Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

SPIE Quantum Technologies

Comparison between high-dimensional time-bin encoded measurement device independent and prepare-and-measure quantum key distribution

Gokul Agasthilingam, Harinee Natarajan, Varun Raghunathan

Published May 28, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Prepare-and-measure (PM) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols offer implementation simplicity but depend on trusted detection, leaving practical systems vulnerable to detector side-channel attacks. Measurement-device-independent (MDI) QKD removes detector trust by shifting measurements to an untrusted relay, but coincidence-based measurements reduce the fraction of detected events contributing to secret key generation. High-dimensional (HD) time-bin encoding can mitigate this throughput penalty by increasing information per detected event and by expanding the set of valid coincidence signatures. In this work, we report a direct experimental comparison between HD time-bin encoded MDI-QKD (HD-MDI) and an HD prepare-and-measure reference based on the coherent-one-way protocol (HD-COW) over a 50 km standard single-mode fiber link. We compare encoding dimensions d = 2, 4, and 8 using standard protocol-specific parameter estimation to evaluate secret key rate (SKR) under comparable receiver constraints and channel loss. The comparison highlights distinct dimensional scaling of HD-MDI relative to HD-PM and identifies practical regimes where HD encoding enables MDI-QKD to approach or exceed PM throughput while retaining detector-side-channel immunity.

DOI
10.1117/12.3098822

Related papers

Large Alphabet Set Time-bin Encoded Measurement-Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution

Gokul Agasthilingam, Harinee Natarajan, Varun Raghunathan

We report on the experimental demonstration of an expanded basis set (called here as alphabet set) time-bin encoded measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution (MDI-QKD). While MDI-QKD is known to prevent detector-side attacks, it inherently suffers from reduced secret key rate (SKR) due to coincidence measurements performed at the central measurement node. To address this limitation, we encode states across multiple time-bins thereby increasing possible coincidence events and mapping each successful alphabet exchange to multiple bits, thereby increasing the information capacity per alphabet transmitted. Using a standard MDI-QKD set-up with real fiber spools and single-photon avalanche photodetectors, we achieve SKRs of 401 (133.6) bps and 28 (10.7) bps for 8 (2) encoded states for distances of 2 and 50 km, respectively, resulting in 3- and 2.63-times improvement, respectively when compared to the conventional two-state encoding. Furthemore, the large alphabet set MDIQKD results are compared with a similar encoding scheme implemented for coherent-one-way (COW) protocol. This comparison reveals a clear advantage of using a larger alphabet set for MDI-QKD, where increased Z-basis coincidence events yields increased SKR. These results provide important insights into the scalability of MDI-QKD key-rates without requiring additional hardware modifications, paving the way for next-generation, quantum key distribution networks.

quant-pharXiv:2606.01262•Jun 2, 2026•0 citations

Fiber-based higher dimensional quantum key distribution implementation using time-bin qudits

Gokul Agasthilingam, Harinee Natarajan, Varun Raghunathan

Higher Dimensional Quantum Key Distribution (HD-QKD) improves information capacity and security compared to binary QKD systems. Previous HD-QKD implementations have required d+1 (d refers to encoding dimension) single-photon detectors, limiting large-scale implementation. In contrast, another HD-QKD implementation using coherent one-way (COW) protocol hardware with two detectors achieved a secret key rate (SKR) of 155 kbps for an 8-D system and 2.7% QBER tolerance for a 16-D system with qubit scrambling across a time window. In this paper, we theoretically simulate and experimentally demonstrate time-bin encoded HD-QKD using COW protocol hardware with two single-photon detectors operating at standard telecom wavelengths, achieving a remarkable maximum encoding of 6 bits per photon (i.e., 56-d system). Our HD-QKD system incorporates a practical decoy-state technique to counter the photon number splitting attack, allowing greater flexibility in choosing higher mean photon number thereby achieving higher SKR and distances. This implementation demonstrates a remarkable ninefold increase in SKR for a 16-d system (210 kbps over 25 km of standard single-mode fiber) compared to qubit-based systems, with a QBER tolerance of 13.5% for d = 16. Notably, we achieved positive key rates for emulated loss up to 131 km of fiber length for d = 8. By optimizing detector deadtime and mean photon number using our theoretical model, we achieve enhanced key rates and security. Our findings highlight the superiority of our approach and lay the foundation for high throughput HD-QKD implementation, offering a secure and efficient method for transmitting sensitive information.

Quantum Computing, Communication, and Simulation•Mar 12, 2024•3 citations

High-dimensional measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution on two-dimensional subspaces

Luca Dellantonio, Anders Søndberg Sørensen, Davide Bacco

Quantum key distribution (QKD) provides ultimate cryptographic security based on the laws of quantum mechanics. For point-to-point QKD protocols, the security of the generated key is compromised by detector side channel attacks. This problem can be solved with measurement-device-independent QKD (mdi-QKD). However, mdi-QKD has shown limited performances in terms of the secret key generation rate, due to postselection in the Bell measurements. We show that high-dimensional (Hi-D) encoding (qudits) improves the performance of current mdi-QKD implementations. The scheme is proven to be unconditionally secure even for weak coherent pulses with decoy states, while the secret key rate is derived in the single-photon case. Our analysis includes phase errors, imperfect sources, and dark counts to mimic real systems. Compared to the standard bidimensional case, we show an improvement in the key generation rate.

arXiv:1809.04405•Physical Review A•Dec 3, 2018•51 citations

One-sided measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution

Wen-Fei Cao, Yi-Zheng Zhen, Yu-Lin Zheng +4 more

Measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution (MDI-QKD) protocol was proposed to remove all the detector side channel attacks, while its security relies on the trusted encoding systems. Here we propose a one-sided MDI-QKD (1SMDI-QKD) protocol, which enjoys detection loophole-free advantage, and at the same time weakens the state preparation assumption in MDI-QKD. The 1SMDI-QKD can be regarded as a modified MDI-QKD, in which Bob's encoding system is trusted, while Alice's is uncharacterized. For the practical implementation, we also provide a scheme by utilizing coherent light source with an analytical two decoy state estimation method. Simulation with realistic experimental parameters shows that the protocol has a promising performance, and thus can be applied to practical QKD applications.

arXiv:1704.04371•Physical Review A•Jan 16, 2018•17 citations

Measurement-device-independent Quantum Cryptography

Zhiyuan Tang

Quantum key distribution (QKD) enables two legitimate parties to share a secret key even in the presence of an eavesdropper. The unconditional security of QKD is based on the fundamental laws of quantum physics. Original security proofs of QKD are based on a few assumptions, e.g., perfect single photon sources and perfect single-photon detectors. However, practical implementations of QKD systems do not fully comply with such assumptions due to technical limitations. The gap between theory and implementations leads to security loopholes in most QKD systems, and several attacks have been launched on sophisticated QKD systems. Particularly, the detectors have been found to be the most vulnerable part of QKD. Much effort has been put to build side-channel-free QKD systems. Solutions such as security patches and device-independent QKD have been proposed. However, the former are normally ad-hoc, and cannot close unidentified loopholes. The latter, while having the advantages of removing all assumptions on devices, is impractical to implement today. Measurement-device-independent QKD (MDI-QKD) turns out to be a promising solution to the security problem of QKD. In MDI-QKD, all security loopholes, including those yet-to-be discovered, have been removed from the detectors, the most critical part in QKD. In this thesis, we investigate issues related to the practical implementation and security of MDI-QKD. We first present a demonstration of polarization-encoding MDI-QKD. Taking finite key effect into account, we achieve a secret key rate of 0.005 bit per second (bps) over 10 km spooled telecom fiber, and a 1600-bit key is distributed. This work, together with other demonstrations, shows the practicality of MDI-QKD. Next we investigate a critical assumption of MDI-QKD: perfect state preparation. We apply the loss-tolerant QKD protocol and adapt it to MDI-QKD to quantify information leakage due to imperfect state preparation. We then present an experimental demonstration of MDI-QKD over 10 km and 40 km of spooled fiber, which for the first time considers the impact of inaccurate polarization state preparation on the secret key rate. This would not have been possible under previous security proofs, given the same amount of state preparation flaws.

•Nov 1, 2016•1 citation

High-rate continuous-variable measurement device-independent quantum key distribution with finite-size security

Adnan A. E. Hajomer, Ulrik L. Andersen, Tobias Gehring

Abstract Building scalable and secure quantum networks requires advanced quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols that support multi-user connectivity. Continuous-variable (CV) measurement-device-independent (MDI) QKD, which eliminates all detector side-channel attacks, is a promising candidate for creating various quantum network topologies-such as quantum access networks and star-type topologies-using standard technology and providing high secure key rates. However, its security has so far only been experimentally demonstrated in asymptotic regimes with limited secret key rates and complex experimental setups, limiting its practical applications. Here, we report an experimental validation of a CV MDI-QKD system, achieving a secure key rate of 2.6 Mbit s −1 against collective attacks in the finite-size regime over a 10 km fiber link. This is achieved using a new system design, incorporating a locally generated local oscillator, a new relay structure, a real-time phase locking system, and a well-designed digital-signal-processing pipeline for quantum state preparation and CV Bell measurements at a symbol rate of 20 MBaud. Our results set a new benchmark for secure key exchange and open the possibility of establishing high-performance CV MDI-QKD networks, paving the way toward a scalable quantum network.

arXiv:2303.01611•Quantum Science and Technology•Feb 5, 2025•16 citations
Prepare-and-measure (PM) quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols offer implementation simplicity but depend on trusted detection, leaving practical systems vulnerable to detector side-channel attacks. Measurement-device-independent (MDI) QKD removes detector trust by shifting measurements to an untrusted relay, but coincidence-based measurements reduce the fraction of detected events contributing to secret key generation. High-dimensional (HD) time-bin encoding can mitigate this throughput penalty by increasing information per detected event and by expanding the set of valid coincidence signatures. In this work, we report a direct experimental comparison between HD time-bin encoded MDI-QKD (HD-MDI) and an HD prepare-and-measure reference based on the coherent-one-way protocol (HD-COW) over a 50 km standard single-mode fiber link. We compare encoding dimensions d = 2, 4, and 8 using standard protocol-specific parameter estimation to evaluate secret key rate (SKR) under comparable receiver constraints and channel loss. The comparison highlights distinct dimensional scaling of HD-MDI relative to HD-PM and identifies practical regimes where HD encoding enables MDI-QKD to approach or exceed PM throughput while retaining detector-side-channel immunity.
We report on the experimental demonstration of an expanded basis set (called here as alphabet set) time-bin encoded measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution (MDI-QKD). While MDI-QKD is known to prevent detector-side attacks, it inherently suffers from reduced secret key rate (SKR) due to coincidence measurements performed at the central measurement node. To address this limitation, we encode states across multiple time-bins thereby increasing possible coincidence events and mapping each successful alphabet exchange to multiple bits, thereby increasing the information capacity per alphabet transmitted. Using a standard MDI-QKD set-up with real fiber spools and single-photon avalanche photodetectors, we achieve SKRs of 401 (133.6) bps and 28 (10.7) bps for 8 (2) encoded states for distances of 2 and 50 km, respectively, resulting in 3- and 2.63-times improvement, respectively when compared to the conventional two-state encoding. Furthemore, the large alphabet set MDIQKD results are compared with a similar encoding scheme implemented for coherent-one-way (COW) protocol. This comparison reveals a clear advantage of using a larger alphabet set for MDI-QKD, where increased Z-basis coincidence events yields increased SKR. These results provide important insights into the scalability of MDI-QKD key-rates without requiring additional hardware modifications, paving the way for next-generation, quantum key distribution networks.
Higher Dimensional Quantum Key Distribution (HD-QKD) improves information capacity and security compared to binary QKD systems. Previous HD-QKD implementations have required d+1 (d refers to encoding dimension) single-photon detectors, limiting large-scale implementation. In contrast, another HD-QKD implementation using coherent one-way (COW) protocol hardware with two detectors achieved a secret key rate (SKR) of 155 kbps for an 8-D system and 2.7% QBER tolerance for a 16-D system with qubit scrambling across a time window. In this paper, we theoretically simulate and experimentally demonstrate time-bin encoded HD-QKD using COW protocol hardware with two single-photon detectors operating at standard telecom wavelengths, achieving a remarkable maximum encoding of 6 bits per photon (i.e., 56-d system). Our HD-QKD system incorporates a practical decoy-state technique to counter the photon number splitting attack, allowing greater flexibility in choosing higher mean photon number thereby achieving higher SKR and distances. This implementation demonstrates a remarkable ninefold increase in SKR for a 16-d system (210 kbps over 25 km of standard single-mode fiber) compared to qubit-based systems, with a QBER tolerance of 13.5% for d = 16. Notably, we achieved positive key rates for emulated loss up to 131 km of fiber length for d = 8. By optimizing detector deadtime and mean photon number using our theoretical model, we achieve enhanced key rates and security. Our findings highlight the superiority of our approach and lay the foundation for high throughput HD-QKD implementation, offering a secure and efficient method for transmitting sensitive information.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) provides ultimate cryptographic security based on the laws of quantum mechanics. For point-to-point QKD protocols, the security of the generated key is compromised by detector side channel attacks. This problem can be solved with measurement-device-independent QKD (mdi-QKD). However, mdi-QKD has shown limited performances in terms of the secret key generation rate, due to postselection in the Bell measurements. We show that high-dimensional (Hi-D) encoding (qudits) improves the performance of current mdi-QKD implementations. The scheme is proven to be unconditionally secure even for weak coherent pulses with decoy states, while the secret key rate is derived in the single-photon case. Our analysis includes phase errors, imperfect sources, and dark counts to mimic real systems. Compared to the standard bidimensional case, we show an improvement in the key generation rate.
Measurement-device-independent quantum key distribution (MDI-QKD) protocol was proposed to remove all the detector side channel attacks, while its security relies on the trusted encoding systems. Here we propose a one-sided MDI-QKD (1SMDI-QKD) protocol, which enjoys detection loophole-free advantage, and at the same time weakens the state preparation assumption in MDI-QKD. The 1SMDI-QKD can be regarded as a modified MDI-QKD, in which Bob's encoding system is trusted, while Alice's is uncharacterized. For the practical implementation, we also provide a scheme by utilizing coherent light source with an analytical two decoy state estimation method. Simulation with realistic experimental parameters shows that the protocol has a promising performance, and thus can be applied to practical QKD applications.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) enables two legitimate parties to share a secret key even in the presence of an eavesdropper. The unconditional security of QKD is based on the fundamental laws of quantum physics. Original security proofs of QKD are based on a few assumptions, e.g., perfect single photon sources and perfect single-photon detectors. However, practical implementations of QKD systems do not fully comply with such assumptions due to technical limitations. The gap between theory and implementations leads to security loopholes in most QKD systems, and several attacks have been launched on sophisticated QKD systems. Particularly, the detectors have been found to be the most vulnerable part of QKD. Much effort has been put to build side-channel-free QKD systems. Solutions such as security patches and device-independent QKD have been proposed. However, the former are normally ad-hoc, and cannot close unidentified loopholes. The latter, while having the advantages of removing all assumptions on devices, is impractical to implement today. Measurement-device-independent QKD (MDI-QKD) turns out to be a promising solution to the security problem of QKD. In MDI-QKD, all security loopholes, including those yet-to-be discovered, have been removed from the detectors, the most critical part in QKD. In this thesis, we investigate issues related to the practical implementation and security of MDI-QKD. We first present a demonstration of polarization-encoding MDI-QKD. Taking finite key effect into account, we achieve a secret key rate of 0.005 bit per second (bps) over 10 km spooled telecom fiber, and a 1600-bit key is distributed. This work, together with other demonstrations, shows the practicality of MDI-QKD. Next we investigate a critical assumption of MDI-QKD: perfect state preparation. We apply the loss-tolerant QKD protocol and adapt it to MDI-QKD to quantify information leakage due to imperfect state preparation. We then present an experimental demonstration of MDI-QKD over 10 km and 40 km of spooled fiber, which for the first time considers the impact of inaccurate polarization state preparation on the secret key rate. This would not have been possible under previous security proofs, given the same amount of state preparation flaws.
Abstract Building scalable and secure quantum networks requires advanced quantum key distribution (QKD) protocols that support multi-user connectivity. Continuous-variable (CV) measurement-device-independent (MDI) QKD, which eliminates all detector side-channel attacks, is a promising candidate for creating various quantum network topologies-such as quantum access networks and star-type topologies-using standard technology and providing high secure key rates. However, its security has so far only been experimentally demonstrated in asymptotic regimes with limited secret key rates and complex experimental setups, limiting its practical applications. Here, we report an experimental validation of a CV MDI-QKD system, achieving a secure key rate of 2.6 Mbit s −1 against collective attacks in the finite-size regime over a 10 km fiber link. This is achieved using a new system design, incorporating a locally generated local oscillator, a new relay structure, a real-time phase locking system, and a well-designed digital-signal-processing pipeline for quantum state preparation and CV Bell measurements at a symbol rate of 20 MBaud. Our results set a new benchmark for secure key exchange and open the possibility of establishing high-performance CV MDI-QKD networks, paving the way toward a scalable quantum network.