The Travelling Salesman Problem (TSP) is a classical NP-hard problem that plays a crucial role in combinatorial optimization. In this paper, we are interested in the quantum search framework for the TSP because it has robust theoretical guarantees. However, we need to first search for all Hamiltonian cycles from a very large solution space, which greatly weakens the advantage of quantum search algorithms. To address this issue, one can first prepare a superposition state of all feasible solutions, and then amplify the amplitude of the optimal solution from it. We propose a quantum algorithm to generate the uniform superposition state of all N-length Hamiltonian cycles as an initial state within polynomial gate complexity based on pure quantum dynamic programming with very few ancillary qubits, which achieves exponential acceleration compared to the previous initial state preparation algorithm. As a result, we realized the theoretical minimum query complexity of quantum search algorithms for a general TSP. Compared to some algorithms that theoretically have lower query complexities but lack practical implementation solutions, our algorithm has feasible circuit implementation.
The Travelling Salesman Problem (TSP) is a classical NP-hard problem that plays a crucial role in combinatorial optimization. In this paper, we are interested in the quantum search framework for the TSP because it has robust theoretical guarantees. However, we need to first search for all Hamiltonian cycles from a very large solution space, which greatly weakens the advantage of quantum search algorithms. To address this issue, one can first prepare a superposition state of all feasible solutions, and then amplify the amplitude of the optimal solution from it. We propose a quantum algorithm to generate the uniform superposition state of all N-length Hamiltonian cycles as an initial state within polynomial gate complexity based on pure quantum dynamic programming with very few ancillary qubits, which achieves exponential acceleration compared to the previous initial state preparation algorithm. As a result, we realized the theoretical minimum query complexity of quantum search algorithms for a general TSP. Compared to some algorithms that theoretically have lower query complexities but lack practical implementation solutions, our algorithm has feasible circuit implementation.
The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) is a classical NP-hard problem that plays a crucial role in combinatorial optimization. In this paper, we are interested in the quantum search framework for the TSP because it has robust theoretical guarantees. However, we need to first search for all Hamiltonian cycles from a very large solution space, which greatly weakens the advantage of quantum search algorithms. To address this issue, one can first prepare a superposition state of all feasible solutions, and then amplify the amplitude of the optimal solution from it. We propose a quantum algorithm to generate the uniform superposition state of all N-length Hamiltonian cycles as an initial state within polynomial gate complexity based on pure quantum dynamic programming with very few ancillary qubits, which achieves exponential acceleration compared to the previous initial state preparation algorithm. As a result, we realized the theoretical minimum query complexity of quantum search algorithms for a general TSP. Compared to some algorithms that theoretically have lower query complexities but lack practical implementation solutions, our algorithm has feasible circuit implementation. Our work provides a meaningful research case on how to fully utilize the structures of specific problems to unleash the acceleration capability of the quantum search algorithms.
Quantum search algorithms, such as Grover's algorithm, are anticipated to efficiently solve constrained combinatorial optimization problems. However, applying these algorithms to the traveling salesman problem (TSP) on a quantum circuit presents a significant challenge. Existing quantum search algorithms for the TSP typically assume that an initial state—an equal superposition of all feasible solutions satisfying the problem's constraints—is pre-prepared. The query complexity of preparing this state using brute-force methods scales exponentially with the factorial growth of feasible solutions, creating a significant hurdle in designing quantum circuits for large-scale TSPs. To address this issue, we propose a two-step quantum search (TSQS) algorithm that employs two sets of operators. In the first step, all the feasible solutions are amplified into their equal superposition state. In the second step, the optimal solution state is amplified from this superposition state. The TSQS algorithm demonstrates greater efficiency compared to conventional search algorithms that employ a single oracle operator for finding a solution within the encoded space. Encoded in the higher order unconstrained binary optimization representation, our approach significantly reduces the qubit requirements. This enables efficient initial state preparation through a unified circuit design, offering a quadratic speedup in solving the TSP without prior knowledge of feasible solutions.
The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) serves as a standard benchmark for assessing potential quantum advantage in combinatorial optimization. This paper provides a critical comparative analysis of quantum annealing, gate-based approaches based on quantum phase estimation, and hybrid quantum–classical dynamic programming methods within a unified complexity and implementation framework. While theoretical results indicate reductions of the classical O ( 2 n ) scaling to approximately O ( 1.728 n ) for general instances and to O ( 1.110 n ) for structured cases, these improvements remain largely asymptotic. In practice, all current quantum approaches are strongly constrained by hardware limitations. Quantum annealing suffers from embedding overhead and noise, hybrid methods rely extensively on classical decomposition without guaranteed optimality, and gate-based implementations are limited by circuit depth and error accumulation. As a result, no clear quantum advantage over classical algorithms has been demonstrated at practically relevant problem scales. By systematically separating intrinsic algorithmic scaling from hardware-induced resource constraints, this work clarifies the origin of the gap between theoretical quantum speedups and experimental performance, providing a critical assessment of the current status and realistic prospects of quantum TSP methods.
The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) is a classical NP-hard problem in combinatorial optimization, where determining the shortest route among a set of cities becomes computationally prohibitive as the problem size increases. This work explores quantum computing as an alternative approach to address this complexity. Unlike existing methods that primarily rely on quantum annealing, we propose a quantum iterative framework integrating Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE) and Grover's search algorithm. Route costs are encoded as quantum phases, enabling QPE to efficiently evaluate them, while Amplitude Amplification, implemented via the Grover-Long algorithm, iteratively refines the solution space toward the optimal route. A proof-of-concept case study on a small-scale TSP instance demonstrates the feasibility of this approach and its potential for scaling to larger optimization problems. Furthermore, under an expectation-based analysis, the algorithm exhibits an expected computational complexity of O(εm2log2(m)log2(1/ε)) which depends on the error tolerance parameter ε. This estimation omits the initialization term, which we expect future refinements to render subdominant to Phase Estimation.
Abstract The travelling salesman problem (TSP) is a popular NP-hard combinatorial optimization problem that requires finding the optimal way for a salesman to travel through different cities once and return to the initial city. The existing methods of solving TSPs on quantum systems are either gate-based or binary variable-based encoding. Both approaches are resource-expensive in terms of the number of qubits, while performing worse compared to existing classical algorithms, even for small-sized problems. A novel encoding scheme is needed to map the TSP problem onto a quantum system, which is addressed in this work. We introduce a distinct geometric approach to encode the TSP on a single qubit and present a quantum-inspired algorithm to solve the problem by invoking the principle of quantum superposition . The cities are represented as quantum states on the Bloch sphere, while the preparation of superposition states allows us to traverse multiple paths at once. The underlying framework of our algorithm is a quantum-inspired version of the classical Brachistochrone approach. Optimal control methods are employed to create a selective superposition of the quantum states to find the shortest route of a given TSP. The numerical simulations solve a sample of four to nine cities for which exact solutions are obtained. The algorithm can be implemented on any quantum platform capable of efficiently rotating a qubit and allowing state tomography measurements. For the TSP problem sizes considered in this work, our algorithm is more resource-efficient and accurate than existing quantum algorithms, with the potential for scalability.
Quantum Divide-and-Conquer for the Traveling Salesman Problem: Surpassing the 2n Barrier
The traveling salesman problem (TSP) is a classic NP-hard problem. Held--Karp dynamic programming~\cite{held1962dynamic, bellman1962dynamic} solves it exactly in O(n22n) time, a barrier that has stood for over six decades. Whether quantum computing can surpass O∗(2n) is a central open question. The authors of~\cite{ambainis2019quantum}\ (SODA~2019) claimed a query complexity of O∗(1.727n), but we identify a structural counting error: when corrected, their scheme requires Ω∗(2n) queries and offers no advantage over classical Held--Karp. We design a quantum divide-and-conquer framework: partition n-vertex set into k subsets, classically precompute shortest paths within each, then search over all k-partitions via quantum minimum finding. We prove k=3 achieves O∗(1.890n), and k=4 attains the global optimum O∗(1.866n), the first quantum algorithm to surpass O∗(2n) for general TSP. To convert the query bound into a time-complexity advantage, we overcome the oracle-construction bottleneck by preparing a set partition state, requiring O(n2) gates and O(n) depth. Leveraging structured state preparation, we achieve a total time complexity of O∗(1.866n). Qiskit simulations on n=6,7 achieve 98.9% and 100% accuracy.