"NOTES"Etude No.3: Classical Exact Solutions for the Zeeman Effect of Hydrogen Atom

O. Ya. Savchenko

Sambhu N. Datta

Abstract The solution of a unitarily transformed Dirac equation for the hydrogenic electron in zero magnetic field is investigated here. The momentum‐space representation is adopted as a natural recourse. The spinor part of the transformed wavefunction in momentum space can be easily prescribed for a central potential. Hence, for the Coulomb potential, a pair of equations is obtained for the radial components in momentum space. It is shown that starting from these radial equations, one can recover the equations previously derived by Rubinowicz, Lévy, and Lombardi for the problem of the Dirac hydrogen atom in momentum space. This establishes equivalence among different approaches based on the momentum representation, including the current treatment. The recovery of the equations due to Rubinowicz permits the exact eigenvalues to be written down and exact expressions to be derived for the radial components of the transformed wavefunction in momentum space. A new approach is adopted to carry out a reduction to the nonrelativistic regime and the nonrelativistic limit. At first the transformed momentum‐space equation for the hydrogen atom is rewritten in terms of the hyperspherical coordinates. The zeroth‐order solutions of the new equation are recovered in the limit c → ∞ where c is the speed of light. These are manifestly separable into positive‐ and negative‐energy forms. For positive energy, these solutions have nonvanishing upper components that are two‐component spinors. The latter exactly correspond to the single‐component, nonrelativistic, momentum‐space solutions derived by Fock. It is shown that when the upper component is corrected through first order in v2/c2 but the separability is still maintained for the transformed wavefunction, one retrieves the Pauli equation in momentum space. It is also shown that for a hydrogen atom placed in a uniform magnetic field, the nonvanishing momentum‐space matrix elements representing the anomalous Zeeman effect have a simple form, namely, the product of a radial integral and an angular integral. These integrals are equal to the well‐known radial and angular integrals in coordinate representation. The matrix elements can be easily evaluated. © 2003 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2003

Ibratjon X. Aliyev, Obbozjon Qo’ldashov, Karimberdi Egamberdiyvich Onarkulov +3 more

A Blom

Contrary to popular belief, the Zeeman effect can be treated exactly in single-electron systems, for arbitrary magnetic field strengths, as long as the term quadratic in the magnetic field can be ignored. These formulas were actually derived already around 1927 by Darwin, using the classical picture of angular momentum, and presented in their proper quantum-mechanical form in 1933 by Bethe, although without any proof. The expressions have since been more or less lost from the literature; instead, the conventional treatment nowadays is to present only the approximations for weak and strong fields, respectively. However, in fusion research and other plasma physics applications, the magnetic fields applied to control the shape and position of the plasma span the entire region from weak to strong fields, and there is a need for a unified treatment. In this paper we present the detailed quantum-mechanical derivation of the exact eigenenergies and eigenstates of hydrogen-like atoms and ions in a static magnetic field. Notably, these formulas are not much more complicated than the better-known approximations. Moreover, the derivation allows the value of the electron spin gyromagnetic ratio g s to be different from 2. For completeness, we then review the details of dipole transitions between two hydrogenic levels, and calculate the corresponding Zeeman spectrum. The various approximations made in the derivation are also discussed in details.

A. M. Mosharrafa

Caio Lima Firme

Quantum mechanics began in very early twentieth century when Max Planck found the expression for black body thermal radiation in which the emitted light was not a continuum as postulated by classical physics. Erwin Schrodinger applied his equation to solve the quantum harmonic oscillator, the quantum rigid rotor, and a hydrogen-like atom. Pertaining to the solution of the Schrodinger equation to hydrogen atoms are the quantum numbers. C. K. Ingold’s overview of Schrodinger wave mechanics: “What can be known about an electron, considered as a particle, is of a statistical nature, and is summarized in the behavior of a wave. When considering singlet substances, the normal Zeeman Effect occurs, providing the discrete values of the orbital angular momentum. In an attempt to rationalize the anomalous Zeeman effect, W. Pauli proposed the fourth degree of freedom of the electron which he called “two-valuedness not describable classically”.