The extensive value and importance of smart grids are evident in their transformative impact on sustainable urban development. However, the swift progression of quantum computing has made the security and privacy of smart grid communications a pressing and vital issue. Although considerable studies have been carried out on authentication and key agreement within smart grids, the predominant body of solutions either come with substantial computation, communication, and storage overheads, or are primarily single-layer schemes. More importantly, they are not designed to withstand advanced quantum attacks. In this paper, we propose a novel quantum-safe and cross-layer authentication and key agreement protocol, named QCLaka, for smart grid communications that overcomes the shortcomings of existing approaches and offers advanced security and functionality features. The proposed QCLakaprotocol integrates lattice-based cryptography with probability physical unclonable function (Prob-PUF) to enable the local gateway and the smart meter to mutually authenticate each other and establish a secure session key. The security of the proposed QCLakaprotocol is assessed through formal security verification to highlight its safety in adversarial environments and its ability to withstand both well-known and advanced cyberattacks. Additionally, the experimental evaluation shows that the proposed QCLakaprotocol outperforms the benchmark schemes regarding the performance in security and efficiency.
The extensive value and importance of smart grids are evident in their transformative impact on sustainable urban development. However, the swift progression of quantum computing has made the security and privacy of smart grid communications a pressing and vital issue. Although considerable studies have been carried out on authentication and key agreement within smart grids, the predominant body of solutions either come with substantial computation, communication, and storage overheads, or are primarily single-layer schemes. More importantly, they are not designed to withstand advanced quantum attacks. In this paper, we propose a novel quantum-safe and cross-layer authentication and key agreement protocol, named QCLaka, for smart grid communications that overcomes the shortcomings of existing approaches and offers advanced security and functionality features. The proposed QCLakaprotocol integrates lattice-based cryptography with probability physical unclonable function (Prob-PUF) to enable the local gateway and the smart meter to mutually authenticate each other and establish a secure session key. The security of the proposed QCLakaprotocol is assessed through formal security verification to highlight its safety in adversarial environments and its ability to withstand both well-known and advanced cyberattacks. Additionally, the experimental evaluation shows that the proposed QCLakaprotocol outperforms the benchmark schemes regarding the performance in security and efficiency.
The development and evolution of the smart grid into complex, cyber-physical energy systems make it essential to secure?communication among the distributed components. The rise of quantum computing has made it even more pressing to develop protocols that?are secure outside the limitations of classical cryptosystems. In this paper, it proposes a quantum-assisting secure communication scheme (QASCP) to?boost the security and energy for smart grid communication systems. The proposed protocol combines quantum key distribution with lightweight entropy-based mutual authentication and dynamic session management. It is designed to defend grid assets such as control centers, smart meters, and distribute energy?resources from sophisticated adversarial models, including quantum-capable threats. The approach consists of system level simulation utilizing a?co-simulation framework customized for quantum smart grid communication. The performance of this scheme was compared?against classical and PQ lattice-based schemes in terms of the authentication latency, energy consumption, entropy preservation, and scalability to handle the load and delay effects, under the assumptions of different loading and delay scenarios. Simulation results show that QASCP is able to reduce the energy consumption and authenticity latency, simultaneously it keeps the high throughput and leaves strong entropy?under attack scenarios. The protocol is also shown to?remain robust with varying quantum bit error rates as well as having a smaller memory footprint on popular network topologies. The results provide evidence for the practical integration of?quantum-secure communication in smart grid architectures. By addressing security and performance simultaneously, the protocol?provides a path to future-proof energy networks which can support dependable operations in a quantum-enhanced environment. This could be future enhance for energy efficiency.
With the enablement of Internet of Things technology, the electrical grid is currently undergoing a drastic revolution, which is known as smart grid. Since massive sensitive data and control commands transmitted via public channels, the smart grid is challenged by various cyber threats. Authenticated key agreement protocols in smart grid effectively ensure the confidentiality and authentication of communication through mutual authentication and establishing session keys. In this article, we review the existing elliptic curve cryptography (ECC)-based authentication and key agreement protocols in smart gird and perform a security analysis of Hu et al.’s protocol. We exhibit that the protocol fails to resist key compromise impersonation (KCI) attack and cannot provide untraceability. Furthermore, we propose a security-enhanced authentication and key agreement protocol based on ECC, which performs registration, authentication, and key agreement phases over public channels to enable mutual authentication and to establish session keys. The protocol is also proved to be security-enhanced by formal proof and informal analysis. The performance analysis results demonstrate that the proposed protocol is comparable to other existing protocols while achieving enhanced security. Therefore, the protocol satisfies the deployment requirements for resource-constrained smart grid.
Abstract Smart grid (SG) facilitates our lives by providing more reliable electricity and enabling better integration of renewable energy sources. Currently, numerous authentication and key agreement (AKA) protocols have been proposed to secure SG communication. However, these solutions often result in considerable cost, making them inappropriate for resource-constrained SG environment. In this paper, we propose a secure and resource-efficient AKA protocol by employing lightweight cryptography primitives including authenticated encryption with associated data (AEAD) primitive ASCON, hash function and XOR operation. The ASCON primitive simultaneously provides data confidentiality, integrity and authenticity with low computation cost, making it suitable for employing in resource-constrained SG environment. The secret intermediate values in the protocol are designed as hash values that incorporate both long-term and short-term secrets, thereby providing enhanced security while further reducing cost. Moreover, a dynamic indexing method is deployed in the protocol to resist de-synchronization attack. The designed protocol performs secure mutual authentication and session key establishment between entities without relying on a central trusted authority. The proposed protocol is proven secure through rigorous security proof under the real-or-random model and formally verified by AVISPA tool. Theoretical performance analysis and simulation results indicate that the proposed protocol outperforms other related protocols due to its lightweight nature and adherence to all fundamental security attributes, making it suitable for deployment in smart grid environment.
The security landscape will change dramatically with the advent of quantum computers and existing security schemes in various domains including smart grid communications must be updated to make them secure from quantum computer-enabled attacks. In this paper, we propose a quantum-safe mutual authentication protocol, leveraging the concepts of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) and Quantum Random Number Generator (QRNG), for secure communication between smart meters and a server. Unlike conventional schemes based on cryptographic algorithms that rely on difficulties to solve certain mathematical problems, the proposed protocol is secure against attacks arising from quantum computers. In the proposed protocol, QKD is employed to establish secure keys in smart meter communications with provable security while QRNG provides truly random numbers that are unknown to any eavesdropper. Specifically, we employ the Measurement-Device-Independent Quantum Key Distribution (MDI QKD), a type of QKD whose security does not rely on any assumptions about measurement devices. We provide a formal security proof for the proposed scheme under the real-or-random (RoR) model. Additionally, we conduct a proof-of-concept experimental demonstration, using the secure keys from a MDI QKD system and random numbers from QRNG, to demonstrate the feasibility and practicality of the proposed scheme.
The key management faces significant challenges in terms of efficiency, scalability, and quantum resistance in smart grid environments. This paper addresses these challenges by proposing a novel mutual authentication and key agreement (AKA) protocol for the Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era. The protocol integrates quantum and classical information streams, enabling secure key agreement without third-party reliance. For the first time, quantum-based mutual identity authentication is applied to smart grid security, with a comprehensive analysis of resilience against various attacks, including man-in-the-middle, quantum computation, relay, impersonation, and DoS. Experimental results show that the scheme achieves a communication cost of 0.9 KB for 2 rounds, outperforming quantum-resistant schemes (2.5 KB) and performing similarly to classical schemes (1.2 KB). The scheme requires 2 quantum preparations and 1 measurement, offering higher efficiency compared to quantum-resistant methods. Compared to QKD and computational hardness-based models, our approach provides superior key management efficiency, practical implementation in non-fault-tolerant quantum systems, and enhanced security protection. Rigorous analysis and validation using IBM’s quantum-enabled environments demonstrate the robustness of the protocol in addressing modern smart grid security challenges.
The recent advancement of smart grid systems, integrating cyber-physical systems with information and communication technologies enables real-time monitoring, control, and data transmission. However, these operations often inherently insecure communication infrastructures increasing exposure to cyber threats and data breaches. Consequently, cryptographic authenticated and key agreement protocols address cyber-attacks, threats, and vulnerabilities to protect data privacy and security in smart grid. Meanwhile, quantum computing progression is rapidly footprinted in real-world application thus quantum computing-based Grover's and Shor’s algorithm is capable for breaking classical cryptographic algorithms mathematical advances. Therefore, this review explores the adaptability of quantum computing, examines its impact on classical cryptography vulnerabilities, and highlights the role of quantum cryptography in enhancing security and scalability of smart grid cyber-physical systems. Accordingly, a comparative analysis was conducted to assess the security and performance of Rivest-Shamir Adleman, elliptic curve cryptography and digital signature algorithms against quantum cryptography for highlighting their respective strengths and limitations in quantum era context. This review provides a foundation of future researchers for integrate quantum technology and develop quantum-resilient solutions that overcome the constraints of classical cryptography.