This thesis investigates the feasibility of a generic, modular compiler that treats an existing three-move straight-line extractability compiler as a black-box building block and extends it to multi-round public-coin protocols. We introduce a recursive compiler that compresses an interactive multi-round protocol layer by layer and analyze how its security and efficiency properties propagate through this recursion. The analysis demonstrates that while the framework successfully preserves completeness, zero knowledge, and knowledge soundness, the modularity incurs a substantial cost. The repetition parameters required at each recursive level cause an exponential blowup in both runtime and communication complexity, restricting the compiler’s efficiency to protocols with a strictly constant number of rounds. Furthermore, preserving the zero-knowledge property requires the input protocol to satisfy 2-Stage special Honest Verifier Zero-Knowledge, a stronger form of special Honest-Verifier Zero-Knowledge introduced in this work. Ultimately, this thesis provides a clean theoretical framework for modular straight-line extractability, but exposes the asymptotic performance gap between our flexible black-box construction and specialized monolithic transformations.
This thesis investigates the feasibility of a generic, modular compiler that treats an existing three-move straight-line extractability compiler as a black-box building block and extends it to multi-round public-coin protocols. We introduce a recursive compiler that compresses an interactive multi-round protocol layer by layer and analyze how its security and efficiency properties propagate through this recursion. The analysis demonstrates that while the framework successfully preserves completeness, zero knowledge, and knowledge soundness, the modularity incurs a substantial cost. The repetition parameters required at each recursive level cause an exponential blowup in both runtime and communication complexity, restricting the compiler’s efficiency to protocols with a strictly constant number of rounds. Furthermore, preserving the zero-knowledge property requires the input protocol to satisfy 2-Stage special Honest Verifier Zero-Knowledge, a stronger form of special Honest-Verifier Zero-Knowledge introduced in this work. Ultimately, this thesis provides a clean theoretical framework for modular straight-line extractability, but exposes the asymptotic performance gap between our flexible black-box construction and specialized monolithic transformations.
Recently there has been a huge emphasis on constructing cryptographic protocols that maintain their security guarantees even in the presence of side channel attacks. Such attacks exploit the physical characteristics of a cryptographic device to learn useful information about the internal state of the device. Designing protocols that deliver meaningful security even in the presence of such leakage attacks is a challenging task. The recent work of Garg, Jain, and Sahai formulates a meaningful notion of zero-knowledge in presence of leakage; and provides a construction which satisfies a weaker variant of this notion called (1 + ɛ)-leakage-resilient-zero-knowledge, for every constant ɛ> 0. In this weaker variant, roughly speaking, if the verifier learns ℓ bits of leakage during the interaction, then the simulator is allowed to access (1 + ɛ) · ℓ bits of leakage. The round complexity of their protocol is ⌈ n ɛ ⌉. In this work, we present the first construction of leakage-resilient zero-knowledge satisfying the ideal requirement of ɛ = 0. While our focus is on a feasibility result for ɛ = 0, our construction also enjoys a constant number of rounds. At the heart of our construction is a new “public-coin preamble ” which allows the simulator to recover arbitrary information from a (cheating) verifier in a “straight line. ” We use non-black-box simulation techniques to accomplish this goal. 1
We present a new constant round protocol for non-malleable zero-knowledge. Using this protocol as a subroutine, we obtain a new constant-round protocol for non-malleable commitments. Our constructions rely on the existence of (standard) collision resistant hash functions. Previous constructions either relied on the existence of trapdoor permutations and hash functions that are collision resistant against sub-exponential sized circuits, or required a super-constant number of rounds.Additional results are the first construction of a non-malleable commitment scheme that is statistically hiding (with respect to opening), and the first non-malleable protocols that satisfy a strict polynomial-time simulation requirement. The latter are constructed by additionally assuming the existence of trapdoor permutations.Our approach differs from the approaches taken in previous works in that we view non-malleable zero-knowledge as a building-block rather than an end goal. This gives rise to a modular construction of non-malleable commitments and results in a somewhat simpler analysis.The techniques that we use to construct our zero-knowl-edge protocol are non black-box, but are different than the non black-box techniques previously used in the context of non-malleable coin-tossing.
One of the most fundamental goals in cryptography is to design protocols that remain secure when adversarial participants can engage in arbitrary malicious behavior. In 1986, Goldreich, Micali, and Wigderson presented a powerful paradigm for designing such protocols: their approach reduced the task of designing secure protocols to designing protocols that only guarantee security against “honest-but-curious” participants. By making use of zero-knowledge proofs, the GMW paradigm enforces honest behavior without compromising secrecy. Over the past two decades, this approach has been the dominant paradigm for cryptographic protocol design, based on zero-knowledge protocols based on computational hardness assumptions. In this work, we describe a new general paradigm/protocol compiler for secure protocol design known as the IPS compiler, that departs considerably from the GMW framework, and provides a method for obtaining efficient protocols with information-theoretic security guarantees in settings where appropriate channels exist. This new approach also reduces the task of designing secure protocols to designing protocols that only guarantee security against honest-but-curious participants. However, the new approach avoids the use of zero-knowledge proofs, and instead makes use of multi-party protocols in a much simpler setting - where the majority of participants are completely honest (such multi-party protocols can exist with information-theoretic security guarantees without assuming any special channels). The IPS paradigm yields protocols that rely on Oblivious Transfer channels (OT) as a building block. This offers a number of advantages in generality and efficiency. In contrast to the GMW paradigm, by avoiding the use of zero-knowledge proofs, the IPS paradigm is able to treat all of its building blocks as “black boxes”. This allows improvement over previous results in the area of secure computation. In particular, the IPS compiler yields conceptually simpler and more efficient ways for basing unconditionally secure cryptography on OT and other noisy channels; more efficient protocols for generating a large number of OTs using a small number of OTs; and secure and efficient protocols which only make a blackbox use of cryptographic primitives or underlying algebraic structures in settings where no such protocols were known before.
We present a round-efficient black-box construction of a general multi-party computation (MPC) protocol that satisfies composability in the plain model. The security of our protocol is proven in the angel-based UC framework [Prabhakaran and Sahai, STOC’04] under the minimal assumption of the existence of semi-honest oblivious transfer protocols. The round complexity of our protocol is max(O(log2n),O(ROT))
when the round complexity of the underlying oblivious transfer protocol is ROT
. Since constant-round semi-honest oblivious transfer protocols can be constructed under standard assumptions (such as the existence of enhanced trapdoor permutations), our result gives a O(log2n)
-round protocol under these assumptions. Previously, only an O(max(nϵ,ROT))
-round protocol was shown, where ϵ>0
is an arbitrary constant. We obtain our MPC protocol by constructing a O(log2n)
-round CCA-secure commitment scheme in a black-box way under the assumption of the existence of one-way functions.
Secure multi-party computation (MPC) enables distrustful parties to jointly perform computations while guaranteeing both the privacy of their inputs and the correctness of the computation.
This thesis explores two aspects of secure multi-party computation: adaptive security and round efficiency. Adaptive security is concerned with an adversary that adaptively determines who and when to corrupt during the course of the computation. Even though this is a very natural and realistic assumption about the adversary, most of the MPC literature addresses security only against a static adversary — an adversary that chooses (and fixes) which parties to corrupt before the protocol starts executing. A protocol is called round-efficient if it runs in a small number of rounds. Constructing such protocols is important since efficiency of a protocol is greatly influenced by its round complexity.
The security in this thesis is formulated in the universal composability (UC) framework introduced by Canetti [Can01]. Protocols secure in the UC framework remain secure even when executed concurrently with other arbitrary protocols running in some larger network, and can be used as subroutines of larger protocols in a modular fashion. This property is important considering that nowadays many protocols are executed concurrently with others in the Internet.
With the focus on adaptive security and round efficiency, we obtain the following results:
(1) We show that with access to an ideal commitment functionality, there exists a protocol that UC realizes any well-formed multi-party functionality against a malicious, adaptive adversary that may corrupt any number of parties, with black-box access to any protocol that UC realizes oblivious transfer against a semi-honest, adaptive adversary.
(2) We show that there exists a protocol that UC realizes oblivious transfer against a semi-honest, adaptive adversary, with black-box access to a cryptographic primitive called a trapdoor simulatable cryptosystem, which is a natural relaxation of a simulatable cryptosystem introduced by Damgard and Nielsen [3N00].
We also show that the primitive can be constructed based on hardness of factoring.
(3) We present a single-message protocol that UC realizes two-party computing with encrypted data (a variant of secure two-party computation), based on the DDH assumption and non- interactive zero-knowledge arguments. The protocol achieves security against a malicious, static adversary.
(4) We present two round-efficient protocols that UC realize multi-party computing with encrypted data (a variant of secure multi-party computation), based on the DDH assumption and non-interactive zero-knowledge arguments. The first (resp. second) protocol requires one round (resp. two rounds) with appropriate preprocessing, which is independent of the exact circuit and actual inputs of the specific instance problem to solve — only the bound on the circuit size is known. Although the first protocol is more round-efficient, the preprocessing of the second is sometimes better under some efficiency considerations. Both protocols achieve security against a malicious, static adversary that may corrupt up to all but one parties.
A central question in the theory of cryptography is whether we can build protocols that achieve stronger security guarantees, e.g., security against malicious adversaries, by combining building blocks that achieve much weaker security guarantees, e.g., security only against semi-honest adversaries; and with the minimal number of rounds. An additional focus is whether these building blocks can be used only as a black-box. Since Oblivious Transfer (OT) is the necessary and sufficient building block to securely realize any two-party (and multi-party) functionality, theoreticians often focus on proving whether maliciously secure OT can be built from a weaker notion of OT. There is a rich body of literature that provides (black-box) compilers that build malicious OT from OTs that achieve weaker security such as semi-malicious OT and defensibly secure OT, within the minimal number of rounds. However, no round-optimal compiler exists that builds malicious OT from the weakest notion of semi-honest OT, in the plain model. Correlation intractable hash (CIH) functions are special hash functions whose properties allow instantiating the celebrated Fiat-Shamir transform, and hence reduce the round complexity of public-coin proof systems. In this work, we devise the first round-optimal compiler from semi-honest OT to malicious OT, by a novel application of CIH for collapsing rounds in the plain model. We provide the following contributions. First, we provide a new CIH-based round-collapsing construction for general cut-and-choose. This gadget can be used generally to prove the correctness of the evaluation of a function. Then, we use our gadget to build the first round-optimal compiler from semi-honest OT to malicious OT. Our compiler uses the semi-honest OT protocol and the other building blocks in a black-box manner. However, for technical reasons, the underlying CIH construction requires the upper bound of the circuit size of the semi-honest OT protocol used. The need for this upper-bound makes our protocol not fully black-box, hence is incomparable with existing, fully black-box, compilers.