What does it mean for a mixed-state topological phase to be chiral? Mathematically, chirality can be sharply characterized through the symmetry algebra of the mixed state. Physically, however, the question is far more subtle. In pure states, chirality in topological phase is tied to a web of familiar diagnostics, involving bulk-boundary correspondence, a gapless entanglement spectrum, a nontrivial modular commutator, and a quantized thermal Hall response. We show that none of these diagnostics remain reliable in mixed states. Instead, for decohered topological phases with a known error-free parent state, we propose two relative-entropy-based measures that can diagnose chirality, with one of them further extracting the chiral central charge. As a concrete example, we use these measures to analyze the $em^2$ -decohered $\mathbb{Z}_3$ toric code, identifying the chirality transition to be in the random-bond Potts class for the particle-hole symmetric channel, and the polarized random bond Potts class for asymmetric channels. Our results emphasize how mixed-state topology demands intrinsically new diagnostics beyond direct analogues of pure-state probes.What does it mean for a mixed-state topological phase to be chiral? Mathematically, chirality can be sharply characterized through the symmetry algebra of the mixed state. Physically, however, the question is far more subtle. In pure states, chirality in topological phase is tied to a web of familiar diagnostics, involving bulk-boundary correspondence, a gapless entanglement spectrum, a nontrivial modular commutator, and a quantized thermal Hall response. We show that none of these diagnostics remain reliable in mixed states. Instead, for decohered topological phases with a known error-free parent state, we propose two relative-entropy-based measures that can diagnose chirality, with one of them further extracting the chiral central charge. As a concrete example, we use these measures to analyze the $em^2$-decohered $\mathbb{Z}_3$ toric code, identifying the chirality transition to be in the random-bond Potts class for the particle-hole symmetric channel, and the polarized random bond Potts class for asymmetric channels. Our results emphasize how mixed-state topology demands intrinsically new diagnostics beyond direct analogues of pure-state probes.

quant-pharXiv:2606.26235Jun 26, 20260 citations

Multi-scale entanglement Renormalization Ansatz and chiral topological phases

Zhi Li, Roger S. K. Mong

Bulletin of the American Physical SocietyMar 14, 20170 citations

Entanglement Measure Response to Modular Flow and Chiral Topological Phases

Yunlong Zang

Recent years have witnessed significant progress in the entanglement-based characterization of quantum phases of matter. The primary objects of interest are the reduced density matrix and its associated entanglement Hamiltonian. As intrinsic properties of a quantum state, these quantities theoretically determine all experimentally accessible local observables. In this work, we investigate the response of two entanglement measures to the real-time dynamics driven by the entanglement Hamiltonian--a process known as modular flow. We demonstrate that our results can be unified into a single generating function, $\langleρ_{AB}^α\mathrm{e}^{λ{Q}_{AB}}\mathrm{e}^{μ{Q}_{BC}}ρ_{BC}^β\rangle$ . This function is of independent interest as it represents a generalization of the recently proposed Rényi modular commutator. In appropriate limits, this function yields the response of Rényi entropy and its charged version, which we find to be uniquely determined by chiral topological invariants, specifically the chiral central charge and the Hall conductance. Our analytical findings are validated through two independent approaches: (i) free fermion systems using the real-space Chern number formula, and (ii) an effective field theory treatment that regularizes the entanglement cut via chiral conformal field theory. Both methods yield consistent results.Recent years have witnessed significant progress in the entanglement-based characterization of quantum phases of matter. The primary objects of interest are the reduced density matrix and its associated entanglement Hamiltonian. As intrinsic properties of a quantum state, these quantities theoretically determine all experimentally accessible local observables. In this work, we investigate the response of two entanglement measures to the real-time dynamics driven by the entanglement Hamiltonian--a process known as modular flow. We demonstrate that our results can be unified into a single generating function, $\langleρ_{AB}^α\mathrm{e}^{λ{Q}_{AB}}\mathrm{e}^{μ{Q}_{BC}}ρ_{BC}^β\rangle$. This function is of independent interest as it represents a generalization of the recently proposed Rényi modular commutator. In appropriate limits, this function yields the response of Rényi entropy and its charged version, which we find to be uniquely determined by chiral topological invariants, specifically the chiral central charge and the Hall conductance. Our analytical findings are validated through two independent approaches: (i) free fermion systems using the real-space Chern number formula, and (ii) an effective field theory treatment that regularizes the entanglement cut via chiral conformal field theory. Both methods yield consistent results.

arXiv:2603.09717Mar 10, 20260 citations

Entanglement Spectrum In Topological Phasess

Bogdan Andrei Bernevig

Bulletin of the American Physical SocietyMar 1, 20120 citations

From Entanglement Generated Dynamics to the Gravitational Anomaly and Chiral Central Charge

Ruihua Fan

We apply modular flow-entanglement generated dynamics-to characterize quantum orders of ground state wave functions. In particular, we study the linear response of the entanglement entropy of a simply connected region with respect to modular flow. First, we apply it to (1+1)D conformal field theories and demonstrate its relationship to the chiral central charge-or, equivalently, the perturbative gravitational anomaly-which is shown to vanish. Next, we apply it to (2+1)D gapped ground states where it reduces to a recently proposed formula by Kim et al. that is conjectured to compute the edge chiral central charge. Modular flow provides an intuitive picture for this conjecture based on bulk-edge correspondence. We also provide numerics on free-fermion models that lend support to our picture.We apply modular flow-entanglement generated dynamics-to characterize quantum orders of ground state wave functions. In particular, we study the linear response of the entanglement entropy of a simply connected region with respect to modular flow. First, we apply it to (1+1)D conformal field theories and demonstrate its relationship to the chiral central charge-or, equivalently, the perturbative gravitational anomaly-which is shown to vanish. Next, we apply it to (2+1)D gapped ground states where it reduces to a recently proposed formula by Kim et al. that is conjectured to compute the edge chiral central charge. Modular flow provides an intuitive picture for this conjecture based on bulk-edge correspondence. We also provide numerics on free-fermion models that lend support to our picture.

arXiv:2206.02823Physical Review LettersDec 22, 202225 citations

em^2

-decohered

\mathbb{Z}_3

toric code, identifying the chirality transition to be in the random-bond Potts class for the particle-hole symmetric channel, and the polarized random bond Potts class for asymmetric channels. Our results emphasize how mixed-state topology demands intrinsically new diagnostics beyond direct analogues of pure-state probes.

\langleρ_{AB}^α\mathrm{e}^{λ{Q}_{AB}}\mathrm{e}^{μ{Q}_{BC}}ρ_{BC}^β\rangle

. This function is of independent interest as it represents a generalization of the recently proposed Rényi modular commutator. In appropriate limits, this function yields the response of Rényi entropy and its charged version, which we find to be uniquely determined by chiral topological invariants, specifically the chiral central charge and the Hall conductance. Our analytical findings are validated through two independent approaches: (i) free fermion systems using the real-space Chern number formula, and (ii) an effective field theory treatment that regularizes the entanglement cut via chiral conformal field theory. Both methods yield consistent results.