Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Observation as a Local View: Why Measurement Looks Irreversible from Inside the System

Eliezer Pala

Published Jun 22, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This essay talks about why measurement appears irreversible even though the quantum dynamics are reversible. Using an intuitive approach with a mental image, we see that the irreversible dynamics are a local view of the reversible global dynamics. The narrative does not require in-depth conceptual knowledge. It is offered as a supportive aid for building intuition about measurement and irreversibility in quantum physics.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20795338

Related papers

Information-Theoretic Equilibration: The Appearance of Irreversibility under Complex Quantum Dynamics

Cozmin Ududec, Nathan Wiebe, Joseph Emerson

The question of how irreversibility can emerge as a generic phenomenon when the underlying mechanical theory is reversible has been a long-standing fundamental problem for both classical and quantum mechanics. We describe a mechanism for the appearance of irreversibility that applies to coherent, isolated systems in a pure quantum state. This equilibration mechanism requires only an assumption of sufficiently complex internal dynamics and natural information-theoretic constraints arising from the infeasibility of collecting an astronomical amount of measurement data. Remarkably, we are able to prove that irreversibility can be understood as typical without assuming decoherence or restricting to coarse-grained observables, and hence occurs under distinct conditions and time scales from those implied by the usual decoherence point of view. We illustrate the effect numerically in several model systems and prove that the effect is typical under the standard random-matrix conjecture for complex quantum systems.

arXiv:1208.3419•Physical Review Letters•Aug 20, 2013•28 citations

Quantum reversibility is relative, or does a quantum measurement reset initial conditions?

Wojciech Hubert Zurek

I compare the role of the information in classical and quantum dynamics by examining the relation between information flows in measurements and the ability of observers to reverse evolutions. I show that in the Newtonian dynamics reversibility is unaffected by the observer's retention of the information about the measurement outcome. By contrast-even though quantum dynamics is unitary, hence, reversible-reversing quantum evolution that led to a measurement becomes, in principle, impossible for an observer who keeps the record of its outcome. Thus, quantum irreversibility can result from the information gain rather than just its loss-rather than just an increase of the (von Neumann) entropy. Recording of the outcome of the measurement resets, in effect, initial conditions within the observer's (branch of) the Universe. Nevertheless, I also show that the observer's friend-an agent who knows what measurement was successfully carried out and can confirm that the observer knows the outcome but resists his curiosity and does not find out the result-can, in principle, undo the measurement. This relativity of quantum reversibility sheds new light on the origin of the arrow of time and elucidates the role of information in classical and quantum physics. Quantum discord appears as a natural measure of the extent to which dissemination of information about the outcome affects the ability to reverse the measurement.This article is part of a discussion meeting issue 'Foundations of quantum mechanics and their impact on contemporary society'.

arXiv:1808.08598•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•May 28, 2018•16 citations

Quantum Measurement as Irreversible Interaction Events

Shinichiro Honda

The quantum measurement problem arises from a structural asymmetry in standard formulations of quantum mechanics: while unitary evolution is treated as fundamental, irreversible events are introduced only through ad hoc postulates. As a result, measurement, decoherence, and probability appear conceptually disconnected. In this work, we propose a minimal reformulation in which irreversible interaction events are taken as ontological primitives. An event is defined as a completely positive, trace-preserving map that is not equivalent to any unitary transformation. Unitary evolution emerges as an effective description valid between events. Within this framework, quantum measurement is not a special process but a particular class of irreversible events with outcome-resolving structure. The Born rule arises naturally from the statistical structure of event realizations, and environmental decoherence is reinterpreted as a high density of irreversible events. No collapse postulate, observer-dependent rule, or modification of quantum dynamics is required. This formulation provides a unified and physically grounded resolution of the measurement problem and establishes a conceptual foundation for event-based extensions connecting quantum theory with spacetime and gravity.

•Jan 21, 2026•0 citations

Quantum Measurements Are Reversible

Asher Peres

Traditionally, quantum measurements have been associated with irreversible transformations of pure states into mixtures. In this paper we show that this old hypothesis is redundant. A simple model is constructed in which the measuring process is described by a continuous unitary transformation of the state vector of the observed system and the apparatus. The final state is pure, but appears to be a mixture if we ignore the degrees of freedom of the apparatus. This property is most strikingly illustrated by reformulating the problem in the Heisenberg picture: The state vector is fixed, and the dynamical variables are changed by the measurement.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1974•31 citations

Complexity-Protected Irreversibility in Quantum Measurement

Marriam Naeem

We present a unitary and operational account of quantum measurement in which outcome irreversibility arises from computational complexity rather than fundamental nonunitarity. Measurement is modeled as a two-stage physical process. First, local interactions dynamically select a pointer basis in which stable classical records are formed via decoherence. Second, subsequent local scrambling dynamics distribute these records globally across a finite quantum memory register. Using explicit circuit constructions based on local random circuits that form approximate unitary k-designs, we show that measurement records are encoded in high-order nonlocal correlations. We prove that reversing such records requires quantum circuits of exponential depth, even allowing ε-approximate reconstruction. This establishes a quantitative complexity barrier rendering outcome reversal physically unrealizable despite global unitarity. We apply the framework to multi-register (Wigner-type) scenarios and show that no physically realizable operation can expose inconsistency between distinct register-relative descriptions. Finally, we prove a conditional no-go theorem excluding any global collapse mechanism compatible with unitary dynamics, locality, and computational feasibility. Measurement irreversibility is therefore shown to be an emergent, complexity-protected phenomenon within standard quantum mechanics.

•Jan 2, 2026•0 citations

Irreversibility and Quantum Measurement

Julio R. Gea-Banacloche

The role played by irreversible processes, at the microscopic scale, in several examples of quantum measurements is studied within a "minimally realist" interpretation of the quantum formalism introduced in a recent publication. The analysis extends and confirms the basic results of the earlier work: separation of the collapse and amplification phases of the measurement, and decoherence and collapse happening already as a consequence of irreversible microscopic processes at the level of the "probe" itself (typically an atom in the examples considered). Additionally, the proposed interpretation of the formalism is shown to be consistent with previous interpretations, and a case for true irreversibility in physics is argued in some detail.

Entropy•Sep 12, 2026•0 citations
This essay talks about why measurement appears irreversible even though the quantum dynamics are reversible. Using an intuitive approach with a mental image, we see that the irreversible dynamics are a local view of the reversible global dynamics. The narrative does not require in-depth conceptual knowledge. It is offered as a supportive aid for building intuition about measurement and irreversibility in quantum physics.
The question of how irreversibility can emerge as a generic phenomenon when the underlying mechanical theory is reversible has been a long-standing fundamental problem for both classical and quantum mechanics. We describe a mechanism for the appearance of irreversibility that applies to coherent, isolated systems in a pure quantum state. This equilibration mechanism requires only an assumption of sufficiently complex internal dynamics and natural information-theoretic constraints arising from the infeasibility of collecting an astronomical amount of measurement data. Remarkably, we are able to prove that irreversibility can be understood as typical without assuming decoherence or restricting to coarse-grained observables, and hence occurs under distinct conditions and time scales from those implied by the usual decoherence point of view. We illustrate the effect numerically in several model systems and prove that the effect is typical under the standard random-matrix conjecture for complex quantum systems.
I compare the role of the information in classical and quantum dynamics by examining the relation between information flows in measurements and the ability of observers to reverse evolutions. I show that in the Newtonian dynamics reversibility is unaffected by the observer's retention of the information about the measurement outcome. By contrast-even though quantum dynamics is unitary, hence, reversible-reversing quantum evolution that led to a measurement becomes, in principle, impossible for an observer who keeps the record of its outcome. Thus, quantum irreversibility can result from the information gain rather than just its loss-rather than just an increase of the (von Neumann) entropy. Recording of the outcome of the measurement resets, in effect, initial conditions within the observer's (branch of) the Universe. Nevertheless, I also show that the observer's friend-an agent who knows what measurement was successfully carried out and can confirm that the observer knows the outcome but resists his curiosity and does not find out the result-can, in principle, undo the measurement. This relativity of quantum reversibility sheds new light on the origin of the arrow of time and elucidates the role of information in classical and quantum physics. Quantum discord appears as a natural measure of the extent to which dissemination of information about the outcome affects the ability to reverse the measurement.This article is part of a discussion meeting issue 'Foundations of quantum mechanics and their impact on contemporary society'.
The quantum measurement problem arises from a structural asymmetry in standard formulations of quantum mechanics: while unitary evolution is treated as fundamental, irreversible events are introduced only through ad hoc postulates. As a result, measurement, decoherence, and probability appear conceptually disconnected. In this work, we propose a minimal reformulation in which irreversible interaction events are taken as ontological primitives. An event is defined as a completely positive, trace-preserving map that is not equivalent to any unitary transformation. Unitary evolution emerges as an effective description valid between events. Within this framework, quantum measurement is not a special process but a particular class of irreversible events with outcome-resolving structure. The Born rule arises naturally from the statistical structure of event realizations, and environmental decoherence is reinterpreted as a high density of irreversible events. No collapse postulate, observer-dependent rule, or modification of quantum dynamics is required. This formulation provides a unified and physically grounded resolution of the measurement problem and establishes a conceptual foundation for event-based extensions connecting quantum theory with spacetime and gravity.
Traditionally, quantum measurements have been associated with irreversible transformations of pure states into mixtures. In this paper we show that this old hypothesis is redundant. A simple model is constructed in which the measuring process is described by a continuous unitary transformation of the state vector of the observed system and the apparatus. The final state is pure, but appears to be a mixture if we ignore the degrees of freedom of the apparatus. This property is most strikingly illustrated by reformulating the problem in the Heisenberg picture: The state vector is fixed, and the dynamical variables are changed by the measurement.
We present a unitary and operational account of quantum measurement in which outcome irreversibility arises from computational complexity rather than fundamental nonunitarity. Measurement is modeled as a two-stage physical process. First, local interactions dynamically select a pointer basis in which stable classical records are formed via decoherence. Second, subsequent local scrambling dynamics distribute these records globally across a finite quantum memory register. Using explicit circuit constructions based on local random circuits that form approximate unitary k-designs, we show that measurement records are encoded in high-order nonlocal correlations. We prove that reversing such records requires quantum circuits of exponential depth, even allowing ε-approximate reconstruction. This establishes a quantitative complexity barrier rendering outcome reversal physically unrealizable despite global unitarity. We apply the framework to multi-register (Wigner-type) scenarios and show that no physically realizable operation can expose inconsistency between distinct register-relative descriptions. Finally, we prove a conditional no-go theorem excluding any global collapse mechanism compatible with unitary dynamics, locality, and computational feasibility. Measurement irreversibility is therefore shown to be an emergent, complexity-protected phenomenon within standard quantum mechanics.
The role played by irreversible processes, at the microscopic scale, in several examples of quantum measurements is studied within a "minimally realist" interpretation of the quantum formalism introduced in a recent publication. The analysis extends and confirms the basic results of the earlier work: separation of the collapse and amplification phases of the measurement, and decoherence and collapse happening already as a consequence of irreversible microscopic processes at the level of the "probe" itself (typically an atom in the examples considered). Additionally, the proposed interpretation of the formalism is shown to be consistent with previous interpretations, and a case for true irreversibility in physics is argued in some detail.