Quantum-like approach to random utility maximization framework: Application to discrete choice modelling Jinseok Kim Technology Management, Economics, and Policy Program Graduate School of Seoul National University Seoul National University Random utility maximization (RUM) framework is the most commonly used approach to model consumer choice and decision-making processes, with the discrete choice model in particular being widely used for choice modeling. However, while the firm economic foundation of random utility theory provides accurate modelling of human behavior in most cases, there has been continuous efforts to improve upon this framework to account for human behavior under risk and uncertainty. Many studies have therefore developed expanded models to incorporate behavioral concepts into the mathematical models of choice. This study takes on this task by examining the impact of ontic uncertainty to human decision-making process. In doing so, this study explores the benefits of applying the key concepts of quantum mechanics framework to choice modelling framework in explaining human behavior under uncertainty. Through this application, this study successfully derives an altered choice probability formulation that expands upon the existing choice probability formulation with an added interference term. It is noticeable that the first term of the derived quantum-like choice probability closely resembles that of the mixed logit model. The interference term reflects the effect of applying the quantum concepts, superposition and interference effect into the discrete choice model framework. This derived formulation is then applied to empirical data to test for performance of the quantum-like discrete choice model and to examine the new implications that the derived model possesses. Estimation of parameters is implemented through the simulated maximum likelihood estimation method. Specifically, through this new methodology, this study intends to analyze and interpret the impact of uncertainty in the decision-making process. Empirical application of the quantum-like discrete choice model revealed that the quantum-like discrete choice model displayed fairly stable estimation of the true parameter values and similar parameter estimations as the mixed logit model. However, as the interference term showed to be of insignificant magnitude, the effect of ontic uncertainty and interference effect needs further examination in further application of quantum concepts to choice modelling framework. Keywords: Choice modelling, quantum probability theory, uncertainty, superposition, interference, mixed logit Student Number: 2020-36904
Quantum-like approach to random utility maximization framework: Application to discrete choice modelling Jinseok Kim Technology Management, Economics, and Policy Program Graduate School of Seoul National University Seoul National University Random utility maximization (RUM) framework is the most commonly used approach to model consumer choice and decision-making processes, with the discrete choice model in particular being widely used for choice modeling. However, while the firm economic foundation of random utility theory provides accurate modelling of human behavior in most cases, there has been continuous efforts to improve upon this framework to account for human behavior under risk and uncertainty. Many studies have therefore developed expanded models to incorporate behavioral concepts into the mathematical models of choice. This study takes on this task by examining the impact of ontic uncertainty to human decision-making process. In doing so, this study explores the benefits of applying the key concepts of quantum mechanics framework to choice modelling framework in explaining human behavior under uncertainty. Through this application, this study successfully derives an altered choice probability formulation that expands upon the existing choice probability formulation with an added interference term. It is noticeable that the first term of the derived quantum-like choice probability closely resembles that of the mixed logit model. The interference term reflects the effect of applying the quantum concepts, superposition and interference effect into the discrete choice model framework. This derived formulation is then applied to empirical data to test for performance of the quantum-like discrete choice model and to examine the new implications that the derived model possesses. Estimation of parameters is implemented through the simulated maximum likelihood estimation method. Specifically, through this new methodology, this study intends to analyze and interpret the impact of uncertainty in the decision-making process. Empirical application of the quantum-like discrete choice model revealed that the quantum-like discrete choice model displayed fairly stable estimation of the true parameter values and similar parameter estimations as the mixed logit model. However, as the interference term showed to be of insignificant magnitude, the effect of ontic uncertainty and interference effect needs further examination in further application of quantum concepts to choice modelling framework. Keywords: Choice modelling, quantum probability theory, uncertainty, superposition, interference, mixed logit Student Number: 2020-36904
Classical models of decision-making under uncertainty, grounded in expected utility theory and Bayesian probability, often fail to account for systematic cognitive anomalies such as preference reversals, order effects, ambiguity aversion, and context-dependent choices. Quantum cognition models offer a novel theoretical framework that applies the mathematical principles of quantum probability—such as superposition, interference, and non-commutativity—to cognitive processes without assuming physical quantum mechanisms in the brain. By representing cognitive states as probabilistic superpositions that collapse through decision “measurements,” these models provide parsimonious explanations for violations of classical rationality. This paper examines how quantum cognition frameworks capture contextual influence, belief updating, and interference effects in uncertain decision environments. Drawing on findings from cognitive psychology and behavioral economics, the study highlights the relevance of quantum cognition for applications in economic choice modeling, legal decision analysis, and artificial intelligence. The analysis suggests that quantum probability offers a robust alternative to classical approaches when modeling human decision-making in complex, ambiguous, and context-sensitive situations.
Classical economic decision-making models rely on assumptions of stable preferences, logical consistency, and additive probabilities. Yet decades of behavioral research consistently reveal systematic violations of these principles, including preference reversals, framing effects, and context-sensitive judgment patterns that challenge rational-choice theory. This study examines how quantum propensity modeling—grounded in mathematical structures derived from quantum theory—offers a compelling alternative for understanding these anomalies. Unlike classical models, quantum cognition treats decisions as evolving cognitive states represented in superposition, allowing individuals to hold simultaneous, uncertain predispositions before committing to a choice. Contextual interference, probability amplitude effects, and state-dependent transitions enable these models to accurately describe how information order, framing, and emotional cues distort decision trajectories. Through qualitative analysis of case studies from behavioral economics, cognitive psychology, and decision theory, this research highlights how quantum models capture the non-commutativity of choices, the instability of preferences under uncertainty, and the mechanisms behind cognitive interference patterns. The findings suggest that quantum propensity modeling not only explains well-documented behavioral anomalies more coherently than classical frameworks but also provides a theoretical foundation for applications in market forecasting, algorithmic pricing, consumer behavior analysis, and policy design. Ultimately, the study argues that quantum-inspired decision models represent a transformative step toward more realistic, context-aware interpretations of economic behavior.
In physics, at the beginning of the twentieth century it was recognized that some experiments could not be explained by the conventional classical mechanics, but the same could be explained by the newly discovered quantum theory. It resulted in a new mechanics called quantum mechanics that revolutionized scientific and technological developments. Again, at the beginning of the twenty-first century, it is being recognized that some experiments related to the human decision-making processes could not be explained by the conventional classical decision theory but the same could be explained by the models based on quantum mechanics. It is now recognized that we need quantum mechanics in psychology as well as in economics and finance. In this paper we attempt to advance and explain the present understanding of applicability of quantum mechanics to the human decision-making processes. Using the postulates analogous to the postulates of quantum mechanics, we show the derivation of the quantum interference equation to illustrate the quantum approach. The explanation of disjunction effect experiments of Tversky and Shafir (Tversky A, Shafir E (1992) The disjunction effect in choice under uncertainty. Psych. Sci. 3(5):305–309) has been chosen to demonstrate the necessity of a quantum model. Further, to suggest the possibility of application of the quantum theory to the business-related decisions, some terms such as price operator, state of mind of the acquiring firm, etc., are introduced and discussed in context of the merger/acquisition of business firms. The possibility of the development in areas such as quantum finance, quantum management, application of quantum mechanics to the human dynamics related to healthcare management, etc., is also indicated.
Quantum probability theory, originally developed in the context of quantum mechanics, has increasingly been applied to social sciences to explain decision-making, cognition, and collective behavior. Unlike classical probability models, which assume pre-existing and well-defined preferences, quantum models incorporate superposition, interference, and non-commutativity to capture the contextual dependence and measurement effects observed in human decisions. This paper systematically explores the theoretical foundations of quantum probability in social sciences, discusses model construction techniques, and reviews empirical findings supporting its application. By examining case studies in quantum cognition, quantum game theory, and quantum voting, we illustrate how quantum approaches provide alternative explanations for phenomena such as order effects, measurement-induced attitude shifts, and collective polarization. The paper also discusses the methodological challenges and limitations of quantum social science, emphasizing the need for rigorous experimental validation and interdisciplinary collaboration. Finally, we highlight the potential for integrating quantum probability models with emerging technologies such as quantum computing and artificial intelligence, opening new avenues for social science research and policy applications.
Purpose: Decision-making under uncertainty remains a foundational challenge in cognitive science and artificial intelligence. Classical Bayesian Probability Models (CBM) often fail to explain paradoxical cognitive behaviors such as order effects, ambiguity aversion, and context-dependent reasoning. This study seeks to compare Quantum Probability Theory (QPT) and Classical Bayesian Models in their ability to capture the dynamics of human decision-making. It aims to determine which framework more accurately reflects the cognitive mechanisms underlying reasoning under uncertainty. Methodology: A qualitative, exploratory research design was adopted, involving in-depth semi-structured interviews with 16 experts across psychology, philosophy, artificial intelligence, and cognitive neuroscience. Participants were purposively selected for their theoretical and empirical expertise in probabilistic reasoning. Data were analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis, guided by the Dual-Process Theory and Busemeyer’s Quantum Cognition framework. The analysis emphasized participants’ perspectives on theoretical assumptions, cognitive plausibility, and predictive utility between QPT and CBM paradigms. Findings: Thematic findings reveal that Quantum Probability Theory offers superior explanatory power in contexts involving cognitive ambiguity, contextual dependence, and non-commutativity of mental operations. Participants consistently reported that QPT better models real-world reasoning tasks where classical logic collapses, capturing the fluid and context-sensitive nature of human judgment. Conversely, while CBM remains effective in structured, low-uncertainty scenarios, it fails to accommodate superposition and interference effects inherent in human cognition. Unique Contribution to Theory, Practice, and Policy (Recommendations): The study contributes theoretically by demonstrating how quantum probabilistic models expand existing theories of bounded rationality and probabilistic reasoning in cognitive science. Practically, it encourages interdisciplinary collaboration between cognitive scientists, AI researchers, and philosophers to refine decision models that mirror human intuition more closely. Policy-wise, the findings support the integration of quantum-inspired approaches in the design of intelligent decision-support systems and cognitive architectures. The study recommends continued empirical validation of QPT within applied domains—such as behavioral economics, machine learning, and cognitive modeling—to strengthen its predictive and explanatory robustness.
Quantum interference effects play a fundamental role in social decision-making, offering a novel perspective beyond classical decision theories. This study explores the theoretical foundations of quantum decision-making, emphasizing the role of quantum probability in explaining cognitive biases, preference reversals, and decision anomalies. The research presents a quantum probability-based decision model and contrasts it with classical probability models. Through theoretical modeling and experimental design, we demonstrate how quantum interference alters decision probabilities and impacts group decision dynamics. The study further examines the applications of quantum decision theory in game theory, policy-making, financial markets, and artificial intelligence. Our findings suggest that quantum probability provides a more comprehensive and realistic framework for understanding human decision-making processes. Future research should focus on empirical validation, interdisciplinary integration, and the application of quantum computing to social decision modeling.