Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Droplet That Walks (Quest for Entropy #6)

Marijus Masteika

Published Aug 10, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quest for Entropy #6: I tried to build a probability wave and failed. So this time I went looking for one that already exists — a droplet of oil that bounces on a vibrating bath and builds its own wave, one splash at a time. Then I sat it down for a quantum exam. - Not a claim that quantum mechanics works this way, and not a derivation of anything quantum. No Born rule appears here and none is attempted. - The orbital-looking pictures are wave modes of a confined system. The resemblance to atomic orbitals is a shared equation, not shared physics. - Nothing here says pilot-wave theory is right or wrong. Walking droplets are a classical analogue, not evidence about what quantum particles do. - The walker results are cited from published work, not reproduced here — including the double-slit replication failure. - "A record that steers" and "stays versus passes through" are readings of why the walker behaves as it does — directions to explore, not established mechanisms.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.21876308

Related papers

Building a Wave (Quest for Entropy #5)

Marijus Masteika

Quest for Entropy #5: I wanted a probability cloud that spreads into a shape and then stops — and oscillates. I built six worlds to find one. Here is exactly how each of them failed. - Nothing here is a claim about how quantum mechanics works, and no Born rule is derived or attempted. This is what classical probability distributions can and cannot do. - Six systems, one ruler, finite runs. The ordering held at every resolution I tried; the exact numbers are the ruler's.

•Aug 6, 2026•0 citations

One-dimensional pilot-wave dynamics of walking droplets

S.J.H. Koerhuis

Pilot-wave dynamics of walking droplets is a field in hydrodynamics that has been studied extensively for its interesting features previously thought to be found only in quantum mechanics. The walking droplets in combination with their pilot-wave form a spatially delocalized entity called a walker, wherefrom quantum-like features arise. \n\nThe behavior and dynamics of the droplet have been described theoretically, where the walker moves in a two-dimensional (plane) bath. We start the theoretical development of an analogous one-dimensional version of this theory that describes the walker's behavior in an one-dimensional (long and narrow) bath. We set up the model basis for the equation of motion of the vertically bouncing droplet by looking at a quasi-static droplet in our one-dimensional system. \n\nOur goal is to develop a theory that eventually describes and rationalizes the dynamics and statistical behavior of a walker in our one-dimensional setting. We predict that the simplification to an one-dimensional setting will make the theory behind the behavior of the walker system more understandable. Hence, the theory, which is the basis for explaining the emerging quantum-like features, will eventually shed some light on what is and what is not fundamental to quantum mechanics.\n\nSpecifically, the surface- and potential energy of a quasi-static droplet are calculated and expressed in an harmonic decomposition of the droplet's shape. The expansion coefficients that arise in the harmonic decomposition are calculated by performing an averaging method on the potential energy and minimizing the total energy of a droplet resting on a rigid surface. The expansion coefficients are shown to accurately describe the droplet's shape for a range of Bond numbers (a dimensionless number representing the relative magnitude of gravity to surface tension per unit area), where the range depends on the contact area that the droplet makes with the underlying surface. These results can be used to further develop the one-dimensional walker theory.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Scattering theory of walking droplets in the presence of obstacles

R. Dubertrand, Maxime Hubert, Peter Schlagheck +3 more

We aim to describe a droplet bouncing on a vibrating bath using a simple and highly versatile model inspired from quantum mechanics. Close to the Faraday instability, a long-lived surface wave is created at each bounce, which serves as a pilot wave for the droplet. This leads to so called walking droplets or walkers. Since the seminal experiment by Couder et al (2006 Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 154101) there have been many attempts to accurately reproduce the experimental results.We propose to describe the trajectories of a walker using a Green function approach. The Green function is related to the Helmholtz equation with Neumann boundary conditions on the obstacle(s) and outgoing boundary conditions at infinity. For a single-slit geometry our model is exactly solvable and reproduces some general features observed experimentally. It stands for a promising candidate to account for the presence of arbitrary boundaries in the walker's dynamics.

•Jan 1, 2016•18 citations

Scattering theory of walking droplets in the presence of obstacles

R. Dubertrand, Maxime Hubert, Peter Schlagheck +3 more

We aim to describe a droplet bouncing on a vibrating bath using a simple and highly versatile model inspired from quantum mechanics. Close to the Faraday instability, a long-lived surface wave is created at each bounce, which serves as a pilot wave for the droplet. This leads to so called walking droplets or walkers. Since the seminal experiment by Couder et al (2006 Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 154101 ) there have been many attempts to accurately reproduce the experimental results.We propose to describe the trajectories of a walker using a Green function approach. The Green function is related to the Helmholtz equation with Neumann boundary conditions on the obstacle(s) and outgoing boundary conditions at infinity. For a single-slit geometry our model is exactly solvable and reproduces some general features observed experimentally. It stands for a promising candidate to account for the presence of arbitrary boundaries in the walker’s dynamics.

arXiv:1605.02370•New Journal of Physics•Nov 22, 2016•19 citations

Walking droplets, pilot waves, and word choices

Jeffery Winkler

After reading John Bush’s article “The new wave of pilot-wave theory” (Physics Today, August 2015, page 47), I want to remind readers of the limitations of the analogy. The oil-drop experiments provide a tangible partial analogue of the pilot-wave picture, but one that is restricted to single-particle phenomena. Such experiments cannot reproduce the types of phenomena that depend on entanglement; only in the case of a single particle does the wavefunction have the same mathematical form—a scalar function over space—as the waves in the oil.Once two particles are involved, the fact that the wavefunction is defined over the configuration space of the system rather than over physical space becomes crucial, and the partial analogy to the oil drops fails. In other words, the analogy does not extend to what most people consider the most interesting aspects of quantum mechanics.© 2016 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Mar 31, 2016•1 citation

The pilot-wave dynamics of walking droplets

Daniel M. Harris, John W. M. Bush

A millimetric droplet can be induced to bounce on the surface of a fluid bath by vibrating the bath near the droplet's resonant frequency (Figure 1(a) ). [superscript 1–3] The localized field of Faraday waves excited by the bouncing droplet can cause it to propel itself laterally across the surface, moving in resonance with its guiding wave field (Figure 1(b) ). [superscript 4,5] These walking droplets, or “walkers,” generally move in a straight line at constant speed; however, they can be diverted through interaction with boundaries or external forces. This hydrodynamic system represents a macroscopic realization of the pilot-wave theory of quantum dynamics proposed by Louis de Broglie, according to which microscopic particles are propelled through a resonant interaction with a wave field generated by the particle's internal vibration. [superscript 6] Coincidentally, it exhibits many behaviors once thought to be exclusive to the microscopic quantum realm, including single-particle diffraction, [superscript 7] tunneling, [superscript 8] quantized orbits, [superscript 9] and orbital-level splitting. [superscript 10]

Physics of Fluids•Sep 1, 2013•22 citations
Quest for Entropy #6: I tried to build a probability wave and failed. So this time I went looking for one that already exists — a droplet of oil that bounces on a vibrating bath and builds its own wave, one splash at a time. Then I sat it down for a quantum exam. - Not a claim that quantum mechanics works this way, and not a derivation of anything quantum. No Born rule appears here and none is attempted. - The orbital-looking pictures are wave modes of a confined system. The resemblance to atomic orbitals is a shared equation, not shared physics. - Nothing here says pilot-wave theory is right or wrong. Walking droplets are a classical analogue, not evidence about what quantum particles do. - The walker results are cited from published work, not reproduced here — including the double-slit replication failure. - "A record that steers" and "stays versus passes through" are readings of why the walker behaves as it does — directions to explore, not established mechanisms.
Pilot-wave dynamics of walking droplets is a field in hydrodynamics that has been studied extensively for its interesting features previously thought to be found only in quantum mechanics. The walking droplets in combination with their pilot-wave form a spatially delocalized entity called a walker, wherefrom quantum-like features arise. \n\nThe behavior and dynamics of the droplet have been described theoretically, where the walker moves in a two-dimensional (plane) bath. We start the theoretical development of an analogous one-dimensional version of this theory that describes the walker's behavior in an one-dimensional (long and narrow) bath. We set up the model basis for the equation of motion of the vertically bouncing droplet by looking at a quasi-static droplet in our one-dimensional system. \n\nOur goal is to develop a theory that eventually describes and rationalizes the dynamics and statistical behavior of a walker in our one-dimensional setting. We predict that the simplification to an one-dimensional setting will make the theory behind the behavior of the walker system more understandable. Hence, the theory, which is the basis for explaining the emerging quantum-like features, will eventually shed some light on what is and what is not fundamental to quantum mechanics.\n\nSpecifically, the surface- and potential energy of a quasi-static droplet are calculated and expressed in an harmonic decomposition of the droplet's shape. The expansion coefficients that arise in the harmonic decomposition are calculated by performing an averaging method on the potential energy and minimizing the total energy of a droplet resting on a rigid surface. The expansion coefficients are shown to accurately describe the droplet's shape for a range of Bond numbers (a dimensionless number representing the relative magnitude of gravity to surface tension per unit area), where the range depends on the contact area that the droplet makes with the underlying surface. These results can be used to further develop the one-dimensional walker theory.
We aim to describe a droplet bouncing on a vibrating bath using a simple and highly versatile model inspired from quantum mechanics. Close to the Faraday instability, a long-lived surface wave is created at each bounce, which serves as a pilot wave for the droplet. This leads to so called walking droplets or walkers. Since the seminal experiment by Couder et al (2006 Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 154101) there have been many attempts to accurately reproduce the experimental results.We propose to describe the trajectories of a walker using a Green function approach. The Green function is related to the Helmholtz equation with Neumann boundary conditions on the obstacle(s) and outgoing boundary conditions at infinity. For a single-slit geometry our model is exactly solvable and reproduces some general features observed experimentally. It stands for a promising candidate to account for the presence of arbitrary boundaries in the walker's dynamics.
We aim to describe a droplet bouncing on a vibrating bath using a simple and highly versatile model inspired from quantum mechanics. Close to the Faraday instability, a long-lived surface wave is created at each bounce, which serves as a pilot wave for the droplet. This leads to so called walking droplets or walkers. Since the seminal experiment by Couder et al (2006 Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 154101 ) there have been many attempts to accurately reproduce the experimental results.We propose to describe the trajectories of a walker using a Green function approach. The Green function is related to the Helmholtz equation with Neumann boundary conditions on the obstacle(s) and outgoing boundary conditions at infinity. For a single-slit geometry our model is exactly solvable and reproduces some general features observed experimentally. It stands for a promising candidate to account for the presence of arbitrary boundaries in the walker’s dynamics.
After reading John Bush’s article “The new wave of pilot-wave theory” (Physics Today, August 2015, page 47), I want to remind readers of the limitations of the analogy. The oil-drop experiments provide a tangible partial analogue of the pilot-wave picture, but one that is restricted to single-particle phenomena. Such experiments cannot reproduce the types of phenomena that depend on entanglement; only in the case of a single particle does the wavefunction have the same mathematical form—a scalar function over space—as the waves in the oil.Once two particles are involved, the fact that the wavefunction is defined over the configuration space of the system rather than over physical space becomes crucial, and the partial analogy to the oil drops fails. In other words, the analogy does not extend to what most people consider the most interesting aspects of quantum mechanics.© 2016 American Institute of Physics.
A millimetric droplet can be induced to bounce on the surface of a fluid bath by vibrating the bath near the droplet's resonant frequency (Figure 1(a) ). [superscript 1–3] The localized field of Faraday waves excited by the bouncing droplet can cause it to propel itself laterally across the surface, moving in resonance with its guiding wave field (Figure 1(b) ). [superscript 4,5] These walking droplets, or “walkers,” generally move in a straight line at constant speed; however, they can be diverted through interaction with boundaries or external forces. This hydrodynamic system represents a macroscopic realization of the pilot-wave theory of quantum dynamics proposed by Louis de Broglie, according to which microscopic particles are propelled through a resonant interaction with a wave field generated by the particle's internal vibration. [superscript 6] Coincidentally, it exhibits many behaviors once thought to be exclusive to the microscopic quantum realm, including single-particle diffraction, [superscript 7] tunneling, [superscript 8] quantized orbits, [superscript 9] and orbital-level splitting. [superscript 10]