Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

A Universal Quantum Descriptor for Electron Correlation in Molecular Systems: The Fbond Framework

Celal Arda

Published Nov 5, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Predicting which molecular systems require post-Hartree-Fock treatment remains a fundamental challenge in quantum chemistry. We introduce Fbond, a universal descriptor that quantifies electron correlation strength through the product of HOMO-LUMO gap and maximum single-orbital entanglement entropy. Validation across seven representative molecules reveals Fbond identifies three distinct electronic regimes spanning three orders of magnitude (10−4 to 10−1 ). Highly polar σ bonds (NH3 , H2O) exhibit Fbond < 0.001, indicating true mean-field behavior adequately described by Hartree-Fock. Covalent σ bonds (CH4 , H2 ) display intermediate values (Fbond ∼ 0.04), revealing weak correlation effects requiring density functional theory or second-order perturbation theory. In contrast, π-bonded systems (C2H4 , N2 , C2H2 ) consistently display Fbond > 0.06, demonstrating strong π-π ∗ correlation requiring coupled-cluster treatment. This three-regime classification provides quantitative thresholds for method selection in quantum chemistry, with implications for high-throughput computational screening and reaction mechanism studies.

DOI
10.26434/chemrxiv-2025-vmd44

Related papers

A Universal Quantum Descriptor for Electron Correlation in Molecular Systems: The Fbond Framework

Celal Arda

Predicting which molecular systems require post-Hartree-Fock treatment remains a fundamental challenge in quantum chemistry. We introduce Fbond, a universal descriptor that quantifies electron correlation strength through the product of HOMO-LUMO gap and maximum single-orbital entanglement entropy. Validation across seven representative molecules using frozen-core FCI with natural orbital analysis reveals Fbond identifies two distinct electronic regimes separated by a factor of two. Pure σ-bonded systems (NH3 , H2O, CH4 , H2 ) exhibit Fbond ≈ 0.03–0.04, indicating weak correlation adequately described by density functional theory or second-order perturbation theory, regardless of bond polarity (∆χ = 0 for H2 to ∆χ = 1.4 for H2O). In contrast, π-bonded systems (C2H4 , N2 , C2H2 ) consistently display Fbond ≈ 0.065–0.072, demonstrating strong π-π ∗ correlation requiring coupled-cluster treatment. This two-regime classification—based on bond type rather than polarity—provides quantitative thresholds for method selection in quantum chemistry, with implications for high-throughput computational screening and reaction mechanism studies. Keywords: electron correlation, quantum entanglement, sigma bonds, pi bonds, coupled-cluster, correlation diagnostics, frozen-core approximation

•Nov 17, 2025•0 citations

Concept of Orbital Entanglement and Correlation in Quantum Chemistry

Lexin Ding, Sam Mardazad, Sreetama Das +4 more

A recent development in quantum chemistry has established the quantum mutual information between orbitals as a major descriptor of electronic structure. This has already facilitated remarkable improvements in numerical methods and may lead to a more comprehensive foundation for chemical bonding theory. Building on this promising development, our work provides a refined discussion of quantum information theoretical concepts by introducing the physical correlation and its separation into classical and quantum parts as distinctive quantifiers of electronic structure. In particular, we succeed in quantifying the entanglement. Intriguingly, our results for different molecules reveal that the total correlation between orbitals is mainly classical, raising questions about the general significance of entanglement in chemical bonding. Our work also shows that implementing the fundamental particle number superselection rule, so far not accounted for in quantum chemistry, removes a major part of correlation and entanglement seen previously. In that respect, realizing quantum information processing tasks with molecular systems might be more challenging than anticipated.

arXiv:2006.00961•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Dec 2, 2020•77 citations

Renyi Entanglement Entropy of Molecules: Interaction Effects and Signatures of Bonding

Norm M. Tubman, Jeremy McMinis

Recent proposals of measuring bipartite Renyi entropy experimentally involve techniques that hold exactly for non-interacting quantum particles. Here we consider the difference between such measurements and the actual Renyi entropy for ground state fermion ab initio molecular systems. To calculate various entanglement measures we extended several different techniques for use with variational Monte Carlo, Hartree-Fock and quantum chemistry methods. Our results show that in systems with strong electron correlations the Renyi entropy may not be accurately determined with the proposed measurements. In addition, we find significant physical insight can be gained by calculating entanglement properties in molecular systems. We see that the Renyi entropy and the entanglement Hamiltonian encode information about the character of the covalent bonds in a molecular system and that such information may lead to better descriptions of bonded systems that have been traditionally hard to describe with standard techniques. In particular our results for the C$_{2}$ dimer suggests all eight valence electrons play a significant role in covalent bonding.

arXiv:1204.4731•Apr 20, 2012•28 citations

Quantum dissection of a covalent bond with the entanglement spectrum

Norm M. Tubman, David ChangMo Yang

We propose that spatial density matrices, which are singularly important in the study of quantum entanglement, encode the electronic fluctuations and correlations responsible for covalent bonding. From these density matrices, we develop tools that allow us to analyse how many body wave functions can be broken up into real space pieces. We apply these tools to the first row dimers, and in particular, we address the conflicting evidence in the literature about the presence of an inverted fourth bond and anti-ferromagnetic correlations in the $\text{C}_2$ molecule. Our results show that many body effects enhance anti-ferromagnetic fluctuations but are not related to the formation of an inverted fourth bond. We identify two inverted bonds in the $\text{C}_2$ molecule and establish their correspondence to the bonds in the $\text{Be}_2$ molecule. Additionally, we provide a new interpretation of the Mayer index, introduce partial bonds to fix deficiencies in molecular orbital theory, and prove the Hartree-Fock wave function for C$_{2}$ is not a triple bond. Our results suggest that entanglement-based methods can lead to a more realistic treatment of molecular and extended systems than possible before.

arXiv:1412.1495•Dec 3, 2014•9 citations

Quantum correlations in molecules: from quantum resourcing to chemical bonding

Lexin Ding, Stefan Knecht, Zoltán Zimborás +1 more

Abstract The second quantum revolution is all about exploiting the quantum nature of atoms and molecules to execute quantum information processing tasks. To boost this growing endeavor and by anticipating the key role of quantum chemistry therein, our work establishes a framework for systematically exploring, quantifying and dissecting correlation effects in molecules. By utilizing the geometric picture of quantum states we compare—on a unified basis and in an operationally meaningful way—total, quantum and classical correlation and entanglement in molecular ground states. To unlock and maximize the quantum informational resourcefulness of molecules an orbital optimization scheme is developed, leading to a paradigm-shifting insight: a single covalent bond equates to the entanglement 2 ln ( 2 ) . This novel and more versatile perspective on electronic structure suggests a generalization of valence bond theory, overcoming deficiencies of modern chemical bonding theories.

arXiv:2205.15881•Quantum Science and Technology•Nov 22, 2022•35 citations

V2Rho-FNO: Fourier Neural Operator for Electronic Density Prediction

Yingdi Jin, Xinming Qin, Ruichen Liu +3 more

Density functional theory (DFT) is a cornerstone of computational chemistry and materials science, but its computational cost limits its use in large-scale and high-throughput applications. While machine learning has accelerated energy prediction for specific molecular classes, transferable prediction of electron density across diverse chemical spaces remains challenging. Here, we present a universal framework based on Fourier Neural Operators (FNOs) that directly learns the mapping from external potentials to electron density distributions. Unlike conventional approaches that rely on explicit atomic orbitals, basis sets, or handcrafted descriptors, the proposed method captures global electronic interactions and long-range correlations through operator learning in the spatial-frequency domain. Trained on datasets spanning multiple elements and molecular geometries, the model achieves zero-shot generalization to entirely unseen molecular systems and accurately predicts their electron densities without retraining. This transferability arises from the intrinsic ability of FNOs to represent global structure in continuous fields. Our work establishes neural operator learning as a promising route for fast, accurate, and transferable electronic structure prediction, with potential applications in high-throughput screening and chemical space exploration.

physics.chem-phCross-listedarXiv:2603.15669•Mar 16, 2026
Predicting which molecular systems require post-Hartree-Fock treatment remains a fundamental challenge in quantum chemistry. We introduce Fbond, a universal descriptor that quantifies electron correlation strength through the product of HOMO-LUMO gap and maximum single-orbital entanglement entropy. Validation across seven representative molecules reveals Fbond identifies three distinct electronic regimes spanning three orders of magnitude (10−4 to 10−1 ). Highly polar σ bonds (NH3 , H2O) exhibit Fbond < 0.001, indicating true mean-field behavior adequately described by Hartree-Fock. Covalent σ bonds (CH4 , H2 ) display intermediate values (Fbond ∼ 0.04), revealing weak correlation effects requiring density functional theory or second-order perturbation theory. In contrast, π-bonded systems (C2H4 , N2 , C2H2 ) consistently display Fbond > 0.06, demonstrating strong π-π ∗ correlation requiring coupled-cluster treatment. This three-regime classification provides quantitative thresholds for method selection in quantum chemistry, with implications for high-throughput computational screening and reaction mechanism studies.
Predicting which molecular systems require post-Hartree-Fock treatment remains a fundamental challenge in quantum chemistry. We introduce Fbond, a universal descriptor that quantifies electron correlation strength through the product of HOMO-LUMO gap and maximum single-orbital entanglement entropy. Validation across seven representative molecules using frozen-core FCI with natural orbital analysis reveals Fbond identifies two distinct electronic regimes separated by a factor of two. Pure σ-bonded systems (NH3 , H2O, CH4 , H2 ) exhibit Fbond ≈ 0.03–0.04, indicating weak correlation adequately described by density functional theory or second-order perturbation theory, regardless of bond polarity (∆χ = 0 for H2 to ∆χ = 1.4 for H2O). In contrast, π-bonded systems (C2H4 , N2 , C2H2 ) consistently display Fbond ≈ 0.065–0.072, demonstrating strong π-π ∗ correlation requiring coupled-cluster treatment. This two-regime classification—based on bond type rather than polarity—provides quantitative thresholds for method selection in quantum chemistry, with implications for high-throughput computational screening and reaction mechanism studies. Keywords: electron correlation, quantum entanglement, sigma bonds, pi bonds, coupled-cluster, correlation diagnostics, frozen-core approximation
A recent development in quantum chemistry has established the quantum mutual information between orbitals as a major descriptor of electronic structure. This has already facilitated remarkable improvements in numerical methods and may lead to a more comprehensive foundation for chemical bonding theory. Building on this promising development, our work provides a refined discussion of quantum information theoretical concepts by introducing the physical correlation and its separation into classical and quantum parts as distinctive quantifiers of electronic structure. In particular, we succeed in quantifying the entanglement. Intriguingly, our results for different molecules reveal that the total correlation between orbitals is mainly classical, raising questions about the general significance of entanglement in chemical bonding. Our work also shows that implementing the fundamental particle number superselection rule, so far not accounted for in quantum chemistry, removes a major part of correlation and entanglement seen previously. In that respect, realizing quantum information processing tasks with molecular systems might be more challenging than anticipated.
Recent proposals of measuring bipartite Renyi entropy experimentally involve techniques that hold exactly for non-interacting quantum particles. Here we consider the difference between such measurements and the actual Renyi entropy for ground state fermion ab initio molecular systems. To calculate various entanglement measures we extended several different techniques for use with variational Monte Carlo, Hartree-Fock and quantum chemistry methods. Our results show that in systems with strong electron correlations the Renyi entropy may not be accurately determined with the proposed measurements. In addition, we find significant physical insight can be gained by calculating entanglement properties in molecular systems. We see that the Renyi entropy and the entanglement Hamiltonian encode information about the character of the covalent bonds in a molecular system and that such information may lead to better descriptions of bonded systems that have been traditionally hard to describe with standard techniques. In particular our results for the C2_{2}2​ dimer suggests all eight valence electrons play a significant role in covalent bonding.
We propose that spatial density matrices, which are singularly important in the study of quantum entanglement, encode the electronic fluctuations and correlations responsible for covalent bonding. From these density matrices, we develop tools that allow us to analyse how many body wave functions can be broken up into real space pieces. We apply these tools to the first row dimers, and in particular, we address the conflicting evidence in the literature about the presence of an inverted fourth bond and anti-ferromagnetic correlations in the C2\text{C}_2C2​ molecule. Our results show that many body effects enhance anti-ferromagnetic fluctuations but are not related to the formation of an inverted fourth bond. We identify two inverted bonds in the C2\text{C}_2C2​ molecule and establish their correspondence to the bonds in the Be2\text{Be}_2Be2​ molecule. Additionally, we provide a new interpretation of the Mayer index, introduce partial bonds to fix deficiencies in molecular orbital theory, and prove the Hartree-Fock wave function for C2_{2}2​ is not a triple bond. Our results suggest that entanglement-based methods can lead to a more realistic treatment of molecular and extended systems than possible before.
Abstract The second quantum revolution is all about exploiting the quantum nature of atoms and molecules to execute quantum information processing tasks. To boost this growing endeavor and by anticipating the key role of quantum chemistry therein, our work establishes a framework for systematically exploring, quantifying and dissecting correlation effects in molecules. By utilizing the geometric picture of quantum states we compare—on a unified basis and in an operationally meaningful way—total, quantum and classical correlation and entanglement in molecular ground states. To unlock and maximize the quantum informational resourcefulness of molecules an orbital optimization scheme is developed, leading to a paradigm-shifting insight: a single covalent bond equates to the entanglement 2 ln ( 2 ) . This novel and more versatile perspective on electronic structure suggests a generalization of valence bond theory, overcoming deficiencies of modern chemical bonding theories.
Density functional theory (DFT) is a cornerstone of computational chemistry and materials science, but its computational cost limits its use in large-scale and high-throughput applications. While machine learning has accelerated energy prediction for specific molecular classes, transferable prediction of electron density across diverse chemical spaces remains challenging. Here, we present a universal framework based on Fourier Neural Operators (FNOs) that directly learns the mapping from external potentials to electron density distributions. Unlike conventional approaches that rely on explicit atomic orbitals, basis sets, or handcrafted descriptors, the proposed method captures global electronic interactions and long-range correlations through operator learning in the spatial-frequency domain. Trained on datasets spanning multiple elements and molecular geometries, the model achieves zero-shot generalization to entirely unseen molecular systems and accurately predicts their electron densities without retraining. This transferability arises from the intrinsic ability of FNOs to represent global structure in continuous fields. Our work establishes neural operator learning as a promising route for fast, accurate, and transferable electronic structure prediction, with potential applications in high-throughput screening and chemical space exploration.