The Colour Space $C^3$ from Borromean Inseparability: A Superselection Proof
G Y Li
Abstract
The companion paper~su3_paper proved that eight Borromean rolling generators on a three-dimensional colour space C^3 satisfy the su(3) commutation relations exactly, but left as Conjecture~3.4 the proof that Borromean topological inseparability forces the state space to be C^3 rather than the full eight-dimensional tensor product C^2^2^2. This paper proves that conjecture. The argument has three steps. First, Borromean inseparability (Theorem~5.2 of~borromean_paper) implies a superselection rule: the individual chirality s_i\{+,-\} of each constituent knot is not a physical observable, because measuring it would require coupling locally to one knot in isolation, which constitutes an admissible splitting and thus costs divergent energy. Second, the total chirality Q = s_1+s_2+s_3 is observable (globally, without separation) and generates four superselection sectors of dimensions 1, 3, 3, 1 --- the orbit structure of S_3 acting on \{+,-\}^3, computed by direct enumeration. Third, the colour-charged sector is the unique three-dimensional sector V_2 = span\{|{++-}, |{+-+}, |{-++}\}, in which exactly one knot carries the minority chirality and thereby acquires a definite colour identity. This sector is isomorphic to C^3, with basis vectors identified as the three colour states |r, |g, |b. Combined with~su3_paper, this completes the proof that the gauge algebra of the Borromean vortex-knot system is su(3), unconditionally within the vortex-knot framework. One step retains a physically natural but technically unformalized assumption: that ``coupling an apparatus to one knot alone'' is equivalent to an admissible splitting in the sense of Definition~5.1 of~borromean_paper. Formalizing this within the vortex-knot measurement theory is identified as the remaining open problem. Keywords: colour space; superselection rule; Borromean rings; C^3; su(3); vortex-knot; topological inseparability; gauge group; quark confinement