Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Superconductivity

Fabrication and electrothermal analysis of multilayer NAW superconducting nanowires

Fei Zhou, Liang Ma, Q Chen, Wenlei Yin, Zhang Mengfan, Huipeng Xia, Rui Yin, Hao Wang, Labao Zhang, Peiheng Wu

Published Jul 4, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Superconducting nanowire geometry has been widely adopted in single-photon detectors. However, its commonly used planar process limits the improvement of performance and the expansion of functionality. In this study, a three-layer stacked superconducting nanowire detectors and its corresponding fabrication process are proposed and implemented. The superconducting layers are composed of nitrogen-doped amorphous tungsten (NAW), whereas the dielectric layers are made of Nb 5 N 6 . Optimized precise etching control and “overhang” electrode filling were applied to achieve high-precision interlayer interconnection and uniform device fabrication. The experimental results show that the three-layer structure results in a critical current ( I c ) of 7.2 μA, which is approximately three times greater than that of a single-layer structure, along with a 2.7× enhancement in the peak response, a 57% reduction in the pulse width (full width at half maximum), and a 2.2× improvement in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Three distinct saturation plateaus observed in the photon count rate–bias current curve confirm the interlayer thermal coupling mechanism, which is consistent with the derived n-layer thermal model. This work provides a structural paradigm and scalable fabrication process for high-performance superconducting nanowire detector arrays, offering promising prospects for advanced quantum information processing and integrated photonic quantum technologies.

DOI
10.1016/j.supcon.2026.100274

Related papers

Photon counting statistics of superconducting single-photon detectors made of a three-layer WSi film

Irina Florya, Yu. P. Korneeva, M. Yu. Mikhaĭlov +3 more

Superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPD) are used in quantum optics when record-breaking time resolution, high speed, and exceptionally low levels of dark counts (false readings) are required. Their detection efficiency is limited, however, by the absorption coefficient of the ultrathin superconducting film for the detected radiation. One possible way of increasing the detector absorption without limiting its broadband response is to make a detector in the form of several vertically stacked layers and connect them in parallel. For the first time we have studied single-photon detection in a multilayer structure consisting of three superconducting layers of amorphous tungsten silicide (WSi) separated by thin layers of amorphous silicon. Two operating modes of the detector are illustrated: an avalanche regime and an arm-trigger regime. A shift in these modes occurs at currents of ∼0.5–0.6 times the critical current of the detector.

Low Temperature Physics•Mar 1, 2018•9 citations

Engineering superconducting single-photon detectors for quantum technologies

Shuyu Dong

Superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPDs) are renowned for their high detection efficiency, low dark count rate, and fast timing resolution, which have emerged as an essential device in quantum technologies, including quantum computing and communication, which also significantly benefits classical applications such as deep-space communication, neuromorphic computing, and light detection and ranging (LiDAR). However, designing and customizing SNSPD into versatile functionalities to satisfy these intensive requirements poses significant challenges, including thin-film deposition, nanofabrication, electrical integration, and light delivery strategies. While prior work has typically optimized individual steps – such as fabrication or characterization – there is a lack of reported systematic, integrated frameworks that span all stages from device design to performance benchmarking. This gap hinders broader adoption of the technology across scientific and industrial communities and limits the rigorous exploration of advanced detection concepts. This thesis aims to establish an end-to-end workflow for the customizable fabrication and comprehensive characterization of superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors, and to demonstrate that such a platform is essential for the investigation of diverse single-photon detection architectures. It begins with the optimization of NbTiN thin-film deposition utilizing an ultrahigh vacuum sputtering system. By systematically identifying and optimizing key deposition parameters, we achieve NbTiN films with targeted superconducting properties along with high uniformity and reproducibility. This fast and reliable workflow establishes a solid foundation for detector fabrication and provides instructions for flexible control over film properties. Furthermore, effective nanofabrication protocols for the high-quality SNSPDs were elaborated, along with the specialized cryogenic packaging techniques for reliable electrical and optical integration. The achieved devices demonstrated performance metrics comparable to commercial systems. The implementation of this full fabrication—characterization cycle also enabled flexible exploration of advanced detector architectures. For example, we investigated superconducting microbridge single-photon detectors (SMSPDs) as a complementary platform, demonstrating a fivefold enhancement in signal-to-noise ratio and a tenfold reduction in recovery time relative to conventional SNSPDs. These results provide quantitative insight into detector design trade-offs. Within this framework, photon-number-resolving (PNR) detection using SNSPDs was further investigated as an essential function for advanced quantum and classical applications. We presented innovative detector architectures—interleaved multi-pixel arrays and multilayer coherent absorption structures—to overcome limitations inherent in conventional multiplexing methods, such as nonuniform detection, temporal degradation, and crosstalk. An interleaved multi-pixel SNSPD array with up to four-photon resolution was achieved with uniform detection, as well as a multilayer architecture based on coherent absorption with uniform and near-unity absorption efficiency. Importantly, a theoretical comparison between these two architectures was conducted to evaluate their absorption efficiency and PNR performance, offering insights into structural optimization and device scalability for advanced PNR detectors. Overall, this thesis establishes a fully in-house SNSPD fabrication and characterization capability, providing a robust foundation for the development, customization, and evaluation of high-performance superconducting single-photon detectors. This platform enables reproducible design optimization, quantitative performance benchmarking, and systematic exploration of detector architectures. By integrating fabrication, characterization, and architectural innovation within a consistent workflow, it facilitates both fundamental investigation and application-driven advancement of single-photon detection technologies in our laboratory and the broader research community in Singapore.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Superconducting nanowire avalanche photodetectors

Sae Woo Nam, Brice Calkins, T. Gerritts +9 more

Superconducting devices offer the potential to perform at speeds and detection efficiencies higher than what is possible using conventional technologies (such as semiconducting avalanche photodiodes and photomultiplier tubs) for wavelengths from the ultraviolet to the mid-infrared. As a result, there has been increasing interest in using superconducting optical photon detectors in a variety of applications. There has been significant progress in using these types of detectors in areas of basic research such as quantum information science and quantum optics. These applications require detectors that have extremely low dark count rates, high count rates, and high quantum efficiency. I will begin by describing some of our earlier work on superconducting Transition-Edge Sensor (TES). In particular, I will describe some of the engineering involved in the cryogenic, electrical, and optical packaging so that these devices can be easily coupled into fiber-based optics. I will also describe our recent work on developing superconducting nanowire single photon detectors (SNSPD or SSPD). An SNSPD is an ultra-thin, ultra-narrow (nm scale) superconducting meander that is current biased just below its critical current density. When one or more photon is absorbed, a hot spot is formed that causes the superconductor to develop a resistance and consequently a voltage pulse. At NIST and JPL, we have been developing nanowire detectors using an amorphous alloy of tungsten-silicide. We will describe to construct systems using tungsten-silicide nanowires to achieve high detection efficiency (>90% at 1550nm). I will also describe our work to improve the performance of the device by fabricating multiple nanowires in an electrically parallel structure to implement a superconducting nanowire avalanche photodiode (SNAP)[1]. One example of this type of detector is shown in Fig 1. In this case, there are two tungsten silicide layers separated by a dielectric layer to optimize detection of light for any polarization[2]. In addition, progress on other types of SNAP detectors will be described to increase the signal size from a single photon, reduce the recovery time of the device, and to improve the jitter.

IEEE Photonics Conference•Sep 1, 2013•4 citations

Performances of NbTiN superconducting nanowire single photon detector

Shigehito Miki, Taro Yamashita, Hirotaka Terai +1 more

We present high performance fiber-coupled niobium titanium nitride superconducting nanowire single photon detectors fabricated on thermally oxidized silicon substrates. By applying a double sided cavity structure, simulated absorptance in the nanowire meander reached 97% at 1550 nm wavelength. The fabricated device showed a system detection efficiency (DE) of 74% at 1550 nm, dark count rate of 100 c/s, and a full width at half maximum timing jitter of 68 ps under a bias current of 18.0 μA with a practical Gifford-McMahon cryocooler system.

IEEE International Superconductive Electronics Conference (ISEC)•Jul 1, 2013•1 citation

Single-photon and photon-number-resolving detectors based on superconducting nanowires

Francesco Marsili

Nanowire superconducting single photon detectors (SSPDs) [1] are characterized by very high sensitivity in the near infrared (detection efficiency η up to 30%, for a dark count rate DK of few Hz), speed (up to ∼1 GHz repetition rate) and time resolution (jitter of 20 ps full width at half maximum, FWHM). They can be operated at temperatures near 4 K, so they can be packaged in cryogenic dipsticks or cryogen-free refrigerators. These features make SSPDs the most promising detectors for telecom-wavelength single-photon counting applications. The basic structure of an SSPD is a narrow (w=50 to 120 nm), thin (th∼4-10 nm) NbN superconducting nanowire folded in a meander pattern. The typical detector active area (i.e. the size of the pixel) is Ad=10 × 10 µm2 (which allows an efficient coupling with the core of optical fibers at telecom wavelengths) with filling factor (f, the ratio of the area occupied by the superconducting meander to the device total area) ranging from 40% to 60%. The meanders are embedded in a 50 Ω coplanar transmission line. At present, the SSPD detection efficiency is limited by its absorbance (α, the ratio of the number of photons absorbed in the nanowire to the number of incident photons on the device active area). Indeed, it has been shown that in the classic front-illumination configuration α cannot exceed 30%. Our approach to increase α consists in integrating SSPDs with advanced optical structures such as distributed Bragg reflectors (DBRs) and optical waveguides. This requires to transfer the challenging SSPD technology (i.e. the deposition of high-quality few-nm thick NbN films and the nano-patterning by electron beam lithography, EBL) from the usual comfortable substrates, i.e. sapphire and MgO, which are known to allow the deposition of few-nm thick NbN films of excellent quality, to an optical substrate like GaAs, on which DBRs and waveguides can be easily obtained. Our first task was then to optimize a process for the deposition of high-quality few-nm thick NbN films on GaAs and AlAs/GaAs-based DBRs. Because of the requirement of compatibility with GaAs, the substrate temperature used for the depositions is 400°C, in order to prevent As evaporation. As GaAs and DBRs are highly mismatched substrates, the deposition parameters were first optimized with respect to the superconducting properties of NbN films on MgO substrates, which allow the growth of high crystal quality NbN films at low temperature. This made easier to separate the influence of stoichiometry from that of microstructure. The optimized deposition parameters were then used to grow NbN films on GaAs and DBRs, under the reasonable assumption (later checked and confirmed) that changing the substrate would not produce a change in film stoichiometry, but only in its microstructure. NbN films ranging from 150nm to 3nm in thickness were then deposited on epitaxial-quality single crystal MgO, GaAs and DBRs structures. The deposition technique is the current controlled DC magnetron sputtering (planar, circular, balanced configuration) of Nb in an Ar + N2 plasma. NbN films deposited on MgO exhibit superconducting critical temperature ΤC=10 Κ, superconducting transition width ΔΤC=0.8 Κ and residual resistivity ratio RRR=R(20K)/R(300K)=0.8 for th=4 nm, which are state of the art values, proof of the excellent quality of our low-temperature deposition process. The quality of films deposited on GaAs and on DBRs is lower than that of NbN deposited on MgO, as for any thickness they systematically exhibit higher ΔΤC and lower ΤC and RRR. However, 5.5 nm-thick NbN films on GaAs still exhibit ΤC=10.7 Κ, ΔΤC=1.1 Κ and RRR=0.7, which compares with 4.5 nm thick films on MgO, making them suitable for device fabrication. To our knowledge, the growth of such high quality thin NbN films on GaAs and DBRs, has never been reported in literature. The degradation of the superconducting properties exhibited by NbN films on GaAs and DBRs was attributed to a highly defected microstructure, due both to a higher lattice misfit between NbN and GaAs and to a poorer quality of the substrate surface. Encouraging preliminary results show that the quality of these films can be improved either cleaning the GaAs/DBR substrate surface more effectively or adding an MgO buffer layer. SSPDs were fabricated on thin NbN films (th=3-7 nm) deposited under optimal conditions on MgO and GaAs by EBL and reactive ion etching. The geometrical parameters of our detectors are: Ad=5×5 µm2, w=60-200 nm, f=40%-60%. The devices were then characterized both electrically and optically. I-V curves of test structures were measured, from which it was possible to deduce important physical parameters used as figures of merit to estimate the superconducting properties of the nanowires, or for the design and the simulation of the devices. The quality of the devices fabricated on GaAs is poorer than those on MgO, most likely due to the lower quality of NbN films deposited on GaAs and to issues related to the EBL nano-patterning step. Measurements of η and of DK as a function of the bias current were performed on SSPDs fabricated on MgO and GaAs. The best performance was exhibited by a w=100 nm, f=40%, th=4 nm meander, showing η=20% and noise equivalent power NEP=10-16 W/Hz1/2 (at λ=1.3 µm and T=4.2 K), which are state of the art values. This result showed for the first time that high performance NbN SSPDs can be realized on a different substrate and from a deposition process at lower temperature than previously reported. High detection efficiencies could not be measured with SSPDs fabricated on GaAs, but it should be noted that at present only first-generation devices (fabricated on GaAs substrates of poor surface quality) have been tested. Better results are expected from devices fabricated on the improved NbN films grown on clean or MgO-buffered GaAs substrates. Although SSPDs on MgO have shown high detection efficiency, the fabrication yield of high performance detectors has to be improved. Variations of the critical current along a nanowire are responsible for the wide distribution in efficiency values of nominally identical SSPDs. In order to understand the physical origin of the nanowire constrictions (i.e. regions of suppressed superconductivity) we performed a spatially-resolved characterization of η of a long straight nanowire, followed by a high resolution SEM (scanning electron microscope) scan on its whole length. Two types of inhomogeneities were evidenced, corresponding to localized efficiency dips and peaks. The peaks likely correspond to constrictions. SEM observations did not evidence any width narrowing at the position of the efficiency peaks, which suggests that constrictions might be due to thickness or quality inhomogeneities of the film occurring during the film deposition or later in the process. On the other hand, the efficiency dips have been correlated with lithography problems discovered on SEM images. Finally, a new photon number resolving detector, the Parallel Nanowire Detector (PND), has been demonstrated, which significantly outperforms existing approaches in terms of sensitivity, speed and multiplication noise in the telecommunication wavelength range. In particular, it provides a repetition rate (80 MHz) three orders of magnitude larger than any existing detector at telecom wavelength, and a sensitivity (NEP=4.2×10-18 W/Hz1/2) one-two orders of magnitude better, with the exception of transition-edge sensors (which require a much lower operating temperature). An electrical equivalent model of the device was developed in order to study its operation. The modeling predicts a physical limit to the reset time of the PND, which is lower than initially estimated. Furthermore, the figures of merit of the device performance in terms of efficiency, speed and sensitivity were defined and their dependency on the design parameters analyzed. Additionally, we developed modeling tools to fully characterize the device and an algorithm to estimate the photon number statistics of an unknown light using the PND. The reconstruction proved to be successful only for low photon fluxes, most likely due to the limited counting capability and the poor calibration of the detector. The PND, with its high repetition rate and high sensitivity, is then suitable for measuring an unknown photon number probability distribution assuming accurate calibration and sufficient counting capability. ______________________________[1] G. N. Gol'tsman, O. Okunev, G. Chulkova, A. Lipatov, A. Semenov, K. Smirnov, B. Voronov, A. Dzardanov, C. Williams, and R. Sobolewski, Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 705 (2001).

•Jan 1, 2009•4 citations

Bias sputtered NbN and superconducting nanowire devices

Andrew E. Dane, Adam N. McCaughan, Di Zhu +6 more

Superconducting nanowire single photon detectors (SNSPDs) promise to combine near-unity quantum efficiency with >100 megacounts per second rates, picosecond timing jitter, and sensitivity ranging from x-ray to mid-infrared wavelengths. However, this promise is not yet fulfilled, as superior performance in all metrics is yet to be combined into one device. The highest single-pixel detection efficiency and the widest bias windows for saturated quantum efficiency have been achieved in SNSPDs based on amorphous materials, while the lowest timing jitter and highest counting rates were demonstrated in devices made from polycrystalline materials. Broadly speaking, the amorphous superconductors that have been used to make SNSPDs have higher resistivities and lower critical temperature (Tc) values than typical polycrystalline materials. Here, we demonstrate a method of preparing niobium nitride (NbN) that has lower-than-typical superconducting transition temperature and higher-than-typical resistivity. As we will show, NbN deposited onto unheated SiO2 has a low Tc and high resistivity but is too rough for fabricating unconstricted nanowires, and Tc is too low to yield SNSPDs that can operate well at liquid helium temperatures. By adding a 50 W RF bias to the substrate holder during sputtering, the Tc of the unheated NbN films was increased by up to 73%, and the roughness was substantially reduced. After optimizing the deposition for nitrogen flow rates, we obtained 5 nm thick NbN films with a Tc of 7.8 K and a resistivity of 253 μΩ cm. We used this bias sputtered room temperature NbN to fabricate SNSPDs. Measurements were performed at 2.5 K using 1550 nm light. Photon count rates appeared to saturate at bias currents approaching the critical current, indicating that the device's quantum efficiency was approaching unity. We measured a single-ended timing jitter of 38 ps. The optical coupling to these devices was not optimized; however, integration with front-side optical structures to improve absorption should be straightforward. This material preparation was further used to fabricate nanocryotrons and a large-area imager device, reported elsewhere. The simplicity of the preparation and promising device performance should enable future high-performance devices.

Applied Physics Letters•Sep 18, 2017•67 citations
Superconducting nanowire geometry has been widely adopted in single-photon detectors. However, its commonly used planar process limits the improvement of performance and the expansion of functionality. In this study, a three-layer stacked superconducting nanowire detectors and its corresponding fabrication process are proposed and implemented. The superconducting layers are composed of nitrogen-doped amorphous tungsten (NAW), whereas the dielectric layers are made of Nb 5 N 6 . Optimized precise etching control and “overhang” electrode filling were applied to achieve high-precision interlayer interconnection and uniform device fabrication. The experimental results show that the three-layer structure results in a critical current ( I c ) of 7.2 μA, which is approximately three times greater than that of a single-layer structure, along with a 2.7× enhancement in the peak response, a 57% reduction in the pulse width (full width at half maximum), and a 2.2× improvement in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Three distinct saturation plateaus observed in the photon count rate–bias current curve confirm the interlayer thermal coupling mechanism, which is consistent with the derived n-layer thermal model. This work provides a structural paradigm and scalable fabrication process for high-performance superconducting nanowire detector arrays, offering promising prospects for advanced quantum information processing and integrated photonic quantum technologies.
Superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPD) are used in quantum optics when record-breaking time resolution, high speed, and exceptionally low levels of dark counts (false readings) are required. Their detection efficiency is limited, however, by the absorption coefficient of the ultrathin superconducting film for the detected radiation. One possible way of increasing the detector absorption without limiting its broadband response is to make a detector in the form of several vertically stacked layers and connect them in parallel. For the first time we have studied single-photon detection in a multilayer structure consisting of three superconducting layers of amorphous tungsten silicide (WSi) separated by thin layers of amorphous silicon. Two operating modes of the detector are illustrated: an avalanche regime and an arm-trigger regime. A shift in these modes occurs at currents of ∼0.5–0.6 times the critical current of the detector.
Superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPDs) are renowned for their high detection efficiency, low dark count rate, and fast timing resolution, which have emerged as an essential device in quantum technologies, including quantum computing and communication, which also significantly benefits classical applications such as deep-space communication, neuromorphic computing, and light detection and ranging (LiDAR). However, designing and customizing SNSPD into versatile functionalities to satisfy these intensive requirements poses significant challenges, including thin-film deposition, nanofabrication, electrical integration, and light delivery strategies. While prior work has typically optimized individual steps – such as fabrication or characterization – there is a lack of reported systematic, integrated frameworks that span all stages from device design to performance benchmarking. This gap hinders broader adoption of the technology across scientific and industrial communities and limits the rigorous exploration of advanced detection concepts. This thesis aims to establish an end-to-end workflow for the customizable fabrication and comprehensive characterization of superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors, and to demonstrate that such a platform is essential for the investigation of diverse single-photon detection architectures. It begins with the optimization of NbTiN thin-film deposition utilizing an ultrahigh vacuum sputtering system. By systematically identifying and optimizing key deposition parameters, we achieve NbTiN films with targeted superconducting properties along with high uniformity and reproducibility. This fast and reliable workflow establishes a solid foundation for detector fabrication and provides instructions for flexible control over film properties. Furthermore, effective nanofabrication protocols for the high-quality SNSPDs were elaborated, along with the specialized cryogenic packaging techniques for reliable electrical and optical integration. The achieved devices demonstrated performance metrics comparable to commercial systems. The implementation of this full fabrication—characterization cycle also enabled flexible exploration of advanced detector architectures. For example, we investigated superconducting microbridge single-photon detectors (SMSPDs) as a complementary platform, demonstrating a fivefold enhancement in signal-to-noise ratio and a tenfold reduction in recovery time relative to conventional SNSPDs. These results provide quantitative insight into detector design trade-offs. Within this framework, photon-number-resolving (PNR) detection using SNSPDs was further investigated as an essential function for advanced quantum and classical applications. We presented innovative detector architectures—interleaved multi-pixel arrays and multilayer coherent absorption structures—to overcome limitations inherent in conventional multiplexing methods, such as nonuniform detection, temporal degradation, and crosstalk. An interleaved multi-pixel SNSPD array with up to four-photon resolution was achieved with uniform detection, as well as a multilayer architecture based on coherent absorption with uniform and near-unity absorption efficiency. Importantly, a theoretical comparison between these two architectures was conducted to evaluate their absorption efficiency and PNR performance, offering insights into structural optimization and device scalability for advanced PNR detectors. Overall, this thesis establishes a fully in-house SNSPD fabrication and characterization capability, providing a robust foundation for the development, customization, and evaluation of high-performance superconducting single-photon detectors. This platform enables reproducible design optimization, quantitative performance benchmarking, and systematic exploration of detector architectures. By integrating fabrication, characterization, and architectural innovation within a consistent workflow, it facilitates both fundamental investigation and application-driven advancement of single-photon detection technologies in our laboratory and the broader research community in Singapore.
Superconducting devices offer the potential to perform at speeds and detection efficiencies higher than what is possible using conventional technologies (such as semiconducting avalanche photodiodes and photomultiplier tubs) for wavelengths from the ultraviolet to the mid-infrared. As a result, there has been increasing interest in using superconducting optical photon detectors in a variety of applications. There has been significant progress in using these types of detectors in areas of basic research such as quantum information science and quantum optics. These applications require detectors that have extremely low dark count rates, high count rates, and high quantum efficiency. I will begin by describing some of our earlier work on superconducting Transition-Edge Sensor (TES). In particular, I will describe some of the engineering involved in the cryogenic, electrical, and optical packaging so that these devices can be easily coupled into fiber-based optics. I will also describe our recent work on developing superconducting nanowire single photon detectors (SNSPD or SSPD). An SNSPD is an ultra-thin, ultra-narrow (nm scale) superconducting meander that is current biased just below its critical current density. When one or more photon is absorbed, a hot spot is formed that causes the superconductor to develop a resistance and consequently a voltage pulse. At NIST and JPL, we have been developing nanowire detectors using an amorphous alloy of tungsten-silicide. We will describe to construct systems using tungsten-silicide nanowires to achieve high detection efficiency (>90% at 1550nm). I will also describe our work to improve the performance of the device by fabricating multiple nanowires in an electrically parallel structure to implement a superconducting nanowire avalanche photodiode (SNAP)[1]. One example of this type of detector is shown in Fig 1. In this case, there are two tungsten silicide layers separated by a dielectric layer to optimize detection of light for any polarization[2]. In addition, progress on other types of SNAP detectors will be described to increase the signal size from a single photon, reduce the recovery time of the device, and to improve the jitter.
We present high performance fiber-coupled niobium titanium nitride superconducting nanowire single photon detectors fabricated on thermally oxidized silicon substrates. By applying a double sided cavity structure, simulated absorptance in the nanowire meander reached 97% at 1550 nm wavelength. The fabricated device showed a system detection efficiency (DE) of 74% at 1550 nm, dark count rate of 100 c/s, and a full width at half maximum timing jitter of 68 ps under a bias current of 18.0 μA with a practical Gifford-McMahon cryocooler system.
Nanowire superconducting single photon detectors (SSPDs) [1] are characterized by very high sensitivity in the near infrared (detection efficiency η up to 30%, for a dark count rate DK of few Hz), speed (up to ∼1 GHz repetition rate) and time resolution (jitter of 20 ps full width at half maximum, FWHM). They can be operated at temperatures near 4 K, so they can be packaged in cryogenic dipsticks or cryogen-free refrigerators. These features make SSPDs the most promising detectors for telecom-wavelength single-photon counting applications. The basic structure of an SSPD is a narrow (w=50 to 120 nm), thin (th∼4-10 nm) NbN superconducting nanowire folded in a meander pattern. The typical detector active area (i.e. the size of the pixel) is Ad=10 × 10 µm2 (which allows an efficient coupling with the core of optical fibers at telecom wavelengths) with filling factor (f, the ratio of the area occupied by the superconducting meander to the device total area) ranging from 40% to 60%. The meanders are embedded in a 50 Ω coplanar transmission line. At present, the SSPD detection efficiency is limited by its absorbance (α, the ratio of the number of photons absorbed in the nanowire to the number of incident photons on the device active area). Indeed, it has been shown that in the classic front-illumination configuration α cannot exceed 30%. Our approach to increase α consists in integrating SSPDs with advanced optical structures such as distributed Bragg reflectors (DBRs) and optical waveguides. This requires to transfer the challenging SSPD technology (i.e. the deposition of high-quality few-nm thick NbN films and the nano-patterning by electron beam lithography, EBL) from the usual comfortable substrates, i.e. sapphire and MgO, which are known to allow the deposition of few-nm thick NbN films of excellent quality, to an optical substrate like GaAs, on which DBRs and waveguides can be easily obtained. Our first task was then to optimize a process for the deposition of high-quality few-nm thick NbN films on GaAs and AlAs/GaAs-based DBRs. Because of the requirement of compatibility with GaAs, the substrate temperature used for the depositions is 400°C, in order to prevent As evaporation. As GaAs and DBRs are highly mismatched substrates, the deposition parameters were first optimized with respect to the superconducting properties of NbN films on MgO substrates, which allow the growth of high crystal quality NbN films at low temperature. This made easier to separate the influence of stoichiometry from that of microstructure. The optimized deposition parameters were then used to grow NbN films on GaAs and DBRs, under the reasonable assumption (later checked and confirmed) that changing the substrate would not produce a change in film stoichiometry, but only in its microstructure. NbN films ranging from 150nm to 3nm in thickness were then deposited on epitaxial-quality single crystal MgO, GaAs and DBRs structures. The deposition technique is the current controlled DC magnetron sputtering (planar, circular, balanced configuration) of Nb in an Ar + N2 plasma. NbN films deposited on MgO exhibit superconducting critical temperature ΤC=10 Κ, superconducting transition width ΔΤC=0.8 Κ and residual resistivity ratio RRR=R(20K)/R(300K)=0.8 for th=4 nm, which are state of the art values, proof of the excellent quality of our low-temperature deposition process. The quality of films deposited on GaAs and on DBRs is lower than that of NbN deposited on MgO, as for any thickness they systematically exhibit higher ΔΤC and lower ΤC and RRR. However, 5.5 nm-thick NbN films on GaAs still exhibit ΤC=10.7 Κ, ΔΤC=1.1 Κ and RRR=0.7, which compares with 4.5 nm thick films on MgO, making them suitable for device fabrication. To our knowledge, the growth of such high quality thin NbN films on GaAs and DBRs, has never been reported in literature. The degradation of the superconducting properties exhibited by NbN films on GaAs and DBRs was attributed to a highly defected microstructure, due both to a higher lattice misfit between NbN and GaAs and to a poorer quality of the substrate surface. Encouraging preliminary results show that the quality of these films can be improved either cleaning the GaAs/DBR substrate surface more effectively or adding an MgO buffer layer. SSPDs were fabricated on thin NbN films (th=3-7 nm) deposited under optimal conditions on MgO and GaAs by EBL and reactive ion etching. The geometrical parameters of our detectors are: Ad=5×5 µm2, w=60-200 nm, f=40%-60%. The devices were then characterized both electrically and optically. I-V curves of test structures were measured, from which it was possible to deduce important physical parameters used as figures of merit to estimate the superconducting properties of the nanowires, or for the design and the simulation of the devices. The quality of the devices fabricated on GaAs is poorer than those on MgO, most likely due to the lower quality of NbN films deposited on GaAs and to issues related to the EBL nano-patterning step. Measurements of η and of DK as a function of the bias current were performed on SSPDs fabricated on MgO and GaAs. The best performance was exhibited by a w=100 nm, f=40%, th=4 nm meander, showing η=20% and noise equivalent power NEP=10-16 W/Hz1/2 (at λ=1.3 µm and T=4.2 K), which are state of the art values. This result showed for the first time that high performance NbN SSPDs can be realized on a different substrate and from a deposition process at lower temperature than previously reported. High detection efficiencies could not be measured with SSPDs fabricated on GaAs, but it should be noted that at present only first-generation devices (fabricated on GaAs substrates of poor surface quality) have been tested. Better results are expected from devices fabricated on the improved NbN films grown on clean or MgO-buffered GaAs substrates. Although SSPDs on MgO have shown high detection efficiency, the fabrication yield of high performance detectors has to be improved. Variations of the critical current along a nanowire are responsible for the wide distribution in efficiency values of nominally identical SSPDs. In order to understand the physical origin of the nanowire constrictions (i.e. regions of suppressed superconductivity) we performed a spatially-resolved characterization of η of a long straight nanowire, followed by a high resolution SEM (scanning electron microscope) scan on its whole length. Two types of inhomogeneities were evidenced, corresponding to localized efficiency dips and peaks. The peaks likely correspond to constrictions. SEM observations did not evidence any width narrowing at the position of the efficiency peaks, which suggests that constrictions might be due to thickness or quality inhomogeneities of the film occurring during the film deposition or later in the process. On the other hand, the efficiency dips have been correlated with lithography problems discovered on SEM images. Finally, a new photon number resolving detector, the Parallel Nanowire Detector (PND), has been demonstrated, which significantly outperforms existing approaches in terms of sensitivity, speed and multiplication noise in the telecommunication wavelength range. In particular, it provides a repetition rate (80 MHz) three orders of magnitude larger than any existing detector at telecom wavelength, and a sensitivity (NEP=4.2×10-18 W/Hz1/2) one-two orders of magnitude better, with the exception of transition-edge sensors (which require a much lower operating temperature). An electrical equivalent model of the device was developed in order to study its operation. The modeling predicts a physical limit to the reset time of the PND, which is lower than initially estimated. Furthermore, the figures of merit of the device performance in terms of efficiency, speed and sensitivity were defined and their dependency on the design parameters analyzed. Additionally, we developed modeling tools to fully characterize the device and an algorithm to estimate the photon number statistics of an unknown light using the PND. The reconstruction proved to be successful only for low photon fluxes, most likely due to the limited counting capability and the poor calibration of the detector. The PND, with its high repetition rate and high sensitivity, is then suitable for measuring an unknown photon number probability distribution assuming accurate calibration and sufficient counting capability. ______________________________[1] G. N. Gol'tsman, O. Okunev, G. Chulkova, A. Lipatov, A. Semenov, K. Smirnov, B. Voronov, A. Dzardanov, C. Williams, and R. Sobolewski, Appl. Phys. Lett. 79, 705 (2001).
Superconducting nanowire single photon detectors (SNSPDs) promise to combine near-unity quantum efficiency with >100 megacounts per second rates, picosecond timing jitter, and sensitivity ranging from x-ray to mid-infrared wavelengths. However, this promise is not yet fulfilled, as superior performance in all metrics is yet to be combined into one device. The highest single-pixel detection efficiency and the widest bias windows for saturated quantum efficiency have been achieved in SNSPDs based on amorphous materials, while the lowest timing jitter and highest counting rates were demonstrated in devices made from polycrystalline materials. Broadly speaking, the amorphous superconductors that have been used to make SNSPDs have higher resistivities and lower critical temperature (Tc) values than typical polycrystalline materials. Here, we demonstrate a method of preparing niobium nitride (NbN) that has lower-than-typical superconducting transition temperature and higher-than-typical resistivity. As we will show, NbN deposited onto unheated SiO2 has a low Tc and high resistivity but is too rough for fabricating unconstricted nanowires, and Tc is too low to yield SNSPDs that can operate well at liquid helium temperatures. By adding a 50 W RF bias to the substrate holder during sputtering, the Tc of the unheated NbN films was increased by up to 73%, and the roughness was substantially reduced. After optimizing the deposition for nitrogen flow rates, we obtained 5 nm thick NbN films with a Tc of 7.8 K and a resistivity of 253 μΩ cm. We used this bias sputtered room temperature NbN to fabricate SNSPDs. Measurements were performed at 2.5 K using 1550 nm light. Photon count rates appeared to saturate at bias currents approaching the critical current, indicating that the device's quantum efficiency was approaching unity. We measured a single-ended timing jitter of 38 ps. The optical coupling to these devices was not optimized; however, integration with front-side optical structures to improve absorption should be straightforward. This material preparation was further used to fabricate nanocryotrons and a large-area imager device, reported elsewhere. The simplicity of the preparation and promising device performance should enable future high-performance devices.