Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Complexity

Theoretical analysis and simulations of memory-based and all-photonic quantum repeaters and networks

Ching-Lin Chan, Charu Jain, Ezra Kissel, Wenji Wu, Edwin Barnes, Sophia E. Economou, Inder Monga

Published Jun 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Scaling quantum networks to long distances necessitates the development of advanced quantum repeater (QR) technologies. Depending on the error mitigation mechanisms adopted to suppress loss and errors, QRs are typically classified into memory-based or all-photonic QRs; and each type of QR may be best suited for a specific type of underlying quantum technology, a particular scale of quantum networks, or a specific regime of operational parameters. This paper presents a comparative theoretical and simulation-based analysis of first-generation memory-based trapped-ion QRs and networks, and all-photonic entanglement-based QRs and networks. Our model incorporates a wide range of realistic parameters and noise sources to evaluate performance trade-offs. Major research findings of this study include: (a) the entanglement rate does not necessarily scale with the number of QRs. Although adding repeaters in a chain helps to reduce photon loss in quantum links, it also introduces overheads that can be attributed to imperfect photon collection, inefficient quantum frequency conversion, and limited detector efficiency. The entanglement rate only improves when the distance between QRs exceeds a certain threshold, specifically, when the reduction in photon loss in quantum links gained by adding QRs outweighs the inherent overheads they introduce. (b) Without quantum error correction and entanglement purification, the entanglement fidelity decreases with the number of QRs, regardless of the chain distance. Finally, the theoretical models and simulation software package developed in this study provide a versatile framework for the design and evaluation of future QR technologies, protocols, and architectures.

DOI
10.1088/2632-072x/ae7b19

Related papers

Theoretical Analysis and Simulations of Memory-based and All-photonic Quantum Repeaters and Networks

Chuen Hei Chan, Charu Jain, Ezra Kissel +4 more

Developing and deploying advanced Quantum Repeater (QR) technologies will be necessary to scale quantum networks to longer distances. Depending on the error mitigation mechanisms adopted to suppress loss and errors, QRs are typically classified into memory-based or all-photonic QRs; and each type of QR may be best suited for a specific type of underlying quantum technology, a particular scale of quantum networks, or a specific regime of operational parameters. We perform theoretical analysis and simulations of quantum repeaters and networks to investigate the relative performance and resource requirements of different quantum network paradigms. Our results will help guide the optimization of quantum hardware and components and shed light on the role of a robust control plane. We present our research findings on theoretical analysis and simulations of memory-based first-generation trapped-ion quantum repeaters and networks, and all-photonic entanglement-based quantum repeaters and networks. We study the relative performance in terms of entanglement generation rate and fidelity, as well as the resource requirements of these two different quantum network paradigms.

quant-pharXiv:2512.23111•Dec 30, 2025•0 citations

A Comparative Study of All-Photonic and Memory-Based Quantum Repeaters and Networks

Ching-Lin Chan, Charu Jain, Ezra Kissel +4 more

Developing and deploying advanced Quantum Repeater (QR) technologies will be necessary to scale quantum networks at longer distances. Depending on the error mitigation mechanisms adopted to suppress loss and errors, QRs are typically classified into “memory-based” or “all-photonic” QRs, and each type of QR may be best suited for a specific type of underlying quantum technology, a particular scale of quantum network, or a specific regime of operational parameters. Modeling and simulation of quantum repeaters and networks can help in understanding the relative performance and resource requirements of different types of QRs, identify tradeoffs of alternative quantum network architectures, optimize quantum hardware, and assist in the design of a robust control plane. This paper introduces a quantum repeater simulation toolkit based on NetSquid, which includes component models and protocols to study advanced quantum repeater networks. We present our initial research findings on modeling and simulation of “allphotonic” entanglement-based QRs and “memory-based” first generation trapped ion QRs. We study the relative performance and resource requirements of these two different types of QRs and networks. The performance metrics include entanglement generation rate and fidelity between the endpoints of the network. For fair comparison of resource requirements of different types of QRs, entanglement generation rate is normalized by the total number of matter qubits involved.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Aug 30, 2025•3 citations

Hybrid Quantum Repeater Chains with Atom-based Quantum Processing Units and Quantum Memory Multiplexers

Shin Sun, Daniel Bhatti, Shaobo Gao +2 more

Quantum repeaters enable the generation of reliable entanglement across long distances despite the underlying channel noise. Nevertheless, realizing quantum repeaters poses a difficult engineering challenge due to various device constraints and design tradeoffs. Herein we propose and analyze an efficient hybrid quantum repeater design that integrates atom-based quantum processing units, spontaneous parametric down-conversion photon sources, and atomic frequency comb quantum memories. Our design leverages the strong spectrotemporal multiplexing capability of the quantum memory to enable high-rate elementary-link entanglement generation between repeater nodes. Transferring the photonic entanglement into matter-qubit entanglement, together with deterministic quantum operations, further enables reliable long-distance entanglement distribution. We analyze photon-loss channels in the hybrid architecture and propose suitable error-suppression strategies that are natively incorporated into our repeater protocol. Using numerical simulations, we demonstrate the advantages of our hybrid design for end-to-end secret key rates in a linear repeater-chain model. With continued advances in relevant hardware technologies, we envision that the proposed hybrid design is well suited for large-scale quantum networks.

quant-pharXiv:2512.21655•Physical Review A•Dec 26, 2025•0 citations

Optimal architectures for long distance quantum communication

Sreraman Muralidharan, Linshu Li, Jungsang Kim +3 more

Despite the tremendous progress of quantum cryptography, efficient quantum communication over long distances (≥ 1000 km) remains an outstanding challenge due to fiber attenuation and operation errors accumulated over the entire communication distance. Quantum repeaters (QRs), as a promising approach, can overcome both photon loss and operation errors, and hence significantly speedup the communication rate. Depending on the methods used to correct loss and operation errors, all the proposed QR schemes can be classified into three categories (generations). Here we present the first systematic comparison of three generations of quantum repeaters by evaluating the cost of both temporal and physical resources, and identify the optimized quantum repeater architecture for a given set of experimental parameters for use in quantum key distribution. Our work provides a roadmap for the experimental realizations of highly efficient quantum networks over transcontinental distances.

arXiv:1509.08435•Scientific Reports•Feb 15, 2016•486 citations

A survey on advances of quantum repeater

Peishun Yan, Lan Zhou, Wei Zhong +1 more

Abstract The distribution of quantum entanglement is essential for quantum communication. Contrary to classical communication, the signal in quantum communication is impossible to copy due to the basic principles of quantum mechanics, i.e. , quantum state collapse and no-cloning theorem. However, the communication range is limited by inevitable photon loss. To counteract this issue, one can insert several repeater stations between two remote end nodes to divide the full distance into several shorter segments and successively operate entanglement swapping between adjacent repeater stations to enable long-distance quantum communication. Up to now, one can classify quantum repeaters (QRs) into three generations based on the methods of reducing errors resulted from photon loss and imperfect operations. In this paper, we will briefly review advances for each generation of QRs and discuss the advantages and challenges of each generation. Moreover, we also discuss some efficient proposals of building blocks to overcome the bottlenecks for QRs.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Oct 1, 2021•30 citations

Resource Management in Heterogeneous Quantum Repeater Networks

Naphan Benchasattabuse

In this thesis, I explore whether it is possible to build a unified Quantum Internet architecture that supports different types of quantum repeaters -- especially the two most distinct and seemingly incompatible ones: memory-based quantum repeaters and all-photonic, memoryless repeaters. These technologies have traditionally been developed with the aim of becoming the single dominant solution, but I ask: Can they work together in the same network? What kind of architecture would support both? And how can simulation help us understand what is needed to manage such a network at scale? To address these questions, I propose an architecture based on an existing recursive network design and programmable RuleSet-based protocols that can coordinate diverse hardware components. I introduce a new emitter-photon building block to bridge memory-based and all-photonic segments, and show how classical networking abstractions can be extended to manage quantum operations. While I have developed a simulation tool grounded in these architectural principles and validated it against existing simulators and analytical models, a full-scale investigation of the resource trade-offs and performance implications remains future work. Nevertheless, the results so far suggest that a unified, heterogeneous quantum network is not only possible but increasingly practical with current technologies -- though ongoing experimental progress will be essential to fully realize this vision.

quant-pharXiv:2605.25132•May 26, 2026•0 citations
Abstract Scaling quantum networks to long distances necessitates the development of advanced quantum repeater (QR) technologies. Depending on the error mitigation mechanisms adopted to suppress loss and errors, QRs are typically classified into memory-based or all-photonic QRs; and each type of QR may be best suited for a specific type of underlying quantum technology, a particular scale of quantum networks, or a specific regime of operational parameters. This paper presents a comparative theoretical and simulation-based analysis of first-generation memory-based trapped-ion QRs and networks, and all-photonic entanglement-based QRs and networks. Our model incorporates a wide range of realistic parameters and noise sources to evaluate performance trade-offs. Major research findings of this study include: (a) the entanglement rate does not necessarily scale with the number of QRs. Although adding repeaters in a chain helps to reduce photon loss in quantum links, it also introduces overheads that can be attributed to imperfect photon collection, inefficient quantum frequency conversion, and limited detector efficiency. The entanglement rate only improves when the distance between QRs exceeds a certain threshold, specifically, when the reduction in photon loss in quantum links gained by adding QRs outweighs the inherent overheads they introduce. (b) Without quantum error correction and entanglement purification, the entanglement fidelity decreases with the number of QRs, regardless of the chain distance. Finally, the theoretical models and simulation software package developed in this study provide a versatile framework for the design and evaluation of future QR technologies, protocols, and architectures.
Developing and deploying advanced Quantum Repeater (QR) technologies will be necessary to scale quantum networks to longer distances. Depending on the error mitigation mechanisms adopted to suppress loss and errors, QRs are typically classified into memory-based or all-photonic QRs; and each type of QR may be best suited for a specific type of underlying quantum technology, a particular scale of quantum networks, or a specific regime of operational parameters. We perform theoretical analysis and simulations of quantum repeaters and networks to investigate the relative performance and resource requirements of different quantum network paradigms. Our results will help guide the optimization of quantum hardware and components and shed light on the role of a robust control plane. We present our research findings on theoretical analysis and simulations of memory-based first-generation trapped-ion quantum repeaters and networks, and all-photonic entanglement-based quantum repeaters and networks. We study the relative performance in terms of entanglement generation rate and fidelity, as well as the resource requirements of these two different quantum network paradigms.
Developing and deploying advanced Quantum Repeater (QR) technologies will be necessary to scale quantum networks at longer distances. Depending on the error mitigation mechanisms adopted to suppress loss and errors, QRs are typically classified into “memory-based” or “all-photonic” QRs, and each type of QR may be best suited for a specific type of underlying quantum technology, a particular scale of quantum network, or a specific regime of operational parameters. Modeling and simulation of quantum repeaters and networks can help in understanding the relative performance and resource requirements of different types of QRs, identify tradeoffs of alternative quantum network architectures, optimize quantum hardware, and assist in the design of a robust control plane. This paper introduces a quantum repeater simulation toolkit based on NetSquid, which includes component models and protocols to study advanced quantum repeater networks. We present our initial research findings on modeling and simulation of “allphotonic” entanglement-based QRs and “memory-based” first generation trapped ion QRs. We study the relative performance and resource requirements of these two different types of QRs and networks. The performance metrics include entanglement generation rate and fidelity between the endpoints of the network. For fair comparison of resource requirements of different types of QRs, entanglement generation rate is normalized by the total number of matter qubits involved.
Quantum repeaters enable the generation of reliable entanglement across long distances despite the underlying channel noise. Nevertheless, realizing quantum repeaters poses a difficult engineering challenge due to various device constraints and design tradeoffs. Herein we propose and analyze an efficient hybrid quantum repeater design that integrates atom-based quantum processing units, spontaneous parametric down-conversion photon sources, and atomic frequency comb quantum memories. Our design leverages the strong spectrotemporal multiplexing capability of the quantum memory to enable high-rate elementary-link entanglement generation between repeater nodes. Transferring the photonic entanglement into matter-qubit entanglement, together with deterministic quantum operations, further enables reliable long-distance entanglement distribution. We analyze photon-loss channels in the hybrid architecture and propose suitable error-suppression strategies that are natively incorporated into our repeater protocol. Using numerical simulations, we demonstrate the advantages of our hybrid design for end-to-end secret key rates in a linear repeater-chain model. With continued advances in relevant hardware technologies, we envision that the proposed hybrid design is well suited for large-scale quantum networks.
Despite the tremendous progress of quantum cryptography, efficient quantum communication over long distances (≥ 1000 km) remains an outstanding challenge due to fiber attenuation and operation errors accumulated over the entire communication distance. Quantum repeaters (QRs), as a promising approach, can overcome both photon loss and operation errors, and hence significantly speedup the communication rate. Depending on the methods used to correct loss and operation errors, all the proposed QR schemes can be classified into three categories (generations). Here we present the first systematic comparison of three generations of quantum repeaters by evaluating the cost of both temporal and physical resources, and identify the optimized quantum repeater architecture for a given set of experimental parameters for use in quantum key distribution. Our work provides a roadmap for the experimental realizations of highly efficient quantum networks over transcontinental distances.
Abstract The distribution of quantum entanglement is essential for quantum communication. Contrary to classical communication, the signal in quantum communication is impossible to copy due to the basic principles of quantum mechanics, i.e. , quantum state collapse and no-cloning theorem. However, the communication range is limited by inevitable photon loss. To counteract this issue, one can insert several repeater stations between two remote end nodes to divide the full distance into several shorter segments and successively operate entanglement swapping between adjacent repeater stations to enable long-distance quantum communication. Up to now, one can classify quantum repeaters (QRs) into three generations based on the methods of reducing errors resulted from photon loss and imperfect operations. In this paper, we will briefly review advances for each generation of QRs and discuss the advantages and challenges of each generation. Moreover, we also discuss some efficient proposals of building blocks to overcome the bottlenecks for QRs.
In this thesis, I explore whether it is possible to build a unified Quantum Internet architecture that supports different types of quantum repeaters -- especially the two most distinct and seemingly incompatible ones: memory-based quantum repeaters and all-photonic, memoryless repeaters. These technologies have traditionally been developed with the aim of becoming the single dominant solution, but I ask: Can they work together in the same network? What kind of architecture would support both? And how can simulation help us understand what is needed to manage such a network at scale? To address these questions, I propose an architecture based on an existing recursive network design and programmable RuleSet-based protocols that can coordinate diverse hardware components. I introduce a new emitter-photon building block to bridge memory-based and all-photonic segments, and show how classical networking abstractions can be extended to manage quantum operations. While I have developed a simulation tool grounded in these architectural principles and validated it against existing simulators and analytical models, a full-scale investigation of the resource trade-offs and performance implications remains future work. Nevertheless, the results so far suggest that a unified, heterogeneous quantum network is not only possible but increasingly practical with current technologies -- though ongoing experimental progress will be essential to fully realize this vision.