This chapter focuses on physical possibility and on a feature of physical frameworks that might complicate the way we understand it: physical theories rely on two kinds of solution spaces associated with the kinematical and dynamical models of the theory. In general, the kinematical models are consistent with the theoretical framework under consideration before dynamical equations are added, whereas the dynamic models further obey the latter constraints. The chapter analyzes how the distinction between kinematics and dynamics is carried out in different physical theories. It shows how the mechanism through which dynamical models are generated from kinematical models varies in different theoretical settings. In classical mechanics and general relativity, dynamical solutions correspond to a subset of the kinematical space, contrary to non-relativistic quantum mechanics, where dynamical models are built out of weighted sums of kinematical solutions.
This chapter focuses on physical possibility and on a feature of physical frameworks that might complicate the way we understand it: physical theories rely on two kinds of solution spaces associated with the kinematical and dynamical models of the theory. In general, the kinematical models are consistent with the theoretical framework under consideration before dynamical equations are added, whereas the dynamic models further obey the latter constraints. The chapter analyzes how the distinction between kinematics and dynamics is carried out in different physical theories. It shows how the mechanism through which dynamical models are generated from kinematical models varies in different theoretical settings. In classical mechanics and general relativity, dynamical solutions correspond to a subset of the kinematical space, contrary to non-relativistic quantum mechanics, where dynamical models are built out of weighted sums of kinematical solutions.
We propose a preliminary mathematical framework for physical theories based on experimentally grounded constraints. A physical theory is represented as a structured object (S, O, D) consisting of a state space, a set of observables, and a dynamical law. We introduce constraint operators acting on the space of candidate theories, encoding symmetry, causality, quantum, and dynamical requirements. The space of physically admissible theories is defined as the intersection of constraint-defined subsets, leading to a constraint-based interpretation of physical laws as consistency conditions. This framework provides a unified mathematical perspective in which classical mechanics, relativity, and quantum theory can be understood as different realizations within a common structure. This work presents a preliminary but structured conceptual and mathematical framework.
This introductory chapter sets out a general structure of physical theories which is applicable to both classical and quantum mechanics. We start with measurable properties of a given physical system, be it classical or quantum. These properties are called observables . We then introduce a definition of the state of a physical system in terms of measured values of a sufficiently large set of observables. A theory to describe the system should consists of four basic components: Basic mathematical framework This comprises a set of elements endowed with some specific mathematical structure and properties. In mathematics such a set is generally known as a space . Description of states States are described by elements of the space in the chosen mathematical framework. For this reason the space is called the state space of the system. Description of observables Observables are to be described by quantities defined on the state space. The description should yield all possible values of observables. The relationship between observables and states should be explicitly stated. The following two cases are of particular interest: 2 For a deterministic theory like classical mechanics a state should determine the values of all observables. For a probabilistic theory like quantum mechanics a state should determine the probability distribution of the values of all observables. Description of time evolution (dynamics).
We examine the possible relations between general relativity and quantum mechanics, from the point of view of their representations of space and time, which are different. We refer to our own understanding of space and time, built in opposition to each other from the physical phenomena, and not constituting an a priori external frame. Within a relation-based thinking, we can only compare the phenomena to the other phenomena, and, from this confrontation, space-time frames arise, as drawn by the trajectories of certain phenomena arbitrarily considered in a privileged way. It is within this framework that one must think the possible association of general relativity (which has not the monopoly of space and time) and quantum mechanics (which has not the monopoly of quantization, to be understood from the comparison of two classes of phenomena within a probabilistic approach). The general question to ask is that of possible exchanges between the different points of views, supported by the various possible phenomena, that is to say those on which space and time are defined, and the others. Space and time do not disappear, the points of views are exchanged. These exchanges are made possible by representing space and time, like the other phenomena, by a pair of fields (r, t); r and t are vectors in a three-dimensional space (time is marked by the position of a moving point in the same space as that defining the positions of the ordinary points), as opposed to field pairs (f, g) associated with the other phenomena (such as the pair of the electric and magnetic fields). One may ultimately envisage quantization of space and time; one may also envisage the definition of time and space solely by quantum mechanics. A preliminary and qualitative framework is presented as a basis for future quantitative research.
Quantum mechanics has achieved unparalleled success as an operational theory, describing a wide range of experiments to remarkable accuracy. However, the physical foundations on which it rests remain as puzzling as they were a century ago, and a concise statement of the physical principles that underlie quantum mechanics is still outstanding. One promising approach holds that these principles should be formulated in terms of information, since many of the counter-intuitive effects in quantum theory concern questions such as what one can know about a quantum system and how the information encoded therein can be processed and distributed between parties. Another challenging feature of quantum theory is its incompatibility with the other cornerstone of modern physics, general relativity. In order to reconcile the two, one must identify and retain only the essential concepts and principles of each theory, and in the case of general relativity, causality has been identified as such a concept. This raises the question of how our classical understanding of causality must change when quantum theory is taken into account. In order to address these questions about information, knowledge and causality, I turn to the framework of causal models. In classical statistics, causal models explain the relations among a set of variables in terms of causal influences, which makes them a powerful tool for structuring our knowledge about complex systems and developing strategies for interacting with them. More importantly, the framework provides the conceptual underpinnings and mathematical methods for addressing questions about causation, information and knowledge in a rigorous manner. In this thesis, I develop a version of the classical causal models framework that is compatible with quantum theory and explore its physical implications. \n \n \nA first step is to define quantum versions of fundamental elements such as variables, conditionals and belief propagation rules. This allows one to consider the question of what one can come to know about a quantum variable from the point of view of causal modelling. The conditionals relating quantum variables are found to have a richer structure than their classical counterparts, which can be exploited for the task of discerning causal relations given limited data -- a central problem in classical causal modelling. The mathematical properties of quantum conditionals also establish a correspondence between various classes of two-party correlations, such as bound and distillable entanglement, and the types of causal structures that can give rise to them, which may become a useful tool for entanglement theory and quantum information processing. In the context of open quantum systems dynamics, quantum causal models provide a clear physical explanation of not completely positive maps and, more broadly, of non-Markovian quantum dynamics. Finally, I consider the possibility of non-classical effects in the way that different causal mechanisms are combined -- that is, non-classical causal structures. For the simple case of two causally ordered variables, I propose indicators that witness different classes of combinations of causal mechanisms, including a non-classical mixture, and describe an experiment realizing examples of the different classes. \n \n \nAs these results illustrate, the framework of quantum causal models provides both greater conceptual clarity and a comprehensive mathematical formalism for studying a diverse set of problems, ranging from foundational questions to applications in open systems dynamics and the exploration of non-classical causal structures, which are likely to feature in a future theory of quantum gravity. The material presented in this thesis is intended as a foundation and inspiration for further applications of quantum causal models.
Abstract Natural modalities are often analysed from an abstract point of view where they are associated with putative laws of nature. However, the way possibilities are represented in physics is more complex. Lagrangian mechanics, for instance, involves two different layers of modalities: kinematical and dynamical possibilities. This paper examines the status of these two layers, both in the classical and quantum case. The quantum case is particularly problematic: we identify four possible interpretive options. The upshot is that a close inspection of the way possibilities are represented in physics could lead to new ways of thinking about natural modalities.
This thesis is concerned with the development of a new spin-1/2 wave equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. This equation is the spin-1/2 analogue of the spin-0 Feshbach-Villars equation. The thesis begins in chapter 1 with a review of the subject of relativistic wave equations and its place in the development of modern physics. Chapter 2 sees the derivation of the new equation (hereafter referred to as the FV1/2 equation). This derivation is presented at three levels of understanding, and is combined with an analysis of the equation using elements of the underlying mathematics of the theories of special relativity and quantum mechanics. The analysis justifies the methods of derivation of the equation, and its suitability as a wave equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. It is shown th a t the FV1/2 equation is different to the Dirac equation and other equations in the literature. One of the striking features of the FV1/2 equation is th a t it contains a less restrictive dynamics than the conventional Dirac equation. Chapter 3 examines the solution space and proves some results using the discrete symmetries C, P and T, which enable a subset of the solution space to be used for physical applications. It is possible to use a subset of solutions which contain the usual Dirac negative energy states, or it is possible to use a subset which contains only positive energy states, but includes states of opposite signs of charge. The second subset corresponds to the physical properties of particles and antiparticles and suggests th a t the FV1/2 equation could be useful in atomic physics. Chapter 4 represents a start on the development of the FV1/2 equation for use in atomic physics. It contains a study of hydrogenic atoms. The energy spectra and wavefunctions for hydrogenic atoms are derived using the FV1/2 equation. The method of solution is of comparable difficulty to th a t using the Dirac equation. The spectra are found to be identical to th a t of the Dirac equation, but the wavefunctions differ. A calculation of the expectation value of the Coulomb energy is performed and the results obtained differ from the Dirac equation results by 6 x 10-3% for Z — 1, and 40% for Z = 70. This suggests th a t physically measureable quantities should be calculated and compared using the FV1/2 and Dirac equations. A calculation is presented to show the energy spectra and wavefunctions obtained are consistent with the literature. The results obtained in this chapter (again) suggest th a t the FV1/2 equation could be useful for calculations in atomic physics. Chapter 5 discusses important further work which should be undertaken if the FV1/2 equation is to become useful to physics. The development in the previous chapters concentrated on the FV1/2 equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. It should be also considered as a quantised field equation. The two electron problem and the calculation of physical quantities are crucial tests of the FV1/2 equation’s applicability in atomic physics. The mathematical analysis in chapter 2 can be extended. Suggestions for gaining a deeper mathematical understanding of the less restrictive dynamics of the FV1/2 equation are given. Finally some conclusions on what has been achieved in the thesis are presented in chapter 6.