Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Far-from-equilibrium dynamics near an anomalous nonthermal fixed point

Niklas Rasch

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study the emergence of distinctly subdiffusive scaling in the vicinity of an anomalous nonthermal fixed point, which reflects spatio-temporally self-similar scaling dynamics, in a quasi-two-dimensional Bose gas in the superfluid phase. In this regime, the far-from-equilibrium dynamics is governed by ensembles of quantum vortices. Mutual annihilation of vortices and antivortices drives coarsening, leading to the observed scaling behavior and an algebraically growing mean inter-defect distance over time. Introducing dipolar interactions provides additional control over the anisotropy and long-range character of the interactions. This control, combined with various parameter regimes and initial conditions, allows us to explore the universality of the subdiffusive scaling near the anomalous nonthermal fixed point. Scaling exponents are extracted from occupation-number spectra, the temporal evolution of inter-defect distances, and the decay of the total vortex number. At late times, compressible excitations of the background condensate grow due to ongoing vortex-antivortex annihilation, resulting in a crossover toward diffusion-type scaling near the Gaussian nonthermal fixed point. The observed temporal scaling depends only weakly on the strength and anisotropy of the dipolar interactions, demonstrating the universality of both anomalous and diffusion-type nonthermal fixed points. Nevertheless, the dipolar case exhibits qualitatively distinct vortex-clustering behavior. In contrast to non-dipolar gases, roton excitations in anisotropic, dipolar interactions appear to suppress same-sign vortex clustering, favoring the formation of vortex dipoles and maximizing the separation between vortices of equal sign. For pure contact interaction, we additionally observe spatial scaling characteristics consistent with Kraichnan--Kolmogorov turbulence. During a universal interval, in which the characteristic length scale associated with the inter-defect distance exhibits subdiffusive power-law growth, the moments of the superfluid velocity circulation around a square contour scale as predicted from classical turbulence theory. Higher-order moments of the velocity circulation reveal intermittent deviations, which are found to be consistent with values measured in fully developed classical turbulence. Notably, the subdiffusive coarsening clearly deviates from values known in classical systems. Collectively, these results provide strong evidence for the universality of the subdiffusive scaling near the anomalous nonthermal fixed point and establish a direct connection to decaying quantum turbulence cascades, highlighting the relevance of nonthermal fixed points in turbulence theory.

DOI
10.11588/heidok.00038531

Related papers

Anomalous nonthermal fixed point in a quasi-two-dimensional dipolar Bose gas

Niklas Rasch, Lauriane Chomaz, Thomas Gasenzer

The emergence of distinctly subdiffusive scaling in the vicinity of an anomalous nonthermal fixed point is discussed in a quasi-two-dimensional dipolar Bose gas in the superfluid phase, carrying ensembles of vortices and antivortices with zero net angular momentum. The observed scaling behavior reflects coarsening dynamics driven by the mutual annihilation of vortices and antivortices, with the mean interdefect distance growing algebraically over time as ${\ensuremath{\ell}}_{\text{v}}(t)\ensuremath{\sim}{t}^{\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\beta}}$. A subdiffusive ($\ensuremath{\beta}<\frac{1}{2}$) exponent $\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\approx}0.2$ is extracted for various parameter regimes, initial conditions, and dipolar configurations from both scaling occupation-number spectra and the evolution of interdefect distances as well as the corresponding total vortex densities. As vortex-antivortex annihilation progresses, excitations of the background condensate increase. This gives rise to a transition in the scaling behavior at late times, toward a nonthermal fixed point governed by diffusion-type scaling with $\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\approx}\frac{1}{2}$ as expected for the mutual annihilation of well-separated vortex-antivortex dipoles. While the temporal scaling with $\ensuremath{\beta}$ does not depend significantly on the strength and anisotropy of the dipolar interactions and thus underlines the universality of the anomalous as well as diffusion-type nonthermal fixed points, we find distinctly different vortex patterns resulting in the dipolar case. While in the superfluid with contact interactions only, same-sign vortices tend to cluster and form large-scale eddies, in the dipolar and tilted cases, roton excitations appear to prevent such motion, giving rather rise to a maximization of distances between vortices of either sign.

arXiv:2506.01653•Physical Review A•Nov 10, 2025•1 citation

Decaying superfluid turbulence near an anomalous nonthermal fixed point

Niklas Rasch, Thomas Gasenzer

We investigate anomalously slow coarsening in a dilute two-dimensional (2d) superfluid closed with respect to particle and energy exchange with the environment. The dynamics is demonstrated to be closely connected to both, a non-thermal fixed point (NTFP) in a far-from-equilibrium quantum system, and to Kraichnan-Kolmogorov turbulence. During a universal dynamical regime associated with an anomalous NTFP, vortex dynamics are understood to be governed by three-vortex collisions that trigger vortex-antivortex annihilation events, leading to a subdiffusive decay of the vortex density and thus growth of the characteristic inter-defect length scale, $\ell_\text{v}\sim t^{\,β}$ with $β\approx1/5$. It is found that, during the same time when this power law in time is seen, the moments of the superfluid velocity circulation $Γ$ around an area of spatial extent $r$ exhibit power-law scaling $Γ^{2}(r)\sim r^{8/3}$, in agreement with Kraichnan-Kolmogorov predictions for an inverse energy cascade in the inertial range, in a driven-open setting. Moreover, in high-order moments, intermittent deviations from linear scaling $Γ^{2p}(r)\sim [Γ^{2}(r)]^{p}$ are observed that are consistent with bifractal intermittency corrections previously measured in fully developed classical turbulence. These results establish a quantitative link between decaying quantum turbulence in a closed superfluid and universal dynamics near a non-thermal fixed point. Notably, the subdiffusive decay exponent $β\approx1/5$ deviates significantly from values reported for classical systems.

arXiv:2509.21285•Physical Review A•May 8, 2026•0 citations

Strongly anomalous non-thermal fixed point in a quenched two-dimensional Bose gas

Markus Karl, Thomas Gasenzer

Universal scaling behavior in the relaxation dynamics of an isolated two-dimensional Bose gas is studied by means of semi-classical stochastic simulations of the Gross–Pitaevskii model. The system is quenched far out of equilibrium by imprinting vortex defects into an otherwise phase-coherent condensate. A strongly anomalous non-thermal fixed point is identified, associated with a slowed decay of the defects in the case that the dissipative coupling to the thermal background noise is suppressed. At this fixed point, a large anomalous exponent and, related to this, a large dynamical exponent are identified. The corresponding power-law decay is found to be consistent with three-vortex-collision induced loss. The article discusses these aspects of non-thermal fixed points in the context of phase-ordering kinetics and coarsening dynamics, thus relating phenomenological and analytical approaches to classifying far-from-equilibrium scaling dynamics with each other. In particular, a close connection between the anomalous scaling exponent η , introduced in a quantum-field theoretic approach, and conservation-law induced scaling in classical phase-ordering kinetics is revealed. Moreover, the relation to superfluid turbulence as well as to driven stationary systems is discussed.

arXiv:1611.01163•New Journal of Physics•Sep 20, 2017•82 citations

Nonthermal fixed points, vortex statistics, and superfluid turbulence in an ultracold Bose gas

Boris Nowak, Jan Schole, Dénes Sexty +1 more

Nonthermal fixed points of the dynamics of a dilute degenerate Bose gas far from thermal equilibrium are analyzed in two and three spatial dimensions. Universal power-law distributions, previously found within a nonperturbative quantum-field theoretical approach and recently shown to be related to vortical dynamics and superfluid turbulence [Phys. Rev. B 84, 020506(R) (2011)], are studied in detail. The results imply an interpretation of the scaling behavior in terms of independent vortex excitations of the superfluid and show that the statistics of topological excitations can be described in the framework of wave turbulence. The particular scaling exponents observed in the single-particle momentum distributions are found to be consistent with irreversibility as well as conservation laws obeyed by the wave interactions. Moreover, long-wavelength acoustic excitations of the vortex-bearing condensate, driven by vortex annihilations, are found to follow a nonthermal power law. Considering vortex correlations in a statistical model, the long-time departure from the nonthermal fixed point is related to vortex-antivortex pairing. The studied nonthermal fixed points are accessible in cold-gas experiments. The results shed light on fundamental aspects of superfluid turbulence and have strong potential implications for related phenomena, for example, in early universe inflation or quark-gluon plasma dynamics.

arXiv:1111.6127•Physical Review A•Apr 30, 2012•136 citations

Nonthermal fixed points: universality, topology, and turbulence in Bose gases

Boris Nowak, Sebastian Erne, Markus Karl +3 more

Abstract This chapter considers nearly coherent Bose gases brought far out of equilibrium and their behavior in the context of connections between universal properties, (quasi-)topological field configurations, and turbulent dynamics. The isolated Bose gas, on its way back to thermal equilibrium, can approach metastable nonequilibrium configurations and spend a long time in their vicinity. In such configurations, termed nonthermal fixed points, the system shows universal long-range properties manifest through scaling, i.e. self-similar correlations. The time evolution near such fixed points undergoes critical slowing down. The spatial field pattern, at the same time, is characterized by the appearance of defects and domain formation whose geometry gives rise to the particular scaling laws seen in the correlation functions. An overall picture is obtained that connects well-known concepts for describing universal dynamics such as wave turbulence, superfluid turbulence, and (quasi-)topological excitations. The extension to fermionic and gauge fields should reveal many interesting new aspects.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 23, 2016•4 citations

Critical non-thermal fixed point and the dynamical condensation phase transition

Anne-Solène Bornens, Elisabeth Gliott, Nicolas Cherroret

Using a non-perturbative quantum kinetic framework, we develop a unified description of the far-from-equilibrium dynamics of three-dimensional Bose gases following cooling quenches across the Bose-Einstein condensation transition. By tracking the spatio-temporal evolution of the momentum distribution, we show that the equilibrium condensation threshold simultaneously acts as a dynamical critical point, separating distinct far-from-equilibrium universality classes governed by different non-equilibrium attractors. While quenches above the transition exhibit a single-timescale relaxation toward a thermal fixed point, quenches below the transition display a crossover from a transient weak-turbulence regime to a coarsening fixed point governed by the diffusive recombination of vortex lines. Quenches directly to the condensation threshold, finally, are controlled by a previously unidentified critical fixed point characterized by the superdiffusive spreading of critical fluctuations and a distinct set of dynamical exponents. Together, these dynamical scaling laws establish a far-from-equilibrium counterpart of the condensation phase transition, in which the equilibrium critical point also organizes the long-time non-equilibrium dynamics.

cond-mat.quant-gasCross-listedarXiv:2607.26620•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations
We study the emergence of distinctly subdiffusive scaling in the vicinity of an anomalous nonthermal fixed point, which reflects spatio-temporally self-similar scaling dynamics, in a quasi-two-dimensional Bose gas in the superfluid phase. In this regime, the far-from-equilibrium dynamics is governed by ensembles of quantum vortices. Mutual annihilation of vortices and antivortices drives coarsening, leading to the observed scaling behavior and an algebraically growing mean inter-defect distance over time. Introducing dipolar interactions provides additional control over the anisotropy and long-range character of the interactions. This control, combined with various parameter regimes and initial conditions, allows us to explore the universality of the subdiffusive scaling near the anomalous nonthermal fixed point. Scaling exponents are extracted from occupation-number spectra, the temporal evolution of inter-defect distances, and the decay of the total vortex number. At late times, compressible excitations of the background condensate grow due to ongoing vortex-antivortex annihilation, resulting in a crossover toward diffusion-type scaling near the Gaussian nonthermal fixed point. The observed temporal scaling depends only weakly on the strength and anisotropy of the dipolar interactions, demonstrating the universality of both anomalous and diffusion-type nonthermal fixed points. Nevertheless, the dipolar case exhibits qualitatively distinct vortex-clustering behavior. In contrast to non-dipolar gases, roton excitations in anisotropic, dipolar interactions appear to suppress same-sign vortex clustering, favoring the formation of vortex dipoles and maximizing the separation between vortices of equal sign. For pure contact interaction, we additionally observe spatial scaling characteristics consistent with Kraichnan--Kolmogorov turbulence. During a universal interval, in which the characteristic length scale associated with the inter-defect distance exhibits subdiffusive power-law growth, the moments of the superfluid velocity circulation around a square contour scale as predicted from classical turbulence theory. Higher-order moments of the velocity circulation reveal intermittent deviations, which are found to be consistent with values measured in fully developed classical turbulence. Notably, the subdiffusive coarsening clearly deviates from values known in classical systems. Collectively, these results provide strong evidence for the universality of the subdiffusive scaling near the anomalous nonthermal fixed point and establish a direct connection to decaying quantum turbulence cascades, highlighting the relevance of nonthermal fixed points in turbulence theory.
The emergence of distinctly subdiffusive scaling in the vicinity of an anomalous nonthermal fixed point is discussed in a quasi-two-dimensional dipolar Bose gas in the superfluid phase, carrying ensembles of vortices and antivortices with zero net angular momentum. The observed scaling behavior reflects coarsening dynamics driven by the mutual annihilation of vortices and antivortices, with the mean interdefect distance growing algebraically over time as ${\ensuremath{\ell}}_{\text{v}}(t)\ensuremath{\sim}{t}^{\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\beta}}$. A subdiffusive ($\ensuremath{\beta}<\frac{1}{2}$) exponent $\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\approx}0.2$ is extracted for various parameter regimes, initial conditions, and dipolar configurations from both scaling occupation-number spectra and the evolution of interdefect distances as well as the corresponding total vortex densities. As vortex-antivortex annihilation progresses, excitations of the background condensate increase. This gives rise to a transition in the scaling behavior at late times, toward a nonthermal fixed point governed by diffusion-type scaling with $\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\approx}\frac{1}{2}$ as expected for the mutual annihilation of well-separated vortex-antivortex dipoles. While the temporal scaling with $\ensuremath{\beta}$ does not depend significantly on the strength and anisotropy of the dipolar interactions and thus underlines the universality of the anomalous as well as diffusion-type nonthermal fixed points, we find distinctly different vortex patterns resulting in the dipolar case. While in the superfluid with contact interactions only, same-sign vortices tend to cluster and form large-scale eddies, in the dipolar and tilted cases, roton excitations appear to prevent such motion, giving rather rise to a maximization of distances between vortices of either sign.
We investigate anomalously slow coarsening in a dilute two-dimensional (2d) superfluid closed with respect to particle and energy exchange with the environment. The dynamics is demonstrated to be closely connected to both, a non-thermal fixed point (NTFP) in a far-from-equilibrium quantum system, and to Kraichnan-Kolmogorov turbulence. During a universal dynamical regime associated with an anomalous NTFP, vortex dynamics are understood to be governed by three-vortex collisions that trigger vortex-antivortex annihilation events, leading to a subdiffusive decay of the vortex density and thus growth of the characteristic inter-defect length scale, ℓv∼t β\ell_\text{v}\sim t^{\,β}ℓv​∼tβ with β≈1/5β\approx1/5β≈1/5. It is found that, during the same time when this power law in time is seen, the moments of the superfluid velocity circulation ΓΓΓ around an area of spatial extent rrr exhibit power-law scaling Γ2(r)∼r8/3Γ^{2}(r)\sim r^{8/3}Γ2(r)∼r8/3, in agreement with Kraichnan-Kolmogorov predictions for an inverse energy cascade in the inertial range, in a driven-open setting. Moreover, in high-order moments, intermittent deviations from linear scaling Γ2p(r)∼[Γ2(r)]pΓ^{2p}(r)\sim [Γ^{2}(r)]^{p}Γ2p(r)∼[Γ2(r)]p are observed that are consistent with bifractal intermittency corrections previously measured in fully developed classical turbulence. These results establish a quantitative link between decaying quantum turbulence in a closed superfluid and universal dynamics near a non-thermal fixed point. Notably, the subdiffusive decay exponent β≈1/5β\approx1/5β≈1/5 deviates significantly from values reported for classical systems.
Universal scaling behavior in the relaxation dynamics of an isolated two-dimensional Bose gas is studied by means of semi-classical stochastic simulations of the Gross–Pitaevskii model. The system is quenched far out of equilibrium by imprinting vortex defects into an otherwise phase-coherent condensate. A strongly anomalous non-thermal fixed point is identified, associated with a slowed decay of the defects in the case that the dissipative coupling to the thermal background noise is suppressed. At this fixed point, a large anomalous exponent and, related to this, a large dynamical exponent are identified. The corresponding power-law decay is found to be consistent with three-vortex-collision induced loss. The article discusses these aspects of non-thermal fixed points in the context of phase-ordering kinetics and coarsening dynamics, thus relating phenomenological and analytical approaches to classifying far-from-equilibrium scaling dynamics with each other. In particular, a close connection between the anomalous scaling exponent η , introduced in a quantum-field theoretic approach, and conservation-law induced scaling in classical phase-ordering kinetics is revealed. Moreover, the relation to superfluid turbulence as well as to driven stationary systems is discussed.
Nonthermal fixed points of the dynamics of a dilute degenerate Bose gas far from thermal equilibrium are analyzed in two and three spatial dimensions. Universal power-law distributions, previously found within a nonperturbative quantum-field theoretical approach and recently shown to be related to vortical dynamics and superfluid turbulence [Phys. Rev. B 84, 020506(R) (2011)], are studied in detail. The results imply an interpretation of the scaling behavior in terms of independent vortex excitations of the superfluid and show that the statistics of topological excitations can be described in the framework of wave turbulence. The particular scaling exponents observed in the single-particle momentum distributions are found to be consistent with irreversibility as well as conservation laws obeyed by the wave interactions. Moreover, long-wavelength acoustic excitations of the vortex-bearing condensate, driven by vortex annihilations, are found to follow a nonthermal power law. Considering vortex correlations in a statistical model, the long-time departure from the nonthermal fixed point is related to vortex-antivortex pairing. The studied nonthermal fixed points are accessible in cold-gas experiments. The results shed light on fundamental aspects of superfluid turbulence and have strong potential implications for related phenomena, for example, in early universe inflation or quark-gluon plasma dynamics.
Abstract This chapter considers nearly coherent Bose gases brought far out of equilibrium and their behavior in the context of connections between universal properties, (quasi-)topological field configurations, and turbulent dynamics. The isolated Bose gas, on its way back to thermal equilibrium, can approach metastable nonequilibrium configurations and spend a long time in their vicinity. In such configurations, termed nonthermal fixed points, the system shows universal long-range properties manifest through scaling, i.e. self-similar correlations. The time evolution near such fixed points undergoes critical slowing down. The spatial field pattern, at the same time, is characterized by the appearance of defects and domain formation whose geometry gives rise to the particular scaling laws seen in the correlation functions. An overall picture is obtained that connects well-known concepts for describing universal dynamics such as wave turbulence, superfluid turbulence, and (quasi-)topological excitations. The extension to fermionic and gauge fields should reveal many interesting new aspects.
Using a non-perturbative quantum kinetic framework, we develop a unified description of the far-from-equilibrium dynamics of three-dimensional Bose gases following cooling quenches across the Bose-Einstein condensation transition. By tracking the spatio-temporal evolution of the momentum distribution, we show that the equilibrium condensation threshold simultaneously acts as a dynamical critical point, separating distinct far-from-equilibrium universality classes governed by different non-equilibrium attractors. While quenches above the transition exhibit a single-timescale relaxation toward a thermal fixed point, quenches below the transition display a crossover from a transient weak-turbulence regime to a coarsening fixed point governed by the diffusive recombination of vortex lines. Quenches directly to the condensation threshold, finally, are controlled by a previously unidentified critical fixed point characterized by the superdiffusive spreading of critical fluctuations and a distinct set of dynamical exponents. Together, these dynamical scaling laws establish a far-from-equilibrium counterpart of the condensation phase transition, in which the equilibrium critical point also organizes the long-time non-equilibrium dynamics.