Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Molecular State Preparation Limit

Jincheng Zhang

Published Aug 21, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper investigates the fundamental limit of achieving a precise molecular state during preparation. We explore the question of how accurately a target molecular state can be realized, defining a preparation limit denoted as εprep. We establish a principle based on the requirement that εprep must be greater than or equal to a minimum value, εmin. The investigation delves into determining the lower bound of this preparation limit, drawing an analogy to measurement limits within physics. The core argument presented herein centers on the inherent uncertainties associated with manipulating quantum systems, suggesting that a preparation limit exists, potentially mirroring the constraints imposed by measurement precision in classical physics. The discussion will outline the considerations for defining and establishing this limit, focusing on the impact of various factors on the achievable precision.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.22039233

Related papers

Molecular Noninvasive Measurement Limit

Jincheng Zhang

This paper investigates the fundamental limit of noninvasive molecular measurement, specifically addressing the question of whether a measurement can be performed without altering the state of the measured molecule. We explore the scenario where a minimal change in entropy, ΔSmin > 0, is desired, and derive the theoretical lower bound for such a measurement. Furthermore, we outline the conditions necessary to identify measurement schemes that satisfy this criterion, recognizing that a truly noninvasive measurement, by definition, is an idealization. The core of the analysis focuses on quantifying the unavoidable perturbation introduced by any measurement process, using concepts from thermodynamics and information theory. The paper establishes a framework for understanding the trade-offs involved in achieving increasingly precise noninvasive measurements and highlights the inherent limitations imposed by the Second Law of Thermodynamics. The discussion extends to considering various measurement modalities, including spectroscopic techniques, and emphasizes the importance of minimizing the measurement's impact on the system being observed. Ultimately, this work provides a theoretical foundation for evaluating the feasibility and limitations of noninvasive molecular sensing.

•Aug 21, 2026•0 citations

Molecular Identifiability Limit

Jincheng Zhang

This paper investigates the fundamental question of whether two fundamentally distinct chemical states can exist, yet remain permanently indistinguishable through any finite set of experiments. The concept of a Molecular Identifiability Limit (MIL) is proposed, defining a theoretical boundary beyond which distinguishing between such states becomes impossible. This work explores the implications of this limit, considering factors such as measurement precision, experimental design, and the inherent limitations of observable properties. The central argument is that while practical distinctions may be achievable within a defined experimental framework, a truly fundamental distinction in chemical state may exist, rendering it permanently unobservable. The paper develops a theoretical framework for understanding the MIL, emphasizing the role of information content and the constraints imposed by the nature of chemical systems. Mathematical formulations are presented to illustrate key concepts and relationships, including the Shannon entropy of observable properties and the relationship between measurement uncertainty and the potential for identification. The exploration highlights the profound implications of the MIL for our understanding of chemical identity and the limits of scientific knowledge.

•Aug 21, 2026•0 citations

Quantum state preparation and control of single molecular ions

D Leibfried

Preparing molecules at rest and in a very pure quantum state is a long-standing aspiration in chemistry and physics, so far achieved only for a select set of molecules in dedicated experimental setups. Here, a quantum-limited combination of mass spectrometry and Raman spectroscopy is proposed that should be applicable to a wide range of molecular ions. Excitation of electrons in the molecule followed by uncontrolled decay and branching into several lower-energy states is avoided. Instead, the molecule is always confined to rotational states within the electronic and vibrational ground-state manifold, while a co-trapped atomic ion provides efficient entropy removal and allows for extraction of information about the molecule. The outlined techniques might enable the preparation, manipulation and measurement of a multitude of molecular ion species with the same instrument, with applications including, but not limited to, precise determination of molecular properties and fundamental tests of physics.

arXiv:1109.0208•New Journal of Physics•Feb 14, 2012•42 citations

Quantum state preparation and control of single molecular ions

Dietrich G. Leibfried

Abstract. Preparing molecules at rest and in a highly pure quantum state is a long standing dream in chemistry and physics, so far achieved only for a select set of molecules in dedicated experimental setups. Here, a quantum-limited combination of mass spectrometry and Raman spectroscopy is proposed that should be applicable to a wide range of molecular ions. Excitation of electrons in the molecule followed by uncontrolled decay and branching into several lower energy states is avoided. Instead, the molecule is always confined to rotational states within the electronic and vibrational ground-state manifold, while a co-trapped atomic ion provides efficient entropy removal and allows for extraction of information on the molecule. The outlined techniques might enable preparation, manipulation and measurement of a large multitude of molecular ion species with the same instrument, with applications including, but not limited to, precise determination of molecular properties and fundamental tests of physics. 1.

•Aug 17, 2016•33 citations

Uncertainty relations as Hilbert space geometry

Samuel L. Braunstein

Precision measurements involve the accurate determination of parameters through repeated measurements of identically prepared experimental setups. For many parameters there is a 'natural' choice for the quantum observable which is expected to give optimal information; and from this observable one can construct an Heinsenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) bound on the precision attainable for the parameter. However, the classical statistics of multiple sampling directly gives us tools to construct bounds for the precision available for the parameters of interest (even when no obvious natural quantum observable exists, such as for phase, or time); it is found that these direct bounds are more restrictive than those of the HUP. The implication is that the natural quantum observables typically do not encode the optimal information (even for observables such as position, and momentum); we show how this can be understood simply in terms of the Hilbert space geometry. Another striking feature of these bounds to parameter uncertainty is that for a large enough number of repetitions of the measurements all V quantum states are 'minimum uncertainty' states - not just Gaussian wave-packets. Thus, these bounds tell us what precision is achievable as well as merely what is allowed.

•May 1, 1994•0 citations

Chemistry at the Uncertainty Limit This contribution is an extended version of a recent commentary published in Nature, in the new section Concepts.[1] The invitation by the Editor of Angewandte Chemie made me steer the piece towards chemistry questions and provide the experimental–theoretical bridge relevant to molecular dynamics.

Ahmed H. Zewail

Spatial and temporal resolution with, until recently, an unimaginable precision—about 0.01 Å and 10 fs, respectively—are today possible thanks to femtochemistry. However, this atomic-scale resolution raises fundamental questions from quantum mechanics: the Uncertainty Paradox. How is it that this is not an obstacle, and what are the future directions? are the themes of this Essay.

Angewandte Chemie International Edition•Dec 3, 2001•46 citations
This paper investigates the fundamental limit of achieving a precise molecular state during preparation. We explore the question of how accurately a target molecular state can be realized, defining a preparation limit denoted as εprep. We establish a principle based on the requirement that εprep must be greater than or equal to a minimum value, εmin. The investigation delves into determining the lower bound of this preparation limit, drawing an analogy to measurement limits within physics. The core argument presented herein centers on the inherent uncertainties associated with manipulating quantum systems, suggesting that a preparation limit exists, potentially mirroring the constraints imposed by measurement precision in classical physics. The discussion will outline the considerations for defining and establishing this limit, focusing on the impact of various factors on the achievable precision.
This paper investigates the fundamental limit of noninvasive molecular measurement, specifically addressing the question of whether a measurement can be performed without altering the state of the measured molecule. We explore the scenario where a minimal change in entropy, ΔSmin > 0, is desired, and derive the theoretical lower bound for such a measurement. Furthermore, we outline the conditions necessary to identify measurement schemes that satisfy this criterion, recognizing that a truly noninvasive measurement, by definition, is an idealization. The core of the analysis focuses on quantifying the unavoidable perturbation introduced by any measurement process, using concepts from thermodynamics and information theory. The paper establishes a framework for understanding the trade-offs involved in achieving increasingly precise noninvasive measurements and highlights the inherent limitations imposed by the Second Law of Thermodynamics. The discussion extends to considering various measurement modalities, including spectroscopic techniques, and emphasizes the importance of minimizing the measurement's impact on the system being observed. Ultimately, this work provides a theoretical foundation for evaluating the feasibility and limitations of noninvasive molecular sensing.
This paper investigates the fundamental question of whether two fundamentally distinct chemical states can exist, yet remain permanently indistinguishable through any finite set of experiments. The concept of a Molecular Identifiability Limit (MIL) is proposed, defining a theoretical boundary beyond which distinguishing between such states becomes impossible. This work explores the implications of this limit, considering factors such as measurement precision, experimental design, and the inherent limitations of observable properties. The central argument is that while practical distinctions may be achievable within a defined experimental framework, a truly fundamental distinction in chemical state may exist, rendering it permanently unobservable. The paper develops a theoretical framework for understanding the MIL, emphasizing the role of information content and the constraints imposed by the nature of chemical systems. Mathematical formulations are presented to illustrate key concepts and relationships, including the Shannon entropy of observable properties and the relationship between measurement uncertainty and the potential for identification. The exploration highlights the profound implications of the MIL for our understanding of chemical identity and the limits of scientific knowledge.
Preparing molecules at rest and in a very pure quantum state is a long-standing aspiration in chemistry and physics, so far achieved only for a select set of molecules in dedicated experimental setups. Here, a quantum-limited combination of mass spectrometry and Raman spectroscopy is proposed that should be applicable to a wide range of molecular ions. Excitation of electrons in the molecule followed by uncontrolled decay and branching into several lower-energy states is avoided. Instead, the molecule is always confined to rotational states within the electronic and vibrational ground-state manifold, while a co-trapped atomic ion provides efficient entropy removal and allows for extraction of information about the molecule. The outlined techniques might enable the preparation, manipulation and measurement of a multitude of molecular ion species with the same instrument, with applications including, but not limited to, precise determination of molecular properties and fundamental tests of physics.
Abstract. Preparing molecules at rest and in a highly pure quantum state is a long standing dream in chemistry and physics, so far achieved only for a select set of molecules in dedicated experimental setups. Here, a quantum-limited combination of mass spectrometry and Raman spectroscopy is proposed that should be applicable to a wide range of molecular ions. Excitation of electrons in the molecule followed by uncontrolled decay and branching into several lower energy states is avoided. Instead, the molecule is always confined to rotational states within the electronic and vibrational ground-state manifold, while a co-trapped atomic ion provides efficient entropy removal and allows for extraction of information on the molecule. The outlined techniques might enable preparation, manipulation and measurement of a large multitude of molecular ion species with the same instrument, with applications including, but not limited to, precise determination of molecular properties and fundamental tests of physics. 1.
Precision measurements involve the accurate determination of parameters through repeated measurements of identically prepared experimental setups. For many parameters there is a 'natural' choice for the quantum observable which is expected to give optimal information; and from this observable one can construct an Heinsenberg uncertainty principle (HUP) bound on the precision attainable for the parameter. However, the classical statistics of multiple sampling directly gives us tools to construct bounds for the precision available for the parameters of interest (even when no obvious natural quantum observable exists, such as for phase, or time); it is found that these direct bounds are more restrictive than those of the HUP. The implication is that the natural quantum observables typically do not encode the optimal information (even for observables such as position, and momentum); we show how this can be understood simply in terms of the Hilbert space geometry. Another striking feature of these bounds to parameter uncertainty is that for a large enough number of repetitions of the measurements all V quantum states are 'minimum uncertainty' states - not just Gaussian wave-packets. Thus, these bounds tell us what precision is achievable as well as merely what is allowed.