Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Space Technology and Applications

Performance Validation of a Deformable Mirror in Adaptive Optics for Quantum Key Distribution

Yulim Lee, Been Yeo, Seonghwan Choi, Kyohoon Ahn

Published Aug 1, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This study presents the performance of a deformable mirror (DM), a key component of the adaptive optics (AO) system, in the context of quantum key distribution (QKD) over free-space optical communications (FSOC). The potential of QKD, which offers theoretically unbreakable encryption by leveraging quantum mechanics, is immense for secure communication, particularly between ground stations and satellites. However, atmospheric turbulence significantly degrades the optical wavefront during FSO communication, leading to signal loss and increased error rates. To counteract these effects, AO systems use real-time wavefront correction via components such as a wavefront sensor, control system, and DM. In this work, the ALPAO DM308-15, featuring 308 actuators, was tested using a Zygo interferometer to evaluate its influence functions, linearity, hysteresis, best flat correction, and ability to reproduce Zernike modes. All influence functions of 308 actuators were precisely measured using a Zygo interferometer. The DM demonstrated excellent linearity with errors below 1.68% and negligible hysteresis. Best flat correction reduced the surface root-mean-square (RMS) error from 52 nm to 7.5 nm, a seven-fold improvement. This research has the potential to significantly impact the field of AO and quantum communication, inspiring new developments and applications. Furthermore, the mirror successfully reproduced 36 Zernike modes with a maximum RMS error deviation of only 8%, confirming its high spatial precision. Stability tests showed minimal degradation over 30 minutes, indicating its suitability for real-time AO operation. The DM not only met but exceeded performance requirements for FSO-QKD applications, providing a high level of precision, responsiveness, and stability. This reassures the audience of its reliable and consistent performance, instilling confidence in its potential for integration into next-generation AO systems aimed at secure satellite-to-ground quantum communication.

DOI
10.52912/jsta.2025.5.3.139

Related papers

Fast adaptive optics for high-dimensional quantum communications in turbulent channels

Lukas Scarfe, Felix Hufnagel, Manuel F. Ferrer-Garcia +3 more

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) promises a provably secure method to transmit information from one party to another. Free-space QKD allows for this information to be sent over great distances and in places where fibre-based communications cannot be implemented, such as ground-satellite. The primary limiting factor for free-space links is the effect of atmospheric turbulence, which can result in significant error rates and increased losses in QKD channels. Here, we employ the use of a high-speed Adaptive Optics (AO) system to make real-time corrections to the wavefront distortions on spatial modes that are used for high-dimensional QKD in our turbulent channel. First, we demonstrate the effectiveness of the AO system in improving the coupling efficiency of a Gaussian mode that has propagated through turbulence. Through process tomography, we show that our system is capable of significantly reducing the crosstalk of spatial modes in the channel. Finally, we show that employing AO reduces the quantum dit error rate for a high-dimensional orbital angular momentum-based QKD protocol, allowing for secure communication in a channel where it would otherwise be impossible. These results are promising for establishing long-distance free-space QKD systems. High-dimensional quantum key distribution will allow for higher information density and greater error tolerance in future quantum networks. This work experimentally demonstrates how implementing an adaptive optics system in a spatial-mode free-space optical link can allow for quantum communications where it would otherwise be impossible.

arXiv:2311.13041•Communications Physics•Feb 24, 2025•38 citations

Adaptive Optics for Free-Space Optical Communication and Quantum Key Distribution

Ido Shlomy, Yizhar Fahima, John Miller +2 more

This article offers a solution to the fragmentation problem through a unified model and simulation showing how Adaptive Optics (AO) improves both classical and quantum communications. Free-space optical links can carry Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) over distances that cannot be reached with fiber; however, atmospheric turbulence corrupts the wavefront. For a single-mode quantum receiver, this drives the quantum bit error rate above the security threshold before detector noise can even be considered. AO addresses this by restoring the wavefront and recovering the coupling loss. The theory, mitigation techniques, and quantum security analysis needed to understand this are spread across three research communities that rarely cite one another: atmospheric turbulence and AO theory, classical modulation over fading channels, and BB84 quantum key distribution. We consolidate and develops all three topics in order to trace the chain from wavefront error to bit error rate and secret key rate. We survey six families of turbulence mitigation and provide an assessment of their suitability for single-mode quantum links. In addition, we survey the free-space QKD experimental record, from terrestrial hops to satellite downlinks. A wave optics case study of a representative 500-km Low Earth Orbit (LEO) downlink, corrected by a closed-loop Shack–Hartmann and deformable-mirror receiver at 1.55 μm ties the review together. Across a turbulence sweep, the correction stabilizes single-mode coupling near its physical ceiling, while the uncorrected channel varies by more than an order of magnitude. When carried into the downlink budget, this lifts the quantum link across the 11% security bound at 12 of 15 turbulence conditions where the uncorrected link yields no key, thereby restoring a secure quantum bit error rate in a narrow 4.2–4.9% band throughout and a secret key rate of 7.6–11.2 kbit/s while simultaneously widening the margin of the co-propagating classical channel above its forward error correction threshold.

Symmetry•Oct 28, 2026•0 citations

Performance of real-time adaptive optics compensation in a turbulent channel with high-dimensional spatial-mode encoding

Jiapeng Zhao, Yiyu Zhou, Boris Braverman +6 more

The orbital angular momentum (OAM) of photons is a promising degree of freedom for high-dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD). However, effectively mitigating the adverse effects of atmospheric turbulence is a persistent challenge in OAM QKD systems operating over free-space communication channels. In contrast to previous works focusing on correcting static simulated turbulence, we investigate the performance of OAM QKD in real atmospheric turbulence with real-time adaptive optics (AO) correction. We show that even though our AO system provides a limited correction, it is possible to mitigate the errors induced by weak turbulence and establish a secure channel. The crosstalk induced by turbulence and the performance of AO systems is investigated in two configurations: a lab-scale link with controllable turbulence, and a 340 m long cross-campus link with dynamic atmospheric turbulence. Our experimental results suggest that an advanced AO system with fine beam tracking, reliable beam stabilization, precise wavefront sensing, and accurate wavefront correction is necessary to adequately correct turbulence-induced error. We also propose and demonstrate different solutions to improve the performance of OAM QKD with turbulence, which could enable the possibility of OAM encoding in strong turbulence.

arXiv:2002.08884•Optics Express•Apr 18, 2020•48 citations

Computational adaptive optics for enabling satellite quantum key distribution in daylight

G. Galvin, A. Asmari, Harry Borrill +3 more

Quantum key distribution (QKD) enables remote users to share cryptographic keys with information theoretic security. Satelliteto-ground QKD offers a route to extend the distances between users that is otherwise limited by losses through optical fibre. However, satellite QKD is typically limited to operation at night due to the background photons from sunlight. A proposed solution to reduce the background counts is tight spatial filtering via single-mode fibre coupling, but this comes at the cost of losses because of imperfect coupling efficiency due to wavefront distortions from atmospheric turbulence. To maximise the number of photons entering the fibre, adaptive optics (AO) can be used to correct for the atmospheric effects. We present results of end-to-end link simulations which show the trade-off between AO complexity and fibre coupling efficiency. These results show that for representative turbulence characteristics, a relatively small deformable mirror is required to obtain the required coupling efficiency for a reasonable key rate. This paves the way for affordable quantum communication in daylight conditions.

IET conference proceedings.•Dec 18, 2023•0 citations

Investigate the performance of real-time adaptive optics correction in a turbulent high-dimensional quantum communication channel

Jiapeng Zhao, Yiyu Zhou, Boris Braverman +6 more

The orbital angular momentum (OAM) of photons is a promising degree of freedom for high-dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD). Due to the greater flexibility in applications and the lower loss, QAM QKD over the free-space channel is still significant. However, effectively mitigating the adverse effects of atmospheric turbulence is a persistent challenge. In contrast to previous works focusing on correcting static simulated turbulence, we investigate the performance of OAM QKD in real atmospheric turbulence with real-time adaptive optics (AO) correction. We show that, it is possible to mitigate the errors induced by weak turbulence and establish a secure channel under some conditions. The cross-talk induced by turbulence and the performance of AO systems are investigated in a lab-scale link with controllable turbulence. The relations between the crosstalk and AO specifications is also studied. Our experimental results suggest that an advanced AO system with fine beam tracking, reliable beam stabilization, precise wavefront sensing and accurate wavefront correction is necessary to adequately correct turbulence-induced error.

Free-space laser communication technologies. Conference•Mar 4, 2020•0 citations

Adaptive spatial filtering for daytime satellite quantum key distribution

Mark T. Gruneisen, Brett A. Sickmiller, Michael Flanagan +3 more

The rate of secure key generation (SKG) in quantum key distribution (QKD) is adversely affected by optical noise and loss in the quantum channel. In a free-space atmospheric channel, the scattering of sunlight into the channel can lead to quantum bit error ratios (QBERs) sufficiently large to preclude SKG. Furthermore, atmospheric turbulence limits the degree to which spatial filtering can reduce sky noise without introducing signal losses. A system simulation quantifies the potential benefit of tracking and higher-order adaptive optics (AO) technologies to SKG rates in a daytime satellite engagement scenario. The simulations are performed assuming propagation from a low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellite to a terrestrial receiver that includes an AO system comprised of a Shack-Hartmann wave-front sensor (SHWFS) and a continuous-face-sheet deformable mirror (DM). The effects of atmospheric turbulence, tracking, and higher-order AO on the photon capture efficiency are simulated using statistical representations of turbulence and a time-domain waveoptics hardware emulator. Secure key generation rates are then calculated for the decoy state QKD protocol as a function of the receiver field of view (FOV) for various pointing angles. The results show that at FOVs smaller than previously considered, AO technologies can enhance SKG rates in daylight and even enable SKG where it would otherwise be prohibited as a consequence of either background optical noise or signal loss due to turbulence effects.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Nov 21, 2014•9 citations
This study presents the performance of a deformable mirror (DM), a key component of the adaptive optics (AO) system, in the context of quantum key distribution (QKD) over free-space optical communications (FSOC). The potential of QKD, which offers theoretically unbreakable encryption by leveraging quantum mechanics, is immense for secure communication, particularly between ground stations and satellites. However, atmospheric turbulence significantly degrades the optical wavefront during FSO communication, leading to signal loss and increased error rates. To counteract these effects, AO systems use real-time wavefront correction via components such as a wavefront sensor, control system, and DM. In this work, the ALPAO DM308-15, featuring 308 actuators, was tested using a Zygo interferometer to evaluate its influence functions, linearity, hysteresis, best flat correction, and ability to reproduce Zernike modes. All influence functions of 308 actuators were precisely measured using a Zygo interferometer. The DM demonstrated excellent linearity with errors below 1.68% and negligible hysteresis. Best flat correction reduced the surface root-mean-square (RMS) error from 52 nm to 7.5 nm, a seven-fold improvement. This research has the potential to significantly impact the field of AO and quantum communication, inspiring new developments and applications. Furthermore, the mirror successfully reproduced 36 Zernike modes with a maximum RMS error deviation of only 8%, confirming its high spatial precision. Stability tests showed minimal degradation over 30 minutes, indicating its suitability for real-time AO operation. The DM not only met but exceeded performance requirements for FSO-QKD applications, providing a high level of precision, responsiveness, and stability. This reassures the audience of its reliable and consistent performance, instilling confidence in its potential for integration into next-generation AO systems aimed at secure satellite-to-ground quantum communication.
Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) promises a provably secure method to transmit information from one party to another. Free-space QKD allows for this information to be sent over great distances and in places where fibre-based communications cannot be implemented, such as ground-satellite. The primary limiting factor for free-space links is the effect of atmospheric turbulence, which can result in significant error rates and increased losses in QKD channels. Here, we employ the use of a high-speed Adaptive Optics (AO) system to make real-time corrections to the wavefront distortions on spatial modes that are used for high-dimensional QKD in our turbulent channel. First, we demonstrate the effectiveness of the AO system in improving the coupling efficiency of a Gaussian mode that has propagated through turbulence. Through process tomography, we show that our system is capable of significantly reducing the crosstalk of spatial modes in the channel. Finally, we show that employing AO reduces the quantum dit error rate for a high-dimensional orbital angular momentum-based QKD protocol, allowing for secure communication in a channel where it would otherwise be impossible. These results are promising for establishing long-distance free-space QKD systems. High-dimensional quantum key distribution will allow for higher information density and greater error tolerance in future quantum networks. This work experimentally demonstrates how implementing an adaptive optics system in a spatial-mode free-space optical link can allow for quantum communications where it would otherwise be impossible.
This article offers a solution to the fragmentation problem through a unified model and simulation showing how Adaptive Optics (AO) improves both classical and quantum communications. Free-space optical links can carry Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) over distances that cannot be reached with fiber; however, atmospheric turbulence corrupts the wavefront. For a single-mode quantum receiver, this drives the quantum bit error rate above the security threshold before detector noise can even be considered. AO addresses this by restoring the wavefront and recovering the coupling loss. The theory, mitigation techniques, and quantum security analysis needed to understand this are spread across three research communities that rarely cite one another: atmospheric turbulence and AO theory, classical modulation over fading channels, and BB84 quantum key distribution. We consolidate and develops all three topics in order to trace the chain from wavefront error to bit error rate and secret key rate. We survey six families of turbulence mitigation and provide an assessment of their suitability for single-mode quantum links. In addition, we survey the free-space QKD experimental record, from terrestrial hops to satellite downlinks. A wave optics case study of a representative 500-km Low Earth Orbit (LEO) downlink, corrected by a closed-loop Shack–Hartmann and deformable-mirror receiver at 1.55 μm ties the review together. Across a turbulence sweep, the correction stabilizes single-mode coupling near its physical ceiling, while the uncorrected channel varies by more than an order of magnitude. When carried into the downlink budget, this lifts the quantum link across the 11% security bound at 12 of 15 turbulence conditions where the uncorrected link yields no key, thereby restoring a secure quantum bit error rate in a narrow 4.2–4.9% band throughout and a secret key rate of 7.6–11.2 kbit/s while simultaneously widening the margin of the co-propagating classical channel above its forward error correction threshold.
The orbital angular momentum (OAM) of photons is a promising degree of freedom for high-dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD). However, effectively mitigating the adverse effects of atmospheric turbulence is a persistent challenge in OAM QKD systems operating over free-space communication channels. In contrast to previous works focusing on correcting static simulated turbulence, we investigate the performance of OAM QKD in real atmospheric turbulence with real-time adaptive optics (AO) correction. We show that even though our AO system provides a limited correction, it is possible to mitigate the errors induced by weak turbulence and establish a secure channel. The crosstalk induced by turbulence and the performance of AO systems is investigated in two configurations: a lab-scale link with controllable turbulence, and a 340 m long cross-campus link with dynamic atmospheric turbulence. Our experimental results suggest that an advanced AO system with fine beam tracking, reliable beam stabilization, precise wavefront sensing, and accurate wavefront correction is necessary to adequately correct turbulence-induced error. We also propose and demonstrate different solutions to improve the performance of OAM QKD with turbulence, which could enable the possibility of OAM encoding in strong turbulence.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) enables remote users to share cryptographic keys with information theoretic security. Satelliteto-ground QKD offers a route to extend the distances between users that is otherwise limited by losses through optical fibre. However, satellite QKD is typically limited to operation at night due to the background photons from sunlight. A proposed solution to reduce the background counts is tight spatial filtering via single-mode fibre coupling, but this comes at the cost of losses because of imperfect coupling efficiency due to wavefront distortions from atmospheric turbulence. To maximise the number of photons entering the fibre, adaptive optics (AO) can be used to correct for the atmospheric effects. We present results of end-to-end link simulations which show the trade-off between AO complexity and fibre coupling efficiency. These results show that for representative turbulence characteristics, a relatively small deformable mirror is required to obtain the required coupling efficiency for a reasonable key rate. This paves the way for affordable quantum communication in daylight conditions.
The orbital angular momentum (OAM) of photons is a promising degree of freedom for high-dimensional quantum key distribution (QKD). Due to the greater flexibility in applications and the lower loss, QAM QKD over the free-space channel is still significant. However, effectively mitigating the adverse effects of atmospheric turbulence is a persistent challenge. In contrast to previous works focusing on correcting static simulated turbulence, we investigate the performance of OAM QKD in real atmospheric turbulence with real-time adaptive optics (AO) correction. We show that, it is possible to mitigate the errors induced by weak turbulence and establish a secure channel under some conditions. The cross-talk induced by turbulence and the performance of AO systems are investigated in a lab-scale link with controllable turbulence. The relations between the crosstalk and AO specifications is also studied. Our experimental results suggest that an advanced AO system with fine beam tracking, reliable beam stabilization, precise wavefront sensing and accurate wavefront correction is necessary to adequately correct turbulence-induced error.
The rate of secure key generation (SKG) in quantum key distribution (QKD) is adversely affected by optical noise and loss in the quantum channel. In a free-space atmospheric channel, the scattering of sunlight into the channel can lead to quantum bit error ratios (QBERs) sufficiently large to preclude SKG. Furthermore, atmospheric turbulence limits the degree to which spatial filtering can reduce sky noise without introducing signal losses. A system simulation quantifies the potential benefit of tracking and higher-order adaptive optics (AO) technologies to SKG rates in a daytime satellite engagement scenario. The simulations are performed assuming propagation from a low-Earth orbit (LEO) satellite to a terrestrial receiver that includes an AO system comprised of a Shack-Hartmann wave-front sensor (SHWFS) and a continuous-face-sheet deformable mirror (DM). The effects of atmospheric turbulence, tracking, and higher-order AO on the photon capture efficiency are simulated using statistical representations of turbulence and a time-domain waveoptics hardware emulator. Secure key generation rates are then calculated for the decoy state QKD protocol as a function of the receiver field of view (FOV) for various pointing angles. The results show that at FOVs smaller than previously considered, AO technologies can enhance SKG rates in daylight and even enable SKG where it would otherwise be prohibited as a consequence of either background optical noise or signal loss due to turbulence effects.