The Ehrenfest theorem is a well-known theoretical result of quantum mechanics. It relates the dynamical evolution of the expectation value of a quantum operator to the expectation value of its corresponding commutator with the Hermitian Hamiltonian operator. However, the proof of validity of the Ehrenfest theorem for quantum gravity field theory has remained elusive, while its validation poses challenging conceptual questions. In fact, this presupposes a number of minimum requirements, which include the prescription of quantum Hamiltonian operator, the definition of scalar product, and the identification of dynamical evolution parameter. In this paper, it is proven that the target can be established in the framework of the manifestly covariant quantum gravity theory (CQG theory). This follows as a consequence of its peculiar canonical Hamiltonian structure and the commutator-bracket algebra that characterizes its representation and probabilistic interpretation. The theoretical proof of the theorem for CQG theory permits to elucidate the connection existing between quantum operator variables of gravitational field and the corresponding expectation values to be interpreted as dynamical physical observables set in the background metric space-time.
The Ehrenfest theorem is a well-known theoretical result of quantum mechanics. It relates the dynamical evolution of the expectation value of a quantum operator to the expectation value of its corresponding commutator with the Hermitian Hamiltonian operator. However, the proof of validity of the Ehrenfest theorem for quantum gravity field theory has remained elusive, while its validation poses challenging conceptual questions. In fact, this presupposes a number of minimum requirements, which include the prescription of quantum Hamiltonian operator, the definition of scalar product, and the identification of dynamical evolution parameter. In this paper, it is proven that the target can be established in the framework of the manifestly covariant quantum gravity theory (CQG theory). This follows as a consequence of its peculiar canonical Hamiltonian structure and the commutator-bracket algebra that characterizes its representation and probabilistic interpretation. The theoretical proof of the theorem for CQG theory permits to elucidate the connection existing between quantum operator variables of gravitational field and the corresponding expectation values to be interpreted as dynamical physical observables set in the background metric space-time.
Key aspects of the manifestly-covariant theory of quantum gravity (Cremaschini and Tessarotto 2015–2017) are investigated. These refer, first, to the establishment of the four-scalar, manifestly-covariant evolution quantum wave equation, denoted as covariant quantum gravity (CQG) wave equation, which advances the quantum state ψ associated with a prescribed background space-time. In this paper, the CQG-wave equation is proved to follow at once by means of a Hamilton–Jacobi quantization of the classical variational tensor field g ≡ g μ ν and its conjugate momentum, referred to as (canonical) g-quantization. The same equation is also shown to be variational and to follow from a synchronous variational principle identified here with the quantum Hamilton variational principle. The corresponding quantum hydrodynamic equations are then obtained upon introducing the Madelung representation for ψ , which provides an equivalent statistical interpretation of the CQG-wave equation. Finally, the quantum state ψ is proven to fulfill generalized Heisenberg inequalities, relating the statistical measurement errors of quantum observables. These are shown to be represented in terms of the standard deviations of the metric tensor g ≡ g μ ν and its quantum conjugate momentum operator.
Background:In quantum mechanics energy is an observable, whereas time is a parameter. Pauli's theorem and the problem of time in canonical quantum gravity reflect this asymmetry.Material and methods:We define the time operator t^=x^/c and form, with the relativistic energy E^R, Einstein's constant κ and the time t^0 in the rest system, operators of gravitational-field and curvature type. Commutation relations, wave equations and spectra are derived in the time and in the energy representation.Results:The commutator [t^,E^R]=ciℏv^x is bounded with norm ℏ and is not a multiple of the identity, so Pauli's theorem is not contradicted. The sum ct^+κE^R is unitarily equivalent to the time operator and has a continuous spectrum with explicit eigenfunctions. A postulated field equation, G^0+Λ^=κE^R, has the structure of Einstein's equation; the term Λ^ is an operator with continuous spectrum, the Ricci scalar operator contains the energy, and for small velocities the equation becomes the Schr\"odinger equation of a particle in a homogeneous field.Conclusion:Based on the postulated field equation, a quantization of the gravitational-field and curvature terms is derived: they become operators with explicit commutation relations and spectra. The metric tensor of Einstein's field equation has not been quantized.\par
We revisit the concept of phase time, which has been previously proposed as a solution to the problem of time in quantum gravity. Concretely, we show how the geometry of configuration space together with the phase of the wave function of the Universe can, under certain conditions, lead to the definition of a positive-definite squared norm from which probabilities can be defined. The norm is conserved under time evolution, and we obtain a version of Ehrenfest's theorem that is analogous to the one in ordinary quantum mechanics. We address how the present approach avoids some difficulties that were encountered in previous attempts at defining an Ehrenfest theorem relative to phase time in the context of relativistic quantum mechanics and canonical quantum gravity, and how it is connected to a notion of gauge fixing the inner product. We conclude with a brief outlook.
The dynamics of quantum expectation values is considered in a geometric setting. First, expectation values of the canonical observables are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the action of the Heisenberg group on quantum states. Then, the Hamiltonian structure of Ehrenfest’s theorem is shown to be Lie–Poisson for a semidirect-product Lie group, named the Ehrenfest group . The underlying Poisson structure produces classical and quantum mechanics as special limit cases. In addition, quantum dynamics is expressed in the frame of the expectation values, in which the latter undergo canonical Hamiltonian motion. In the case of Gaussian states, expectation values dynamics couples to second-order moments, which also enjoy a momentum map structure. Eventually, Gaussian states are shown to possess a Lie–Poisson structure associated with another semidirect-product group, which is called the Jacobi group. This structure produces the energy-conserving variant of a class of Gaussian moment models that have previously appeared in the chemical physics literature.
The dynamics of quantum expectation values is considered in a geometric setting. First, expectation values of the canonical operators are shown to be equivariant momentum maps for the action of the Heisenberg group on quantum states. Then, the Hamiltonian structure of Ehrenfest's theorem is shown to be Lie-Poisson for a semidirect-product Lie group, named the `Ehrenfest group'. In addition, quantum dynamics is expressed in the frame of the expectation values, in which the latter undergo canonical Hamiltonian motion. In the case of Gaussian states, expectation values dynamics couples to second-order moments, which also enjoy a momentum map structure. Eventually, Gaussian states are shown to possess a Lie-Poisson structure associated to a semidirect-product subgroup of the Ehrenfest group, which is called the Jacobi group. This structure produces new energy-conserving terms in a class of Gaussian moment models (previously appeared in the chemical physics literature) that suffer from lack of energy conservation in the general case.
The unsatisfactory status of the interpretation of the wave function of the Universe in canonical quantum gravity is reviewed. The ``naive interpretation'' obtained by straightforwardly applying the standard interpretive rules to the canonical quantization of general relativity is manifestly unacceptable; the ``WKB interpretation'' has only a limited domain of applicability; and the ``conditional probability interpretation'' requires one to pick out a ``preferred time variable'' (or preferred class of such variables) from among the dynamical variables. Evidence against the possibility of using a dynamical variable to play the role of ``time'' in the conditional probability interpretation is provided by the fact (proven here) that in ordinary Schr\"odinger quantum mechanics for a system with a Hamiltonian bounded from below, no dynamical variable can correlate monotonically with the Schr\"odinger time parameter t, and thus the role of t in the interpretation of Schr\"odinger quantum mechanics cannot be replaced by that of a dynamical variable. We also argue that the interpretive problems of quantum gravity are not alleviated by the incorporation of observers into the theory. Faced with these difficulties, we seek a formulation of canonical quantum gravity in which an appropriate nondynamical time parameter is present. By analogy with a parametrized form of ordinary Schr\"odinger quantum mechanics, we make a proposal for such a formulation. A specific proposal considered in detail yields a theory which corresponds at the classical level to general relativity with an arbitrary, unspecified cosmological constant. In minisuperspace models, this proposal yields a quantum theory with satisfactory interpretive properties, although it is unlikely that this theory will admit sufficiently many observables for general spacetimes. Nevertheless, we feel that the approach suggested here is worthy of further investigation.