Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum computing fundamentals with mixed qubit types in 137Ba+

Jamie Leppard

Published Jan 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Trapped-ion systems are leading candidates for quantum computing, offering long coherence times and high-fidelity gate operations. Scaling them, however, requires advanced capabilities such as mid-circuit measurement, qubit reset, and cooling, which together enable quantum error correction. One approach is the use of mixed qubit types, for example employing different ion species for cooling and computation. Recently, the omg blueprint [1] has gained attention as a method for coherently converting between qubit types within a single ion species, removing the overhead of mixed-species architectures while retaining their flexibility. In this thesis, we realise mixed qubit types in 137Ba+ using optical and metastable qubits. We demonstrate coherent control of both, as well as their coherent interconversion, achieving error rates at the 10−4 level suitable for NISQ applications. To enable selective control in multi-ion chains, we integrate a novel photonic chip for individual addressing of Raman beams [2]. We achieve cross-talk levels at or below 10−3 across all zones, and as low as 10−5 in some cases, establishing the scalability of our approach. Building on this, we present a new protocol for heralded state preparation and measurement (SPAM) [3]. This approach combines high-fidelity measurement with coherent conversion between qubit types to mitigate errors associated with qubit loss, decay, and imperfect SPAM. We demonstrate record-low SPAM error rates across optical, metastable, and ground-state qubits, with a minimum of 5(4)×10−6. This protocol can be integrated with erasure conversion techniques to enable in-sequence qubit loss correction, providing a pathway to scalable error correction even with finite qubit lifetimes. Finally, we introduce two-qubit operations through an implementation of the optical-transition dipole force (OTDF) gate [4]. This is the first implementation of the OTDF gate in 137Ba+, or in any ion with hyperfine structure, and it is directly compatible with our existing 532 nm laser system. Crucially, this gate operates in the σZ basis, avoiding the need for phase coherence between the driving field and the qubit, making it an excellent candidate for use in mixed-qubit-type systems. These results demonstrate the application of mixed-qubit-type architectures within a single ion species and establish a foundation for scaling trapped-ion quantum computers.

DOI
10.5287/ora-zro8gbedw

Related papers

High-fidelity entanglement of metastable trapped-ion qubits with integrated erasure conversion

A. Quinn, G. J. Gregory, I. D. Moore +6 more

Today's most advanced ion trap quantum computers have significant overhead due to the need for dual-species operation. Looking ahead, logical qubit register sizes will be limited by the encoding rate needed to correct generic Pauli errors. We address both of these issues by establishing high-fidelity control of metastable qubits, a key component of \textit{omg} or dual-type architectures, which enables converting a significant fraction of gate errors to erasures. We first implement an erasure conversion scheme which enables detection of $\sim 94\%$ of spontaneous Raman scattering errors during logic gates and nearly all errors from qubit decay. Second, we perform a two-ion geometric phase gate using far-detuned (-44\,THz) stimulated Raman transitions to produce an entangled state with a raw Bell state fidelity of 97.73\% and a SPAM-corrected Bell state fidelity of 98.61\%. When subtracting erasure errors, this fidelity becomes 99.16\%. These results, along with projections based on our detailed error budget, demonstrate metastable trapped-ion qubits as a platform for low-overhead, fault-tolerant quantum computing.

arXiv:2411.12727•Physical Review A•Mar 17, 2026•1 citation

Tips and Tricks for Building a Quantum Computer with $^{133}\mathrm{Ba}^{+}$

Zachary James Wall

Building a fault-tolerant quantum computer requires more than improving physical hardware in isolation. Hardware-level design choices must be guided by the architecture of the full quantum computer and by the bottlenecks that ultimately limit its performance. The 133Ba+ ion is well suited for this kind of architecture-driven optimization. Its simple nuclear spin structure, with I = 1/2, enables fast, high-fidelity state preparation and measurement (SPAM). We leverage this advantage to demonstrate record SPAM fidelity, along with a state-preparation time more than three orders of magnitude faster than previous record-level SPAM demonstrations. This makes 133Ba+ especially promising as a reusable ancilla qubit for quantum error correction.The long-lived D5/2 state, with τ = 30 s, also makes 133Ba+ uniquely positioned to take advantage of the optical-metastable-ground (OMG) qubit protocol, which enables same-species sympathetic cooling. Within this protocol, we demonstrate a magic polarization condition that allows global gates with 532 nm light to be applied in one qubit subspace while leaving other subspaces largely unaffected. We also demonstrate stimulated Raman gates in both the ground and metastable qubit subspaces with errors below the fault-tolerance threshold, supported by a direct measurement of the spontaneous Raman scattering rate. The main practical drawback of 133Ba+ is its radioactivity. Here, we mitigate this challenge by demonstrating ion loading from a 133Ba target below the Nuclear Regulatory Commission exempt quantity of 10 µCi. This is enabled by a new autoionization loading scheme that substantially reduces loading times for barium ions.

•Sep 11, 2026•0 citations

Mixed-Species Ion Chains for Quantum Networks

Ksenia Sosnova

Quantum computing promises solutions to some of the world's most important problems that classical computers have failed to address. The trapped-ion-based quantum computing platform has a lot of advantages for doing so: ions are perfectly identical and near-perfectly isolated, feature long coherent times, and allow high-fidelity individual laser-controlled operations. One of the greatest remaining obstacles in trapped-ion-based quantum computing is the issue of scalability. The approach that we take to address this issue is a modular architecture: separate ion traps, each with a manageable number of ions, are interconnected via photonic links. To avoid photon-generated crosstalk between qubits and utilize advantages of different kinds of ions for each role, we use two distinct species - ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ as memory qubits and ¹³⁸Ba⁺ as communication qubits. The qubits based on ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ are defined within the hyperfine "clock" states characterized by a very long coherence time while ¹³⁸Ba⁺ ions feature visible-range wavelength emission lines. Current optical and fiber technologies are more efficient in this range than at shorter wavelengths. We present a theoretical description and experimental demonstration of the key elements of a quantum network based on the mixed-species paradigm. The first one is entanglement between an atomic qubit and the polarization degree of freedom of a pure single photon. We observe a value of the second-order correlation function g⁽²⁾(0) = (8.1 ± 2.3)⨉10⁻⁵ without background subtraction, which is consistent with the lowest reported value in any system. Next, we show mixed-species entangling gates with two ions using the Mølmer-Sørensen and Cirac-Zoller protocols. Finally, we theoretically generalize mixed-species entangling gates to long ion chains and characterize the roles of normal modes there. In addition, we explore sympathetic cooling efficiency in such mixed-species crystals. Besides these developments, we demonstrate new techniques for manipulating states within the D₃⸝₂-manifold of zero-nuclear-spin ions - a part of a protected qubit scheme promising seconds-long coherence times proposed by Aharon et al. in 2013. As a next step, we provide a detailed description of the protocols for three- and four-node networks with mixed species, along with a novel design for the third trap with in-vacuum optics to optimize light collection.

•Jan 1, 2020•1 citation

Long-lived metastable-qubit memory

Xiaoyang Shi, Jasmine Sinanan-Singh, Kyle DeBry +3 more

Coherent storage of quantum information is crucial to many quantum technologies. Long coherence times have been demonstrated in trapped-ion qubits, typically using the hyperfine levels within the ground state of a single ion. However, recent research suggests qubits encoded in metastable states could provide architectural benefits for quantum information processing, such as the possibility of effective dual-species operation in a single-species system and erasure-error conversion for fault-tolerant quantum computing. Here we demonstrate long-lived encoding of a quantum state in the metastable states of a trapped ion. By sympathetically cooling with another ion of the same species and constantly monitoring for erasure errors, we demonstrate a coherence time of 136(42) seconds with a qubit encoded in the metastable $5D_{5/2}$ state of a single $^{137}$Ba$^+$ ion. In agreement with a model based on empirical results from dynamical-decoupling-based noise spectroscopy, we find that dephasing of the metastable levels is the dominant source of error once erasure errors are removed.

arXiv:2408.00975•Aug 2, 2024•0 citations

High-fidelity mixed species entanglement of trapped ions

K. Thirumalai

Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.

•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

Experimental Realization of Direct Entangling Gates between Dual-Type Qubits

Chenxi Wang, Chuanxin Huang, Hongxuan Zhang +6 more

Dual-type qubits have become a promising way to suppress the crosstalk error of auxiliary operations in large-scale ion trap quantum computation. Here we demonstrate a direct entangling gate between dual-type qubits encoded in the S_{1/2} and D_{5/2} hyperfine manifolds of ^{137}Ba^{+} ions. Our scheme is economic in the hardware, requiring only a single 532 nm laser system to entangle both qubit types by driving their Raman transitions. We achieve a Bell state fidelity of 96.3(4)% for the dual-type Molmer-Sorensen gate between an S-D ion pair, comparable to that for the same-type S-S or D-D gates. This technique can reduce the overhead for back-and-forth conversions between dual-type qubits in the quantum circuit with wide applications in quantum error correction and ion-photon quantum networks.

arXiv:2410.05659•Physical Review Letters•Jan 3, 2025•5 citations
Trapped-ion systems are leading candidates for quantum computing, offering long coherence times and high-fidelity gate operations. Scaling them, however, requires advanced capabilities such as mid-circuit measurement, qubit reset, and cooling, which together enable quantum error correction. One approach is the use of mixed qubit types, for example employing different ion species for cooling and computation. Recently, the omg blueprint [1] has gained attention as a method for coherently converting between qubit types within a single ion species, removing the overhead of mixed-species architectures while retaining their flexibility. In this thesis, we realise mixed qubit types in 137Ba+ using optical and metastable qubits. We demonstrate coherent control of both, as well as their coherent interconversion, achieving error rates at the 10−4 level suitable for NISQ applications. To enable selective control in multi-ion chains, we integrate a novel photonic chip for individual addressing of Raman beams [2]. We achieve cross-talk levels at or below 10−3 across all zones, and as low as 10−5 in some cases, establishing the scalability of our approach. Building on this, we present a new protocol for heralded state preparation and measurement (SPAM) [3]. This approach combines high-fidelity measurement with coherent conversion between qubit types to mitigate errors associated with qubit loss, decay, and imperfect SPAM. We demonstrate record-low SPAM error rates across optical, metastable, and ground-state qubits, with a minimum of 5(4)×10−6. This protocol can be integrated with erasure conversion techniques to enable in-sequence qubit loss correction, providing a pathway to scalable error correction even with finite qubit lifetimes. Finally, we introduce two-qubit operations through an implementation of the optical-transition dipole force (OTDF) gate [4]. This is the first implementation of the OTDF gate in 137Ba+, or in any ion with hyperfine structure, and it is directly compatible with our existing 532 nm laser system. Crucially, this gate operates in the σZ basis, avoiding the need for phase coherence between the driving field and the qubit, making it an excellent candidate for use in mixed-qubit-type systems. These results demonstrate the application of mixed-qubit-type architectures within a single ion species and establish a foundation for scaling trapped-ion quantum computers.
Today's most advanced ion trap quantum computers have significant overhead due to the need for dual-species operation. Looking ahead, logical qubit register sizes will be limited by the encoding rate needed to correct generic Pauli errors. We address both of these issues by establishing high-fidelity control of metastable qubits, a key component of \textit{omg} or dual-type architectures, which enables converting a significant fraction of gate errors to erasures. We first implement an erasure conversion scheme which enables detection of ∼94%\sim 94\%∼94% of spontaneous Raman scattering errors during logic gates and nearly all errors from qubit decay. Second, we perform a two-ion geometric phase gate using far-detuned (-44\,THz) stimulated Raman transitions to produce an entangled state with a raw Bell state fidelity of 97.73\% and a SPAM-corrected Bell state fidelity of 98.61\%. When subtracting erasure errors, this fidelity becomes 99.16\%. These results, along with projections based on our detailed error budget, demonstrate metastable trapped-ion qubits as a platform for low-overhead, fault-tolerant quantum computing.
Tips and Tricks for Building a Quantum Computer with 133Ba+^{133}\mathrm{Ba}^{+}133Ba+
Building a fault-tolerant quantum computer requires more than improving physical hardware in isolation. Hardware-level design choices must be guided by the architecture of the full quantum computer and by the bottlenecks that ultimately limit its performance. The 133Ba+ ion is well suited for this kind of architecture-driven optimization. Its simple nuclear spin structure, with I = 1/2, enables fast, high-fidelity state preparation and measurement (SPAM). We leverage this advantage to demonstrate record SPAM fidelity, along with a state-preparation time more than three orders of magnitude faster than previous record-level SPAM demonstrations. This makes 133Ba+ especially promising as a reusable ancilla qubit for quantum error correction.The long-lived D5/2 state, with τ = 30 s, also makes 133Ba+ uniquely positioned to take advantage of the optical-metastable-ground (OMG) qubit protocol, which enables same-species sympathetic cooling. Within this protocol, we demonstrate a magic polarization condition that allows global gates with 532 nm light to be applied in one qubit subspace while leaving other subspaces largely unaffected. We also demonstrate stimulated Raman gates in both the ground and metastable qubit subspaces with errors below the fault-tolerance threshold, supported by a direct measurement of the spontaneous Raman scattering rate. The main practical drawback of 133Ba+ is its radioactivity. Here, we mitigate this challenge by demonstrating ion loading from a 133Ba target below the Nuclear Regulatory Commission exempt quantity of 10 µCi. This is enabled by a new autoionization loading scheme that substantially reduces loading times for barium ions.
Quantum computing promises solutions to some of the world's most important problems that classical computers have failed to address. The trapped-ion-based quantum computing platform has a lot of advantages for doing so: ions are perfectly identical and near-perfectly isolated, feature long coherent times, and allow high-fidelity individual laser-controlled operations. One of the greatest remaining obstacles in trapped-ion-based quantum computing is the issue of scalability. The approach that we take to address this issue is a modular architecture: separate ion traps, each with a manageable number of ions, are interconnected via photonic links. To avoid photon-generated crosstalk between qubits and utilize advantages of different kinds of ions for each role, we use two distinct species - ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ as memory qubits and ¹³⁸Ba⁺ as communication qubits. The qubits based on ¹⁷¹Yb⁺ are defined within the hyperfine "clock" states characterized by a very long coherence time while ¹³⁸Ba⁺ ions feature visible-range wavelength emission lines. Current optical and fiber technologies are more efficient in this range than at shorter wavelengths. We present a theoretical description and experimental demonstration of the key elements of a quantum network based on the mixed-species paradigm. The first one is entanglement between an atomic qubit and the polarization degree of freedom of a pure single photon. We observe a value of the second-order correlation function g⁽²⁾(0) = (8.1 ± 2.3)⨉10⁻⁵ without background subtraction, which is consistent with the lowest reported value in any system. Next, we show mixed-species entangling gates with two ions using the Mølmer-Sørensen and Cirac-Zoller protocols. Finally, we theoretically generalize mixed-species entangling gates to long ion chains and characterize the roles of normal modes there. In addition, we explore sympathetic cooling efficiency in such mixed-species crystals. Besides these developments, we demonstrate new techniques for manipulating states within the D₃⸝₂-manifold of zero-nuclear-spin ions - a part of a protected qubit scheme promising seconds-long coherence times proposed by Aharon et al. in 2013. As a next step, we provide a detailed description of the protocols for three- and four-node networks with mixed species, along with a novel design for the third trap with in-vacuum optics to optimize light collection.
Coherent storage of quantum information is crucial to many quantum technologies. Long coherence times have been demonstrated in trapped-ion qubits, typically using the hyperfine levels within the ground state of a single ion. However, recent research suggests qubits encoded in metastable states could provide architectural benefits for quantum information processing, such as the possibility of effective dual-species operation in a single-species system and erasure-error conversion for fault-tolerant quantum computing. Here we demonstrate long-lived encoding of a quantum state in the metastable states of a trapped ion. By sympathetically cooling with another ion of the same species and constantly monitoring for erasure errors, we demonstrate a coherence time of 136(42) seconds with a qubit encoded in the metastable 5D5/25D_{5/2}5D5/2​ state of a single 137^{137}137Ba+^++ ion. In agreement with a model based on empirical results from dynamical-decoupling-based noise spectroscopy, we find that dephasing of the metastable levels is the dominant source of error once erasure errors are removed.
Harnessing quantum mechanics to solve problems intractable on classical computers is one of the foremost goals of applied physics. Trapped ions make an excellent physical platform for such a quantum computer, as they have demonstrated unparalleled qubit operation fidelities and memory times, but significant challenges remain in scaling up these systems. A promising scalable architecture is a photonically connected network of mixed element trapped ion nodes, each containing a few ions of two species. Poor quality remote entanglement links between nodes can be tolerated, if entanglement between ions in the same node can be achieved with high fidelity. While local gates have been repeatedly demonstrated between ions of the same species, the fidelity of mixed element quantum gates have not previously surpassed the fault tolerant threshold, above which errors can in principle be corrected. In this thesis we demonstrate an entangling operation between 43Ca+, useful for its long lived qubits, and 88Sr+, well suited for remote entanglement, using a novel mechanism requiring only one laser to manipulate both species. This relatively simple scheme, which is independent of either qubit frequency, allows us to achieve Bell state fidelities of F = 99.8(1)%. We assess the operation of the gate further with state and process tomography, which achieve Bell state fidelity F = 98.1% and average gate fidelity F̅ = 99.05(6)% respectively, though they are hampered by experimental drifts during the long data collection. Finally, we use interleaved randomised benchmarking to get the best estimate of our gate errors, finding an average gate fidelity of F̅ = 99.62(3)% for a sequence of 60 interleaved gates. Along with a demonstration of entanglement between two 88Sr+ ions, achieved with fidelity F = 95.9(4)%, this work paves the way towards demonstrating an elementary mixed species quantum network in future experiments.
Dual-type qubits have become a promising way to suppress the crosstalk error of auxiliary operations in large-scale ion trap quantum computation. Here we demonstrate a direct entangling gate between dual-type qubits encoded in the S_{1/2} and D_{5/2} hyperfine manifolds of ^{137}Ba^{+} ions. Our scheme is economic in the hardware, requiring only a single 532 nm laser system to entangle both qubit types by driving their Raman transitions. We achieve a Bell state fidelity of 96.3(4)% for the dual-type Molmer-Sorensen gate between an S-D ion pair, comparable to that for the same-type S-S or D-D gates. This technique can reduce the overhead for back-and-forth conversions between dual-type qubits in the quantum circuit with wide applications in quantum error correction and ion-photon quantum networks.