Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A remark on the quantum correlation function and the Pearson coefficient of classical projections

Roberto Pavani

Published Jun 13, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An elementary identity is noted: the quantum correlation E(a,b) = −cos(a−b) predicted for a singlet state is numerically identical to the Pearson correlation coefficient of two classical cosine projections sharing a common hidden angle. The question is posed whether this coincidence has structural significance. The connection to Fine's theorem (1982) on joint distributions and CHSH inequalities is discussed.

DOI
10.5281/zenodo.20676811

Related papers

Quantum entanglement and classical correlation have the same form

Arto Annila, Mårten K.F. Wikström

Abstract In agreement with the data, the quantum correlation between spins violates Bell’s inequality by following a cosine curve when one analyzer is rotated relative to the other. In contrast, the linear correlation attributed to hidden variables has never been observed. Besides these well-established facts, we show here that classical covariance, Pearson correlation, between spins projected as up or down on the analyzer axes also follows the cosine form hitherto uniquely ascribed to the quantum mechanical expectation value. The common cause for the classical correlation is the conservation of intrinsic angular momentum that aligns the two spins antiparallel at the breakup. Thus, as long as the spins retain their orientations relative to each other, the measurement of one spin in a chosen frame of reference also discloses the opposite orientation of the other in that frame. Realizing that classical correlation has the same functional form as quantum entanglement sheds light on the foundations of modern physics and quantum computing.

The European Physical Journal Plus•Jun 27, 2024•10 citations

Classical two-channel detector model reproducing quantum correlations in Bell experiments

Roberto Pavani

A study in inverse model identification. Using only pre-quantum physics (analogue mixer, low-pass filtering, Malus's law, Pearson correlation), we build a deterministic local coherent-detection model whose raw correlations are Bell-compliant (|S_raw| = √2/4). Pearson normalisation yields −cos(a−b), and the CHSH polynomial on these coefficients gives 2√2 (scale-invariant). This C_Pearson is not a Bell correlator and no Bell violation is claimed. The point: the value 2√2, taken from normalised correlation data alone (blind test), does not uniquely identify the generating mechanism — an explicit classical pre-image of the same data is exhibited. Bell-CHSH is used only as an extreme illustration.

•Jun 17, 2026•0 citations

Angular correlations of photons

Iwo Białynicki‐Birula, Zofia Białynicka-Birula

We study angular correlations of the radiation emitted by spatially extended sets of atoms. Such correlations result from the fact that the photons are identical quantum particles. We show that the symmetry (or the antisymmetry) alone of the wave function for identical, indistinguishable particles always leads to significant angular correlations and that in full agreement with our intuition, bosons tend to travel in the same direction while fermions tend to travel in opposite directions. In order to quantify these intuitive notions, we introduce---as a measure of angular correlations---the average value of the cosine of the angle between the directions of the momenta of two particles. The angular correlation coefficient is calculated for simple, model wave functions and the results are compared with those obtained from an exactly soluble model describing radiating harmonic oscillators. We find that even though the interaction modifies the exact values of the angular correlation coefficient, the gross features can be obtained from quantum statistics, i.e., from the symmetry of the many-photon wave functions. Moreover, the angular correlations as measured by the average cosine exhibit an almost universal character, at least for a small number of emitting atoms. Finally, we compare angular correlations obtained in quantum electrodynamics with the correlations resulting from the phenomenologically introduced randomness of the phases in the classical description of the electromagnetic field.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1990•7 citations

A Local Phase-Field Framework for Spin Entanglement Correlations

Doron Kwiat

We introduce a local phase-field framework for spin-entanglement correlations. In this framework, the relevant hidden variable is an internal scalar phase associated with each fermion and derived from two underlying real fields. The fields are assumed to evolve locally in ordinary spacetime. When a particle pair is produced at a common spacetime event, the pair acquires a shared phase-locking condition at creation; after separation, the two internal phases evolve independently and no nonlocal interaction is introduced. Spin measurements by Stern–Gerlach analyzers are modeled as local filtering operations. Each local response depends only on the internal phase carried by the particle and on the orientation of the local analyzer. The local response function A(α,λ) = cos(λ − 2α) is derived from the spinorial transformation law of the underlying real field pair and the projection geometry of the detector interaction; it is not a phenomenological ansatz. From these deterministic local responses we derive an analog correlator. The raw product moment of the continuous detector outputs evaluates to ⟨AB⟩ = −½ cos 2(α − β), which satisfies classical Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) bounds. After Pearson normalization—the operationally appropriate correlation measure for continuous analog detector outputs, justified by channel-contrast physics and scale invariance—the normalized correlator yields E(α,β) = −cos 2(α − β), matching the quantum singlet correlator in functional form. When this normalized correlator is inserted into the CHSH expression, it yields the numerical value 2√2. This result is a structural consequence of the reduced marginal variance of continuous response functions relative to the unit-variance dichotomic observables assumed in Bell’s derivation; it does not constitute a violation of Bell’s inequality. The model does not reproduce quantum singlet statistics at the level of binary detector outcomes, where the correlator takes a triangular rather than cosine form. The contribution is therefore ontological and conceptual rather than predictive. The framework preserves parameter independence and no-signaling throughout. It provides a concrete real-field ontology for spin correlations based on internal phase structure, and it demonstrates that the functional form of the quantum singlet correlation can be obtained from a strictly local deterministic description, provided that the detector responses are treated as continuous analog quantities and normalized accordingly. We compare the model with earlier phase-based approaches and discuss experimental configurations—including time-resolved and multi-stage Stern–Gerlach measurements—that could in principle probe the proposed internal-phase dynamics at the pre-registration level.

Quantum Reports•May 15, 2026•0 citations

The Relationship Between Classical and Quantum Correlation in Games

Adam M. Brandenburger

Quantum games have been argued to extend classical games (Eisert-Wilkens-Lewenstein [8, 1999], Meyer [18, 1999], and subsequent papers). Levine [17, 2005] has questioned this assertion. We offer what we believe to be the simplest expression of the disagreement. In doing so, we also establish a general correspondence, at the probabilistic level, between the analyses of correlation in game theory and in quantum mechanics.

•Aug 3, 2008•1 citation

Critical Remarks on "Joint Definability, Context–Instantiated Geometry, and the Inapplicability of Fine's Theorem" (Sanctuary, Quantum Rep. 2026, 8, 96)

Anton Lorenz Vrba, Richard David Gill

We examine the logical and mathematical structure of Sanctuary's recent paper (\emph{Quantum Rep.}\ 2026, 8, 96), which argues that spin observables in the Bivector Standard Model (BiSM) are not jointly definable on a single Kolmogorov probability space, so that the CHSH quadruple cannot be formed and Bell's and Fine's theorems do not apply. The paper contains two constructions: local response functions of the analyser setting and a shared source phase, and a separate prescription that produces the correlation $-\cos(a-b)$. We show that the first construction, as specified, meets the hypotheses of Bell's theorem. Its outcome maps are defined on a common source domain with a setting-independent distribution, so the non-existence claim (Lemma~3, Corollary~3) does not hold for it, its product correlations obey the CHSH bound, and the paper's own simulation of it yields the Bell triangle. The cosine is obtained instead from a scalar computed jointly from both stations' phases and then digitised; it is not shown to be the correlation of the local outcomes. Execution of the supplementary programs further shows that the four BiSM\_v2 populations do not form the partition stated in the paper, and that the doubled-angle harmonic attributed to the raw coherence data appears only after a sign convention is applied on the second half-cycle.

•Sep 29, 2026•0 citations
An elementary identity is noted: the quantum correlation E(a,b) = −cos(a−b) predicted for a singlet state is numerically identical to the Pearson correlation coefficient of two classical cosine projections sharing a common hidden angle. The question is posed whether this coincidence has structural significance. The connection to Fine's theorem (1982) on joint distributions and CHSH inequalities is discussed.
Abstract In agreement with the data, the quantum correlation between spins violates Bell’s inequality by following a cosine curve when one analyzer is rotated relative to the other. In contrast, the linear correlation attributed to hidden variables has never been observed. Besides these well-established facts, we show here that classical covariance, Pearson correlation, between spins projected as up or down on the analyzer axes also follows the cosine form hitherto uniquely ascribed to the quantum mechanical expectation value. The common cause for the classical correlation is the conservation of intrinsic angular momentum that aligns the two spins antiparallel at the breakup. Thus, as long as the spins retain their orientations relative to each other, the measurement of one spin in a chosen frame of reference also discloses the opposite orientation of the other in that frame. Realizing that classical correlation has the same functional form as quantum entanglement sheds light on the foundations of modern physics and quantum computing.
A study in inverse model identification. Using only pre-quantum physics (analogue mixer, low-pass filtering, Malus's law, Pearson correlation), we build a deterministic local coherent-detection model whose raw correlations are Bell-compliant (|S_raw| = √2/4). Pearson normalisation yields −cos(a−b), and the CHSH polynomial on these coefficients gives 2√2 (scale-invariant). This C_Pearson is not a Bell correlator and no Bell violation is claimed. The point: the value 2√2, taken from normalised correlation data alone (blind test), does not uniquely identify the generating mechanism — an explicit classical pre-image of the same data is exhibited. Bell-CHSH is used only as an extreme illustration.
We study angular correlations of the radiation emitted by spatially extended sets of atoms. Such correlations result from the fact that the photons are identical quantum particles. We show that the symmetry (or the antisymmetry) alone of the wave function for identical, indistinguishable particles always leads to significant angular correlations and that in full agreement with our intuition, bosons tend to travel in the same direction while fermions tend to travel in opposite directions. In order to quantify these intuitive notions, we introduce---as a measure of angular correlations---the average value of the cosine of the angle between the directions of the momenta of two particles. The angular correlation coefficient is calculated for simple, model wave functions and the results are compared with those obtained from an exactly soluble model describing radiating harmonic oscillators. We find that even though the interaction modifies the exact values of the angular correlation coefficient, the gross features can be obtained from quantum statistics, i.e., from the symmetry of the many-photon wave functions. Moreover, the angular correlations as measured by the average cosine exhibit an almost universal character, at least for a small number of emitting atoms. Finally, we compare angular correlations obtained in quantum electrodynamics with the correlations resulting from the phenomenologically introduced randomness of the phases in the classical description of the electromagnetic field.
We introduce a local phase-field framework for spin-entanglement correlations. In this framework, the relevant hidden variable is an internal scalar phase associated with each fermion and derived from two underlying real fields. The fields are assumed to evolve locally in ordinary spacetime. When a particle pair is produced at a common spacetime event, the pair acquires a shared phase-locking condition at creation; after separation, the two internal phases evolve independently and no nonlocal interaction is introduced. Spin measurements by Stern–Gerlach analyzers are modeled as local filtering operations. Each local response depends only on the internal phase carried by the particle and on the orientation of the local analyzer. The local response function A(α,λ) = cos(λ − 2α) is derived from the spinorial transformation law of the underlying real field pair and the projection geometry of the detector interaction; it is not a phenomenological ansatz. From these deterministic local responses we derive an analog correlator. The raw product moment of the continuous detector outputs evaluates to ⟨AB⟩ = −½ cos 2(α − β), which satisfies classical Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) bounds. After Pearson normalization—the operationally appropriate correlation measure for continuous analog detector outputs, justified by channel-contrast physics and scale invariance—the normalized correlator yields E(α,β) = −cos 2(α − β), matching the quantum singlet correlator in functional form. When this normalized correlator is inserted into the CHSH expression, it yields the numerical value 2√2. This result is a structural consequence of the reduced marginal variance of continuous response functions relative to the unit-variance dichotomic observables assumed in Bell’s derivation; it does not constitute a violation of Bell’s inequality. The model does not reproduce quantum singlet statistics at the level of binary detector outcomes, where the correlator takes a triangular rather than cosine form. The contribution is therefore ontological and conceptual rather than predictive. The framework preserves parameter independence and no-signaling throughout. It provides a concrete real-field ontology for spin correlations based on internal phase structure, and it demonstrates that the functional form of the quantum singlet correlation can be obtained from a strictly local deterministic description, provided that the detector responses are treated as continuous analog quantities and normalized accordingly. We compare the model with earlier phase-based approaches and discuss experimental configurations—including time-resolved and multi-stage Stern–Gerlach measurements—that could in principle probe the proposed internal-phase dynamics at the pre-registration level.
We examine the logical and mathematical structure of Sanctuary's recent paper (\emph{Quantum Rep.}\ 2026, 8, 96), which argues that spin observables in the Bivector Standard Model (BiSM) are not jointly definable on a single Kolmogorov probability space, so that the CHSH quadruple cannot be formed and Bell's and Fine's theorems do not apply. The paper contains two constructions: local response functions of the analyser setting and a shared source phase, and a separate prescription that produces the correlation −cos⁡(a−b)-\cos(a-b)−cos(a−b). We show that the first construction, as specified, meets the hypotheses of Bell's theorem. Its outcome maps are defined on a common source domain with a setting-independent distribution, so the non-existence claim (Lemma~3, Corollary~3) does not hold for it, its product correlations obey the CHSH bound, and the paper's own simulation of it yields the Bell triangle. The cosine is obtained instead from a scalar computed jointly from both stations' phases and then digitised; it is not shown to be the correlation of the local outcomes. Execution of the supplementary programs further shows that the four BiSM\_v2 populations do not form the partition stated in the paper, and that the doubled-angle harmonic attributed to the raw coherence data appears only after a sign convention is applied on the second half-cycle.