This project prospectively validates the Paired-Delta Protocol (PDP) as a diagnostic architecture for paired quantum random number generator (QRNG) data. PDP divides a single QRNG call into two simultaneously generated streams, allowing analysis of each stream individually, their paired difference, and statistical relationships between them. This expanded measurement space may provide diagnostic information unavailable in a conventional single-stream design, but it also requires validation that the architecture and its relational measures behave as intended under known conditions. The validation will test whether prespecified PDP diagnostics can distinguish known classes of data-generating changes. These include marginal changes affecting an individual stream, common-mode and differential changes, changes confined to the relationship between streams while preserving their marginal distributions, lagged relationships at prespecified lags from −2 through +2, and changes in the stability of local coupling that may occur without a corresponding change in average coupling. The validation will also assess whether alternative methods of partitioning the same QRNG output create systematic paired or relational structure. Diagnostic procedures, disturbance classes, parameter ranges, classification rules, and success criteria will be specified before generation of the held-out validation datasets. The validation data will then be generated under known ground-truth conditions and analyzed using the frozen diagnostic procedure. Performance will be evaluated by whether the procedure detects and correctly localizes the intended changes, preserves expected null and marginal properties, and distinguishes among the prespecified generating classes. Misclassification patterns will also be examined to identify diagnostic boundaries and mechanisms that cannot be distinguished from the paired observations alone. The purpose of this study is methodological. Developmental analyses used to construct and refine the diagnostic procedures are separate from the prospectively evaluated validation set and will not be counted as validation evidence. The expected outcome is a quantitative characterization of which forms of marginal, differential, temporal, and relational structure PDP can reliably distinguish under controlled conditions, together with explicit identification of its limitations. Successful validation would support the use of PDP's additional observables for exploratory hypothesis generation and for diagnostic characterization of independently established effects, rather than as additional opportunities for unconstrained significance testing.
This project prospectively validates the Paired-Delta Protocol (PDP) as a diagnostic architecture for paired quantum random number generator (QRNG) data. PDP divides a single QRNG call into two simultaneously generated streams, allowing analysis of each stream individually, their paired difference, and statistical relationships between them. This expanded measurement space may provide diagnostic information unavailable in a conventional single-stream design, but it also requires validation that the architecture and its relational measures behave as intended under known conditions. The validation will test whether prespecified PDP diagnostics can distinguish known classes of data-generating changes. These include marginal changes affecting an individual stream, common-mode and differential changes, changes confined to the relationship between streams while preserving their marginal distributions, lagged relationships at prespecified lags from −2 through +2, and changes in the stability of local coupling that may occur without a corresponding change in average coupling. The validation will also assess whether alternative methods of partitioning the same QRNG output create systematic paired or relational structure. Diagnostic procedures, disturbance classes, parameter ranges, classification rules, and success criteria will be specified before generation of the held-out validation datasets. The validation data will then be generated under known ground-truth conditions and analyzed using the frozen diagnostic procedure. Performance will be evaluated by whether the procedure detects and correctly localizes the intended changes, preserves expected null and marginal properties, and distinguishes among the prespecified generating classes. Misclassification patterns will also be examined to identify diagnostic boundaries and mechanisms that cannot be distinguished from the paired observations alone. The purpose of this study is methodological. Developmental analyses used to construct and refine the diagnostic procedures are separate from the prospectively evaluated validation set and will not be counted as validation evidence. The expected outcome is a quantitative characterization of which forms of marginal, differential, temporal, and relational structure PDP can reliably distinguish under controlled conditions, together with explicit identification of its limitations. Successful validation would support the use of PDP's additional observables for exploratory hypothesis generation and for diagnostic characterization of independently established effects, rather than as additional opportunities for unconstrained significance testing.
This preregistration describes a confirmatory study of an upstream conditioning architecture in a quantum error-correction workflow. The project’s purpose is to test whether an intervention applied prior to the primary decoder produces a real and reproducible decoder-relevant effect, remains compatible with more than one downstream decoder family, generates a measurable exposed-observable statistical footprint, and improves or preserves performance across a preregistered regime rather than only at a single operating point. The study is intentionally limited to architecture-level evaluation, with the public claim set confined to exposed observables, frozen transformations, preregistered statistical tests, explicit negative controls, and bounded interpretation rules. The confirmatory design is organized around five preregistered tests: category existence, decoder compatibility, structural footprint, observable statistical signature, and regime robustness. Across these tests, the central comparison is between a baseline control pipeline and a conditioned pipeline in which the upstream intervention is applied while all non-conditioning settings are held fixed. The study uses frozen observables and frozen execution rules, including matched seeds, shot counts, code distances, physical error rates, geometry, and baseline decoder settings, so that any supported effect can be interpreted as evidence about the architecture under test rather than as a byproduct of post hoc tuning. To preserve a clean-room boundary, the registration restricts primary analysis to exposed, decoder-facing quantities only. These include logical failure, an exposed defect-count summary, and an exposed decoder-difficulty proxy, along with a locked scalar error-load construction derived from control-only standardization. The study does not rely on decoder-internal state variables, hidden confidence traces, or implementation-specific internal diagnostics in its primary confirmatory analyses. This structure is intended to let readers evaluate whether the architecture leaves a reproducible footprint in decoder-facing behavior without disclosing reconstruction-level mechanism details. Expected outcomes are defined in confirmatory rather than speculative terms. If the preregistered hypotheses are supported, the study is expected to provide evidence that an upstream conditioning intervention exists as a real architectural category in QEC, acts before the primary decoder, is compatible with downstream decoding, changes decoder-relevant exposed structure, and produces a reproducible observable statistical footprint in logical-failure behavior. If support is absent, mixed, or null, those outcomes will still be recorded under the frozen rules without rescue through post hoc metric changes, reweighting, or reinterpretation. In either case, the expected result of the registration is a bounded, auditable public record of whether this architecture class shows reproducible category-level behavior under a preregistered confirmatory design. The preregistration is not intended to establish a unique mechanism identity, identify a privileged implementation, disclose implementation-specific reconstruction details, or support claims about exact targeting logic, suppression laws, subset-sizing logic, telemetry-governed control, or broader cross-domain theory narratives. Public-facing interpretation is therefore intentionally limited to category validation and exposed-observable behavior. This is meant to support rigorous public evaluation while preserving strict clean-room limits around protected implementation detail.
This record contains a manuscript and supporting reproducibility materials for “Ledger-Valid Recovery Diagnostics for Quantum Computing: A Prespecified Sequential Audit for Claim-Limited Recovery Validation.” The paper proposes a methodological validation framework for quantum-computing recovery claims. Its central claim is that endpoint recovery success is necessary but not sufficient for a strong recovery claim when calibration failure, false-carrier acceptance, postselection artifacts, leakage, sentinel blindness, or hidden discard can carry failure modes out of view. The manuscript introduces a prespecified S0–S4 ledger audit that converts familiar diagnostic ingredients—label calibration, candidate recovery, false-carrier challenge tests, postselection/leakage accounting, and sentinel observability—into an ordered, claim-limiting taxonomy. A supportive recovery claim is permitted only when all required gates pass; otherwise, the first failed stage determines a lower claim ceiling and an interpretable failure class. The evaluation is based on synthetic endpoint-level validation suites rather than circuit-level simulation or hardware data. These suites test the behavior of the decision architecture under clean support, degraded observability, false-carrier artifacts, postselection/leakage artifacts, sentinel-blind cases, correlated artifacts, and adversarial overlap. The results show a strong specificity/sensitivity tradeoff: the full ledger protocol sharply reduces synthetic non-support supportive-call rates relative to endpoint-only reporting, but with substantial loss of mechanism-positive support sensitivity. The paper explicitly treats this as a conservative claim-validity architecture, not as a new quantum error-correcting code, new physical observable, hardware speedup, or proof of improved device performance. The supporting materials document the final synthetic validation protocol, endpoint definitions, decision-bound implementation, direction-aware threshold sensitivity analysis, latent-threshold eligibility analysis, mechanism-negative/latent-eligible boundary cases, and figure/table traceability. The archive is intended to support review of the manuscript’s aggregate numerical claims and methodological provenance. Hardware implementation, independent simulator validation, and full raw-event-ledger reproduction are identified as future extensions. Suggested keywords: quantum computing; quantum error correction; validation methodology; recovery diagnostics; leakage; postselection; benchmarking; synthetic validation; decision architecture; reproducibility.
This project presents a preregistered, confirmatory evaluation of a state-dependent pre-decoder conditioning approach in quantum error correction (QEC). The study investigates whether an upstream intervention applied to syndrome-derived information—prior to decoding—produces a consistent and reproducible effect on downstream decoding behavior under controlled conditions. The central objective is to evaluate the existence, robustness, and generality of an upstream conditioning effect at the architectural level, without assuming or asserting a specific internal mechanism. The intervention is treated as a black-box transformation that modifies the representation of syndrome information before it is provided to a decoder, enabling assessment of its observable footprint in decoder-relevant outcomes. The experimental design follows a fully specified, preregistered protocol with all primary elements defined in advance. A four-arm structure is employed: (i) an untreated control condition, (ii) a uniformly applied intervention, (iii) a state-dependent differential intervention, and (iv) a budget-matched comparison that isolates allocation effects under fixed total intervention magnitude. All arms are evaluated across fixed code distances and physical error-rate grids using shared seed schedules and identical decoding backends. Evaluation is conducted in a decoder-agnostic framework in which conditioned representations are generated once per instance and routed unchanged to multiple downstream decoders. This ensures that any observed differences arise from the upstream intervention rather than decoder-specific adaptation or tuning. Primary outcomes are defined in terms of logical failure behavior and exposed error-load observables derived from each instance. These observables are combined into a standardized composite metric using control-only normalization procedures, with all transformations, binning rules, and statistical tests specified in advance and frozen prior to confirmatory analysis. Conditional analyses are performed using bins defined exclusively from control distributions, with consistent application across all experimental arms. The preregistration includes explicit governance rules covering pilot-to-confirmatory transition, parameter freeze conditions, and the handling of any deviations. Pilot-authorized adjustments (such as parameter grid refinement or binning resolution) are finalized and documented prior to continuation of confirmatory execution. No post hoc modification of primary endpoints, evaluation criteria, or aggregation procedures is permitted. The expected outcome of this study is not a predetermined direction of effect, but a rigorous determination of whether an upstream conditioning intervention produces a measurable, reproducible, and structurally consistent footprint in decoder-relevant behavior under preregistered conditions. Results will be reported strictly according to the predefined analysis plan, with negative controls and reproducibility checks included to validate robustness. This work is intended to establish or refute the presence of an architectural-level effect in QEC pipelines while maintaining a strict separation between publicly disclosed evaluation structure and non-public implementation details.
Project WHISPER is a preregistered experimental protocol testing whether statistical properties of quantum random number generator (QRNG) output recorded prior to a future event are independent of a later, independently generated target bit. The study specifies a single, falsifiable hypothesis: that summary statistics computed on a fixed pre-event window of QRNG data are either independent of, or systematically biased toward, a future target value generated by an independent QRNG. All hypotheses, analysis windows, statistical tests, and significance thresholds are preregistered prior to data unblinding. The protocol is designed to eliminate classical information leakage, experimenter bias, and analytical flexibility. A null result supports standard quantum mechanical assumptions of temporal independence; a positive result would motivate independent replication and further investigation.
Quantum compiler assurance requires a semantic relation that matches the intended use and observations that can expose violations at the delivered interface. This critical integrative survey compares verified transformations, equivalence checking, differential and metamorphic testing, property-based testing, and evidence for assurance across revisions. A source catalogue and focused extraction matrix distinguish formal guarantees, reported empirical findings, analytical deductions, and proposed practice. A recorded coverage update and source-level selection decisions make the review auditable within its declared scope. Four documented failure cases connect conditional applicability, parameter association, termination, and phase conventions to method selection. A worked example involving layout metadata, parameter bindings, and ancillary qubits demonstrates why validating a circuit under a reconstructed interpretation can leave the delivered interface unchecked. An illustrative revision scenario then separates fault detection from change attribution. The resulting guidance specifies applicability, complementary observations, and treatment of inconclusive outcomes. Published bug counts, mutation results, and processing benchmarks support different claims and do not establish a common effectiveness ranking. The proposed regression architecture remains unevaluated as a complete system; its practical value requires controlled comparisons on independently adjudicated compiler-change events.
This project pre-registers and reports a blinded, pre-registered validation of HilbertBench, a non-intrusive diagnostic framework for quantum machine learning (QML). HilbertBench records quantum-circuit executions into append-only, cryptographically sealed traces and computes mechanism-level diagnostics — barren plateaus, shot noise, expressibility, optimization convergence, circuit structure, and hardware noise — offline, without perturbing the experiment under test. The instrument is open-source and frozen at version 1.0.0 (Zenodo DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21009245). Purpose. We test a single question: can an analyst with no knowledge of how a QML run was produced correctly identify why it failed — barren plateau, shot starvation, noise domination, or none — using only the recorded trace and the tool's built-in analyzers? To our knowledge this is the first blinded, pre-registered validation of a QML diagnostic, modeled on the methodology of clinical trials. Design. Researcher A generates a labeled corpus of runs with planted failure modes (each label known by construction), publishes a SHA-256 cryptographic commitment of the answer key, and — only after this pre-registration is timestamped — hands the blinded runs to an independent diagnostician, Researcher B, who has not seen the corpus design. The corpus has two strata: a simulated set with clean, isolated ground truth (the primary analysis) and a real-hardware subset on a single IBM device (real-device credibility), diagnosed with primary plus optional secondary labels. Analyzer thresholds are frozen at library defaults on a disjoint development corpus before any test data is generated. Expected outcomes. We report diagnosis accuracy against the 25% four-class chance baseline with 95% Wilson confidence intervals, per-class precision/recall, and a full confusion matrix — whatever the result. We additionally pre-register a hardware prediction: on real devices, barren plateaus and noise domination are physically entangled (the circuit depth that induces an intrinsic plateau also collapses fidelity), which the confusion matrix is expected to reveal. Supporting analyses recover the McClean (2018) barren-plateau scaling exponent and validate calibration-based fidelity prediction against real hardware. All data, code, seeds, and the answer key are archived for full reproducibility.