Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Popperの傾向性解釈 : その欠点と現代的意義

友也 高村, Tomoya Takamura

Published Jan 1, 2009• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The propensity interpretation of probability is introduced faithfully with Popper's original description. It is shown that the propensity interpretation itself has little to do with the central problem of quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, some insights of Popper seem to have meanings in modern interpretations of quantum mechanics. Especially, the relation to stochastic mechanics and stochastic interpretation of quantum mechanics is considered. Many respects of the propensity interpretation are on Popper's intention or almost accidentally same with the stochastic interpretation when the stochasticity is considered to be objective. We give also some details to be supplemented for the realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics by means of the stochastic interpretation, most of which are neglected in Popper's consideration.

Related papers

Survey of Karl Popper's Propensity Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Zhao We

Popper's propensity interpretation of quantum mechanics is believed to be his outstanding contribution to physics and philosophy.The paper first introduces the traditional interpretation of quantum theory given by the Coperhagen school,then describes how Popper's propensity of quantum theory was developed.Negative comments on Popper's theory are also mentioned.

Journal of Wuhan Engineering Institute•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Popper and Bohr on Realism in Quantum Mechanics

Don A. Howard

Popper's program in the foundations of quantum mechanics defending objectivity and realism developed out of a profound dissatisfaction with the point of view associated with Bohr, which is usually designated the Copenhagen interpretation. Here I will argue that while Popper's aim is a noble one, his program does not succeed on two counts: he does not succeed in showing that Bohr's philosophy must be rejected as a variety of subjectivism, and his alternative interpretation of indeterminacy rests on a highly questionable assumption according to which simultaneously precise conjugate parameters are possible. Nevertheless I like Popper's propensity interpretation of probability and think that the propensity idea deserves further research. Quanta 2012; 1: 33–57.

Quanta•Nov 15, 2012•10 citations

Popper's Dream and the Propensity Interpretation of Probability

Vladimír Havlík

The article deals with Popper's propensity interpretation of probability in the context of his metaphysical epilogue to Schisma of physics. The analysis is devoted to Popper's conjecture about propensity and indeterminism, to description of the new picture of physical reality and to the new metaphysical program of propensity cosmology.

•Jan 1, 2003•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Interpretations of Probability Theory

Neal Grossman

Several philosophers of science have claimed that the conceptual difficulties of quantum mechanics can be resolved by appealing to a particular interpretation of probability theory. For example, Popper bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the propensity interpretation of probability, and Margenau bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the frequency interpretation of probability. The purpose of this paper is (i) to consider and reject such claims, and (ii) to discuss the question of whether the ψ-function refers to an individual system or to an ensemble of systems.

Philosophy of Science•Dec 1, 1972•6 citations

Popper, probabilidade e mecânica quântica

Freire Jr., Olival

RESUMO: Este trabalho analisa idéias e atividades de Karl Popper referentes à controvérsia sobre interpretações e fundamentos da mecânica quântica. Atenção especial será dedicada às relações entre Popper e o físico italiano Franco Selleri, ao longo da década de 1980. A interpretação proposta por Popper para os enunciados probabilísticos como propensões, bem como seu ponto de vista realista, contribuíram para estabelecer uma ponte entre suas investigações filosóficas e a pesquisa física em mecânica quântica, ainda que sua idéia sobre as propensões tenha tido uma pequena repercussão entre físicos, matemáticos e filósofos. Argumentaremos neste trabalho que a influência de Popper na física foi possível devido à legitimação, a partir de 1970, da controvérsia sobre os fundamentos da teoria quântica como uma genuína controvérsia científica com implicações filosóficas. Popper foi beneficiado por essa legitimação, mas ele também contribuiu para fazer aquela controvérsia chegar a um público mais amplo que aquele dos físicos envolvidos na própria controvérsia. Palavras-chave: Popper, propensões, mecânica quântica, Selleri, ondas vazias. POPPER, PROBALITY AND QUANTUM MECHANICS Abstract: I intend to present in this paper Karl Popper’s ideas and activities concerning the controversy about the interpretations and foundations of quantum mechanics. I will pay special attention to Popper’s relationship with the Italian physicist Franco Selleri, during the 1980s. Popper’s ideas of propensity and realism contributed to build a bridge between his philosophy and physical research in quantum mechanics, even if his idea of propensity has had a weak reception among physicists, mathematicians and philosophers. I will argue that Popper’s contributions to physics were possible due to the legitimization in the 1970s of the controversy about the foundations of quantum mechanics, a process which permitted a trading zone between physics and philosophy. Popper was benefited by that process, but he also contributed to give to that controversy a larger audience than that of the physicists involved in that controversy. Keywords: Popper, propensities, quantum mechanics, Selleri, empty waves.

•Jun 1, 2004•2 citations

Popper's propensity interpretation of probability and quantum mechanics

Jeffrey Bub

1 online resource (PDF, page 416-429)

•Jan 1, 1975•7 citations
The propensity interpretation of probability is introduced faithfully with Popper's original description. It is shown that the propensity interpretation itself has little to do with the central problem of quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, some insights of Popper seem to have meanings in modern interpretations of quantum mechanics. Especially, the relation to stochastic mechanics and stochastic interpretation of quantum mechanics is considered. Many respects of the propensity interpretation are on Popper's intention or almost accidentally same with the stochastic interpretation when the stochasticity is considered to be objective. We give also some details to be supplemented for the realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics by means of the stochastic interpretation, most of which are neglected in Popper's consideration.
Popper's program in the foundations of quantum mechanics defending objectivity and realism developed out of a profound dissatisfaction with the point of view associated with Bohr, which is usually designated the Copenhagen interpretation. Here I will argue that while Popper's aim is a noble one, his program does not succeed on two counts: he does not succeed in showing that Bohr's philosophy must be rejected as a variety of subjectivism, and his alternative interpretation of indeterminacy rests on a highly questionable assumption according to which simultaneously precise conjugate parameters are possible. Nevertheless I like Popper's propensity interpretation of probability and think that the propensity idea deserves further research. Quanta 2012; 1: 33–57.
Several philosophers of science have claimed that the conceptual difficulties of quantum mechanics can be resolved by appealing to a particular interpretation of probability theory. For example, Popper bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the propensity interpretation of probability, and Margenau bases his treatment of quantum mechanics on the frequency interpretation of probability. The purpose of this paper is (i) to consider and reject such claims, and (ii) to discuss the question of whether the ψ-function refers to an individual system or to an ensemble of systems.
RESUMO: Este trabalho analisa idéias e atividades de Karl Popper referentes à controvérsia sobre interpretações e fundamentos da mecânica quântica. Atenção especial será dedicada às relações entre Popper e o físico italiano Franco Selleri, ao longo da década de 1980. A interpretação proposta por Popper para os enunciados probabilísticos como propensões, bem como seu ponto de vista realista, contribuíram para estabelecer uma ponte entre suas investigações filosóficas e a pesquisa física em mecânica quântica, ainda que sua idéia sobre as propensões tenha tido uma pequena repercussão entre físicos, matemáticos e filósofos. Argumentaremos neste trabalho que a influência de Popper na física foi possível devido à legitimação, a partir de 1970, da controvérsia sobre os fundamentos da teoria quântica como uma genuína controvérsia científica com implicações filosóficas. Popper foi beneficiado por essa legitimação, mas ele também contribuiu para fazer aquela controvérsia chegar a um público mais amplo que aquele dos físicos envolvidos na própria controvérsia. Palavras-chave: Popper, propensões, mecânica quântica, Selleri, ondas vazias. POPPER, PROBALITY AND QUANTUM MECHANICS Abstract: I intend to present in this paper Karl Popper’s ideas and activities concerning the controversy about the interpretations and foundations of quantum mechanics. I will pay special attention to Popper’s relationship with the Italian physicist Franco Selleri, during the 1980s. Popper’s ideas of propensity and realism contributed to build a bridge between his philosophy and physical research in quantum mechanics, even if his idea of propensity has had a weak reception among physicists, mathematicians and philosophers. I will argue that Popper’s contributions to physics were possible due to the legitimization in the 1970s of the controversy about the foundations of quantum mechanics, a process which permitted a trading zone between physics and philosophy. Popper was benefited by that process, but he also contributed to give to that controversy a larger audience than that of the physicists involved in that controversy. Keywords: Popper, propensities, quantum mechanics, Selleri, empty waves.