Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Light Science & Applications

Coherent control of electron-ion entanglement in multiphoton ionization

Yi-Jia Mao, Zhaohan Zhang, Yang Li, Takeshi Sato, Kenichi L. Ishikawa, Feng He

Published Mar 6, 2026• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Quantitative control and measurement of quantum entanglement are essential for advancing quantum technologies. Photoionization induced by ultrashort laser pulses provides a unique platform for studying entanglement between photoelectrons and residual ions, representing one of the most intriguing quantum phenomena in attosecond physics. Although extensive studies have focused on the coherence properties within either the emitted electrons or the ions individually, the electron-ion entanglement has remained largely unexplored. In this work, we bridge this gap by investigating the resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization of argon atoms driven by two time-delayed ultrashort ultraviolet pulses. Employing state-of-the-art first-principles multi-electron simulations, we demonstrate the ability to reconstruct and precisely manipulate the purity of electron quantum states through detailed analysis of the photoelectron angular distributions. Our results reveal distinct scattering-phase differences among various electron configurations within the same partial wave channel, providing unequivocal evidence of electron-ion correlation and entanglement. With the fast development of free-electron lasers, this study establishes an experimentally feasible framework for directly controlling quantum entanglement in ultrafast ionization processes, offering new insights and powerful methodologies for exploring complex electron dynamics in many-electron systems.

DOI
10.1038/s41377-025-02151-y

Related papers

Coherent Control of Absorption and Entanglement via Ultrafast Strong Coupling

Axel Stenquist

This thesis investigates quantum dynamics induced in atoms by ultrashort pulses of light. The work is motivated by recent developments in free-electron lasers, which generate ultrashort pulses of intense, coherent light and enable coherent control of quantum dynamics. We develop theoretical models to study the processes of absorption and emission in laser-atom interactions. Additionally, we study photoionisation, which creates an ion and an electron, and the entanglement that can be generated between these particles. Finally, we have investigated how the spontaneous decay of the ion induces entanglement transfer from the ion-electron pair to the electron-photon pair.This thesis compiles seven papers. Paper I investigates the absorption of light from an attosecond pulse by an atom in a prepared coherent superposition of states. We show how the evolution of the phase of the superposition wave packet influences the attosecond transient absorption spectra. Paper II predicts the existence of Mollow-like triplets in the absorption spectra of strongly coupled atoms. We establish the conditions for the pulse envelope under which this triplet pattern can be supported.Paper III studies two-photon Rabi oscillations, establishing which systems can sustain such dynamics. We find that a two-photon Rabi oscillating system can induce giant counter-rotating oscillations in the population dynamics, enabling investigations of physical effects beyond the rotating-wave approximation.Paper IV studies ionisation from an atom strongly coupled by a dichromatic field, where interference between the two frequency components shapes the temporal symmetry of the atomic dynamics, allowing for coherent control of the photoelectron distribution.Paper V considers an experiment performed at a Free-Electron Laser facility where a helium atom is ionised and the resulting ion is subsequently strongly coupled. The photoelectron spectra are theoretically reproduced and the entanglement between the ion and photoelectron is studied. Paper VI investigates how the entanglement in the ion--electron pair, generated via photoionisation followed by strong coupling, can be coherently controlled by harnessing the time symmetry of the pulse. We find that the observable manifestation of the entanglement can be altered in such a way that the electron energy becomes associated with the ionic state, allowing the entanglement to be detected via coincidence measurements. Paper VII investigates how quantum correlations between the ion and the electron can be coherently controlled by sequential strong coupling of the ion. We find that both the build-up of entanglement and its manifestation can be controlled, and we establish a quantitative measure of the amplitude entanglement that explains the dynamics in an intuitive way. Paper VIII studies the process of entanglement transfer induced by the spontaneous decay of the ion. We find that the ion--electron entanglement generated during the ultrashort interaction with the laser field is transferred to the electron--photon system over the much longer timescale of fluorescence.

•Sep 3, 2026•0 citations

Coherent Control of Ion-Photoelectron Dynamics through Rabi Oscillations: An ab initio study

Shen, Bo-Ren, Yi-Jia Mao, Zhaohan Zhang +4 more

We present first-principles numerical simulations of photoionization in neon induced by bichromatic extreme ultraviolet pulses with frequencies $ω$ and $2ω$, specially chosen to make $ω$ equal to the energy difference between the $2s$ and $2p$ subshells. This allows for the production of photoelectrons from the $2s$ shell by $2ω$ pulse and from the $2p$ shell by $ω$ pulse with the same energy. Using the multi-configurational time-dependent Hartree-Fock method, we explore how Rabi coupling between subshells generates coherence between the corresponding photoelectron wave packets. Our \textit{ab initio} calculations confirm the analytical results derived from the essential-states approach in [K. L. Ishikawa, K. C. Prince, and K. Ueda, J. Phys. Chem. A 127, 10638 (2023)], validating the theoretical predictions. Although we focus on the Ne $2p$ and $2s$ subshells, our approach is applicable to a broad range of systems exhibiting photoionization from multiple subshells. The laser parameters employed in our simulations are available in modern Free Electron Lasers (FELs), and we anticipate that this work could stimulate experimental investigations using FELs to study ion-photoelectron coherence and entanglement.

arXiv:2505.19681•May 26, 2025•0 citations

Bell Test of Quantum Entanglement in Attosecond Photoionization

Marco Ruberti, Vitali Averbukh, Florian Mintert

Attosecond physics enables the study of ultrafast coherent electron dynamics in matter upon photoexcitation and photoionization, revealing spectacular effects such as hole migration and coherent Auger dynamics in molecules. In the photoionization scenario, there has been a strong focus on probing the physical manifestations of internal quantum coherence within the individual parent ion and photoelectron systems. However, quantum correlations between these two subsystems emerging from attosecond photoionization events have thus far remained much more elusive. In this work, we design theoretically and model numerically a direct probe of quantum entanglement in attosecond photoionization in the form of a Bell test. We simulate from first principles a Bell test protocol for the case of noble gas atoms photoionized by ultrashort, circularly polarized infrared laser pulses in the strong-field regime predicting robust violation of the Bell inequality. This theoretical result paves the way for the direct observation of entanglement in the context of ultrafast photoionization of many-electron systems. Our work provides a novel perspective on attosecond physics directed toward the detection of quantum correlations between systems born during attosecond photoionization and unraveling the signatures of entanglement in ultrafast coherent molecular dynamics, including in the chemical decomposition pathways of molecular ions. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2312.05036•Physical Review X•Nov 13, 2024•15 citations

Coherent Control of Quantum and Classical Correlations in Photoionization

Axel Stenquist, Jan Marcus Dahlström

The ability to control quantum correlations in strongly driven systems is a central challenge across quantum science, with implications for ultrafast dynamics, quantum control, and information processing. In photoionization, the emitted electron and residual ion may form an entangled system whose correlations encode the underlying light-matter interaction, yet control of their generation and observable manifestation in continuum systems remains largely unexplored. Here we demonstrate phase-resolved control of electron-ion correlations using phase-locked pulse sequences in the strong-coupling regime. We show that entanglement can be halted and reshaped with attosecond precision, and that phase-dependent correlations can be redistributed into population-based correlations, leading to entanglement that is directly reflected in joint observables. These results establish a route to coherently shape entanglement in photoionization and open new possibilities for accessing and controlling quantum correlations in systems where measurements are intrinsically basis constrained.

quant-pharXiv:2606.30038•Jun 30, 2026•0 citations

Attosecond Coherent Control of Single and Double Photoionization in Argon

Craig Hogle, Xiao‐Min Tong, Leigh S. Martin +3 more

Ultrafast high harmonic beams provide new opportunities for coherently controlling excitation and ionization processes in atoms, molecules, and materials on attosecond time scales by employing multiphoton two-pathway electron-wave-packet quantum interferences. Here we use spectrally tailored and frequency tuned vacuum and extreme ultraviolet harmonic combs, together with two phase-locked infrared laser fields, to show how the total single and double photoionization yields of argon can be coherently modulated by controlling the relative phases of both optical and electronic-wave-packet quantum interferences. This Letter is the first to apply quantum control techniques to double photoionization, which is a fundamental process where a single, high-energy photon ionizes two electrons simultaneously from an atom.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 22, 2015•17 citations

Time Delays as Attosecond Probe of Interelectronic Coherence and Entanglement

Wei‐Chao Jiang, Ming-Chen Zhong, Yong-Kang Fang +4 more

Attosecond chronoscopy enables the exploration of correlated electron dynamics in real time. One key observable of attosecond physics is the determination of "time zero" of photoionization, the time delay with which the wave packet of the ionized electron departs from the ionic core. This observable has become accessible by experimental advances in attosecond streaking and reconstruction of attosecond beating by interference of two-photon transitions (RABBIT) techniques. In this Letter, we explore photoionization time delays by strong extreme ultraviolet fields beyond the linear-response limit. We identify novel signatures in time delays signifying strong coupling between atoms and light fields and the light-field dressing of the ion. As a prototypical case, we study the interelectronic coherence and entanglement in helium driven by a strong extreme ultraviolet field. By the numerical solution of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation in its full dimensionality, we show that the time delay of the photoionized electron allows one to monitor the ultrafast variations of coherence dynamics and entanglement in real time.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 15, 2024•31 citations
Quantitative control and measurement of quantum entanglement are essential for advancing quantum technologies. Photoionization induced by ultrashort laser pulses provides a unique platform for studying entanglement between photoelectrons and residual ions, representing one of the most intriguing quantum phenomena in attosecond physics. Although extensive studies have focused on the coherence properties within either the emitted electrons or the ions individually, the electron-ion entanglement has remained largely unexplored. In this work, we bridge this gap by investigating the resonance-enhanced multiphoton ionization of argon atoms driven by two time-delayed ultrashort ultraviolet pulses. Employing state-of-the-art first-principles multi-electron simulations, we demonstrate the ability to reconstruct and precisely manipulate the purity of electron quantum states through detailed analysis of the photoelectron angular distributions. Our results reveal distinct scattering-phase differences among various electron configurations within the same partial wave channel, providing unequivocal evidence of electron-ion correlation and entanglement. With the fast development of free-electron lasers, this study establishes an experimentally feasible framework for directly controlling quantum entanglement in ultrafast ionization processes, offering new insights and powerful methodologies for exploring complex electron dynamics in many-electron systems.
This thesis investigates quantum dynamics induced in atoms by ultrashort pulses of light. The work is motivated by recent developments in free-electron lasers, which generate ultrashort pulses of intense, coherent light and enable coherent control of quantum dynamics. We develop theoretical models to study the processes of absorption and emission in laser-atom interactions. Additionally, we study photoionisation, which creates an ion and an electron, and the entanglement that can be generated between these particles. Finally, we have investigated how the spontaneous decay of the ion induces entanglement transfer from the ion-electron pair to the electron-photon pair.This thesis compiles seven papers. Paper I investigates the absorption of light from an attosecond pulse by an atom in a prepared coherent superposition of states. We show how the evolution of the phase of the superposition wave packet influences the attosecond transient absorption spectra. Paper II predicts the existence of Mollow-like triplets in the absorption spectra of strongly coupled atoms. We establish the conditions for the pulse envelope under which this triplet pattern can be supported.Paper III studies two-photon Rabi oscillations, establishing which systems can sustain such dynamics. We find that a two-photon Rabi oscillating system can induce giant counter-rotating oscillations in the population dynamics, enabling investigations of physical effects beyond the rotating-wave approximation.Paper IV studies ionisation from an atom strongly coupled by a dichromatic field, where interference between the two frequency components shapes the temporal symmetry of the atomic dynamics, allowing for coherent control of the photoelectron distribution.Paper V considers an experiment performed at a Free-Electron Laser facility where a helium atom is ionised and the resulting ion is subsequently strongly coupled. The photoelectron spectra are theoretically reproduced and the entanglement between the ion and photoelectron is studied. Paper VI investigates how the entanglement in the ion--electron pair, generated via photoionisation followed by strong coupling, can be coherently controlled by harnessing the time symmetry of the pulse. We find that the observable manifestation of the entanglement can be altered in such a way that the electron energy becomes associated with the ionic state, allowing the entanglement to be detected via coincidence measurements. Paper VII investigates how quantum correlations between the ion and the electron can be coherently controlled by sequential strong coupling of the ion. We find that both the build-up of entanglement and its manifestation can be controlled, and we establish a quantitative measure of the amplitude entanglement that explains the dynamics in an intuitive way. Paper VIII studies the process of entanglement transfer induced by the spontaneous decay of the ion. We find that the ion--electron entanglement generated during the ultrashort interaction with the laser field is transferred to the electron--photon system over the much longer timescale of fluorescence.
We present first-principles numerical simulations of photoionization in neon induced by bichromatic extreme ultraviolet pulses with frequencies ωωω and 2ω2ω2ω, specially chosen to make ωωω equal to the energy difference between the 2s2s2s and 2p2p2p subshells. This allows for the production of photoelectrons from the 2s2s2s shell by 2ω2ω2ω pulse and from the 2p2p2p shell by ωωω pulse with the same energy. Using the multi-configurational time-dependent Hartree-Fock method, we explore how Rabi coupling between subshells generates coherence between the corresponding photoelectron wave packets. Our \textit{ab initio} calculations confirm the analytical results derived from the essential-states approach in [K. L. Ishikawa, K. C. Prince, and K. Ueda, J. Phys. Chem. A 127, 10638 (2023)], validating the theoretical predictions. Although we focus on the Ne 2p2p2p and 2s2s2s subshells, our approach is applicable to a broad range of systems exhibiting photoionization from multiple subshells. The laser parameters employed in our simulations are available in modern Free Electron Lasers (FELs), and we anticipate that this work could stimulate experimental investigations using FELs to study ion-photoelectron coherence and entanglement.
Attosecond physics enables the study of ultrafast coherent electron dynamics in matter upon photoexcitation and photoionization, revealing spectacular effects such as hole migration and coherent Auger dynamics in molecules. In the photoionization scenario, there has been a strong focus on probing the physical manifestations of internal quantum coherence within the individual parent ion and photoelectron systems. However, quantum correlations between these two subsystems emerging from attosecond photoionization events have thus far remained much more elusive. In this work, we design theoretically and model numerically a direct probe of quantum entanglement in attosecond photoionization in the form of a Bell test. We simulate from first principles a Bell test protocol for the case of noble gas atoms photoionized by ultrashort, circularly polarized infrared laser pulses in the strong-field regime predicting robust violation of the Bell inequality. This theoretical result paves the way for the direct observation of entanglement in the context of ultrafast photoionization of many-electron systems. Our work provides a novel perspective on attosecond physics directed toward the detection of quantum correlations between systems born during attosecond photoionization and unraveling the signatures of entanglement in ultrafast coherent molecular dynamics, including in the chemical decomposition pathways of molecular ions. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
The ability to control quantum correlations in strongly driven systems is a central challenge across quantum science, with implications for ultrafast dynamics, quantum control, and information processing. In photoionization, the emitted electron and residual ion may form an entangled system whose correlations encode the underlying light-matter interaction, yet control of their generation and observable manifestation in continuum systems remains largely unexplored. Here we demonstrate phase-resolved control of electron-ion correlations using phase-locked pulse sequences in the strong-coupling regime. We show that entanglement can be halted and reshaped with attosecond precision, and that phase-dependent correlations can be redistributed into population-based correlations, leading to entanglement that is directly reflected in joint observables. These results establish a route to coherently shape entanglement in photoionization and open new possibilities for accessing and controlling quantum correlations in systems where measurements are intrinsically basis constrained.
Ultrafast high harmonic beams provide new opportunities for coherently controlling excitation and ionization processes in atoms, molecules, and materials on attosecond time scales by employing multiphoton two-pathway electron-wave-packet quantum interferences. Here we use spectrally tailored and frequency tuned vacuum and extreme ultraviolet harmonic combs, together with two phase-locked infrared laser fields, to show how the total single and double photoionization yields of argon can be coherently modulated by controlling the relative phases of both optical and electronic-wave-packet quantum interferences. This Letter is the first to apply quantum control techniques to double photoionization, which is a fundamental process where a single, high-energy photon ionizes two electrons simultaneously from an atom.
Attosecond chronoscopy enables the exploration of correlated electron dynamics in real time. One key observable of attosecond physics is the determination of "time zero" of photoionization, the time delay with which the wave packet of the ionized electron departs from the ionic core. This observable has become accessible by experimental advances in attosecond streaking and reconstruction of attosecond beating by interference of two-photon transitions (RABBIT) techniques. In this Letter, we explore photoionization time delays by strong extreme ultraviolet fields beyond the linear-response limit. We identify novel signatures in time delays signifying strong coupling between atoms and light fields and the light-field dressing of the ion. As a prototypical case, we study the interelectronic coherence and entanglement in helium driven by a strong extreme ultraviolet field. By the numerical solution of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation in its full dimensionality, we show that the time delay of the photoionized electron allows one to monitor the ultrafast variations of coherence dynamics and entanglement in real time.