Implementing quantum computers using linear photonics is currently constrained by the low success probabilities of CNOT gates. While the KLM protocol has shown efficient scalability, it still incurs cost in terms of the number of modes and the use of error correcting codes. Variational quantum circuits have shown intrinsic error mitigation properties, however, this generally requires post-processing, essentially requiring extra circuit executions, hurting execution times. Therefore, it is now typical to augment variational circuits with error-correcting codes to mitigate error for all quantum implementation technologies. This paper studies the error mitigation effect of variational quantum classifiers on probabilistic quantum photonics CNOT gates with no extra executions. We have observed that the gate failure noise does not affect all prepared states equally. Moreover, the corresponding error-immune states still provide a high level of expressibility and entangling capability, indicating the possibility for training to achieve error mitigation effects. Moreover, we also observed another subspace of the parameter space in which error can be suppressed through parameter corrections without the need for post-processing. The paper also conducts a photonics simulation study for a range of probabilistic CNOT gates for a simple binary classification problem and studies the effect of circuit hyperparameters on the error mitigation. The simulations show acceptable accuracy results on the learning tasks, showing the possible utility of linear photonics in quantum learning classification tasks.
Implementing quantum computers using linear photonics is currently constrained by the low success probabilities of CNOT gates. While the KLM protocol has shown efficient scalability, it still incurs cost in terms of the number of modes and the use of error correcting codes. Variational quantum circuits have shown intrinsic error mitigation properties, however, this generally requires post-processing, essentially requiring extra circuit executions, hurting execution times. Therefore, it is now typical to augment variational circuits with error-correcting codes to mitigate error for all quantum implementation technologies. This paper studies the error mitigation effect of variational quantum classifiers on probabilistic quantum photonics CNOT gates with no extra executions. We have observed that the gate failure noise does not affect all prepared states equally. Moreover, the corresponding error-immune states still provide a high level of expressibility and entangling capability, indicating the possibility for training to achieve error mitigation effects. Moreover, we also observed another subspace of the parameter space in which error can be suppressed through parameter corrections without the need for post-processing. The paper also conducts a photonics simulation study for a range of probabilistic CNOT gates for a simple binary classification problem and studies the effect of circuit hyperparameters on the error mitigation. The simulations show acceptable accuracy results on the learning tasks, showing the possible utility of linear photonics in quantum learning classification tasks.
We report on a gate-based variational quantum classifier implemented with single photons and probabilistic gates, to emulate the standard quantum circuit model framework. We evaluate the expressive power of two deployable quantum neural networks (QNNs) by computing their effective dimension, a capacity measure grounded in a proven generalization-error bound, and compare them with classical artificial neural networks (ANNs) of equivalent trainable-parameter count. Supervised binary classification tasks are used to benchmark performance across photonic and superconducting QNNs, both of which exhibit superior converged (lower) cross-entropy loss and (higher) prediction accuracy relative to matched-parameter ANNs. For a nonlinearly separable task, our photonic QNN with a single pair of trainable parameters successfully converged (loss 0.04 and accuracy 100%), whereas the equivalent ANN failed to learn the decision boundary, saturating at random-guessing performance. We simulate photonic quantum circuits, training them on the XOR problem and a two-class Iris subset using gradient-free optimization, and assess their robustness to sampling errors under realistic noise processes including photon loss and phase-shifter imperfections. Circuits with comparatively high effective dimension were deployed remotely on a six-qubit photonic quantum processor, achieving classification accuracies of up to 100% in both online and offline learning settings. Notably, even the simplest QNN deployed, with just two trainable parameters, successfully solved tasks that classically require ANNs with at least quadruple the number of parameters, suggesting an emergent algorithmic advantage. Overall, these results demonstrate a clear proof-of-principle that gate-based QNNs can be realized and trained effectively on current photonic hardware, providing proof of algorithmic advantage on a gate-based photonic QNN.
Integrated photonic circuits play a crucial role in implementing quantum information processing in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era. Variational learning is a promising avenue that leverages classical optimization techniques to enhance quantum advantages on NISQ devices. However, most variational algorithms are circuit-model-based and encounter challenges when implemented on integrated photonic circuits, because they involve explicit decomposition of large quantum circuits into sequences of basic entangled gates, leading to an exponential decay of success probability due to the non-deterministic nature of photonic entangling gates. Here, we present a variational learning approach for designing quantum photonic circuits, which directly incorporates post-selection and elementary photonic elements into the training process. The complicated circuit is treated as a single nonlinear logical operator, and a unified design is discovered for it through variational learning. Engineering an integrated photonic chip with automated control, we adjust and optimize the internal parameters of the chip in real time for task-specific cost functions. We utilize a simple case of designing photonic circuits for a single ancilla CNOT gate with improved success rate to illustrate how our proposed approach works, and then apply the approach in the first demonstration of quantum stochastic simulation using integrated photonics.
Classification is one of the main applications of supervised learning. Recent advancements in developing quantum computers have opened a new possibility for machine learning on such machines. Due to the noisy performance of near-term quantum computers, error mitigation techniques are essential for extracting meaningful data from noisy raw experimental measurements. Here, we propose two ensemble-learning error mitigation methods, namely, bootstrap aggregating and adaptive boosting, which can significantly enhance the performance of variational quantum classifiers for both classical and quantum datasets. The idea is to combine several weak classifiers, each implemented on a shallow noisy quantum circuit, to make a strong one with high accuracy. While both of our protocols substantially outperform error-mitigated primitive classifiers, the adaptive boosting shows better performance than the bootstrap aggregating. The protocols have been exemplified for classical handwriting digits as well as quantum phase discrimination of a symmetry-protected topological Hamiltonian, in which we observe a significant improvement in accuracy. Our ensemble-learning methods provide a systematic way of utilizing shallow circuits to solve complex classification problems. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Abstract Quantum machine learning (QML) is an emerging field that promises advantages such as faster training, improved reliability and superior feature extraction over classical counterparts. However, its implementation on quantum hardware is challenging due to the noise inherent in these systems, necessitating the use of quantum error correction (QEC) codes. Current QML research remains primarily theoretical, often assuming noise-free environments and offering little insight into the integration of QEC with QML implementations. To address this, we investigate the performance of a simple, parity-classifying Variational Quantum Classifier (VQC) implemented with the [[4,2,2]] error-detecting stabiliser code in a simulated noisy environment. To our knowledge, this is the first implementation of a stabiliser-based error detection code to a QML algorithm. We invoke ancilla qubits to logically encode rotation gates, and classically simulate the logically-encoded VQC under two simple noise models representing gate noise and environmental noise. We demonstrate that the stabiliser code improves the training accuracy at convergence compared to noisy implementations without error detection. However, we find that the effectiveness and reliability of error detection is contingent upon keeping the ancilla qubit error rates below a specific threshold, due to the propagation of ancilla errors to the physical qubits. Our results provide an important insight that extends to QML implemented with full error-correction: when the QEC code requires ancilla qubits for logical rotations but cannot fully correct errors propagated between ancilla and physical qubits, the maximum achievable accuracy of the QML model is constrained. This highlights the need for additional error correction or mitigation strategies to support the practical implementation of QML algorithms with QEC on quantum devices.
Machine Learning-based quantum error mitigation (ML-QEM) has emerged as a promising approach for improving the performance of noisy quantum algorithms. However, existing ML-QEM methods often have restricted applicability to variational circuits and rely on inaccessible noiseless training data. In this work, we propose a practical ML-QEM protocol tailored to variational quantum algorithms, which generates training data by simulating (near-)Clifford circuits. This data is used for model selection and training, producing a mitigation model that can correct variational circuits with arbitrary parameters and transfer across different target Hamiltonians of similar structure. We benchmark the proposed method on the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) task for the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Hamiltonian of up to n=12 qubits under various noise models, analyzing its effect on trainability and comparing its performance against standard Zero-Noise Extrapolation (ZNE). The results demonstrate consistent several-fold error suppression across all tested settings and superior performance over ZNE in the high-noise regime, providing evidence for the applicability of the proposed protocol to present-day NISQ processors.
Quantum error mitigation techniques are at the heart of quantum hardware implementation, and are the key to performance improvement of the variational quantum learning scheme (VQLS). Although VQLS is partially robust to noise, both empirical and theoretical results exhibit that noise would rapidly deteriorate the performance of most variational quantum algorithms in large-scale problems. Furthermore, VQLS suffers from the barren plateau phenomenon---the gradient generated by the classical optimizer vanishes exponentially with respect to the qubit number. Here we devise a resource and runtime efficient scheme, the quantum architecture search scheme (QAS), to maximally improve the robustness and trainability of VQLS. In particular, given a learning task, QAS actively seeks an optimal circuit architecture to balance benefits and side-effects brought by adding more quantum gates. Specifically, while more quantum gates enable a stronger expressive power of the quantum model, they introduce a larger amount of noise and a more serious barren plateau scenario. Consequently, QAS can effectively suppress the influence of quantum noise and barren plateaus. We implement QAS on both the numerical simulator and real quantum hardware, via the IBM cloud, to accomplish data classification and quantum chemistry tasks. Numerical and experimental results show that QAS significantly outperforms conventional variational quantum algorithms with heuristic circuit architectures. Our work provides practical guidance for developing advanced learning-based quantum error mitigation techniques on near-term quantum devices.