While the dynamics of fully connected systems is dominated by mean-field effect, in the classical limit the single-particle observables are observed to relax toward a nonthermal stationary value. This phenomenon is known as violent relaxation and it is generally absent at the quantum-mechanical level, where single-particle observables exhibits long-lived oscillations. In this paper we explain this discrepancy by determining some very restrictive conditions that quantum single-site Hamiltonians should meet in order for the system to undergo relaxation. We thus check them by introducing a new model (the so-called $w$ model) which can exhibit dynamical phase transition among thermal behavior, persistent excitations, and violent relaxation. We also propose a way to implement it within light-matter coupling. We finally explain how the classical limit restore this behavior, thus showing that, even if the mean-field dynamics of quantum models is usually thought to be classical, quantum effects still play an important role in it.
While the dynamics of fully connected systems is dominated by mean-field effect, in the classical limit the single-particle observables are observed to relax toward a nonthermal stationary value. This phenomenon is known as violent relaxation and it is generally absent at the quantum-mechanical level, where single-particle observables exhibits long-lived oscillations. In this paper we explain this discrepancy by determining some very restrictive conditions that quantum single-site Hamiltonians should meet in order for the system to undergo relaxation. We thus check them by introducing a new model (the so-called w model) which can exhibit dynamical phase transition among thermal behavior, persistent excitations, and violent relaxation. We also propose a way to implement it within light-matter coupling. We finally explain how the classical limit restore this behavior, thus showing that, even if the mean-field dynamics of quantum models is usually thought to be classical, quantum effects still play an important role in it.
In general, classical fully-connected systems are known to undergo violent relaxation. This phenomenon refers to the relaxation of observables to stationary, non-thermal, values on a finite timescale, despite their long-time dynamics being dominated by mean-field effects in the thermodynamic limit. Here, we analyze the ``quantum" violent relaxation by studying the dynamics of generic many-body systems with two-body, all-to-all, interactions in the thermodynamic limit. We show that, in order for violent relaxation to occur very specific conditions on the spectrum of the mean-field effective Hamiltonian have to be met. These conditions are hardly met and ``quantum" violent relaxation is observed rarely with respect to its classical counterpart. Our predictions are validated by the study of a spin model which, depending on the value of the coupling, shows a transition between violent-relaxation and a generic prethermal phase. We also analyze a spin version of the quantum Hamiltonian-Mean-Field model, which is shown not to exhibit violent-relaxation. Finally, we discuss how the violent-relaxation picture emerges back in the classical limit. Our results demonstrate how, even in the mean-field regime, quantum effects have a rather dramatic impact on the dynamics, paving the way to a better understanding of light-matter coupled systems.
Violent relaxation is a process that occurs in systems with long-range interactions. It has the peculiar feature of dramatically amplifying small perturbations, and rather than driving the system to equilibrium, it instead leads to slowly evolving configurations known as quasistationary states that fall outside the standard paradigm of statistical mechanics. Violent relaxation was originally identified in gravity-driven stellar dynamics; here, we extend the theory into the quantum regime by developing a quantum version of the Hamiltonian mean field (HMF) model which exemplifies many of the generic properties of long-range interacting systems. The HMF model can either be viewed as describing particles interacting via a cosine potential, or equivalently as the kinetic XY model with infinite-range interactions, and its quantum fluid dynamics can be obtained from a generalized Gross-Pitaevskii equation. We show that singular caustics that form during violent relaxation are regulated by interference effects in a universal way described by Thom's catastrophe theory applied to waves and this leads to emergent length scales and timescales not present in the classical problem. In the deep quantum regime we find that violent relaxation is suppressed altogether by quantum zero-point motion. Our results are relevant to laboratory studies of self-organization in cold atomic gases with long-range interactions.
We present a general theory of classical metastability in open quantum systems. Metastability is a consequence of a large separation in timescales in the dynamics, leading to the existence of a regime when states of the system appear stationary, before eventual relaxation toward a true stationary state at much larger times. In this work, we focus on the emergence of classical metastability, i.e., when metastable states of an open quantum system with separation of timescales can be approximated as probabilistic mixtures of a finite number of states. We find that a number of classical features follow from this approximation, for the manifold of metastable states, long-time dynamics between them, and symmetries of the dynamics. Namely, those states are approximately disjoint and thus play the role of metastable phases, the relaxation toward the stationary state is approximated by a classical stochastic dynamics between them, and weak symmetries correspond to their permutations. Importantly, the classical dynamics is observed not only on average but also at the level of individual quantum trajectories: We show that time coarse-grained continuous measurement records can be viewed as noisy classical trajectories, while their statistics can be approximated by that of the classical dynamics. Among others, this explains how first-order dynamical phase transitions arise from metastability. Finally, to verify the presence of classical metastability in a given open quantum system, we develop an efficient numerical approach that delivers the set of metastable phases together with the effective classical dynamics. Since the proximity to a first-order dissipative phase transition manifests as metastability, the theory and tools introduced in this work can be used to investigate such transitions---which occur in the large size limit---through the metastable behavior of many-body systems of moderate sizes accessible to numerics.
Abstract Real-world complex systems often show robust, persistent oscillatory dynamics, e.g.~non-trivial attractors. On the quantum level this behaviour has only been found in semi-classical or weakly correlated systems under restrictive assumptions. However, strongly interacting systems without classical limits, e.g.~electrons on a lattice or spins, typically relax quickly to a stationary state (trivial attractors). This raises the puzzling question of how non-trivial attractors can arise from the quantum laws. Here, we introduce strictly local dynamical symmetries that lead to extremely robust and persistent oscillations in quantum many-body systems without a classical limit. Observables that do not have overlap with the symmetry operators can relax, losing memory of their initial conditions. The remaining observables enter complex dynamical cycles, signalling the emergence of a quantum many-body attractor. We provide a recipe for constructing Hamiltonians featuring local dynamical symmetries. As an example, we introduce the spin lace – a model of a quasi-1D quantum magnet.
The relationship between classical and quantum mechanics is usually understood via the limit ħ→0. This is the underlying idea behind the quantization of classical objects. The apparent incompatibility of general relativity with quantum mechanics and quantum field theory has challenged for many decades this basic idea. We recently showed (Bru and de Siqueira Pedra, 0000; Bru and de Siqueira Pedra, 2021 [46,47]) the emergence of classical dynamics for very general quantum lattice systems with mean-field interactions, without (complete) suppression of its quantum features, in the infinite volume limit. This leads to a theoretical framework in which the classical and quantum worlds are entangled. Such an entanglement is noteworthy and is a consequence of the highly non-local character of mean-field interactions. Therefore, this phenomenon should not be restricted to systems with mean-field interactions only, but should also appear in presence of interactions that are sufficiently long-range, yielding effective, classical background fields, in the spirit of the Higgs mechanism of quantum field theory. In order to present the result in a less abstract way than in its original version, here we apply it to a concrete, physically relevant, example and discuss, by this means, various important aspects of our general approach. The model we consider is not exactly solvable and the particular results obtained are new.
We investigate the relaxation dynamics in an isolated quantum many-body system. The stationary value of an observable after relaxation is a topic of researches in the field of quantum thermalization, since thermalization is a relaxation phenomena where this stationary value coincides with the equilibrium value. Therefore, computing the stationary value in quantum many-body systems is regarded as an important problem. We, however, prove that the stationary value in quantum many-body systems is incomputable. More precisely, we show that whether the stationary value is in the vicinity of a given value or not is an undecidable problem. Our undecidable result is still satisfied when we restrict our system to a one-dimensional shift-invariant system with nearest-neighbor interaction, our initial state to a product state of a state on a single site, and our observable to a shift-sum of a one-body observable. This result clearly shows that there is no general theorem or procedure to decide the presence or absence of thermalization in a given quantum many-body system.