The wave–particle duality is the quintessence of quantum mechanics. This duality gives rise to distinct behaviors depending on the experimental setup, with the system exhibiting either wave-like or particle-like properties, depending on whether the focus is on interference (wave) or trajectory (particle). In the interaction with a beam splitter, photons with particle behavior can transform into a wave behavior and vice versa. In Wheeler’s delayed-choice gedanken experiment, this interaction is delayed so that the wave that initially travels through the interferometer can become a particle, avoiding the interaction. We show that this contradiction can be resolved using polarized entangled photon pairs. An analysis of Shannon’s entropy supports this proposal.
The wave–particle duality is the quintessence of quantum mechanics. This duality gives rise to distinct behaviors depending on the experimental setup, with the system exhibiting either wave-like or particle-like properties, depending on whether the focus is on interference (wave) or trajectory (particle). In the interaction with a beam splitter, photons with particle behavior can transform into a wave behavior and vice versa. In Wheeler’s delayed-choice gedanken experiment, this interaction is delayed so that the wave that initially travels through the interferometer can become a particle, avoiding the interaction. We show that this contradiction can be resolved using polarized entangled photon pairs. An analysis of Shannon’s entropy supports this proposal.
Delaying Quantum Choice Photons can display wavelike or particle-like behavior, depending on the experimental technique used to measure them. Understanding this duality lies at the heart of quantum mechanics. In two reports, Peruzzo et al. (p. 634 ) and Kaiser et al. (p. 637 ; see the Perspective on both papers by Lloyd ) perform an entangled version of John Wheeler's delayed-choice gedanken experiment, in which the choice of detection can be changed after a photon passes through a double-slit to avoid the measurement process affecting the state of the photon. The original proposal allowed the wave and particle nature of light to be interchanged after the light had entered the interferometer. By contrast in this study, entanglement allowed the wave and particle nature to be interchanged after the light was detected and revealed the quantum nature of the photon, for example, it displays wave- and particle-like behavior simultaneously.
Wheeler’s gedanken experiment is the most fascinating and subtle illustration of wave-particle duality [1]. If we consider a single-photon light pulse in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, one can either measure the interference at the output – evidencing the “wave-like” behavior of the photon- or one can detect the path followed by the photon – evidencing its “particle-like” behavior. In order to pinpoint how surprising this is, John Wheeler considered a “delayed-choice” regime where the choice of measuring either property is done only after the photon has entered the interferometer.
Wheeler's delayed-choice experiment demonstrates wave-particle duality of particles using different experimental configurations of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. In a quantum version of this experiment, the wave-particle behavior of photons can be observed by controlling presence or absence of the second beam splitter. Here, we implement a delayed-choice experiment with dual selections based on entangled photons, experimentally controlling both of two beam splitters in the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, where the presence and absence of the second beam splitter are simultaneously controlled through path encoding. Our experiment reveals the wave-particle behavior of single photons under different configurations of two beam splitters. We further discuss the scenario when two beam splitters are in a quantum superposition of being present and absent, photons will be in a wave-particle quantum superposition state.
Bohr's complementarity notion is at the heart of quantum physics. It suggests that quantum systems are observed as waves or particles depending on the type of measurement, i.e., the experimental arrangement, they are subjected to. For instance, sending single photons to an open or closed Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) leads to the observation of particle or wave behaviours, respectively. In 1984, Wheeler proposed a "Gedanken" delayed-choice experiment in which the interferometer configuration is chosen at will by the experimentalist only after the photon has already passed the input beam-splitter (BS_in) of the device. This experiment was realized using a single photon source and showed that Bohr's complementarity notion was still obeyed.It was recently proposed to take Wheeler's experiment one step further by employing an output "quantum beam-splitter" (QBS), i.e.,preparing BS_out in a coherent superposition of being absent and present. This allows choosing the type of measurement, i.e., wave or particle, only after having determined the state of the QBS, which can be (in principle) infinitely delayed.We realized such an experiment by exploiting the resource of entanglement, in this case pairs of polarization entangled photons. The behaviour of one of the paired photons, called the test photon, is analysed using a MZI having a QBS at its output. This QBS is enabled by entanglement and made of a polarization dependent beam-splitter. The other photon, called the corroborative photon, allows determining the state of the QBS, and consequently, which test photon behaviour (wave, particle, or both) is observed.By manipulating the corroborative photon polarization state, we demonstrate a continuous morphing of the test photon from wave to particle behaviour. This refutes simple models of single photons behaving exclusively as waves or particles. The state of the QBS is determined via the measurement of the corroborative photon only after the test photon has already been detected. The space-like separation between the two measurements invalidates local-hidden variable models associated with pre-existing information about the measurement outcomes. In other words, when the test photon is detected, no information is available about the type of measurement it underwent. These results still perfectly obey Bohr's complementarity notion and its extension.
Bohr's complementarity notion is at the heart of quantum physics, and suggests that in a quantum experiment, the observed phenomena are inherently linked to the type of measurement that is performed. For example, sending single photons to an open or closed Mach-Zehnder interferometer leads to the observation of particle or wave behaviours. In 1984, Wheeler proposed a 'Gedanken' experiment in which the experimentalist chooses the interferometer configuration, at will, only after the photon has already passed the input beam-splitter (BSin) of the device. This experiment was realized using a diamond-based single photon source, and it was shown that Bohr's complementarity notion was still obeyed, as expected. It was recently proposed theoretically to take Wheeler's experiment one step further by employing a 'quantum beam-splitter' (QBS) at the interferometer output. In this case, the output beam-splitter (BSout) is placed in a coherent superposition of being absent and present, which also allows to further delay the choice of the measurement type. The type of measurement is determined only after having measured the state of the QBS, which can be (in principle) infinitely delayed. We demonstrate the realization of such an experiment by exploiting entanglement. In particular, we take advantage of pairs of polarization entangled photons. The behaviour of one of the paired photons, called the test photon, is analysed by sending it to a Mach-Zehnder interferometer having an entanglement-enabled QBS at its output. This device is made of a polarization dependent beam-splitter followed by polarization state erasers. The other photon, called the corroborative photon, allows determining the actual state of the QBS, and consequently, which test photon behaviour (wave, particle, or both) is measured. By manipulating the corroborative photon, we demonstrate a continuous morphing from wave to particle behaviour, which refutes too simple views of single photons behaving exclusively as waves or particles. The measurements on the test photon and the interferometer configuration are performed in a strictly delayed manner. The state of the QBS is measured only after the test photon already left the interferometer, and is detected, which means that it is destroyed before the type of measurement it under- goes is determined. We find that even in this configuration, Bohr's complementarity notion, and its extension, are perfectly obeyed. The space-like separation between the measurements invalidates local-hidden variable models associated with pre-existing information about the measurement out- comes. In other words, when the test photon is detected, no information is available about the type of measurement that was performed. This assertion is confirmed by the violation of the Bell's inequalities with more than 10 standard deviations. The presence of entanglement shows furthermore that genuine quantum behaviour for the test photons has been observed. As a conclusion, we have demonstrated the experimental realization of the quantum version of Wheeler's experiment. Trying to explain our observations in classical terms causes severe contradictions, but the results are in perfect agreement with quantum physics, in which the measurement timing order does not matter. The beauty in such experiments is that space and time do not seem to play any role.
Wave-particle duality lies at the root of quantum mechanics and is central in the description of interferences observed with elementary objects. In a delayed-choice experiment, the decision to observe the particle or wave character of a quantum system is delayed with respect to the time at which the system enters the interferometer. This paper reviews the history of the delayed-choice idea, introduced as a challenge to a realistic explanation of the wave-particle duality. It also describes recent experimental realizations of this idea and discusses intriguing extensions, such as the duality between separability and entanglement in multiple quantum systems.