Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

New Journal of Physics

Efficient computation of topological order

Louis Fraatz, Amit Jamadagni, Hendrik Weimer

Published Jan 1, 2026• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract We analyze the computational aspects of detecting topological order in a quantum many-body system. We contrast the widely used topological entanglement entropy with a recently introduced operational definition for topological order based on error correction properties, finding exponential scaling with the system size for the former and polynomial scaling for the latter. We exemplify our approach for a variant of the paradigmatic toric code model with mobile particles, finding that the error correction method allows to treat substantially larger system sizes. In particular, the phase diagram of the model can be successfully computed using error correction, while the topological entanglement entropy is too severely limited by finite size effects to obtain conclusive results. While we mainly focus on one-dimensional systems whose ground states can be expressed in terms of matrix product states, our strategy can be readily generalized to higher dimensions and systems out of equilibrium, even allowing for an efficient detection of topological order in current quantum simulation experiments.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/ae3598

Related papers

Efficient computation of topological order

Louis Fraatz, Amit Jamadagni, Hendrik Weimer

We analyze the computational aspects of detecting topological order in a quantum many-body system. We contrast the widely used topological entanglement entropy with a recently introduced operational definition for topological order based on error correction properties, finding exponential scaling with the system size for the former and polynomial scaling for the latter. We exemplify our approach for a variant of the paradigmatic toric code model with mobile particles, finding that the error correction method allows to treat substantially larger system sizes. In particular, the phase diagram of the model can be successfully computed using error correction, while the topological entanglement entropy is too severely limited by finite size effects to obtain conclusive results. While we mainly focus on one-dimensional systems whose ground states can be expressed in terms of matrix product states, our strategy can be readily generalized to higher dimensions and systems out of equilibrium, even allowing for an efficient detection of topological order in current quantum simulation experiments.

arXiv:2409.12704•Sep 19, 2024•0 citations

Novel approaches to topological order involving open boundaries in closed and open quantum systems

Amit Jamadagni

The fundamental understanding of phases and their transitions has been a central theme in condensed matter physics. Until recently, it was largely believed that the Landau symmetry breaking principle was effective in distinguishing different phases of matter, with broken symmetries signaling the phase transition. But with the discovery of topological phases which are beyond the Landau symmetry breaking principle, the identification and classification of quantum phases at absolute zero has opened up new unexplored avenues thus leading to exciting theoretical discoveries further propelling technological advancement. Topological phases of matter are characterized by the notion of topological order and in this work we aim to explore and understand topological phases by introducing novel signatures which characterize topological order. The robustness of these phases to external perturbation makes them an ideal candidate to store and manipulate quantum information thus making them an unique and interesting prospect for realizing quantum computers. There have been several signatures to characterize intrinsic topological order, for instance the invariance of the topologically ordered state under local operators, the dependence of ground state degeneracy on the underlying manifold and its robustness to external perturbation, topological entanglement entropy related to the quantum dimension of the supers-selection sectors, the inability to construct the topologically ordered state from a product state via constant depth unitary transformations. With toric code as the toy model, we analyze the robustness of topological order on a manifold supporting open boundaries by computing some of the above signatures which effectively detect a topological to trivial phase transition. We then probe the existence of a quantum criticality between distinct topological phases obtained by varying the underlying manifold. In these scenarios, most of the above signatures turn out to be ineffective in detecting the distinct phases leading to the introduction of an non- local order parameter whose construction is facilitated by the phenomenon of anyon condensation. The signatures for quantitatively and qualitatively characterizing intrinsic topological order being highly scenario dependent and also with its definition for mixed states being elusive we introduce an operational definition based on concepts of topological error correction. We define a state to be topologically ordered if the errors in the state can be corrected by an error correction circuit of finite depth. To concretize the notion of topological to trivial phase transition in an open setting we turn to nonequilibrium phenomenon, for example: Directed Percolation, with the change in percolation rate driving a dynamical phase transition between absorbing and active states with the former being topologically ordered while the latter being topologically trivial. Additionally, we explore the notion of topological phase transitions between distinct topological phases obtained by varying underlying topology in an open setting, analogous to the closed setting discussed earlier. To summarize, we have introduced various mixed states which exhibit topological order and also an operational definition to quantify topological order applicable across multitude of scenarios. We extend the above operational definition to quantify and detect quantum phase transitions in the case of Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) phases. To further validate the above notion, we consider the perturbed variants of the Su-Schrieffer–Heeger (SSH) models and detect quantum phase transitions to a high accuracy by employing the techniques from the framework of tensor networks. It is significant to note the distinction of the error correction algorithms applied earlier in the case of intrinsic topological order were independent of symmetry constraints while in the current scenario we impose additional symmetry constraints to accurately detect the phase transition. In addition, we also devise error correction strategies with respect to topologically trivial states to detect quantum phase transitions which do not involve topological phases. This gives rise to a very fundamental question on whether error correction statistics with a well defined error correction algorithm, not necessarily optimal, are capable of detecting a equivalence classes of phases and thereby acting as a reliable probe to effectively detect topological/quantum phase transitions? From theoretical and numerical end of the spectrum we shift gears to explore possible experimental platforms with an aim to realize some of the quantum many-body phenomenon discussed earlier. While there have been several innovative experimental avenues to realize the above, one such promising candidate has been ultracold polar molecules setups that offer additional degrees of freedom due to the ro-vibrational degrees of freedom. Based on the chemical reaction between atoms and molecules which results in a quantum Zeno-based blockade, we devise several optimal strategies to efficiently detect molecules using atom as probe, we further extend the above technique to entangle the internal states of molecules and atoms. In addition, we also present optimal strategies for dissipative state engineering using the atom-molecule interactions.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

An entanglement perspective on phase transitions, conventional and topological order

Johannes Helmes

The interplay of the constituents of interacting many-body systems may reveal emergent properties on the macroscopic scale which are not inherent to the individual constituents. These properties are expressed in macroscopic observables \ndescribing the state — denoted as the phase of the system. Continuous phase transition between phases are generically manifested in critical behavior, for example, a divergence of a macroscopic observable. The identification of the present phase of a system and the classification of critical phenomena into universality classes are exciting challenges of condensed-matter physics. \nIn this thesis, we use entanglement entropies as macroscopic quantities for the characterization of phases of quantum matter and critical theories. For groundstates of quantum many-body systems the entanglement entropy is a measure of \nthe amount of entanglement between two subsystems. The generic dependence of the entanglement entropy on the size and shape of the subsystems is contained in the well-known boundary law — stating a scaling of the entanglement entropy with the boundary between the two subsystems. We numerically investigate how the coefficient of this dependence reflects quantum phase transitions in simple spin-half bilayer models. \nSubleading terms to the boundary law such as a logarithmic contribution provide universal numbers for the criticality of field theories. We examine free and interacting theories from an entanglement entropy perspective in order to assess the role of the coefficient of the logarithmic correction induced by corners in the subsystems. Beyond its universality, this coefficient also quantifies degrees of freedom of low-lying excitations in the conformal field theory describing a critical point. \nA constant contribution to the boundary law indicates the presence of so-called topological order in the ground state of a many-body system. This extremely useful property can also be identified in classical counterparts of entanglement entropy which we study at the example of various toric code models. To this endeavor, we have designed Monte Carlo techniques which allow for an efficient numerical computation of the constant contribution. In particular, we analyze via entanglement entropies under which conditions remnants of topological order are present in the quantum system at finite temperature and at perturbations from a magnetic field. The major motivation behind this effort is to use topological order for the robust storage of a quantum information — a basic need for the construction of quantum \ncomputers.

•Aug 16, 2017•3 citations

Realizing topologically ordered states on a quantum processor

Kevin J. Satzinger, Yu-Jie Liu, Adam Smith +95 more

The discovery of topological order has revised the understanding of quantum matter and provided the theoretical foundation for many quantum error-correcting codes. Realizing topologically ordered states has proven to be challenging in both condensed matter and synthetic quantum systems. We prepared the ground state of the toric code Hamiltonian using an efficient quantum circuit on a superconducting quantum processor. We measured a topological entanglement entropy near the expected value of -ln2 and simulated anyon interferometry to extract the braiding statistics of the emergent excitations. Furthermore, we investigated key aspects of the surface code, including logical state injection and the decay of the nonlocal order parameter. Our results demonstrate the potential for quantum processors to provide insights into topological quantum matter and quantum error correction.

•Dec 2, 2021•424 citations

Realizing topologically ordered states on a quantum processor

Kevin J. Satzinger, Yu-Jie Liu, A. Smith +95 more

The discovery of topological order has revised the understanding of quantum matter and provided the theoretical foundation for many quantum error–correcting codes. Realizing topologically ordered states has proven to be challenging in both condensed matter and synthetic quantum systems. We prepared the ground state of the toric code Hamiltonian using an efficient quantum circuit on a superconducting quantum processor. We measured a topological entanglement entropy near the expected value of –ln2 and simulated anyon interferometry to extract the braiding statistics of the emergent excitations. Furthermore, we investigated key aspects of the surface code, including logical state injection and the decay of the nonlocal order parameter. Our results demonstrate the potential for quantum processors to provide insights into topological quantum matter and quantum error correction.

arXiv:2104.01180•Science•Dec 2, 2021•21 citations

Accuracy of Topological Entanglement Entropy on Finite Cylinders

Hong‐Chen Jiang, Rajiv R. P. Singh, Leon Balents

Topological phases are unique states of matter which support nonlocal excitations which behave as particles with fractional statistics. A universal characterization of gapped topological phases is provided by the topological entanglement entropy (TEE). We study the finite size corrections to the TEE by focusing on systems with a Z2 topological ordered state using density-matrix renormalization group and perturbative series expansions. We find that extrapolations of the TEE based on the Renyi entropies with a Renyi index of n≥2 suffer from much larger finite size corrections than do extrapolations based on the von Neumann entropy. In particular, when the circumference of the cylinder is about ten times the correlation length, the TEE obtained using von Neumann entropy has an error of order 10(-3), while for Renyi entropies it can even exceed 40%. We discuss the relevance of these findings to previous and future searches for topological ordered phases, including quantum spin liquids.

arXiv:1304.0780•Physical Review Letters•Sep 5, 2013•18 citations
Abstract We analyze the computational aspects of detecting topological order in a quantum many-body system. We contrast the widely used topological entanglement entropy with a recently introduced operational definition for topological order based on error correction properties, finding exponential scaling with the system size for the former and polynomial scaling for the latter. We exemplify our approach for a variant of the paradigmatic toric code model with mobile particles, finding that the error correction method allows to treat substantially larger system sizes. In particular, the phase diagram of the model can be successfully computed using error correction, while the topological entanglement entropy is too severely limited by finite size effects to obtain conclusive results. While we mainly focus on one-dimensional systems whose ground states can be expressed in terms of matrix product states, our strategy can be readily generalized to higher dimensions and systems out of equilibrium, even allowing for an efficient detection of topological order in current quantum simulation experiments.
We analyze the computational aspects of detecting topological order in a quantum many-body system. We contrast the widely used topological entanglement entropy with a recently introduced operational definition for topological order based on error correction properties, finding exponential scaling with the system size for the former and polynomial scaling for the latter. We exemplify our approach for a variant of the paradigmatic toric code model with mobile particles, finding that the error correction method allows to treat substantially larger system sizes. In particular, the phase diagram of the model can be successfully computed using error correction, while the topological entanglement entropy is too severely limited by finite size effects to obtain conclusive results. While we mainly focus on one-dimensional systems whose ground states can be expressed in terms of matrix product states, our strategy can be readily generalized to higher dimensions and systems out of equilibrium, even allowing for an efficient detection of topological order in current quantum simulation experiments.
The fundamental understanding of phases and their transitions has been a central theme in condensed matter physics. Until recently, it was largely believed that the Landau symmetry breaking principle was effective in distinguishing different phases of matter, with broken symmetries signaling the phase transition. But with the discovery of topological phases which are beyond the Landau symmetry breaking principle, the identification and classification of quantum phases at absolute zero has opened up new unexplored avenues thus leading to exciting theoretical discoveries further propelling technological advancement. Topological phases of matter are characterized by the notion of topological order and in this work we aim to explore and understand topological phases by introducing novel signatures which characterize topological order. The robustness of these phases to external perturbation makes them an ideal candidate to store and manipulate quantum information thus making them an unique and interesting prospect for realizing quantum computers. There have been several signatures to characterize intrinsic topological order, for instance the invariance of the topologically ordered state under local operators, the dependence of ground state degeneracy on the underlying manifold and its robustness to external perturbation, topological entanglement entropy related to the quantum dimension of the supers-selection sectors, the inability to construct the topologically ordered state from a product state via constant depth unitary transformations. With toric code as the toy model, we analyze the robustness of topological order on a manifold supporting open boundaries by computing some of the above signatures which effectively detect a topological to trivial phase transition. We then probe the existence of a quantum criticality between distinct topological phases obtained by varying the underlying manifold. In these scenarios, most of the above signatures turn out to be ineffective in detecting the distinct phases leading to the introduction of an non- local order parameter whose construction is facilitated by the phenomenon of anyon condensation. The signatures for quantitatively and qualitatively characterizing intrinsic topological order being highly scenario dependent and also with its definition for mixed states being elusive we introduce an operational definition based on concepts of topological error correction. We define a state to be topologically ordered if the errors in the state can be corrected by an error correction circuit of finite depth. To concretize the notion of topological to trivial phase transition in an open setting we turn to nonequilibrium phenomenon, for example: Directed Percolation, with the change in percolation rate driving a dynamical phase transition between absorbing and active states with the former being topologically ordered while the latter being topologically trivial. Additionally, we explore the notion of topological phase transitions between distinct topological phases obtained by varying underlying topology in an open setting, analogous to the closed setting discussed earlier. To summarize, we have introduced various mixed states which exhibit topological order and also an operational definition to quantify topological order applicable across multitude of scenarios. We extend the above operational definition to quantify and detect quantum phase transitions in the case of Symmetry Protected Topological (SPT) phases. To further validate the above notion, we consider the perturbed variants of the Su-Schrieffer–Heeger (SSH) models and detect quantum phase transitions to a high accuracy by employing the techniques from the framework of tensor networks. It is significant to note the distinction of the error correction algorithms applied earlier in the case of intrinsic topological order were independent of symmetry constraints while in the current scenario we impose additional symmetry constraints to accurately detect the phase transition. In addition, we also devise error correction strategies with respect to topologically trivial states to detect quantum phase transitions which do not involve topological phases. This gives rise to a very fundamental question on whether error correction statistics with a well defined error correction algorithm, not necessarily optimal, are capable of detecting a equivalence classes of phases and thereby acting as a reliable probe to effectively detect topological/quantum phase transitions? From theoretical and numerical end of the spectrum we shift gears to explore possible experimental platforms with an aim to realize some of the quantum many-body phenomenon discussed earlier. While there have been several innovative experimental avenues to realize the above, one such promising candidate has been ultracold polar molecules setups that offer additional degrees of freedom due to the ro-vibrational degrees of freedom. Based on the chemical reaction between atoms and molecules which results in a quantum Zeno-based blockade, we devise several optimal strategies to efficiently detect molecules using atom as probe, we further extend the above technique to entangle the internal states of molecules and atoms. In addition, we also present optimal strategies for dissipative state engineering using the atom-molecule interactions.
The interplay of the constituents of interacting many-body systems may reveal emergent properties on the macroscopic scale which are not inherent to the individual constituents. These properties are expressed in macroscopic observables \ndescribing the state — denoted as the phase of the system. Continuous phase transition between phases are generically manifested in critical behavior, for example, a divergence of a macroscopic observable. The identification of the present phase of a system and the classification of critical phenomena into universality classes are exciting challenges of condensed-matter physics. \nIn this thesis, we use entanglement entropies as macroscopic quantities for the characterization of phases of quantum matter and critical theories. For groundstates of quantum many-body systems the entanglement entropy is a measure of \nthe amount of entanglement between two subsystems. The generic dependence of the entanglement entropy on the size and shape of the subsystems is contained in the well-known boundary law — stating a scaling of the entanglement entropy with the boundary between the two subsystems. We numerically investigate how the coefficient of this dependence reflects quantum phase transitions in simple spin-half bilayer models. \nSubleading terms to the boundary law such as a logarithmic contribution provide universal numbers for the criticality of field theories. We examine free and interacting theories from an entanglement entropy perspective in order to assess the role of the coefficient of the logarithmic correction induced by corners in the subsystems. Beyond its universality, this coefficient also quantifies degrees of freedom of low-lying excitations in the conformal field theory describing a critical point. \nA constant contribution to the boundary law indicates the presence of so-called topological order in the ground state of a many-body system. This extremely useful property can also be identified in classical counterparts of entanglement entropy which we study at the example of various toric code models. To this endeavor, we have designed Monte Carlo techniques which allow for an efficient numerical computation of the constant contribution. In particular, we analyze via entanglement entropies under which conditions remnants of topological order are present in the quantum system at finite temperature and at perturbations from a magnetic field. The major motivation behind this effort is to use topological order for the robust storage of a quantum information — a basic need for the construction of quantum \ncomputers.
The discovery of topological order has revised the understanding of quantum matter and provided the theoretical foundation for many quantum error-correcting codes. Realizing topologically ordered states has proven to be challenging in both condensed matter and synthetic quantum systems. We prepared the ground state of the toric code Hamiltonian using an efficient quantum circuit on a superconducting quantum processor. We measured a topological entanglement entropy near the expected value of -ln2 and simulated anyon interferometry to extract the braiding statistics of the emergent excitations. Furthermore, we investigated key aspects of the surface code, including logical state injection and the decay of the nonlocal order parameter. Our results demonstrate the potential for quantum processors to provide insights into topological quantum matter and quantum error correction.
The discovery of topological order has revised the understanding of quantum matter and provided the theoretical foundation for many quantum error–correcting codes. Realizing topologically ordered states has proven to be challenging in both condensed matter and synthetic quantum systems. We prepared the ground state of the toric code Hamiltonian using an efficient quantum circuit on a superconducting quantum processor. We measured a topological entanglement entropy near the expected value of –ln2 and simulated anyon interferometry to extract the braiding statistics of the emergent excitations. Furthermore, we investigated key aspects of the surface code, including logical state injection and the decay of the nonlocal order parameter. Our results demonstrate the potential for quantum processors to provide insights into topological quantum matter and quantum error correction.
Topological phases are unique states of matter which support nonlocal excitations which behave as particles with fractional statistics. A universal characterization of gapped topological phases is provided by the topological entanglement entropy (TEE). We study the finite size corrections to the TEE by focusing on systems with a Z2 topological ordered state using density-matrix renormalization group and perturbative series expansions. We find that extrapolations of the TEE based on the Renyi entropies with a Renyi index of n≥2 suffer from much larger finite size corrections than do extrapolations based on the von Neumann entropy. In particular, when the circumference of the cylinder is about ten times the correlation length, the TEE obtained using von Neumann entropy has an error of order 10(-3), while for Renyi entropies it can even exceed 40%. We discuss the relevance of these findings to previous and future searches for topological ordered phases, including quantum spin liquids.