International Conference on Machine Intelligence and Smart Innovation (ICMISI)
Benchmarking Quantum and Classical Solvers for the 1D Burgers' Equation: QTN, HSE, and PINN
Vanshaj Kerni, A H Helmi Ahmed, Syed Ali Asghar
Abstract
We present a comprehensive benchmarking of quantum-inspired, quantum native, and deep learning algorithms against classical baselines for solving the 1D viscous Burgers equation in a shock-dominated regime. We compared the Quantum Tensor Networks (QTN), the Hydrodynamic Schrödinger Equation (HSE), and Physics Informed Neural Networks (PINN) against classical GMRES and spectral solvers. Evaluated the results on accuracy, runtime scaling, and hardware resource overhead across spatial resolutions ranging from$N=4$to$N=128$, our results show a hierarchy in solver performance. The QTN exhibits precision with an$L_{2}$error$\sim 10^{-7}$and exhibits near constant runtime scaling. In the HSE algorithm, while the finite difference HSE remains robust, the spectral HSE method exhibits catastrophic numerical instability at high resolutions, diverging significantly at$N=128$due to the prohibitive circuit depth overhead of global quantum operators. PINNs offer a flexible, mesh-free framework; the standard implementation suffers from severe spectral bias and remains constrained to lower accuracy tiers with$L_{2}$errors near${10}^{-1}$. We also observed that advanced architectures, like PirateNets, though outperforms standard PINNs, they still exhibit a notable performance lag in absolute$L_{2}$error compared to the QTN implementation for smaller qubit numbers. Ultimately, this study demonstrates that while quantum and neural paradigms offer profound representational advantages for low-resolution or specialised geometries, they do not currently yield a strict computational advantage over mature classical fluid dynamics solvers without the advent of fault-tolerant hardware or significant algorithmic breakthroughs in nonlinear processing.