather than from any fundamental time asymmetry in the underlying laws. This manuscript is intended as a foundational and unifying perspective, connecting quantum thermodynamics, information theory, and observer-dependent physics. It is archived here as a citable preprint to establish priority and provide a stable reference point for subsequent technical developments and potential journal submissions.

•Dec 21, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Thermodynamics of Entropy Production and Time – An Approach to Irreversibility

Herbert W. Zimmermann

We consider the temporal evolution of an isolated system of particles from a non-equilibrium state of entropy S = S′ to the equilibrium state of maximum entropy S = S max, S′ ≤ S max. The application of usual density matrix theory to the temporal development of S leads us to the unexpected result P = dS/dt = 0. The entropy does not change in time. This result is valid in case of the equilibrium state. However it is wrong for a non-equilibrium state, which could not irreversibly change from S′ to S max by entropy production P > 0. This contradicts the second law of thermodynamics. The paradoxial result can be traced back to the Liouville theorem. To overcome this difficulty, we introduce the t–P space. The time t and the entropy production P are observables in quantum thermodynamics. They are defined by the eigenvalue equations t|t〉 = t|t〉 and P|P〉 = P|P〉. The operators t and P do not commute. We have a non-vanishing commutator, [t,P] = ik, and consequently a t–P uncertainty relation, ΔtΔP ≥ k/2. The Boltzmann constant k is characteristic of quantum thermodynamics and represents the atomic entropy unit. — The time evolution operator U(τ) = exp[−(i/k)τP] shifts the time t by τ, U(τ)|t〉 = |t + τ〉. The generator of τ is the operator P of entropy production. Then the eigenvector |P〉 is also an eigenket of U(t), and it follows with progressing time τ ≥ 0 that τP ≥ 0 and hence P = dS/dt ≥ 0. This is the second law of thermodynamics, which is correctly reproduced in quantum thermodynamics. — Exchanging −τ for +τ replaces the equations of forward time +τ by the equations of backward time −τ. Independent of the direction of the arrow of time, the entropy of the system always increases or remains constant in the limit of the equilibrium state, dS ≥ 0. This is characteristic of irreversibility, for the system does not return to its initial state on time reversal. — The t–P uncertainty relation allows to discuss the temporal evolution of the expectation value 〈P〉 of entropy production and the lifetime Δt of the transient states, the system passes through on approaching the equilibrium state. In case of a non-equilibrium state 〈P〉, ΔP, and Δt are finite. On approaching the equilibrium state, 〈P〉 and ΔP decrease, consequently Δt increases. Finally, in the case of equilibrium (eq), we have 〈P〉eq = 0, ΔP eq = 0, and Δt eq → ∞. The lifetime of the equilibrium state is unlimited, because the entropy production 〈P〉 and the uncertainty of entropy production ΔP exactly vanish. The temporal evolution of the system can be described by means of a phenomenological equation.

Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie•Aug 1, 2006•5 citations

Termodinâmica quântica invariante de calibre: fundamentos e aplicações em sistemas críticos

Gabriel Fernandez Ferrari Melo

In this formalism, thermodynamic quantities are described as functionals of the density operator and emerge from a coarse-graining process over all unitary transformations that preserve the system’s energy - a set we refer to as the thermodynamic group. This approach intrinsically incorporates informational access limitations to the system, constrained to energy basis measurements. Our contribution generalizes the expressions for invariant heat and work beyond the treatment presented in [3], explicitly including the consideration of dynamic degenerate energy levels. More than a formal extension, we establish a rigorous physical interpretation of these quantities through the non-unitary dynamics of the effective state obtained by the coarse-graining induced by the thermodynamic group. We demonstrate that the fundamental restriction to energy basis measurements implies the inaccessibility of part of the system’s energy, interpreted as an effective heat associated with the production of coherences in the energy basis. Consequently, the derived work corresponds to the system’s effective work, with its energetic contribution reduced by the portion allocated as heat. Within the second law context, we introduce the gauge-invariant entropy, proving it satisfies all required properties for a thermodynamic entropy. This entropy exhibits an explicit dependence on the thermodynamic group, manifested through an entropic contribution directly linked to the Hamiltonian’s spectral degeneracies. Crucially, we identify that the origin of entropy production coincides with that of heat in closed systems, both emerging from the inherent non-unitarity in the coarse-grained state’s dynamics. As a final application, we implement our formalism in the quantum dynamics of spin systems undergoing quenches, revealing that coherent heat captures signatures of irreversibility. In critical systems, the quantities derived within this theory prove fundamental for understanding modifications in the system’s symmetry structure relative to the internal symmetries of the thermodynamic gauge group

•Apr 4, 2025•0 citations

Informational and algebraic renormalization group

Takato Mori, Teruaki Nagasawa

Renormalization group (RG) is a core concept from statistical mechanics to quantum field theory, yet its schemes differ widely across literature. We formulate Wilsonian RG for generic, including finite-dimensional, quantum systems as a quantum channel combining coarse graining with isometric rescaling, whose Kraus representation yields pure conditional trajectories for pure inputs and recovers mixed-state flows upon averaging. We then develop an algebraic extension without assuming tensor-product factorization: the retained low-energy algebra is constructed from the one-particle spectrum, and coarse graining is a conditional expectation onto it. Identifying the channel's Cesàro mean with a resource-destroying map onto fixed states establishes a resource theory of RG and yields a relative-entropy monotone without variational optimization. For thermal states in the zero-temperature limit, the resulting Bogoliubov--Kubo--Mori metric per unit spacetime volume is proportional to the Zamolodchikov metric, directly relating the resource density to $c-c_{\rm IR}$ near a two-dimensional IR fixed point. We also introduce the relative entropy of coarse graining to measure discarded UV information, prove its monotonicity along successive coarse grainings, and evaluate it holographically in global $\mathrm{AdS}_3$.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2609.30362•Sep 28, 2026•1 citation

The Arrow of Time from Entropy–Order Balance: Classical and Quantum Manifestations via Finite-Scale Coarse-Graining

Platek, Nir

Why does time seem to have a direction when the microscopic laws do not? This paper gives a rigorous answer. We show that if you look at a system at a fixed resolution where its dynamics are reversible and satisfy a standard regularity condition (a log–Sobolev inequality), then there is no intrinsic arrow of time: entropy production is exactly balanced by an equal “ordering flux,” a state we call entropy–order balance (EOB). The arrow appears only when we observe the system through a lossy filter—such as averaging, ignoring variables, or tracing out an environment. Mathematically, this is a channel that merges many microscopic states into the same observed outcome and therefore forces a one-way loss of distinguishability. The main result is an Arrow Structure Theorem: an arrow of time exists at a given resolution if and only if the observation map is genuinely irreversible in a precise information-theoretic sense. We quantify its strength using a new, scale-dependent number—the arrow intensity As(O;t)∈[0,1]A_s(O;t) \in [0,1]As(O;t)∈[0,1]—which measures how much distinguishability is lost and behaves like a resource that can only increase under further coarse-graining. The same mechanism applies in both the classical and quantum cases and allows one to predict and measure how quickly an observed description forgets details, and to compare the strength of the arrow across platforms using a single information-theoretic yardstick. Conceptually, the work separates what the world does from what we access and provides a structural resolution of Loschmidt’s paradox: the arrow is not a property of the microscopic laws, but of the lossy channels through which we observe them.

•Nov 23, 2025•0 citations

Entropy Scaling Law and the Quantum Marginal Problem

Isaac H. Kim

Quantum many-body states that frequently appear in physics often obey an entropy scaling law, meaning that an entanglement entropy of a subsystem can be expressed as a sum of terms that scale linearly with its volume and area, plus a correction term that is independent of its size.We conjecture that these states have an efficient dual description in terms of a set of marginal density matrices on bounded regions, obeying the same entropy scaling law locally.We prove a restricted version of this conjecture for translationally invariant systems in two spatial dimensions.Specifically, we prove that a translationally invariant marginal obeying three nonlinear constraints-all of which follow from the entropy scaling law straightforwardlymust be consistent with some global state on an infinite lattice.Moreover, we derive a closed-form expression for the maximum-entropy density compatible with those marginals, deriving a variational upper bound on the thermodynamic free energy.The main assumptions of our construction are satisfied exactly by solvable models of topological order and approximately by finite-temperature Gibbs states of certain quantum spin Hamiltonians.

arXiv:2010.07424•Physical Review X•May 20, 2021•16 citations
The irreversibility of the renormalization group (RG) is often described in thermodynamic language: information is "lost" under coarse-graining, c "decreases like an entropy", scale behaves like a temperature, and the RG arrow is compared with the arrow of time. This paper sorts such statements into four kinds (theorems, exact identities, standard physics applied to scale, and conjecture) and checks every exact statement numerically. (1) The c, F and a theorems state that c_UV > c_IR, a decrease from the ultraviolet to the infrared. In the entropic proofs this follows from strong subadditivity and Lorentz invariance, not from a thermodynamic law. For a massive lattice Dirac fermion, the Casini–Huerta function c(ℓ) = 3ℓ dS/dℓ decreases monotonically to zero. At the critical point it reproduces c = 1 times the finite-size chord factor (πℓ/N)cot(πℓ/N). (2) The monotonicity of relative entropy under quantum channels gives a rigorous H-theorem: if an RG step is a channel with an invariant state σ*, then D(Φⁿ(ρ)‖σ*) is non-increasing. This is verified on block restrictions of Gaussian fermion states. (3) Read the heat-kernel time τ as an inverse temperature on the Laplacian spectrum. Then S(τ) = ln P + τ⟨λ⟩ = −D(π_τ‖μ) is non-increasing, where μ is the density-of-states measure. The heat capacity C = τ²Var(λ) obeys C = d_s/2 − (1/2) dd_s/d ln τ, so on scaling plateaus the spectral dimension is twice a heat capacity. For hypercubic lattices C has a closed form, with a Schottky-type maximum of 0.6799 d and the equipartition limit d/2. (4) A physical protocol that changes the correlation length of a lattice field in time obeys the Jarzynski and Crooks relations exactly. For a sudden quench, the Jarzynski estimator has finite variance if and only if ω_f²/ω_i² > 1/2 for every mode. For finite ramp times, an exact Riccati equation for the tilted Gaussian density shows that the softening protocol keeps an infinite variance at every simulated ramp time. For the stiffening protocol the exact relative variances predict the observed standard errors. Jarzynski and Bennett acceptance-ratio estimates recover ΔF to within 0.015. Landauer's bound applies to physical erasure, not to the theorist's coarse-graining map. The identification of the RG arrow with the arrow of time, suggested by dS/CFT and by holographic c-theorems, is stated as a conjecture. Natural bulk candidates are the covariant entropy bound and the area law for past holographic screens. The conjecture does not explain the low-entropy initial state (the Past Hypothesis). This is the fifth paper of a series. The earlier papers are 10.5281/zenodo.23189575, 10.5281/zenodo.23193512, 10.5281/zenodo.23194419 and 10.5281/zenodo.23195881. Code, data and figures: https://github.com/Ruqing1963/scale-thermodynamics
This work presents a conceptual and mathematical framework addressing the longstanding tension between microscopic reversibility in quantum mechanics and macroscopic irreversibility in thermodynamics. Rather than modifying unitary quantum dynamics or invoking ad hoc coarse-graining procedures, the paper proposes that the thermodynamic arrow of time arises as an information-theoretic consequence of the physical limitations of observers. The central hypothesis, termed the Holographic Shannon–Landauer (HSL) framework, models the observer as a finite-bandwidth quantum channel (a Completely Positive Trace-Preserving map). Within this framework, entropy is redefined not as an intrinsic property of matter, but as the quantum relative entropy between the true global quantum state and the state accessible to a bandwidth-limited observer. By formalizing observation as a channel-capacity–constrained physical process, the work derives a Bandwidth–Entropy Monotonicity Theorem, demonstrating that reduced observational resolution necessarily leads to increased observed entropy via the data processing inequality. The Second Law of Thermodynamics emerges naturally from the dynamical spreading of entanglement into degrees of freedom inaccessible to the observer, rather than from any fundamental time asymmetry in the underlying laws. This manuscript is intended as a foundational and unifying perspective, connecting quantum thermodynamics, information theory, and observer-dependent physics. It is archived here as a citable preprint to establish priority and provide a stable reference point for subsequent technical developments and potential journal submissions.
We consider the temporal evolution of an isolated system of particles from a non-equilibrium state of entropy S = S′ to the equilibrium state of maximum entropy S = S max, S′ ≤ S max. The application of usual density matrix theory to the temporal development of S leads us to the unexpected result P = dS/dt = 0. The entropy does not change in time. This result is valid in case of the equilibrium state. However it is wrong for a non-equilibrium state, which could not irreversibly change from S′ to S max by entropy production P > 0. This contradicts the second law of thermodynamics. The paradoxial result can be traced back to the Liouville theorem. To overcome this difficulty, we introduce the t–P space. The time t and the entropy production P are observables in quantum thermodynamics. They are defined by the eigenvalue equations t|t〉 = t|t〉 and P|P〉 = P|P〉. The operators t and P do not commute. We have a non-vanishing commutator, [t,P] = ik, and consequently a t–P uncertainty relation, ΔtΔP ≥ k/2. The Boltzmann constant k is characteristic of quantum thermodynamics and represents the atomic entropy unit. — The time evolution operator U(τ) = exp[−(i/k)τP] shifts the time t by τ, U(τ)|t〉 = |t + τ〉. The generator of τ is the operator P of entropy production. Then the eigenvector |P〉 is also an eigenket of U(t), and it follows with progressing time τ ≥ 0 that τP ≥ 0 and hence P = dS/dt ≥ 0. This is the second law of thermodynamics, which is correctly reproduced in quantum thermodynamics. — Exchanging −τ for +τ replaces the equations of forward time +τ by the equations of backward time −τ. Independent of the direction of the arrow of time, the entropy of the system always increases or remains constant in the limit of the equilibrium state, dS ≥ 0. This is characteristic of irreversibility, for the system does not return to its initial state on time reversal. — The t–P uncertainty relation allows to discuss the temporal evolution of the expectation value 〈P〉 of entropy production and the lifetime Δt of the transient states, the system passes through on approaching the equilibrium state. In case of a non-equilibrium state 〈P〉, ΔP, and Δt are finite. On approaching the equilibrium state, 〈P〉 and ΔP decrease, consequently Δt increases. Finally, in the case of equilibrium (eq), we have 〈P〉eq = 0, ΔP eq = 0, and Δt eq → ∞. The lifetime of the equilibrium state is unlimited, because the entropy production 〈P〉 and the uncertainty of entropy production ΔP exactly vanish. The temporal evolution of the system can be described by means of a phenomenological equation.
In this formalism, thermodynamic quantities are described as functionals of the density operator and emerge from a coarse-graining process over all unitary transformations that preserve the system’s energy - a set we refer to as the thermodynamic group. This approach intrinsically incorporates informational access limitations to the system, constrained to energy basis measurements. Our contribution generalizes the expressions for invariant heat and work beyond the treatment presented in [3], explicitly including the consideration of dynamic degenerate energy levels. More than a formal extension, we establish a rigorous physical interpretation of these quantities through the non-unitary dynamics of the effective state obtained by the coarse-graining induced by the thermodynamic group. We demonstrate that the fundamental restriction to energy basis measurements implies the inaccessibility of part of the system’s energy, interpreted as an effective heat associated with the production of coherences in the energy basis. Consequently, the derived work corresponds to the system’s effective work, with its energetic contribution reduced by the portion allocated as heat. Within the second law context, we introduce the gauge-invariant entropy, proving it satisfies all required properties for a thermodynamic entropy. This entropy exhibits an explicit dependence on the thermodynamic group, manifested through an entropic contribution directly linked to the Hamiltonian’s spectral degeneracies. Crucially, we identify that the origin of entropy production coincides with that of heat in closed systems, both emerging from the inherent non-unitarity in the coarse-grained state’s dynamics. As a final application, we implement our formalism in the quantum dynamics of spin systems undergoing quenches, revealing that coherent heat captures signatures of irreversibility. In critical systems, the quantities derived within this theory prove fundamental for understanding modifications in the system’s symmetry structure relative to the internal symmetries of the thermodynamic gauge group
Renormalization group (RG) is a core concept from statistical mechanics to quantum field theory, yet its schemes differ widely across literature. We formulate Wilsonian RG for generic, including finite-dimensional, quantum systems as a quantum channel combining coarse graining with isometric rescaling, whose Kraus representation yields pure conditional trajectories for pure inputs and recovers mixed-state flows upon averaging. We then develop an algebraic extension without assuming tensor-product factorization: the retained low-energy algebra is constructed from the one-particle spectrum, and coarse graining is a conditional expectation onto it. Identifying the channel's Cesàro mean with a resource-destroying map onto fixed states establishes a resource theory of RG and yields a relative-entropy monotone without variational optimization. For thermal states in the zero-temperature limit, the resulting Bogoliubov--Kubo--Mori metric per unit spacetime volume is proportional to the Zamolodchikov metric, directly relating the resource density to c−cIRc-c_{\rm IR}c−cIR​ near a two-dimensional IR fixed point. We also introduce the relative entropy of coarse graining to measure discarded UV information, prove its monotonicity along successive coarse grainings, and evaluate it holographically in global AdS3\mathrm{AdS}_3AdS3​.
Why does time seem to have a direction when the microscopic laws do not? This paper gives a rigorous answer. We show that if you look at a system at a fixed resolution where its dynamics are reversible and satisfy a standard regularity condition (a log–Sobolev inequality), then there is no intrinsic arrow of time: entropy production is exactly balanced by an equal “ordering flux,” a state we call entropy–order balance (EOB). The arrow appears only when we observe the system through a lossy filter—such as averaging, ignoring variables, or tracing out an environment. Mathematically, this is a channel that merges many microscopic states into the same observed outcome and therefore forces a one-way loss of distinguishability. The main result is an Arrow Structure Theorem: an arrow of time exists at a given resolution if and only if the observation map is genuinely irreversible in a precise information-theoretic sense. We quantify its strength using a new, scale-dependent number—the arrow intensity As(O;t)∈[0,1]A_s(O;t) \in [0,1]As(O;t)∈[0,1]—which measures how much distinguishability is lost and behaves like a resource that can only increase under further coarse-graining. The same mechanism applies in both the classical and quantum cases and allows one to predict and measure how quickly an observed description forgets details, and to compare the strength of the arrow across platforms using a single information-theoretic yardstick. Conceptually, the work separates what the world does from what we access and provides a structural resolution of Loschmidt’s paradox: the arrow is not a property of the microscopic laws, but of the lossy channels through which we observe them.
Quantum many-body states that frequently appear in physics often obey an entropy scaling law, meaning that an entanglement entropy of a subsystem can be expressed as a sum of terms that scale linearly with its volume and area, plus a correction term that is independent of its size.We conjecture that these states have an efficient dual description in terms of a set of marginal density matrices on bounded regions, obeying the same entropy scaling law locally.We prove a restricted version of this conjecture for translationally invariant systems in two spatial dimensions.Specifically, we prove that a translationally invariant marginal obeying three nonlinear constraints-all of which follow from the entropy scaling law straightforwardlymust be consistent with some global state on an infinite lattice.Moreover, we derive a closed-form expression for the maximum-entropy density compatible with those marginals, deriving a variational upper bound on the thermodynamic free energy.The main assumptions of our construction are satisfied exactly by solvable models of topological order and approximately by finite-temperature Gibbs states of certain quantum spin Hamiltonians.