Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Conference on Computing, Intelligence, and Application (CIACON)

Beyond Accuracy: A Statistical Benchmarking of Variational Quantum Circuits and Classical Regressors for Molecular Atomization Energy Prediction

Amrita Kundu, Souvik Ghosh, Vegi Fernando A, Mithaguru

Published Jul 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The use of quantum machine learning (QML) in computational chemistry has received significant attention as a potential substitute to classical approaches for molecular property prediction. The following paper presents a comparative study of the performance of different quantum circuits and classical techniques for predicting atomization energies based on the QM7 dataset. The molecular structure is mapped to Coulomb matrices, which are then transformed into a flattened vector and truncated into 10 principal components based on Principal Component Analysis (PCA). Three quantum circuit designs have been considered; VQC-1 based on RY gates and ladder entanglement using CNOT gate, VQC-2 based on rotation RX & RZ gates and CNOT gate entanglement, and VQC-3 based on seven layers of strongly entangled gates on ten qubits. The four classical model-based baseline approaches tested are Linear Regression, Support Vector Regression (SVR), Gradient Boosting, and Random Forest. The measures used for performance analysis are MAE, RMSE, and$\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}$. From the experimental analysis, SVR outperforms the other algorithms and gets an$\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}$of 0.2208, followed by Gradient Boosting and Random Forest, and the quantum-based models perform poorly with near-zero or negative values of$\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}$. VQC-3 performs best among the quantum models, yielding an$\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}$value of 0.0380 and demonstrating the advantages of deep entanglement architectures. An analysis of statistical significance using independent t-tests reveals no significant difference between the distributions of errors in VQC-3 and those of the other classical models, reflecting the current shortcomings of variational quantum circuits in solving structured regression problems.

DOI
10.1109/ciacon70148.2026.11688717

Related papers

Quantum Kernel Regression and Variational Quantum Regression for the CCS Prediction of Dissolved Organic Matter: A Comparative Benchmarking Study

Sadollah Ebrahimi, Armand Soldera, Céline Guéguen

Recent advances in quantum machine learning (QML) offer new opportunities for chemical property prediction, yet their practical performance relative to established classical models remains poorly characterized on real-world datasets. Building on our previous benchmark of classical and deep learning models for collision cross-section (CCS) predictions, we present an empirical comparison of quantum kernel regression (QKR) and a variational quantum regressor (VQR) against classical machine learning (CML) techniques, including Random Forest (RF), support vector regression (SVR), Lasso, and a Voting Regressor (VR) ensemble. Using an aquatic dissolved organic matter (DOM) dataset with five molecular descriptors and five chemical classes, we systematically investigate QKR feature map repetitions and classical readout kernels, as well as VQR circuit depths and optimizer choices, to identify performance-optimal QML configurations. Regression performance is evaluated using the mean absolute error (MAE), root mean square error (RMSE), and coefficient of determination (R2) across training-set sizes up to 600 molecules per class. Overall, RF and Lasso deliver the most robust CCS predictions, achieving R2 ≥ 0.9 for lignins, carbohydrates, lipids, and proteins. Meanwhile, the optimized QKR architecture exhibits substantial gains as data increase and achieves competitive performance on chemically homogeneous subsets such as carbohydrates and lipids. In contrast, the VQR ansatz remains consistently weaker than both QKR and the classical baselines across all classes and data sizes. The results highlight the strong influence of dataset size, feature representation, and molecular heterogeneity on QML performance while also identifying conditions under which quantum methods may become competitive in future studies.

Journal of the American Society for Mass Spectrometry•Sep 10, 2026•0 citations

Adapting Quantum Machine Learning for Energy Dissociation of Bonds

Swathi Chandrasekhar, Shiva Raj Pokhrel, Navneet Singh

Accurate prediction of bond dissociation energies (BDEs) underpins mechanistic insight and the rational design of molecules and materials. We present a systematic, reproducible benchmark comparing quantum and classical machine learning models for BDE prediction using a chemically curated feature set encompassing atomic properties (atomic numbers, hybridization), bond characteristics (bond order, type), and local environmental descriptors. Our quantum framework, implemented in Qiskit Aer on six qubits, employs ZZFeatureMap encodings with variational ansätz (RealAmplitudes) across multiple architectures Variational Quantum Regressors (VQR), Quantum Support Vector Regressors (QSVR), Quantum Neural Networks (QNN), Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks (QCNN), and Quantum Random Forests (QRF). These are rigorously benchmarked against strong classical baselines, including Support Vector Regression (SVR), Random Forests (RF), and Multi-Layer Perceptrons (MLP). Comprehensive evaluation spanning absolute and relative error metrics, threshold accuracies, and error distributions shows that top-performing quantum models (QCNN, QRF) match the predictive accuracy and robustness of classical ensembles and deep networks, particularly within the chemically prevalent mid-range BDE regime. These findings establish a transparent baseline for quantum-enhanced molecular property prediction and outline a practical foundation for advancing quantum computational chemistry toward near-chemical accuracy.

arXiv:2510.06563•Sep 25, 2025•4 citations

Variational Quantum Circuits for Pesticide Environmental Fate Prediction: A Comparative Study with Classical Machine Learning on the EU SPIN Database

Celal Arda

Predicting pesticide environmental fate properties specifically soil degradation half-life (DegT50) and organic carbon sorption coefficient (K oc)-is essential for regulatory risk assessment under EC 1107/2009. Classical QSAR models achieve moderate predictive power for K oc but struggle with DegT50 due to its dependence on complex soil microbial processes. This work investigates whether variational quantum circuits (VQCs) can capture non-linear molecular descriptor relationships that elude classical regressors. We encode 17 physicochemical descriptors for 111 EU-registered pesticides into a 12-qubit IQP-style quantum circuit with data re-uploading and 8 variational layers (301 trainable parameters). Leave-one-out cross-validation benchmarks reveal that Random Forest (RF) achieves R 2 = 0.194 for DegT50 and 0.726 for K oc (on a circularity-free 16-feature set excluding the bioaccessibility proxy), while Gradient Boosting (GB) reaches 0.223 and 0.764, respectively. The VQC underperforms classical baselines on DegT50 (R 2 < 0, 5-fold CV), consistent with severe overfitting expected from the unfavorable parameter-to-sample ratio (N params /N data ≈ 2.7). A hybrid stacking framework blending QML and RF predictions yields α = 0.20, but the resulting R 2 improvement (+0.02) is not statistically significant. We also assess adverse outcome pathway (AOP) features derived from AOP-Wiki data as additional descriptors, finding no improvement over structural features alone. These results provide a rigorous benchmark for near-term quantum machine learning applied to regulatory chemistry and highlight the critical role of dataset size in VQC generalization.

•Mar 11, 2026•0 citations

Variational Quantum Regression for Binding Affinity Prediction: A Hybrid Quantum-Classical Framework with Explainable Molecular Descriptors

Volkan Erol

Predicting drug-target binding affinity with limited training data remains a central challenge in computational drug discovery. We introduce a hybrid quantum-classical framework combining molecular descriptors with variational quantum circuits for interpretable binding affinity prediction. Seven physicochemical descriptors (MW, logP, TPSA, HBD/HBA, rotatable bonds, aromatic rings) were encoded into 6-qubit variational circuits using parameterized rotations and controlled-Z entanglement. Quantum kernels were extracted and used for regression on 1,200 BindingDB molecules across kinase, GPCR, and protease targets, with external validation on 300 ChEMBL compounds. Performance was compared against SVR, random forest, gradient boosting, and neural network baselines using 100-fold bootstrap validation. Variational quantum regression achieved MSE = 0.056 ± 0.009, outperforming SVR by 32% (0.082 ± 0.013), RF by 28%, and GBM by 24%. Quantum advantage was most significant in low-data regimes (n < 500), where VQR maintained R2 > 0.85 versus R2 < 0.72 for classical methods. External validation confirmed generalization (R2 = 0.83). Our Explainable Quantum Pharmacology framework revealed TPSA and logP as dominant predictive features through gradientbased sensitivity analysis, aligning with established medicinal chemistry principles. Quantum kernels provide measurable, chemically interpretable improvements for molecular property prediction in data-limited scenarios. This work demonstrates practical quantum advantage for early-stage drug discovery applications on near-term quantum hardware.

•Oct 20, 2025•1 citation

Comparative Study of Classical and Quantum Machine Learning Models: Insights into Quantum Advantage in Materials Informatics

Aris Tri Jaka Harjanta, Hindriyanto Dwi Purnomo, Hendry

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has emerged as a promising paradigm for addressing increasing computational and representational demands in materials informatics. While classical models such as Support Vector Machines (SVM) achieve strong predictive performance, they often struggle to capture complex, highly correlated interactions in high-dimensional materials data. QML addresses this challenge by leveraging quantum-mechanical principles to construct expressive feature embeddings, where prospective quantum advantage lies in generating feature spaces that are difficult to approximate classically. In this study, 1,000 crystalline compounds from the Open Quantum Materials Database (OQMD) are evaluated in a binary classification task based on formation-energy stability. The dataset is normalized, reduced to four dimensions via Principal Component Analysis (PCA), and encoded into quantum circuits. Three QML models—QSVM, VQC, and QNN—are benchmarked against a classical SVM using repeated stratified evaluation. Results show that the classical SVM achieves the highest accuracy (91.8% ± 0.012), followed by QSVM (60.8% ± 0.035), while VQC and QNN perform significantly worse. This gap is driven by limited qubit capacity, encoding inefficiencies, restricted circuit expressivity, and optimization challenges. Nevertheless, QSVM demonstrates stable performance, suggesting that potential quantum advantage may emerge from improved feature encoding and kernel design rather than deeper variational circuits.

Advance Sustainable Science Engineering and Technology•Apr 30, 2026•0 citations

A Comparative Study of Classical and Variational Quantum Machine Learning Models for Breast Cancer Classification

Divya Guthi

Early and accurate diagnosis of breast cancer plays a critical role in improving patient survival rates and reducing treatment costs. Classical machine learning algorithms such as Logistic Regression and Support Vector Machines (SVM) have demonstrated strong performance in medical diagnosis tasks; however, their scalability and representational limits motivate the exploration of emerging paradigms. Quantum Machine Learning (QML), particularly Variational Quantum Classifiers (VQC), has recently gained attention due to its potential to model complex decision boundaries using quantum circuits. This paper presents a comparative analysis between a Variational Quantum Classifier and classical machine learning models for binary breast cancer classification. The study employs dimensionality-reduced clinical data and evaluates model performance using accuracy, confusion matrices, decision boundary visualization, Principal Component Analysis (PCA), and Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves. Experimental results indicate that the VQC achieves competitive performance with classical approaches, demonstrating its feasibility for small-scale medical datasets and highlighting the promise of quantum-enhanced learning in healthcare applications.

International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations
The use of quantum machine learning (QML) in computational chemistry has received significant attention as a potential substitute to classical approaches for molecular property prediction. The following paper presents a comparative study of the performance of different quantum circuits and classical techniques for predicting atomization energies based on the QM7 dataset. The molecular structure is mapped to Coulomb matrices, which are then transformed into a flattened vector and truncated into 10 principal components based on Principal Component Analysis (PCA). Three quantum circuit designs have been considered; VQC-1 based on RY gates and ladder entanglement using CNOT gate, VQC-2 based on rotation RX & RZ gates and CNOT gate entanglement, and VQC-3 based on seven layers of strongly entangled gates on ten qubits. The four classical model-based baseline approaches tested are Linear Regression, Support Vector Regression (SVR), Gradient Boosting, and Random Forest. The measures used for performance analysis are MAE, RMSE, andR2\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}R2. From the experimental analysis, SVR outperforms the other algorithms and gets anR2\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}R2of 0.2208, followed by Gradient Boosting and Random Forest, and the quantum-based models perform poorly with near-zero or negative values ofR2\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}R2. VQC-3 performs best among the quantum models, yielding anR2\mathbf{R}^{\mathbf{2}}R2value of 0.0380 and demonstrating the advantages of deep entanglement architectures. An analysis of statistical significance using independent t-tests reveals no significant difference between the distributions of errors in VQC-3 and those of the other classical models, reflecting the current shortcomings of variational quantum circuits in solving structured regression problems.
Recent advances in quantum machine learning (QML) offer new opportunities for chemical property prediction, yet their practical performance relative to established classical models remains poorly characterized on real-world datasets. Building on our previous benchmark of classical and deep learning models for collision cross-section (CCS) predictions, we present an empirical comparison of quantum kernel regression (QKR) and a variational quantum regressor (VQR) against classical machine learning (CML) techniques, including Random Forest (RF), support vector regression (SVR), Lasso, and a Voting Regressor (VR) ensemble. Using an aquatic dissolved organic matter (DOM) dataset with five molecular descriptors and five chemical classes, we systematically investigate QKR feature map repetitions and classical readout kernels, as well as VQR circuit depths and optimizer choices, to identify performance-optimal QML configurations. Regression performance is evaluated using the mean absolute error (MAE), root mean square error (RMSE), and coefficient of determination (R2) across training-set sizes up to 600 molecules per class. Overall, RF and Lasso deliver the most robust CCS predictions, achieving R2 ≥ 0.9 for lignins, carbohydrates, lipids, and proteins. Meanwhile, the optimized QKR architecture exhibits substantial gains as data increase and achieves competitive performance on chemically homogeneous subsets such as carbohydrates and lipids. In contrast, the VQR ansatz remains consistently weaker than both QKR and the classical baselines across all classes and data sizes. The results highlight the strong influence of dataset size, feature representation, and molecular heterogeneity on QML performance while also identifying conditions under which quantum methods may become competitive in future studies.
Accurate prediction of bond dissociation energies (BDEs) underpins mechanistic insight and the rational design of molecules and materials. We present a systematic, reproducible benchmark comparing quantum and classical machine learning models for BDE prediction using a chemically curated feature set encompassing atomic properties (atomic numbers, hybridization), bond characteristics (bond order, type), and local environmental descriptors. Our quantum framework, implemented in Qiskit Aer on six qubits, employs ZZFeatureMap encodings with variational ansätz (RealAmplitudes) across multiple architectures Variational Quantum Regressors (VQR), Quantum Support Vector Regressors (QSVR), Quantum Neural Networks (QNN), Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks (QCNN), and Quantum Random Forests (QRF). These are rigorously benchmarked against strong classical baselines, including Support Vector Regression (SVR), Random Forests (RF), and Multi-Layer Perceptrons (MLP). Comprehensive evaluation spanning absolute and relative error metrics, threshold accuracies, and error distributions shows that top-performing quantum models (QCNN, QRF) match the predictive accuracy and robustness of classical ensembles and deep networks, particularly within the chemically prevalent mid-range BDE regime. These findings establish a transparent baseline for quantum-enhanced molecular property prediction and outline a practical foundation for advancing quantum computational chemistry toward near-chemical accuracy.
Predicting pesticide environmental fate properties specifically soil degradation half-life (DegT50) and organic carbon sorption coefficient (K oc)-is essential for regulatory risk assessment under EC 1107/2009. Classical QSAR models achieve moderate predictive power for K oc but struggle with DegT50 due to its dependence on complex soil microbial processes. This work investigates whether variational quantum circuits (VQCs) can capture non-linear molecular descriptor relationships that elude classical regressors. We encode 17 physicochemical descriptors for 111 EU-registered pesticides into a 12-qubit IQP-style quantum circuit with data re-uploading and 8 variational layers (301 trainable parameters). Leave-one-out cross-validation benchmarks reveal that Random Forest (RF) achieves R 2 = 0.194 for DegT50 and 0.726 for K oc (on a circularity-free 16-feature set excluding the bioaccessibility proxy), while Gradient Boosting (GB) reaches 0.223 and 0.764, respectively. The VQC underperforms classical baselines on DegT50 (R 2 < 0, 5-fold CV), consistent with severe overfitting expected from the unfavorable parameter-to-sample ratio (N params /N data ≈ 2.7). A hybrid stacking framework blending QML and RF predictions yields α = 0.20, but the resulting R 2 improvement (+0.02) is not statistically significant. We also assess adverse outcome pathway (AOP) features derived from AOP-Wiki data as additional descriptors, finding no improvement over structural features alone. These results provide a rigorous benchmark for near-term quantum machine learning applied to regulatory chemistry and highlight the critical role of dataset size in VQC generalization.
Predicting drug-target binding affinity with limited training data remains a central challenge in computational drug discovery. We introduce a hybrid quantum-classical framework combining molecular descriptors with variational quantum circuits for interpretable binding affinity prediction. Seven physicochemical descriptors (MW, logP, TPSA, HBD/HBA, rotatable bonds, aromatic rings) were encoded into 6-qubit variational circuits using parameterized rotations and controlled-Z entanglement. Quantum kernels were extracted and used for regression on 1,200 BindingDB molecules across kinase, GPCR, and protease targets, with external validation on 300 ChEMBL compounds. Performance was compared against SVR, random forest, gradient boosting, and neural network baselines using 100-fold bootstrap validation. Variational quantum regression achieved MSE = 0.056 ± 0.009, outperforming SVR by 32% (0.082 ± 0.013), RF by 28%, and GBM by 24%. Quantum advantage was most significant in low-data regimes (n < 500), where VQR maintained R2 > 0.85 versus R2 < 0.72 for classical methods. External validation confirmed generalization (R2 = 0.83). Our Explainable Quantum Pharmacology framework revealed TPSA and logP as dominant predictive features through gradientbased sensitivity analysis, aligning with established medicinal chemistry principles. Quantum kernels provide measurable, chemically interpretable improvements for molecular property prediction in data-limited scenarios. This work demonstrates practical quantum advantage for early-stage drug discovery applications on near-term quantum hardware.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has emerged as a promising paradigm for addressing increasing computational and representational demands in materials informatics. While classical models such as Support Vector Machines (SVM) achieve strong predictive performance, they often struggle to capture complex, highly correlated interactions in high-dimensional materials data. QML addresses this challenge by leveraging quantum-mechanical principles to construct expressive feature embeddings, where prospective quantum advantage lies in generating feature spaces that are difficult to approximate classically. In this study, 1,000 crystalline compounds from the Open Quantum Materials Database (OQMD) are evaluated in a binary classification task based on formation-energy stability. The dataset is normalized, reduced to four dimensions via Principal Component Analysis (PCA), and encoded into quantum circuits. Three QML models—QSVM, VQC, and QNN—are benchmarked against a classical SVM using repeated stratified evaluation. Results show that the classical SVM achieves the highest accuracy (91.8% ± 0.012), followed by QSVM (60.8% ± 0.035), while VQC and QNN perform significantly worse. This gap is driven by limited qubit capacity, encoding inefficiencies, restricted circuit expressivity, and optimization challenges. Nevertheless, QSVM demonstrates stable performance, suggesting that potential quantum advantage may emerge from improved feature encoding and kernel design rather than deeper variational circuits.
Early and accurate diagnosis of breast cancer plays a critical role in improving patient survival rates and reducing treatment costs. Classical machine learning algorithms such as Logistic Regression and Support Vector Machines (SVM) have demonstrated strong performance in medical diagnosis tasks; however, their scalability and representational limits motivate the exploration of emerging paradigms. Quantum Machine Learning (QML), particularly Variational Quantum Classifiers (VQC), has recently gained attention due to its potential to model complex decision boundaries using quantum circuits. This paper presents a comparative analysis between a Variational Quantum Classifier and classical machine learning models for binary breast cancer classification. The study employs dimensionality-reduced clinical data and evaluates model performance using accuracy, confusion matrices, decision boundary visualization, Principal Component Analysis (PCA), and Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves. Experimental results indicate that the VQC achieves competitive performance with classical approaches, demonstrating its feasibility for small-scale medical datasets and highlighting the promise of quantum-enhanced learning in healthcare applications.