Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Long-lived collective modes of light in cold atoms : experimental and numerical studies on subradiance and Anderson localization

A. Cipris

Published Mar 7, 2022• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The objective of this thesis is to expand our understanding of collective light-scattering phenomena, which manifest themselves in the strong suppression of radiation from the scattering medium. In particular, we are interested in subradiance, a collective effect in spontaneous emission which, as a result of the dissipative coupling of atoms through common electromagnetic modes, creates long-lived excitation modes in an ensemble of cold atoms, with lifetimes much longer than those of individual, isolated atoms. Previously, subradiance had been well-characterized for dilute cold-atom scattering media and the low-intensity limit of the driving laser (linear-optics regime). In this thesis, we study this collective phenomenon beyond the linear-optics and dilute regimes.To study experimentally subradiance beyond the linear-optics regime, we varied the saturation parameter of the excitation laser up to relatively large values and we have observed the increase of the subradiant population with increasing saturation parameter. More importantly, we have identified the super-linear scaling of the subradiant population beyond the linear-optics regime, due to a process similar to optical pumping via multi-excitation superradiant states. This study showed that the increase in the intensity of the driving laser beyond the linear-optics regime can overcome the weak coupling of subradiant modes with the external world.Moreover, we have numerically studied subradiance using the vectorial coupled-dipole model, with a focus on understanding the effect of the near-field dipole-dipole interaction. For that, we extensively compared the vectorial and scalar (which does not contain near-field interaction terms) models and studied the subradiant lifetime as a function of the density and optical thickness of the cold-atom cloud. We observed that the near-field terms are detrimental for subradiance, which was seen in the reduction of the subradiant lifetimes with increasing density. This detrimental character of near-field terms can be interpreted as being due to an effective inhomogeneous broadening induced by the near-field interaction, which reduces the subradiant lifetimes as the density increases.The detrimental character of near-field interaction has also been previously numerically identified for Anderson localization of light waves (Anderson localization is a coherent multiple-scattering wave phenomenon in a strongly scattering medium that results in a cessation of a diffusive wave transport; it also yields long-lived modes): the scalar coupled-dipole model predicts Anderson localization of light waves, but not the vectorial one. However, adding a strong magnetic field allows one to recover localized modes for vectorial light. In this context, we numerically studied a possible signature of Anderson localization of light in cold atoms, based on the measurement of intensity fluctuations of the scattered light. We have shown that at the transition to the localized regime, the fluctuations are enhanced. In particular, for vectorial light, we have demonstrated the absence and recovery of enhanced intensity fluctuations without and with the applied magnetic field, which further corroborates that the intensity fluctuations could serve as an experimental way to probe the localized states.

DOI
10.70675/94e1e7ecz144cz4a37z847fz746c5ebb88da

Related papers

Population of collective modes in light scattering by many atoms

William Guerin, Robin Kaiser

The interaction of light with an atomic sample containing a large number of particles gives rise to many collective (or cooperative) effects, such as multiple scattering, superradiance, and subradiance, even if the atomic density is low and the incident optical intensity weak (linear optics regime). Tracing over the degrees of freedom of the light field, the system can be well described by an effective atomic Hamiltonian, which contains the light-mediated dipole-dipole interaction between atoms. This long-range interaction is at the origin of the various collective effects, or of collective excitation modes of the system. Even though an analysis of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of these collective modes does allow distinguishing superradiant modes, for instance, from other collective modes, this is not sufficient to understand the dynamics of a driven system, as not all collective modes are significantly populated. Here, we study how the excitation parameters, i.e., the driving field, determines the population of the collective modes. We investigate in particular the role of the laser detuning from the atomic transition, and demonstrate a simple relation between the detuning and the steady-state population of the modes. This relation allows understanding several properties of cooperative scattering, such as why superradiance and subradiance become independent of the detuning at large enough detuning without vanishing, and why superradiance, but not subradiance, is suppressed near resonance. We also show that the spatial properties of the collective modes allow distinguishing diffusive modes, responsible for radiation trapping, from subradiant modes.

arXiv:1702.01053•Physical Review A•May 26, 2017•31 citations

Light-atom interaction: mean-field approach and intensity fluctuations

Florent Cottier

In this thesis, we investigate the coherent scattering of light propagating in a random medium.We are interested in phenomena like the super-and subradiance and Anderson localization that are related to waves interferences and spatial disorder.However, the fundamental difference between subradiance and Anderson localization still needs to be clarified.This thesis gives new elements for the understanding of these phenomena and we present a new method to observe Anderson localization.A mean-field model that does not contain disorder is developed, and we show that super-and subradiance do not require disorder whereas Anderson localization does.In this theoretical work, the coupling between the light and many atoms is reduced to a coupling matrix between the atoms by tracing over the degrees of freedom of the light, which results in a linear problem for the atomic dipoles.The study of the eigenvalues and eigenmodes of this matrix then allows to determine the super-and subradiant modes, and to probe the Anderson localization phase transition with a scaling analysis.Furthermore, the link to the experiment is realized by showing that the intensity fluctuations present an increase at the localization transition.The system is studied in the steady-state regime when the medium is continuously charged by a laser until reaches a stationary regime, and the decay dynamics, when the laser is switched off, so the cloud releases the energy stored.Finally, we present a preliminary work that shows that the diagonal disorder might be a good strategy to reach Anderson localization.

•May 28, 2019•0 citations

Subradiance with Saturated Atoms: Population Enhancement of the Long-Lived States

A. Cipris, Noel Araujo Moreira, T. S. do Espirito Santo +5 more

Dipole-dipole interactions are at the origin of long-lived collective atomic states, often called subradiant, which are explored for their potential use in novel photonic devices or in quantum protocols. Here, we study subradiance beyond the single-excitation regime and experimentally demonstrate a 200-fold increase in the population of these modes, as the saturation parameter of the driving field is increased. We attribute this enhancement to a mechanism similar to optical pumping through the well-coupled superradiant states. The lifetimes are unaffected by the pump strength, as the system is ultimately driven toward the single-excitation sector. Our study is a new step in the exploration of the many-body dynamics of large open systems.

arXiv:2009.05172•Physical Review Letters•Mar 12, 2021•42 citations

Super- and subradiance in a dilute cloud of cold atoms

M. Araujo

The problem of the interaction of N atoms with a laser beam and vacuum modes can give rise to many interesting phenomena concerning the spontaneous emission of light and its propagation in the medium. The cooperative effects, for example, such as superadiance and subradiance, are effects related to the coherence created between the atoms when a photon is emitted spontaneously by a single excited atom. Superradiance can be defined as the enhancement of the spontaneous emission due to constructive interference of the scattered light. Its counterpart, subradiance, is the trapping of some remaining light due to destructive interference. In cold atoms, some previous theoretical works predict and characterize these two cooperative effects in a large and diluted atomic cloud, in the regime of low intensities and large detunings of the incident laser. The theoretical model is a coupled-dipole model for two-level atoms driven by a low-intensity field and in the scalar approach. The experiment consists in measuring the super- and subradiant decay rates from the temporal emitted intensity after the switch off of the incident laser in the steady state. Our experimental setup consists in a magneto-optical trap of rubidium 87 atoms at large resonant optical thicknesses. A probe beam excites the atoms close to the D2 line. The intensity emitted is detected by a single photon detector with no afterpulsing and a calibration procedure allows us to determine the resonant optical thickness of the cloud and its temperature. In this work, we report the experimental observation of super- and subradiance in a large cloud of cold atoms. For subradiance, the main result is the linear evolution of the characteristic time with the resonant optical thickness of the cloud and its independence of the detuning. For superradiance, we observe superradiance out of the forward direction. We verify the validity of our interpretations with the predictions of the coupled-dipole model. Finally, we discuss the interplay of subradiance and radiation trapping, as well as theoretical predictions for: a setup of a phased cloud, to control the subradiant amplitude emission; and temperature effects, where subradiance is shown to be robust in a large range of temperatures.

•Dec 11, 2018•0 citations

Subradiance and radiation trapping in cold atoms

P. Weiss, M. Araujo, Robin Kaiser +1 more

We experimentally and numerically study the temporal dynamics of light scattered by large clouds of cold atoms after the exciting laser is switched off, in the low intensity (linear-optics) regime. Radiation trapping due to multiple scattering as well as subradiance lead to decay much slower than the single atom fluorescence decay. These two effects have already been observed separately, but the interplay between them remained to be understood. Here, we show that with well chosen parameters of the driving field, the two effects can occur at the same time, but follow different scaling behaviors. The subradiant decay is observed at late time and its rate is independent of the detuning, while the radiation trapping decay is observed at intermediate time and depends on the detuning through the optical depth of the sample. Numerical simulations based on random walk process and coupled-dipole equations support our interpretations. Our study clarifies the different interpretations and physical mechanisms at the origin of slow temporal dynamics of light in cold atoms.

arXiv:1803.01646•New Journal of Physics•May 17, 2018•63 citations

Decay dynamics in the coupled-dipole model

M. Araujo, William Guerin, Robin Kaiser

Cooperative scattering in cold atoms has gained renewed interest, in particular in the context of single-photon superradiance, with the recent experimental observation of super- and subradiance in dilute atomic clouds. Numerical simulations to support experimental signatures of cooperative scattering are often limited by the number of dipoles which can be treated, well below the number of atoms in the experiments. In this paper, we provide systematic numerical studies aimed at matching the regime of dilute atomic clouds. We use a scalar coupled-dipole model in the low excitation limit and an exclusion volume to avoid density-related effects. Scaling laws for super- and subradiance are obtained and the limits of numerical studies are pointed out. We also illustrate the cooperative nature of light scattering by considering an incident laser field, where half of the beam has a π phase shift. The enhanced subradiance obtained under such condition provides an additional signature of the role of coherence in the detected signal.

arXiv:1705.02190•Journal of Modern Optics•Oct 5, 2017•29 citations
The objective of this thesis is to expand our understanding of collective light-scattering phenomena, which manifest themselves in the strong suppression of radiation from the scattering medium. In particular, we are interested in subradiance, a collective effect in spontaneous emission which, as a result of the dissipative coupling of atoms through common electromagnetic modes, creates long-lived excitation modes in an ensemble of cold atoms, with lifetimes much longer than those of individual, isolated atoms. Previously, subradiance had been well-characterized for dilute cold-atom scattering media and the low-intensity limit of the driving laser (linear-optics regime). In this thesis, we study this collective phenomenon beyond the linear-optics and dilute regimes.To study experimentally subradiance beyond the linear-optics regime, we varied the saturation parameter of the excitation laser up to relatively large values and we have observed the increase of the subradiant population with increasing saturation parameter. More importantly, we have identified the super-linear scaling of the subradiant population beyond the linear-optics regime, due to a process similar to optical pumping via multi-excitation superradiant states. This study showed that the increase in the intensity of the driving laser beyond the linear-optics regime can overcome the weak coupling of subradiant modes with the external world.Moreover, we have numerically studied subradiance using the vectorial coupled-dipole model, with a focus on understanding the effect of the near-field dipole-dipole interaction. For that, we extensively compared the vectorial and scalar (which does not contain near-field interaction terms) models and studied the subradiant lifetime as a function of the density and optical thickness of the cold-atom cloud. We observed that the near-field terms are detrimental for subradiance, which was seen in the reduction of the subradiant lifetimes with increasing density. This detrimental character of near-field terms can be interpreted as being due to an effective inhomogeneous broadening induced by the near-field interaction, which reduces the subradiant lifetimes as the density increases.The detrimental character of near-field interaction has also been previously numerically identified for Anderson localization of light waves (Anderson localization is a coherent multiple-scattering wave phenomenon in a strongly scattering medium that results in a cessation of a diffusive wave transport; it also yields long-lived modes): the scalar coupled-dipole model predicts Anderson localization of light waves, but not the vectorial one. However, adding a strong magnetic field allows one to recover localized modes for vectorial light. In this context, we numerically studied a possible signature of Anderson localization of light in cold atoms, based on the measurement of intensity fluctuations of the scattered light. We have shown that at the transition to the localized regime, the fluctuations are enhanced. In particular, for vectorial light, we have demonstrated the absence and recovery of enhanced intensity fluctuations without and with the applied magnetic field, which further corroborates that the intensity fluctuations could serve as an experimental way to probe the localized states.
The interaction of light with an atomic sample containing a large number of particles gives rise to many collective (or cooperative) effects, such as multiple scattering, superradiance, and subradiance, even if the atomic density is low and the incident optical intensity weak (linear optics regime). Tracing over the degrees of freedom of the light field, the system can be well described by an effective atomic Hamiltonian, which contains the light-mediated dipole-dipole interaction between atoms. This long-range interaction is at the origin of the various collective effects, or of collective excitation modes of the system. Even though an analysis of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of these collective modes does allow distinguishing superradiant modes, for instance, from other collective modes, this is not sufficient to understand the dynamics of a driven system, as not all collective modes are significantly populated. Here, we study how the excitation parameters, i.e., the driving field, determines the population of the collective modes. We investigate in particular the role of the laser detuning from the atomic transition, and demonstrate a simple relation between the detuning and the steady-state population of the modes. This relation allows understanding several properties of cooperative scattering, such as why superradiance and subradiance become independent of the detuning at large enough detuning without vanishing, and why superradiance, but not subradiance, is suppressed near resonance. We also show that the spatial properties of the collective modes allow distinguishing diffusive modes, responsible for radiation trapping, from subradiant modes.
In this thesis, we investigate the coherent scattering of light propagating in a random medium.We are interested in phenomena like the super-and subradiance and Anderson localization that are related to waves interferences and spatial disorder.However, the fundamental difference between subradiance and Anderson localization still needs to be clarified.This thesis gives new elements for the understanding of these phenomena and we present a new method to observe Anderson localization.A mean-field model that does not contain disorder is developed, and we show that super-and subradiance do not require disorder whereas Anderson localization does.In this theoretical work, the coupling between the light and many atoms is reduced to a coupling matrix between the atoms by tracing over the degrees of freedom of the light, which results in a linear problem for the atomic dipoles.The study of the eigenvalues and eigenmodes of this matrix then allows to determine the super-and subradiant modes, and to probe the Anderson localization phase transition with a scaling analysis.Furthermore, the link to the experiment is realized by showing that the intensity fluctuations present an increase at the localization transition.The system is studied in the steady-state regime when the medium is continuously charged by a laser until reaches a stationary regime, and the decay dynamics, when the laser is switched off, so the cloud releases the energy stored.Finally, we present a preliminary work that shows that the diagonal disorder might be a good strategy to reach Anderson localization.
Dipole-dipole interactions are at the origin of long-lived collective atomic states, often called subradiant, which are explored for their potential use in novel photonic devices or in quantum protocols. Here, we study subradiance beyond the single-excitation regime and experimentally demonstrate a 200-fold increase in the population of these modes, as the saturation parameter of the driving field is increased. We attribute this enhancement to a mechanism similar to optical pumping through the well-coupled superradiant states. The lifetimes are unaffected by the pump strength, as the system is ultimately driven toward the single-excitation sector. Our study is a new step in the exploration of the many-body dynamics of large open systems.
The problem of the interaction of N atoms with a laser beam and vacuum modes can give rise to many interesting phenomena concerning the spontaneous emission of light and its propagation in the medium. The cooperative effects, for example, such as superadiance and subradiance, are effects related to the coherence created between the atoms when a photon is emitted spontaneously by a single excited atom. Superradiance can be defined as the enhancement of the spontaneous emission due to constructive interference of the scattered light. Its counterpart, subradiance, is the trapping of some remaining light due to destructive interference. In cold atoms, some previous theoretical works predict and characterize these two cooperative effects in a large and diluted atomic cloud, in the regime of low intensities and large detunings of the incident laser. The theoretical model is a coupled-dipole model for two-level atoms driven by a low-intensity field and in the scalar approach. The experiment consists in measuring the super- and subradiant decay rates from the temporal emitted intensity after the switch off of the incident laser in the steady state. Our experimental setup consists in a magneto-optical trap of rubidium 87 atoms at large resonant optical thicknesses. A probe beam excites the atoms close to the D2 line. The intensity emitted is detected by a single photon detector with no afterpulsing and a calibration procedure allows us to determine the resonant optical thickness of the cloud and its temperature. In this work, we report the experimental observation of super- and subradiance in a large cloud of cold atoms. For subradiance, the main result is the linear evolution of the characteristic time with the resonant optical thickness of the cloud and its independence of the detuning. For superradiance, we observe superradiance out of the forward direction. We verify the validity of our interpretations with the predictions of the coupled-dipole model. Finally, we discuss the interplay of subradiance and radiation trapping, as well as theoretical predictions for: a setup of a phased cloud, to control the subradiant amplitude emission; and temperature effects, where subradiance is shown to be robust in a large range of temperatures.
We experimentally and numerically study the temporal dynamics of light scattered by large clouds of cold atoms after the exciting laser is switched off, in the low intensity (linear-optics) regime. Radiation trapping due to multiple scattering as well as subradiance lead to decay much slower than the single atom fluorescence decay. These two effects have already been observed separately, but the interplay between them remained to be understood. Here, we show that with well chosen parameters of the driving field, the two effects can occur at the same time, but follow different scaling behaviors. The subradiant decay is observed at late time and its rate is independent of the detuning, while the radiation trapping decay is observed at intermediate time and depends on the detuning through the optical depth of the sample. Numerical simulations based on random walk process and coupled-dipole equations support our interpretations. Our study clarifies the different interpretations and physical mechanisms at the origin of slow temporal dynamics of light in cold atoms.
Cooperative scattering in cold atoms has gained renewed interest, in particular in the context of single-photon superradiance, with the recent experimental observation of super- and subradiance in dilute atomic clouds. Numerical simulations to support experimental signatures of cooperative scattering are often limited by the number of dipoles which can be treated, well below the number of atoms in the experiments. In this paper, we provide systematic numerical studies aimed at matching the regime of dilute atomic clouds. We use a scalar coupled-dipole model in the low excitation limit and an exclusion volume to avoid density-related effects. Scaling laws for super- and subradiance are obtained and the limits of numerical studies are pointed out. We also illustrate the cooperative nature of light scattering by considering an incident laser field, where half of the beam has a π phase shift. The enhanced subradiance obtained under such condition provides an additional signature of the role of coherence in the detected signal.