Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Tunneling, the Equilibrium Constant, and Epicatalysis: A Second-Law Paradox?

Jack Denur

Published May 15, 2025• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential- energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[-(EH - EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. Next, we provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis. Then we spotlight that only one aspect of the Second Law can challenged: the aspect thereof that precludes a net decrease in entropy. Following concluding remarks, the minimum work that the Second Law requires to change Keq is evaluated in the Appendix.

DOI
10.20944/preprints202503.0123.v3

Related papers

Tunneling, the Equilibrium Constant, and Epicatalysis: A Second-Law Paradox?

Jack Denur

Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential-energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[−(EH – EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. Next, we provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis. Then we spotlight that only one aspect of the Second Law can challenged: the aspect thereof that precludes a net decrease in entropy. Following concluding remarks, the minimum work that the Second Law requires to change Keq is evaluated in the Appendix.

•Mar 14, 2025•0 citations

Tunneling, the Equilibrium Constant, and Epicatalysis: A Second-Law Paradox?

Jack Denur

Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential- energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[-(EH - EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. Next, we provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis. Then we spotlight that only one aspect of the Second Law can challenged: the aspect thereof that precludes a net decrease in entropy. Following concluding remarks, the minimum work that the Second Law requires to change Keq is evaluated in the Appendix.

•May 20, 2025•0 citations

Tunneling, the Equilibrium Constant, and Epicatalysis: A Second-Law Paradox?

Jack Denur

Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential-energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher- (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[−(EH – EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. We then provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis, followed by concluding remarks.

•Mar 4, 2025•0 citations

Tunneling, the Equilibrium Constant, and Epicatalysis: A Second-Law Paradox?

Jack Denur

Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential-energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher- (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[−(EH – EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. We then provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis, followed by concluding remarks.

•Mar 3, 2025•0 citations

Particle Entropies and Entropy Quanta: IV. The Ideal Gas, the Second Law of Thermodynamics, and the P–t Uncertainty Relation

Herbert W. Zimmermann

Abstract The quantum thermodynamics of the ideal gas is treated by means of the particle entropies σ=ka. The non-dimensional entropy numbers a are calculated by the extended, temperature-dependent Schrödinger equation applying periodic boundary conditions. The Boltzmann constant k represents the atomic entropy unit. The quantized particle entropies a are used to calculate the Boltzmann distribution f=exp(α−a), the density of entropy levels D(a), the dimensionless chemical potential α=μ/kT, etc. – The thermodynamics of the ideal gas is treated on the basis of entropy quanta by means of the density matrix formalism. In this way we obtain the total particle entropy A, the thermodynamic entropy S (equation of Sackur-Tetrode), the internal and the Helmholtz free energy E and F, respectively, etc. Moreover, it can also be shown on the basis of entropy quanta that the entropy of a closed system in thermal equilibrium has a maximum value, S=S max. Against this, the entropy S ′ of an arbitrary non-equilibrium state is always smaller, S′ < S max (second law of thermodynamics). – Application of ordinary density matrix theory to a closed system of N particles leads to the result that the entropy S does not change in time, dS/dt=0, regardless whether we consider an equilibrium state, S=S max, or a non-equilibrium state, S=S′. Consequently, S cannot irreversibly change from S′ to S max. However, any irreversible process is accompanied by a positive entropy production P=dS/dt>0. In order to overcome this obvious contradiction, we discuss the entropy evolution in time by means of the commutator equation G =i[ P , t ], which is deduced from very general assumptions. Here P and t are the operators of the entropy production P and the time t. Accordingly, P and t do not commute in general, and hence P and t are not sharply defined simultaneously. Instead we have uncertainties ΔP and Δt, which are expressed by the uncertainty relation of the N-particle system, ΔPΔt≥(1/2)|〈 G 〉|=(γ/2)k. This P − t uncertainty relation easily allows a discussion of the evolution of the entropy S in time t from S′ to S max. Now the irreversible steps are correctly described by the entropy production P=dS/dt > 0, and the thermal equilibrium by P=0, ∆P=0, and thus the lifetime ∆t=∞.

Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie•Jan 1, 2003•6 citations

A REMARK ON BOLTZMANN H THEOREM

CHANG TSUNG-SDEI, 中国科学院数学研究所,北京师范大学物理系

It is pointed out that the quantum-mechanical Boltzmann H theorem in the restricted sense (i.e. with explicit consideration of the statistics of the particles constituting the system and their interactions) does not lead directly to the distribution laws for the particles among their various states as is commonly believed, but to the equality of the probability for all states belonging to the system as a whole if the system is isolated, (or to the Boltzmann factor for the probabilities of states belonging to a system at constant temperature), in agreement with the result of the generalized quantum-mechanical H theorem as given by Pauli. The distribution laws for the particles among their various states may of course be deduced from the latter.In the course of proof, we have also introduced the following minor improvements:(i) To avoid conservation of energy in microscopic processes which lead to changes in the states of the particles and thus to equilibrium, we let our system be in interaction with a heat reservoir, so that energy may be supplied by or given to it. This is tauto-mount to changing the study of the entropy for an isolated system to that of the free energy for a system at constant temperature.(ii) Interaction energies between the particles which affect the total energy of the system and thus the distribution laws for the particles among their various states are included.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 1954•2 citations
Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential- energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[-(EH - EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. Next, we provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis. Then we spotlight that only one aspect of the Second Law can challenged: the aspect thereof that precludes a net decrease in entropy. Following concluding remarks, the minimum work that the Second Law requires to change Keq is evaluated in the Appendix.
Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential-energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[−(EH – EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. Next, we provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis. Then we spotlight that only one aspect of the Second Law can challenged: the aspect thereof that precludes a net decrease in entropy. Following concluding remarks, the minimum work that the Second Law requires to change Keq is evaluated in the Appendix.
Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential- energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[-(EH - EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. Next, we provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis. Then we spotlight that only one aspect of the Second Law can challenged: the aspect thereof that precludes a net decrease in entropy. Following concluding remarks, the minimum work that the Second Law requires to change Keq is evaluated in the Appendix.
Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential-energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher- (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[−(EH – EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. We then provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis, followed by concluding remarks.
Consider one particle (which could be an atom, molecule, Brownian particle, etc.) in thermodynamic equilibrium with a heat reservoir at temperature T. This particle can be in a low-potential-energy well L whose energy floor is EL and whose degeneracy is GL or in a higher- (or at least equally high) potential-energy well H whose energy floor is EH and whose degeneracy is GH. L and H are separated by a barrier B, which the particle can traverse. The Second Law of Thermodynamics asserts that the ratio of the probability of this particle being in H to that of it being in L, i.e., the equilibrium constant Keq corresponding to its dissemination between the two wells L and H, is in accordance with the Boltzmann (or canonical) distribution: Keq = (GH/GL)exp[−(EH – EL)/kT]. Given thermodynamic equilibrium this indeed always obtains if transits between L and H occur only via thermal excitation of our particle. But we show that despite thermodynamic equilibrium this does not obtain if transits between L and H occur both via thermal excitation and via tunneling. Implications concerning the Second Law of Thermodynamics are discussed. We then provide general remarks pertaining to catalysis versus epicatalysis, followed by concluding remarks.
Abstract The quantum thermodynamics of the ideal gas is treated by means of the particle entropies σ=ka. The non-dimensional entropy numbers a are calculated by the extended, temperature-dependent Schrödinger equation applying periodic boundary conditions. The Boltzmann constant k represents the atomic entropy unit. The quantized particle entropies a are used to calculate the Boltzmann distribution f=exp(α−a), the density of entropy levels D(a), the dimensionless chemical potential α=μ/kT, etc. – The thermodynamics of the ideal gas is treated on the basis of entropy quanta by means of the density matrix formalism. In this way we obtain the total particle entropy A, the thermodynamic entropy S (equation of Sackur-Tetrode), the internal and the Helmholtz free energy E and F, respectively, etc. Moreover, it can also be shown on the basis of entropy quanta that the entropy of a closed system in thermal equilibrium has a maximum value, S=S max. Against this, the entropy S ′ of an arbitrary non-equilibrium state is always smaller, S′ < S max (second law of thermodynamics). – Application of ordinary density matrix theory to a closed system of N particles leads to the result that the entropy S does not change in time, dS/dt=0, regardless whether we consider an equilibrium state, S=S max, or a non-equilibrium state, S=S′. Consequently, S cannot irreversibly change from S′ to S max. However, any irreversible process is accompanied by a positive entropy production P=dS/dt>0. In order to overcome this obvious contradiction, we discuss the entropy evolution in time by means of the commutator equation G =i[ P , t ], which is deduced from very general assumptions. Here P and t are the operators of the entropy production P and the time t. Accordingly, P and t do not commute in general, and hence P and t are not sharply defined simultaneously. Instead we have uncertainties ΔP and Δt, which are expressed by the uncertainty relation of the N-particle system, ΔPΔt≥(1/2)|〈 G 〉|=(γ/2)k. This P − t uncertainty relation easily allows a discussion of the evolution of the entropy S in time t from S′ to S max. Now the irreversible steps are correctly described by the entropy production P=dS/dt > 0, and the thermal equilibrium by P=0, ∆P=0, and thus the lifetime ∆t=∞.
It is pointed out that the quantum-mechanical Boltzmann H theorem in the restricted sense (i.e. with explicit consideration of the statistics of the particles constituting the system and their interactions) does not lead directly to the distribution laws for the particles among their various states as is commonly believed, but to the equality of the probability for all states belonging to the system as a whole if the system is isolated, (or to the Boltzmann factor for the probabilities of states belonging to a system at constant temperature), in agreement with the result of the generalized quantum-mechanical H theorem as given by Pauli. The distribution laws for the particles among their various states may of course be deduced from the latter.In the course of proof, we have also introduced the following minor improvements:(i) To avoid conservation of energy in microscopic processes which lead to changes in the states of the particles and thus to equilibrium, we let our system be in interaction with a heat reservoir, so that energy may be supplied by or given to it. This is tauto-mount to changing the study of the entropy for an isolated system to that of the free energy for a system at constant temperature.(ii) Interaction energies between the particles which affect the total energy of the system and thus the distribution laws for the particles among their various states are included.