Neural network approaches to machine learning problems rely on statistical frameworks that are designed to generalize to many situations, whereas traditional physics-based approaches to quantum problems stem from specific physical laws that govern the behavior of certain classes of systems. While quantum physics and machine learning have been largely disparate fields for most of their history, their interplay has gained considerable attention in recent years, primarily driven by the premise that the most powerful computational models are those whose foundations stem from both physical and statistical principles. Two overarching strategies in this area include building physics-based machine learning models from the ground up, or alternatively, looking for hidden ways that statistical models include aspects of physical systems. Many-body quantum systems turn out to be a useful testing ground for both of these approaches, due to the complex behavior that arises from simple fundamental rules. Here, we present several ways that neural networks can represent many-body spin states, which enables the exploration into the underlying nature of neural networks, as well as gaining insight into how effective different classes of models are for simulating physical systems. The main focus areas of this thesis are (1) connecting convolutional neural networks to maximum-entropy distributions when applied to spin systems, (2) using generative models to gain physical insights into experimental tomographic data, and (3) applying inverse reinforcement learning to probe the nature of agent-based quantum circuit design.
Neural network approaches to machine learning problems rely on statistical frameworks that are designed to generalize to many situations, whereas traditional physics-based approaches to quantum problems stem from specific physical laws that govern the behavior of certain classes of systems. While quantum physics and machine learning have been largely disparate fields for most of their history, their interplay has gained considerable attention in recent years, primarily driven by the premise that the most powerful computational models are those whose foundations stem from both physical and statistical principles. Two overarching strategies in this area include building physics-based machine learning models from the ground up, or alternatively, looking for hidden ways that statistical models include aspects of physical systems. Many-body quantum systems turn out to be a useful testing ground for both of these approaches, due to the complex behavior that arises from simple fundamental rules. Here, we present several ways that neural networks can represent many-body spin states, which enables the exploration into the underlying nature of neural networks, as well as gaining insight into how effective different classes of models are for simulating physical systems. The main focus areas of this thesis are (1) connecting convolutional neural networks to maximum-entropy distributions when applied to spin systems, (2) using generative models to gain physical insights into experimental tomographic data, and (3) applying inverse reinforcement learning to probe the nature of agent-based quantum circuit design.
Most interacting many-body systems in physics are not analytically solvable. Instead, numerical methods are needed for the study of these complex and high-dimensional problems. At present, there are many interesting problems in strongly correlated systems that remain unsolved with current methods. At the heart of this problem is finding an efficient representation that incorporates symmetries, correlations and general features. \n \nIn the context of computer science, machine learning techniques have had astonishing success at reducing the dimensionality of data. The leading method is through the use of artificial neural networks. These networks have been enormously successful at sifting through vast amounts of data to find patterns and regularities. In a sense, neural networks are themselves a statistical system whose properties are adjusted to mimic the features of the data. By finding an effective low-dimensional representation of the data, machine learning has greatly subdued the curse of dimensionality found in many real-world problems. \n \nIn this Thesis, we apply several machine learning techniques to the study of interacting many-body systems in classical and quantum statistical physics. We explore supervised classification of phases of matter with an emphasis on physical interpretation of the net- work. In doing so, we design a custom network architecture that possesses rotational symmetry as an inductive bias. We further investigate connections between the renormalization group and deep learning through applying a super-resolving neural network to the classical Ising model. Towards experimental efforts, we also repurpose generative machine learning to quantum state tomography for the calibration and testing of quantum devices. We conclude with a latent variable model inspired by near-term quantum algorithms. This maps to a variational Monte Carlo ansatz that produces samples efficiently for interacting quantum systems.
Spin glasses are, in essence, simply systems of magnetic moments with disordered interactions. Despite this basic premise, spin glasses have become relevant in a wide variety of fields, including condensed matter physics, complexity and optimization theory, error correction, quantum computing, machine learning, and even neuroscience. The pervasiveness of spin glasses stems from the fact that they are paradigmatic examples of how global complexity emerges from disordered interactions between a large number of basic constituents. The inclusion of quantum effects in spin glasses creates an even richer picture, due to the interplay between the energy barriers arising from disorder and quantum fluctuations which allow for tunneling. This thesis initially focuses on quantum glasses and how their initial states explore their Hilbert spaces. Two complementary approaches are used. One is comparison of the spectral statistics, particularly the spectral form factor, with the spectral statistics of random matrix ensembles, a hallmark of quantum chaotic behavior. The other approach uses the Thouless-Anderson-Palmer mean-field equations to determine the number of local minima which appear in the free energy landscape. This thesis then applies methods from spin glass theory to the field of machine learning. Neural networks, like spin glasses, are systems in which remarkable behavior emerges from interactions between basic constituents. By studying the phase diagrams of spin models analogous to snapshots of neural networks throughout their training process, insight is gained into the mechanisms of learning. Finally, this thesis investigates how quantum effects can lead to advantages in machine learning. It is shown, through classical simulation and experiments on both trapped-ion and superconducting quantum computing hardware, that a natural quantization of a classical neural network can demonstrate superior generalization performance due to the injection of quantum uncertainty.
The simulation of quantum matter with classical hardware plays a central role in the discovery and development of quantum many-body systems, with far-reaching implications in condensed matter physics and quantum technologies. In general, efficient and sophisticated algorithms are required to overcome the severe challenge posed by the exponential scaling of the Hilbert space of quantum systems. In contrast, hardware built with quantum bits of information are inherently capable of efficiently finding solutions of quantum many-body problems. While a universal and scalable quantum computer is still beyond the horizon, recent advances in qubit manufacturing and coherent control of synthetic quantum matter are leading to a new generation of intermediate scale quantum hardware. \n \nThe complexity underlying quantum many-body systems closely resembles the one encountered in many problems in the world of information and technology. In both contexts, the complexity stems from a large number of interacting degrees of freedom. A powerful strategy in the latter scenario is machine learning, a subfield of artificial intelligence where large amounts of data are used to extract relevant features and patterns. In particular, artificial neural networks have been demonstrated to be capable of discovering low-dimensional representations of complex objects from high-dimensional dataset, leading to the profound technological revolution we all witness in our daily life. \n \nIn this Thesis, we envision a new paradigm for scientific discovery in quantum physics. On the one hand, we have the essentially unlimited data generated with the increasing amount of highly controllable quantum hardware. On the other hand, we have a set of powerful algorithms that efficiently capture non-trivial correlations from high-dimensional data. Therefore, we fully embrace this data-driven approach to quantum mechanics, and anticipate new exciting possibilities in the field of quantum many-body physics and quantum information science. We revive a powerful stochastic neural network called a restricted Boltzmann machine, which slowly moved out of fashion after playing a central role in the machine learning revolution of the early 2010s. We introduce a neural-network representation of quantum states based on this generative model. We propose a set of algorithms to reconstruct unknown quantum states from measurement data and numerically demonstrate their potential, with important implications for current experiments. These include the reconstruction of experimentally inaccessible properties, such as entanglement, and diagnostics to determine sources of noise. Furthermore, we introduce a machine learning framework for quantum error correction, where a neural network learns the best decoding strategy directly from data. We expect that the full integration between quantum hardware and artificial intelligence will become the gold standard, and will drive the world into the era of fault-tolerant quantum computing and large-scale quantum simulations.
The challenge posed by the many-body problem in quantum physics originates from the difficulty of describing the nontrivial correlations encoded in the exponential complexity of the many-body wave function. Here we demonstrate that systematic machine learning of the wave function can reduce this complexity to a tractable computational form for some notable cases of physical interest. We introduce a variational representation of quantum states based on artificial neural networks with a variable number of hidden neurons. A reinforcement-learning scheme we demonstrate is capable of both finding the ground state and describing the unitary time evolution of complex interacting quantum systems. Our approach achieves high accuracy in describing prototypical interacting spins models in one and two dimensions.
Convolutional neural networks (CNNs) have been employed along with variational Monte Carlo methods for finding the ground state of quantum many-body spin systems with great success. However, it remains uncertain how CNNs, with a model complexity that scales at most linearly with the number of particles, solve the “curse of dimensionality” and efficiently represent wavefunctions in exponentially large Hilbert spaces. In this work, we use methodologies from information theory, group theory and machine learning, to elucidate how CNN captures relevant physics of quantum systems. We connect CNNs to a class of restricted maximum entropy (MaxEnt) and entangled plaquette correlator product state (EP-CPS) models that approximate symmetry constrained classical correlations between subsystems. For the final part of the puzzle, inspired by similar analyses for matrix product states and tensor networks, we show that the CNNs rely on the spectrum of each subsystem's entanglement Hamiltonians as captured by the size of the convolutional filter. All put together, these allow CNNs to simulate exponential quantum wave functions using a model that scales at most linear in system size as well as provide clues into when CNNs might fail to simulate Hamiltonians. We incorporate our insights into a new training algorithm and demonstrate its improved efficiency, accuracy, and robustness. Finally, we use regression analysis to show how the CNNs solutions can be used to identify salient physical features of the system that are the most relevant to an efficient approximation. Our integrated approach can be extended to similarly analyzing other neural network architectures and quantum spin systems.
Quantum machine learning is at the crossroads of two of the most exciting current areas of research: quantum computing and classical machine learning. Although the field is still in its infancy, the body of literature is already large enough to warrant several review articles [1–3]. This short survey focuses on a selection of significant recent results on the subtopic of quantum neural networks, an area that hopes to build on the enormous impact that classical neural networks have had. In particular, we concentrate on quantum generalizations of popular neural-network concepts such as Boltzmann machines, generative adversarial networks and autoencoders, as well as applications of classical neural networks to quantum information and vice versa. Examples of Boltzmann machines. In a fully connected Boltzmann machine, connections exist between all visible and hidden neurons. In a restricted Boltzmann machine (RBM), there are no connections between neurons of the same type. A deep Boltzmann machine (DBM) consists of adding one or more additional layers of hidden neurons to an RBM, with no connections between neurons in the same layer. The energy-based nature of BMs gives a natural framework for considering quantum generalizations of their behavior. The BM energy function is equivalent to the Hamiltonian of a simple Ising model and one might hope that more general Hamiltonians allowed by quantum mechanics could explain certain data sets better than classically. Amin et al. [4] adopt this approach, and take the so-called transverse field Ising Hamiltonian as the energy function. This increased generality brings certain difficulties, however, as the transverse field term makes training the quantum Boltzmann machine (QBM) non-trivial. Although the general scaling and performance of QBMs is not yet well understood, for certain small-size examples the authors observe that their QBMs can learn data distributions better than classical BMs. Kieferova and Wiebe [5] extend the formalism of Amin et al. and consider more general Hamiltonians that, unlike the transverse Ising model, are not in general believed to be classically efficiently simulatable. Furthermore, they propose new methods for training that allow for parameters corresponding to quantum terms to be learned. Finally, their QBM enables a form of quantum-state tomography that can learn non-classical data, and also generate copies of the reconstructed state. Again, small-scale numerical evidence suggests that their proposals may provide an advantage over classical BMs, although their tendency to overfit data must be investigated further. The practical value of BMs, either classical or quantum, relies in part on the ease with which they are trained. This in turn depends on sampling efficiently from the Boltzmann distribution. Classically this can be done approximately only for the special case of restricted Boltzmann machines (RBM), i.e. where connections are between visible and hidden units, and no connections exist between neurons of the same type. Wiebe et al. [6] propose two quantum algorithms for Boltzmann sampling, based on starting from a state corresponding to the product distribution that is closest to the target Boltzmann distribution. While small-scale numerical studies are encouraging, true bounds on the running time of their algorithms rely on a problem-dependent parameter κ, the scaling of which is hard to estimate. The hope remains though that empirically their algorithms work well in practice, even for multi-layer and fully connected BMs. The expressive power of BMs for compactly representing complicated probability distributions has led to another line of investigation, namely their use for representing quantum many-body wave functions. The authors apply this technique to two prototypical spin models and achieve high accuracy in both ground-state estimation and dynamical evolution, improving on existing state-of-the-art techniques. Their results indicate that RBM states can capture complex many-body correlations in an efficient manner—evidence reinforced by the work of Deng et al. [8], who show that certain topological quantum states in one, two and three dimensions can be represented by RBM states with a number of parameters only linear in the system size. In a subsequent study, however, Gao and Duan [9] prove that although RBM states can indeed represent many highly entangled states, their expressive power is limited in that they cannot represent arbitrary states generated by polynomial-sized quantum circuits, nor those that are the ground states of k-local Hamiltonians with polynomial-sized energy gaps, unless the polynomial hierarchy from computational complexity theory collapses. On the other hand, they show that these two important classes of states can be efficiently represented by a deep Boltzmann machine of three layers. Intriguingly though, another paper by Deng et al. [10] gives an analytic construction of a family of RBM states with a number of parameters linear in the system size that exhibits maximal volume-law entanglement, and that cannot be represented efficiently by either matrix product states (MPS) or tensor-network (TN) states. This shows that the expressive power of even efficiently parametrized RBM states is not limited by entanglement in the same way that other popular compact representations are. This gives the hope that RBM states may prove a valuable tool in understanding entangled quantum systems intractable by traditional methods. Levine et al. [11] establish another connection between the many-body wave function and neural networks, this time in the form of convolutional arithmetic circuits (ConvAC), a variant of the popular convolutional neural networks in widespread use today. By proving a one-to-one equivalence between a ConvAC circuit and TN quantum states, the authors are able to use tools from quantum information theory to analyze the entanglement present in the corresponding TN, and quantify the neural network's ability to model complex correlations between its inputs. This in turn can be used to obtain bounds on the expressivity of a given ConvAC architecture and be of practical use in choosing network parameters tailored to the data. While ConvAC are not widely used in practice, the authors empirically validate that the insights gained can be applied successfully to more common convolutional neural-network designs. Generative adversarial networks (GAN) are machine-learning algorithms in which two players—a generator and a discriminator—compete against each another. The generator's goal is to create and send fake data samples to the discriminator and maximize the probability that the discriminator erroneously believes that the sample comes from some true data distribution. The discriminator attempts to discern real from fake data as best as possible. Under reasonable assumptions the game converges to a point where the discriminator is unable to discriminate with probability greater than 1/2 (i.e. no better than random guessing), and the generator in fact has learned to generate data from the true distribution. Lloyd and Weedbrook [12] consider the natural extension in which one or both of the generator and discriminator are equipped with quantum information processors. When the data to be learned are a quantum state and both parties have quantum processors, the authors show that the unique end point of the adversarial game also coincides with the generator producing a quantum state corresponding to the true data statistics, and the discriminator unable to discern true from false data better than random guessing. They further argue that a different outcome may hold when the true samples are produced by the measurement of some quantum state, and the generator is purely classical. The concept of quantum supremacy is based on the assumption that there exist probability distributions accessible to a quantum computer that no classical computer can efficiently sample from. If the true data correspond to one of these distributions, then no classical generator can efficiently generate fake data reproducing the true statistics and, in principle, the discriminator can successfully discriminate true from fake data. However, whether the discriminator can efficiently find the measurements required to do so is unclear. Quantum-computing techniques have also found applications in autoencoders—neural networks where a larger number of input and output neurons are connected via a smaller number of intermediary latent neurons. The goal is to tune the weights of the network so that a training set of classical bit strings can be approximately recovered after being passed through the autoencoder. Romero et al. [13] consider instead a training set of quantum states, and ask whether a quantum circuit with a similar bottleneck structure can compress and approximately recover the data. The circuits that they consider consist of gates chosen from some set of parametrized unitary operations, and arranged in some fixed order. The parameters are then optimized classically so that the circuit best predicts the training-set labels. The authors demonstrate the validity of this approach by showing that ground states of the Hubbard model and certain molecules can indeed be compressed and recovered by such circuits. However, in general, the performance of such quantum autoencoders will be highly dependent on the kind of programmable circuit on which they are based, and at present there does not seem to be a structured way of determining this. Quantum neural networks are still in their infancy and, while the above works are important steps towards bridging our understanding between classical neural networks and quantum computing, many questions remain unanswered. If the expressivity of Boltzmann machine states is not restricted by entanglement in the same way that MPS and tensor-network states are, what is the best way of understanding their limitations? How can physicists use the correspondence between ConvAC and TN to their advantage in finding efficient, expressive representations of many-body wave functions? Can classical data distributions be learned more efficiently by quantum GAN than classical GAN? Whatever the outcome of these and many other related questions, this promises to be an exciting and active area of research in the years to come.